HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cucumber3732842

1,080 karma · joined January 20, 2026

I'm not so vain as to put contact info here.
submissionscomments
cucumber3732842··on Nearly 200 people under observation after Irkutsk lab worker dies from plague
Because people who spewed all manner of vitriol on pretenses that now with hindsight should have been visible as shaky at the time would rather bicker trying to justify it than examine how they could've done that.
cucumber3732842··on Nearly 200 people under observation after Irkutsk lab worker dies from plague
Internet comments are beyond lousy with people of a a certain ideological bent that makes them love institutionalized science while also paternalistically racist.

Given the choice between blaming "the system" and all the ideologically unimaginable questions that would come with that and blaming some elderly Chinese guy who didn't cook his bat soup well enough, well that's not really a choice.

Imagine trying to tell some mid tier guy in the Taliban about the pros of educated women. It's just gonna bounce right off. That it could ever be worth it is just incomprehensibly foreign to him.

The lab leak theory bounced right off of a lot of people here for all the same reasons.

cucumber3732842··on What is going on with ceiling fans
More like getting downvoted for equating vapid GlobalHomo(TM) megacorp press release/blog post nothingness with "better".

AI is great at saying nothing specific really flamboyantly or juicing up very little substance with a whole bunch of that sort of puffery that's endemic to corporate communication. It is very bad at the subtle pairing of tone and diction with subject matter and audience that humans just do naturally.

cucumber3732842··on So you think you could be an electrician?
Residential also has to deal with regulators who are capricious jerks and might (have a boss who does) not like your boss, the contractor who hired your boss, the property owner, etc, etc. and will happily screw you out of thousands of dollars of opportunity cost to get at them.

Working for BigCo you never get that stuff because anyone who wants to screw you has to go through BigCo's legal team to do it.

cucumber3732842··on So you think you could be an electrician?
They're "pretty safe" though because they've all got 50-100yo licensing rackets that intertwine them with the state

Things have to get real, real, real bad before the state decides that it's better for the state to lower barriers to entry than keep them.

cucumber3732842··on Federal judge calls Flock 'indiscriminate mass surveillance'
No, it's not a crime. In the US civil/administrative enforcement authorities are given insane authority under the law and "haha, spend $10k on lawyering to exhaust our kangaroo court and then spend another 20 to sue us in big boy court" is your recourse. Your 4th through 8th amendment rights basically don't exist if the subject is one of fines and fees and bureaucrats and not one of gun toting, door kicking cops trying to put you in a cage. And this is the US. I can only imagine what it's like in China.

Read your municipal code (they're fairly homogenous these days because of the feds and their stupid grants) if you don't believe me.

cucumber3732842··on Federal judge calls Flock 'indiscriminate mass surveillance'
There are a lot of evil authoritarians who are pissed that Flock is gonna rack up some bad precedents before they've had a chance to implement some 1984 type system where some guy winds up losing his house because he drove drunk for 100ft to get his car where it wouldn't be towed for street cleaning or threw a broken TV in a ditch or some other crime that's really not all that bad in the grand scheme of things but deeply offends people of a certain social class and ideological bent.

And there's another whole bunch of petty authoritarians who have grand plans to fine the shit out of everyone they see leaving Home Depot with a water heater and no open building permit. They're also just as pissed off this might get reigned in before they've got their chance to put the population under their jackboot.

cucumber3732842··on Two American Airlines Flights End Up with the Same Flight Numbers
Not to mention the huge WTF factor of them being in different parts of their flight and the instant issues that would cause when the ATCs try to do anything with them.

"Hey why did you just tell a flight that's on approach to taxi"

"What do you mean they're right here?"

"No they're on final you twat"

"No this is Patrick"

????????

<issue straightened out>

cucumber3732842··on Federal judge calls Flock 'indiscriminate mass surveillance'
The root problem here is that we've got a government that has a hundred years of legal "litter" they can enforce on a whim.

No one bad law is too bad on it's own, like litter in the park. But you add it all up and it's disgusting. There's a law for everything but each one is defensible in abstract in a "my litter isn't responsible for this whole mess" way.

The prospect of all those laws potentially being enforced and cheaply on the whim of the government really lays bare how bad our laws are in their totality.

