HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cooldeal

5,923 karma · joined March 6, 2011

Lead Technical Architect working in the DC Metro area.

Email: cooldeal@outlook.com

submissionscomments
cooldeal··on Flat Design and Color Trends
The marketing department markets the phones, it does not design the UI.
cooldeal··on How I Escaped North Korea
Where are you getting your information from? You're just simply wrong on many counts.

>During the 65 years of its independence, Federal government in India has remained under the control of one single family (the Gandhi family). Being the "biggest democracy" is just a farce. Similarly, most of the state governments are under the control of a select few families.

>Not really. They are not allowed to protest.

There's no good way to say it, that is simply factually wrong and unadulterated bullshit.

You must have been reading propaganda or have an axe to grind if you think the federal government has been under the control of the Gandhis 65 years since independence.

cooldeal··on Apple reports $9.5 billion second quarter profit
I don't see how it is all that impressive. Nokia has been shipping a million plus phones a day from a long time ago.
cooldeal··on Apple reports $9.5 billion second quarter profit
Cliche at this point, but got to be said.

"The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent." John Maynard Keynes, (attributed) English economist (1883 - 1946)

cooldeal··on Apple reports $9.5 billion second quarter profit
>The iPad Mini didn't exist last year, and that's surely a lower margin product

Why is it "surely" so? We're talking percentage margin here, not the margin in dollar terms. The iPad Mini can theoretically have a higher margin than the iPad.

cooldeal··on Mac Makes 45% of PC Industry's Operating Profit
45% is not greater than 55%. Headline is wrong.

http://www.asymco.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Screen-Shot...

cooldeal··on Stick a fork in it: Windows is done
Does this mean it's time to lift the anti-monopoly restrictions on Microsoft and Windows?
cooldeal··on AppGratis Is Nothing More Than A Black Hat Marketing Company
Everytime there's a discussion about the walled garden, people say that it's to prevent malware, but Apple is going way beyond that by forcing a cut of in-app purchases, banning application prototyping apps, rejecting an Android magazine app, and crap like this.

I somehow feel that if AppGratis was paying the 30% cut to Apple, it wouldn't have been banned from the store.

cooldeal··on Stolen From Apple
Since page is not loading, full text:

In 1980, a company called Franklin Computer produced a clone of the Apple II called the Franklin Ace, designed to run the same software. They copied almost every detail of the Apple II, including all of its ROM based software and all the documentation, and sold it at a lower price than Apple. We even found a place in the manual where they forgot to change "Apple" to "Ace". Apple was infuriated, and sued Franklin. They eventually won, and forced Franklin to withdraw the Ace from the market.

Even though Apple won the case, it was pretty scary for a while, and it wasn't clear until the end that the judge would rule in Apple's favor - Franklin argued that they had a right to copy the Apple II ROMs, since it was just a "functional mechanism" necessary for software compatibility. We anticipated that someone might try a similar trick with the Macintosh someday. If they were clever enough (which Franklin wasn't), they could disguise the code (say by systematically permuting some registers) so it wouldn't look that similar at the binary level. We thought that we better take some precautions.

Steve decided that if a company copied the Mac ROM into their computer, he would like to be able to do a demo during the trial, where he could type a few keystokes into an unmodified infringing machine, and have a large "Stolen From Apple" icon appear on its screen. The routines and data to accomplish that would have to be incorporated into our ROM in a stealthy fashion, so the cloners wouldn't know how to find or remove it.

It was tricky enough to be a fun project. Susan designed a nice "Stolen from Apple" icon, featuring prison bars. Steve Capps had recently come up with a simple scheme for compressing ROM-based icons to save space, so we compressed the icon using his technique, which not only reduced the overhead but also made it much harder to detect the icon. Finally, we wrote a tiny routine to decompress the icon, scale it up and display it on the screen. We hid it in the middle of some data tables, so it would be hard to spot when disassembling the ROM.

All you had to do to invoke it is enter the debugger and type a 6 digit hexadecimal address followed by a "G", which meant execute the routine at that address. We demoed it for Steve and he liked it. We were kind of hoping someone would copy the ROM just so we could show off our foresight.

As far as I know, no one ever did copy the ROM in a commercial project, so it wasn't really necessary, but it did create some intrigue for a while. We let it slip that there was a "stolen from Apple" icon hidden in there somewhere, partially to deter people from copying the ROM. At least one hacker became moderately obsessed with trying to find it.

Steve Jasik was the author of the MacNosy disassembler/debugger, which could be used to create pseudo-source for the ROM. He found out about the "stolen from Apple" icon pretty early on, and became determined to isolate it. He lived in Palo Alto, so I would occasionally bump into him, and he would ask me for hints or tell me his latest theory about how it was concealed, which was invariably wrong.

This went on for two or three years, before he finally cracked it: I ran into him and he had it nailed, telling me about the compressed icon and the address of the display routine. I congratulated him, but was never sure if he figured it out himself or if someone with access to the source code told him.

cooldeal··on Ask PG, HN: Is someone tampering with article positions?
There are a few ways that an article can appear lower than it should.

