HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

cynicalkane

6,541 karma · joined October 11, 2009

submissionscomments
cynicalkane··on The the the the induction of jamais vu: word alienation and semantic satiation
No, but https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_and_the_English_Langu... is a good essay on the use of propaganda to destroy language, and the natural process with which it's bought into.
cynicalkane··on Sam Altman is not on YC's board. So why claim to be its chair?
It's worth noting that `dang` is one of the people who noted the evolution happening.
cynicalkane··on The Age of Rage: Why Are People Are So Angry?
This point of view is not supported by anthropological evidence.

I'll give an example. In the 90s and 00s, there was a wave of Marxist attempts to cancel anthropologists who had reported on the competition for dominance, competition for status, physical and sexual violence, and overall strife present in primitive societies that were studied. The whole affair about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Darkness_in_El_Dorado is the most famous example of this. The accusations were largely discredited, but the damage was done. One consequence is that unsympathetic anthropologists were banned from Venezuela, where there is now nobody allowed to report on the slow, systematic extermination of the country's indigenous peoples.

The reduction of certain evils to economic essentialism is frequently itself a tool to assert ideological superiority--itself an 'antisocial behavior', one done not for money or profit but for the simple desire to feel superior to another, and excuse the evils of their in-group. In an ironic way, the above post is its own counterexample.

cynicalkane··on AlphaFold 3 predicts the structure and interactions of life's molecules
What always struck me about Chomskyists is that they chose a notion of interpretable model that required unrealistic amounts of working interpretation. So Chomsky grammars have significant polynomial memory and computational costs for grammars as they approach something resembling human grammar. And you say, ok, the human brain can handle much more computation than that, and that's fine. But (for example) context-free grammars aren't just O(n^3) in computational cost; for a realistic description of human language they're O(n^3) in human-interpretable rules.

Other Chomsky-like models of human grammars have different asymptotic behavior and different choices of n, but the same fundamental problem; the big-O constant factor isn't neurons firing but rather human connections between the n inputs. How can you conceive of human minds being able to track O(n^3) (or whatever) cost where that n is everything being communicated -- words, concepts, symbols, representations, all that jazz and the polynomial relationships between them?

But I feel an apology is in order: I've had quite a few beers before coming home, and it's probably a mistake to try to express academically charged and difficult views on the Internet while in an inebriated state. Probably the alcohol has substantially decreased my mental computational power. However, it has only mildly impaired my ability to string together words and sentences in a grammatically complex fashion. In fact, I often feel that the more sober and clear-minded I am, the simpler my language is. Maybe human grammar is actually sub-polynomial. I have observed the same in ChatGPT; the more flowery and wordy it has become over time, the dumber its output.

cynicalkane··on Nestlé adds sugar to infant milk sold in poorer countries, report finds
This link is about a Chinese company that isn't Nestlé and only affected Nestlé products in trace amounts.
cynicalkane··on A new phase of matter: Physicists show non-Abelian anyons in quantum processor
As a former math-head, let me chime in. The parent poster is probably not looking for an explanation of what exchange operators are, which are rather abstract and uninteresting in a physical vacuum, but rather how they are related to physical reality.

I’ve learned a lot about both and still am not sure why exchange operators and physical meaning are related. Why does the fermion care if you do an exchange operator to it? I get that fields of fermions demand that behavior but it still feels abstract.

cynicalkane··on Japan to introduce six-month residency visa for 'digital nomads'
> I know for a fact there are FAANG employees that do it today.

The fact that many companies are risk-averse and don't allow it doesn't mean it's not legal. Like I said, at least one FAANG (maybe more) is fine with its employees working remote internationally if they follow the rules.

cynicalkane··on Japan to introduce six-month residency visa for 'digital nomads'
There's digital nomads everywhere, and it's not hard to do legally under tourist visas. I know for a fact there are FAANG employees who do it today -- companies who would certainly shut that down if it was illegal.