But people are not capable of confronting the tough compromise of giving up the laws for things they like so here we are screeching about this easy button that law enforcement has at its disposal.

cucumber3732842··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
All of the government is the state but not all of the state is the govenrment.
cucumber3732842··on Crypto Capture of Foreign Aid
This. All the perverted incentives and money wasting inefficiency of federal grant funded local projects but for poor brown people half a world away.
cucumber3732842··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
First off your argument is just the "women in the workforce will make us all richer" argument but with Epstein island demographics of women.

Second, I wasn't even looking at it on that level. I was just looking at the high level economics. I'm saying that it takes certain amount of material plenty to get a kid from vagina to workforce. You've got food, clothing, the labor of educators, etc, etc, etc. None of that is free. Current foster care system costs do not scale. Our society is simply not wealthy enough to afford that for any sizable fraction of children. You could perhaps cheapen it up but I don't see much potential there since the outcomes are already sub par. You could perhaps make it more efficient, but what form would that take?

Unless we commit to walking back the standards of acceptable levels of investment in children by 70-100yr there's just no way rich western countries are gonna have more kids. Even if you pop them out of artificial wombs the whole rest of the "infant to workforce" pipeline is a mess.

cucumber3732842··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
>Signing away your rights/responsibility to the child and leaving your embryos to be "birthed" and raised by the state could replace many abortions.

For a given quality of "output" at age 18 it takes a certain amount of input to get there, at least at a macro level.

Even assuming that you can figure something out that doesn't suck and produce way to high of a ratio of shitty non-productive people the way the current foster care system does, where is the surplus that the state can seize to raise these kids gonna come from?

cucumber3732842··on America's Largest Producer of Coal Is Operating Under an Expired Permit
It was an "innocent typo" designed for perfect rage bait.
cucumber3732842··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
>careful, we have a very intelligent individual over here

If you want to take it as a well deserved slight in your direction that's fine but the point was the opposite. Just about anyone can make the insight I did. You don't have to be a genius to see what's going on here.

>do you mean the US government?

It's one of many dozens on the list.

cucumber3732842··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
>This is the primary worry with governments getting involved with dating apps, is it not?

<insert bad faith comment about how it's ok because they're not literally sterilizing anyone and you can opt out of you want>

(bonus points if it's from an account that has a bunch of comments whining about interface defaults and algorithmic nudges matter in technical contexts)

cucumber3732842··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
You'll have to do that over the dead bodies of everyone who benefits from all those things being expensive.

That's a lot of bodies.

cucumber3732842··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
>That’s an irrational reaction, probably conditioned by ideology.

And yours isn't?

Like it doesn't take much beyond a room temperature IQ to look at the arc of just about every government these days and make an estimation of where it's going without some substantial unforeseen change of course. The state of the world should merit a little pause and/or self doubt there.

>A well-run state has been perhaps one of the most successful enabling factors for human flourishing in human history.

Historically the states that have dabbled in this area of policy area has been "well run" in only the most dishonest "they accomplished their short term goals" sense of the phrase.

cucumber3732842··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
There's plenty of other motivators.

I give it about a month before they start gaming the algorithm to pair people who are likely to be on government benefits with people who can support them.

You make $150k, congratulations all your matches are McDonalds crew members.

You make $200k, the same but now they're all mentally ill because the algorithm deems you capable of supporting thyat too.

cucumber3732842··on How Singapore's government-run dating service works
>t's hard to see how they could do a _worse_ job

Spending a couple decades with the government putting it's thumb on the scale trying to get people who score high on government metrics to pair up with other people who score high on government metrics seems like a great way to start a civil war a couple generations down the line.

But I'm sure the marriages will be stable all the way there so there's that.

cucumber3732842··on Automatic Transmission – a data-privacy study of connected vehicles
Half of it. And the easy half not the hard half.
cucumber3732842··on Automatic Transmission – a data-privacy study of connected vehicles
More like "we can't prove he's driving in a way we like so we'll make him pay more for insurance"
cucumber3732842··on Automatic Transmission – a data-privacy study of connected vehicles
> Is my insurance going raise my rates because my vehicle won't provide telemetry for them to buy?

They will do it and some sneering POS in the comments will defend the practice.

cucumber3732842··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
>[1](https://www.thepsmiths.com/p/review-aztecs-by-inga-clendinne...)