1) Flagging by people with karma over the threshold (currently set at 500).

2) For some domains, only 1/3rd of the upvotes count, e.g. Reddit, XKCD, images, tweets.

3) There is a "controversial" score which can bring down a story. Not sure how it is computed but perhaps it's based on number of comments versus number of points.

4) Voting ring detector. This can bring down a post pretty hard if it's triggered.

5) I suspect the HN supermoderators can cause a post to sink to the second page instantly.

Most of the time it's #1 that causes posts to go down.

I've usually seen it happen to posts that are anti-Apple, anti-Google or posts related to Microsoft that are not negative towards it. It's like the moderators flag posts that they don't want others to be seeing.

For example, the Surface Pro review

http://i.imgur.com/uFPTSqR.png

http://i.imgur.com/ADMcanz.png

cooldeal··on What I would like to see from Microsoft regarding OSS
Here's the how-to to add your own keys.

http://blog.hansenpartnership.com/owning-your-windows-8-uefi...

cooldeal··on What I would like to see from Microsoft regarding OSS
>Make the ability to add personal keys to secure boot a requirement for having a Windows logo

Sigh, that's already the requirement.

If I had a cent for every poster that is ignorant about secure boot but rants against it as if they are a guru, I'd be very rich. Why so many tech savvy folks are clueless when it comes to Secure Boot, I will never know. These facts are known from over a year, but the FUDsters have succeeded in fudging the facts and spreading mistruths.

cooldeal··on What I would like to see from Microsoft regarding OSS
>It's about microsoft insisting that the only pre-loaded encryption key is theirs, to the exclusion of all other encryption keys.

Bullshit, they do no such thing. The OEMs are perfectly able and willing to preload other keys. It's the community that is unable to step up to having a signing infrastructure. Why don't you contribute to the effort of a signing mechanism for Linux instead of just spreading anti-Microsoft lies?

Edit: I see that my post is getting downvoted while the factually incorrect parent post is not. This feels like /r/Linux, where facts are not welcome and where FUD gets voted up.

cooldeal··on What I would like to see from Microsoft regarding OSS
I love the phrasing "ARM device" as opposed to Windows RT. Somehow the largest selling "ARM Devices" i.e iPads are not blamed for having locked bootloaders. But on a barely selling platform, suddenly it's a huge deal.
cooldeal··on Taking a stand on open source and patents
>There's a link in the very line that you're quoting that goes to an article that discusses "open systems" and "open-source software" as distinct things

This is what it says about open systems.

>Another way to look at the difference between open and closed systems is that open systems allow innovation at all levels — from the operating system to the application layer — not just at the top. This means that one company doesn't have to depend on another's benevolence to ship a product. If the GNU C compiler that I'm using has a bug, I can fix it since the compiler is open source. I don't have to file a bug report and hope for a timely response.

From that it appears that they're conflating "open systems" and "open source software", not drawing a distinction like you're claiming.

>At no point does your quote say that open-source always wins, or that all things should be open-source, so it's like you didn't read even those two sentences.

From the same link that you site, Google says this:

>We believe that open is the only way for this to have the broadest impact for the most people. We are technology optimists who trust that the chaos of open benefits everyone. We will fight to promote it every chance we get.

>Open will win. It will win on the Internet and will then cascade across many walks of life: The future of government is transparency. The future of commerce is information symmetry. The future of culture is freedom. The future of science and medicine is collaboration.

cooldeal··on The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time
>instead of just using the same scare tactic MPEG-LA used before, of empty threats to kill momentum for VP8

Empty threats? They have publicly listed the patents that they think are being infringed. That is more than the MPEG-LA ever did.

>If you have something against Google/VP8, sue them already.

It doesn't work like that. You need to show the judge that you exhausted all possible avenues before filing a case.

And you seem to think patent trials take no time. They take years. The fastest way for VP8 to be clear of this mess is if Google thinks the patents have some merit and they quickly come to a licensing agreement with Nokia like they did with MPEG-LA.

cooldeal··on The Nokia Patents and VP8 – Prior Art Hunting Time
The way Groklaw was cheering on Google/Motorola/Samsung's abuse of standards essential FRAND patents to obtain injunctions was quite telling that they're more of a cheer squad for their favorite companies(not to mention the Apple/Microsoft/Oracle hate) instead of being genuinely concerned about openness and patent abuse in tech.
cooldeal··on Bacteria in the Intestines May Help Tip the Bathroom Scale, Studies Show
The body isn't a closed thermodynamic system. You have to take into account metabolism, the human waste that is eliminated, the satiety of the foods consumed, etc. Not to mention the make up of bacteria as evidenced in the article.
cooldeal··on Linux users file EU complaint against Microsoft
>If the OS refuses to boot when you disable Secure Boot, then you can't dual boot the pre-installed OS, and it takes a lot of effort to get things working again.

What? Which OS refuses to boot when you disable Secure Boot?