There are legal gotchas and grey areas. I would guess the Japan visa is aimed at clarifying the matter for long stays, because there's certainly no shortage of digital nomads in Japan.

cynicalkane··on What Happened to David Graeber?
I suspect you actually found good factual critiques, but decided to label them "quibbles".

The Fed issues the modern world's most important debt instrument, and has a structure and purpose that Graeber gets fundamentally wrong. The reason critics focus on this is that, if he's lazy and wrong about the modern world's most important debt instrument... in a book about "debt"... it's probably a good sign you can't trust the rest of the book.

cynicalkane··on Mathematicians Found 12,000 Solutions to the Notoriously Hard Three-Body Problem
This isn't why. You can always use a convenient Taylor series to approximate cosine anything to arbitrary precision. For the three-body problem, small changes to initial conditions diverge into incalculably chaotic behavior.
cynicalkane··on Why decline in generalists leads to disjointed games and harms tool quality
I think this is also interesting in the direction of the OP's opinion. The new Zelda, for all its AAA chops, has in its main storyline the writing and directing of a bafflingly terrible anime. Incongruously, the story concept itself is compelling, and the scriptwriting for the game's many side characters is verbose (conventionally for Zelda) but otherwise cromulent.

I kind of wonder if something internal happened that the original article is describing. Side NPCs are designed by game designers, so probably written by them or people close to them. The game's concept is probably worked on closely with the top people in charge. But for the main story's execution, one might imagine there's no organizational requirement that the guys in charge have to have a clue how to write or direct a game or even any clue how to write or direct at all.

cynicalkane··on Why decline in generalists leads to disjointed games and harms tool quality
I think this harmoniousness operates in more subtle ways, too. I'm playing through the new Zelda game, Tears of the Kingdom, and it's a lot of fun, but there's something that doesn't quite click... like the UI is a behavorial engagement layer over the game, and not part of the game itself. Like you can never be completely in the world because something outside is holding your hand all the way.

The 16- through 64- bit Zeldas, for their clunkiness, were compellingly immersive. I don't think it's just nostalgia; I've played indie games where the UI is part of a whole that sucks you in. This is true even if the UI has a modern feel, like Hollow Knight, which felt overpolished in its presentation and interface, to me at least, in a way that was off-kilter -- yet something about it sucks you in instead of pulling you out, being part of the world's presentation and in an aesthetically transitive sense part of the world itself. There's something about these modern AAA games where you feel like you're not playing a game but rather a Skinner box containing a game. It's just not the same. I can't exactly put my finger on it.

cynicalkane··on Apocalypse Proof: 33 Thomas Street in New York City
In my experience, conspiracy theorists don't have a lot of interest in these. Unprovable conspiracy theories are more interesting because it affirms their sense of paranoia, identity, feeling special, entitlement to the truth.

Conspiracy theorists might go on and on about JFK or 9/11 or Pizzagate, but how often do you hear the conspiracy type obsess about Jan. 6, an actual proven conspiracy to overthrow the government of the United States? The "proven" conspiracy theories they do care about, like MKUltra, are generally cast as far more consequential than most people would say they actually are.

cynicalkane··on AWS: IPv4 addresses cost too much, so you’re going to pay
Standard SLAAC only uses 64-bit prefixes. This is a problem if you want subnets and have an uncooperative ISP handing out 64-bit prefixes. Or maybe you have a /48 or /56 but want a nice readable hierarchy of subnets.

You don't even need 64 bits. IIRC with SLAAC you send NDP messages to the entire broadcast domain. So you need broadcast-domain-sized (i.e., small) device counts on every data-link-layer subnet. So why assign /64? But because some devices won't give up if SLAAC routers aren't there and and some mysteriously default to SLAAC when they shouldn't and in fact some devices only use it, now every bottom level subnet has to be /64. Blech.

This is just one of many IPv6 annoyances that don't even need to exist.

cynicalkane··on Google’s AI-powered ‘inclusive warnings’ feature is very broken
This entire comment is a lie. Terms like "motherboard" are readily findable on Google's internal search. I could not find anything referencing a banned non-inclusive words policy in the employee policy guide. I have never heard of anything remotely resembling someone catching heat for saying "motherboard" or whatever.