"Starbucks-and-airport-lounges class" is a good phrase. I'm gonna use that one.

cucumber3732842··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
It was probably more like "I have committed treason and burned the ships we arrived on, the only way any of us are getting out of here alive is if we bring back so much gold they can't be angry"

The dude was beyond in over his head but somehow pulled it off.

cucumber3732842··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
>mass-suffering caused by systemic collapse

As opposed to slow burn suffering caused by living under a poor exploitative system? Say nothing of the opportunity cost...

It's not like bronze age societies had invented peaceful power transitions between fundamentally opposed factions. Whatever state they were stuck in they were there until a regime change, if you're lucky that'll only kill a few people at the top. But most societies aren't that lucky.

>- On longer scales, stability wins. Collapse should be treated as a hard failure, not a mechanic.

Japan was stable for a hell of a long time. Not hard to imagine had they been located somewhere slightly different in the world they'd have wound up slaves to some random European power. Stability works until you get into a local maximum you can't get out of A lot of those local maximums you are not getting out of except over the dead bodies of whoever benefits from them (see also: US civil war), if you're lucky. If you're unlucky you get subjugated by someone else.

cucumber3732842··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
I think it's hard to overstate just how categorical a difference in organizational and social doctrine the Spanish were away from the Aztecs. Everything from tactics to logistics train to how the soldiers are motivated. Look at the European wars of colonizing Africa in the 19th century if you want to see how that plays out when they meet in the field.

Like put the Black Prince up against Alexander and even Alexander has a uphill battle. Now take away Alexander's cavalry and give the Black Prince primitive firearms. Unless Alexander gets the jump on him or finds a way to make the meeting of forces otherwise highly unequal, that battle is probably only going one way, and that's for forces of comparable motivation levels.

The numbers disparity only gets you so far ancient empires generally lack the social sophistication to motivate soldiers (especially when recruited from their possessions/allies) to the degree that more modern societies do. Those Aztec conscripts who have been "voluntold" into service by their communities at best are not going to fight to the bloody end. They do not consider themselves citizens of "The Aztec Empire". They are not going to march to their near certain deaths for the benefit of the empire like they're some Red Army machine gun squad piling into a rowboat to cross the Volga in 1941. They can not even have the mental framework for that because a pre-industrial society does not run enough surplus for the state to do the things it must to create that in more than a "kings guard" sized force.

Edit: For a comparison point, the Romans are "a level up" from a lot (but not all) of the societies match up with and they just mop the floor with them. And consequently, anyone who doesn't get subjugated right off the bat winds up looking a lot like the Romans socially and militarily because that's what it takes to compete with them. The Aztecs are competing with borderline stone age societies. They are essentially a bronze age society that's mastered the art of subjugating stone age societies. Spain is half a dozen or so levels up from that. So while the outcome wasn't guaranteed it shouldn't really surprise anyone that the kind of force that Spain can project across an ocean and beat what the Aztecs can field in their own back yard.

cucumber3732842··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
>Time and time again in the history of the region a king, pharaoh, or other despot would make examples of rebels, put down rebels, and march armies up and down the region to ensure fealty and assign minor lords to protect a region. They could have found the smelters and destroyed them or seized them, those working on it could have been killed.

And when all those rebellions cost the Pharaoh 3x what they used to to put down you're forced to be a lot more diplomatic. Less extraction under threat of violence means smaller army means worse negotiating position for the next one. It's a cycle.

And for every full scale armies meeting in the field type rebellion there's a lot of "sir a second village has lynched the tax men" which compel you to dispense policing forces, etc, etc.

Just because you "can" do something in moderation doesn't mean it's a sustainable way to run your empire at scale.

You can't "just regulate the smiths" like some 21st century despot because those smiths also make the iron tools those people need to farm to pay your taxes. And you can't just "supervise" them with your loyal people because this is pre-industrial and there do not exist sufficient surpluses to feed those nonproductive mouths.

cucumber3732842··on Why the Bronze Age Collapsed
>Iron weapons aren't any better than bronze ones

"Quantity has a quality all its own"

cucumber3732842··on Cities Forced to Funnel License Plate Data to Federal Surveillance Program
This is dark side of the "grants with strings" taxes->federal->state->local money flow that the overwhelmingly prevailing sentiment here is to cheer for when it's being used in ways people like.
← PreviousPage 10 of 34Next →