>This is all a stupid mess which could have been solved by allowing users to install their own certificates

Exactly which UEFI Secure Boot does. Here's a guide.

http://blog.hansenpartnership.com/owning-your-windows-8-uefi...

cooldeal··on Linux users file EU complaint against Microsoft
This is because the primary goal of most malware writers is not to make the machine unusable, but to hide the malware and use the machine to spam, DDoS, collect site and bank credentials etc.

Also, you can go and turn secure boot off to boot your infected machine, so it's not really bricked or unusable.

cooldeal··on Linux users file EU complaint against Microsoft
EU had already previously responded to this and I believe this complaint by a "8000-strong" body is not going to change it.

>The Commission is aware of the Microsoft Windows 8 security requirements. According to these requirements, in order to conform to the Windows 8 certification program, computer manufacturers (‘OEMs’) have to use Unified Extensible Firmware Interface (‘UEFI’) secure boot.

>The Commission has at its disposal various legal instruments to ensure that competition is preserved in the markets. The basic provisions are contained in the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (‘TFEU’) in Article 101 and 102 TFEU.

>Whether there is a violation of EU competition rules depends however on a range of factual, legal and economic considerations. The Commission is currently not in possession of evidence suggesting that the Windows 8 security requirements would result in practices in violation of EU competition rules as laid down in Articles 101 and 102 TFEU. In particular, on the basis of the information currently available to the Commission it appears that the OEMs can decide to give the end users the option to disable the UEFI secure boot.

>The Commission will however continue to monitor the market developments so as to ensure that competition and a level playing field are preserved amongst all market players.

From http://www.europarl.europa.eu/sides/getAllAnswers.do?referen...

cooldeal··on How Google Sliced Away Our Knife Ads
>Google probably thinks they are being benevolent by taking an anti-weapons stance

I think consistency is the bigger issue here. If they take that stance, the should go after Amazon and others and not just the site linked here.

cooldeal··on How Google Sliced Away Our Knife Ads
Google has such a large percentage of search traffic that your competitors who are not flagged will have a huge advantage over you.
cooldeal··on Testers Say IE11 Includes 'Like Gecko' in User Agent String
Aren't they making releases faster with IE11 compared to earlier cycles of taking years between versions? IE10 is from 5 or 6 months ago.
cooldeal··on Chrome Inspector Detector
It's becoming increasing clear that on HN you're a second class citizen if you don't use Chrome on a Mac and develop on RoR.
cooldeal··on Nokia discloses their patents on VP8/WebM
> A standard should NEVER ever be controlled/represented/defended by a group of companies with monetary interests.

You mean like VP8/WebM by Google?

cooldeal··on Browser Wars Revisited
They should've stated that the data comes from StatCounter upfront. I thought they had their own metrics.

Pasting from an earlier comment:

One big difference is that NetMarketShare tries to measure unique clients, while StatCounter measures web page hits.

Since the power users browse (probably a magnitude of order) more web pages than the normal users, Chrome and to a lesser extent Firefox is overrepresented in power users who browse a ton.

Toothpaste marketshare analogy. It's possible that 70% of people use Colgate and 30% use Crest, but Colgate sales by volume are only 40% vs. 60% for Crest, since Crest users tend to brush more daily and use more of the toothpaste when they do for some reason.

Or a car analogy: Toyota sells 40% of cars and Honda only 30%, but 60% of miles driven on roads are by Honda cars since they use it more. Which has a higher marketshare?

cooldeal··on Adria Richards, PyCon, and How We All Lost
For the life of me I cannot fathom why PlayHaven went to the extreme step of firing the dev in question.

What he did was certainly wrong, but certainly not a firable offense. A stern warning from HR would've sufficed.

Also, I don't understand the hate and DDoS directed towards SendGrid. I think if any, PlayHaven should've been subject of it and pressured to reinstate the dev in question.

SendGrid should've been pressured to warn her, not fire her like it happened.

We commit mistakes every once in a while, and losing your job is a big punishment. It's like getting your car seized by the government for speeding 10% over the speed limit.

Unfortunately the outcome is that a message is sent that DDoS works to get people that the internet mob doesn't like fired, and that a part of the male tech community is wielding that power.

What if parts of the female tech community retaliate with a DDoS against SendGrid now?

Looks like the male privilege extends to having the resources to perform DDoS.

cooldeal··on SendGrid has terminated the employment of Adria Richards?
>Couldn't SendGrid have offered the guy a job and apologized profusely.

I can't imagine the office environment with these two working together as anything but cordial.

cooldeal··on SendGrid has terminated the employment of Adria Richards?
Nooooo.... this is NOT a good thing. The good thing would have been PlayHaven reinstating the fired person, and everyone apologizing to each other for bad behavior.

Firing is NOT the answer for such minor transgressions. Yes, there were mistakes on both sides, but to lose your job over it is a huge overreaction from HR. Perhaps the DDoS should've been directed at PlayHaven for overreacting and not SendGrid?

← PreviousPage 2 of 27Next →