Source: I also work at Google.

cynicalkane··on David Graeber’s Possible Worlds
I actually followed the Graeber-DeLong argument when it broke, and found Graeber to be quite unhinged. In one tweet I found memorable, he accuses DeLong of "war crimes" -- presumably for supporting free trade or neoliberal economics or something[1]. At other points he threatened legal action.

But it doesn't matter, really. Graeber knew the target audience on HN wasn't aware of the debate--why would most of them be aware? He expected the audience to simply accept his greatness without evidence.

[1] https://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/304604741126721536

cynicalkane··on David Graeber’s Possible Worlds
The point is issuance of American debt, and the Fed's role in it, is not privately controlled, neither in fact or in essence. Saying otherwise is an obvious lie in both senses.
cynicalkane··on David Graeber’s Possible Worlds
American debt is issued entirely by Congress and the Treasury, and its monetization controlled by the Fed's Board of Governors, which is appointed by the government and independently operated. There's no means of control over these two things outside the U.S. government. There's also the FOMC, but this is relatively unessential such that it's unlikely to be related to whatever "essential truth" Graeber has in mind. In particular, they don't set monetary policy but do whatever the Board of Governors orders in that regard.
cynicalkane··on David Graeber’s Possible Worlds
To name just one of Graeber's essential lies: he makes the claim that Federal Reserve issuing American debt is privately controlled and weaves an extensive chapter based in fundamental ways on this misapprehension. This is a lie that's not "minor" nor "a matter of interpretation" nor unrelated to the "character of the book or arguments within": it's a fundamental misapprehension of the most important debt instrument in modern history (perhaps all history). In a book about debt in history.

I don't really care too much for Graeber's self-important response. If the answer is, yes, Graeber's entitled to say what he wants because people celebrate and have conferences about him, and those who disagree are implied to be beneath him... well, the brazen self-importance is so astonishing that I can't rightly understand how one can agree with that degree of self-importance so directly presented, especially when it comes paired with no actual defense of his statements -- not even a link.

Statements of the form "I'm right because I'm important, and that's all I need to say" are not usually tolerated from almost anyone as a substitute for basic, bare truths. That they are accepted here is not only a comment on the character of Graeber but on the character of his followers.

cynicalkane··on David Graeber’s Possible Worlds
I want to add to the above comment. Graeber's lack of integrity and disregard for facts should cast a shadow of mistrust over his other work, not to mention his explosive reaction on being called out for it.

If you can't trust someone's writings on facts you know about, why trust them on facts you don't know about? One of the essential things to understand when taking in information is to first understand: is this information trustworthy?

I see the above as clear evidence Graeber is not only untrustworthy but explicitly seems to feel he has the right to be so. Worse yet, he writes from the perspective of an expert on economic anthropology, but has taken a position where very basic facts of that field are beyond his ken. Not because of a lack of intellect or understanding, but because he has taken that position on purpose.

And now I see so many people on a site for hackers and technology celebrating someone's ideas without first wondering if those ideas are even factually correct and it puzzles me how we ended up here. Discussion about the factual correctness of Graeber's ideas, or the trustworthiness of his perspective and person, seems to be actively discouraged.

cynicalkane··on Google's infamous internal 2010 “I just want to serve 5TB” video now public
Assuming this is sarcasm, you realize Google has a massive userbase all over the globe from all walks of life, right? Does it make business sense to accidentally exclude certain people? Or ethical sense?
cynicalkane··on Apple acquires classical music streaming service Primephonic
I kind of disagree with this. For the post-Beethoven era, sure, but the standard way of playing Beethoven and before tends to be heavily biased towards an uninformed modern idea of what classical music "should" be, which is stodgy, slow, smooth, heavily refined, overcooked with crescendoes and decrescendos, and quite inauthentic. Almost as though it's shameful for music to be immediate and exciting at the risk of being unrefined. If you compare Furtwängler's[1] Beethoven symphonies to Christopher Hogwood's... one sounds like music for wealthy old people at a concert hall. The other sounds like music. (Don't get me started on the routine butchering of Bach...)

But that's just my opinion. The point is it really pays to try different conductors, performers and performances before the 1830s or so. I'm not sure why that time changes things, but I'd guess the romantic style that came after more closely aligns with artsy-fartsy performance practices, and that composers also became more careful about marking how their works should be performed. Anyway, trying different things is also a good exercise in developing personal taste, which is a key ingredient of music appreciation.

[1] I originally had von Karajan here, but I went back to have a listen and it wasn't as bad as I remembered. Substituted Furtwängler's inexplicably famous recordings, which sound like the entire orchestra took Valium: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3bOxcryX1VE . Compare to Beethoven's recommended tempo and historical style: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Y07M8e5g-Y

cynicalkane··on New exotic matter particle, a tetraquark, discovered at CERN
Spoilers.

There are a few parts of the book, according to the translator, that are done in the manner of a Chinese folktale, which he tried to translate to a different style in English. I'm no expert, but I got the impression the sophont chapter was in this category. It has this otherworldly silliness with the multiple attempts to create a sophont going wrong in different dimensions, calculated to fit the repetitive pattern of a fairy tale.

I think the thrust, which might be hard to read in translation, is this: we can't imagine the technology a superior alien species would come up with, so it's related as a fairy tale beyond technological realism.

Anyway, I doubt it was meant to be hard sci-fi.

cynicalkane··on The Most Dangerous Censorship
> You can cite 100 studies, when you start to argue that women drop out of high stress jobs because they're neurotic you might as well commit seppuku.

I mean, you could characterize this as a problematic presentation, but I'm not sure I'd say presentation is the problem with that sort of statement.

cynicalkane··on Life as a public school teacher in the San Francisco Bay Area in 2021
The system giving these rules is set up so the two are indistinguishable. Some people can't even tell the difference. Others can, but they keep quiet so their career isn't destroyed.
cynicalkane··on Washington state approves capital gains tax
Real estate has a powerful lobby and many property owners are well-connected themselves. A lot of people own property and don't see it as free money. They empathize with property owners. Though it's easier money if you're politically connected and/or already wealthy.

Stocks are held by rich people and techbros, in the minds of the public. Whether something is valuable or not valuable depends on who you empathize with. Right now occupations held by the wealthy are disliked and unpopular.

Really you should just tax income at high rates and investment at near-0%. When people cash out their investments, tax them at ordinary income rates. This is how your 401(k) or IRA already works. You'll need to raise taxes on the affluent who spend instead of save, but that's not a bad thing.

cynicalkane··on Qurt: The ancient road snack of Central Asian nomads
Tolkien both claimed that LOTR was allegorical and that it wasn't. Probably he was using the common definition of allegory in one context and the literary definition in the other.

When Tolkien said he disliked allegory, he meant he disliked literary works that map directly onto some external meaning that was necessary for understanding the story. He thought a story should stand on its own, and, further, it wasn't good writing to try to force a story into allegory rather than let it take its own direction. But we also know from his letters that he purposefully incorporated religious (specifically, Catholic) metaphors into LOTR, which most people would call allegory, including Tolkien on some occasions.

cynicalkane··on Tech’s flight from San Francisco is a relief to some advocates
It's your claim that it's "tech"'s job to solve these issues, rather than the city government, the people whose actual job it is to solve these issues?

Flush with extra cash from the taxes paid by "tech", to boot.

Like, what do you want here? Should "tech" appropriate a significant part of the government's job in addressing these issues? I'm sure you don't actually want that.

cynicalkane··on Get $15k to move to Michigan and work remotely
You have to tell your employer where you live for tax purposes. You can lie, but that’s called tax fraud.
cynicalkane··on Reading too much political news is bad for your well-being
That may be true in many times and places, but to be German, in the East of the country, through the period of the 20th century in which he lived -- politics was rather thrust upon you. And the politically literate and illiterate alike had rather more to fear than "multinational companies".
← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →