1,476 karma · joined February 25, 2016
https://gum.co/landingpagecookbook
Exactly. That's why your traffic lights example is puzzling to me? They're a notorious example of a case of something that can very easily be (and often is) ambiguous.
For every person who asks a question expecting (and deserving) a literal answer, there are dozens of ill-posed questions that require a clarifying preamble to get to any answer at all. It's better not to waste anybody's time.
Support people tend to be able to distinguish between the two pretty well, too. If you ask a precise syntax question, you'll have a precise answer. Ask a vague "do my homework" question, and expect people will ask for clarifications.
The parent's description of this as LARPing is eerily accurate.
I wish for once people on Hacker News didn't make sweeping statements about a profession that isn't theirs? Most good designers will recognize those are bad design choices.
Nobody's missing the "important point" because everybody who's been on Hacker News for five minutes has heard Paul Graham make that point. Indeed, people have made jokes about startup business plans for decades. Literally everyone knows that those things don't matter for super early stage startups.
The tweet, however, and very much like many of Paul Graham's latest essays and tweets, seems to purposely elude any context, make a very generic a debatable statement, and assert it with complete aplomb. For someone who just wrote an essay about putting ideas into words, if he can't see that this tweet will be interpreted as "balance sheets are useless", he needs to put in a bit more work.
That's what people react to, because the only conclusion is that since he doesn't want to tweet bromides, he must be trying to say something "controversial."
It's really bordering on trolling, which for a man with his age and reputation is kind of cringy, embarrassing, and frankly disappointing to people who enjoyed his past stuff.
[1] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motus_(jeu_t%C3%A9l%C3%A9vis%C...
P.S. Of course, most interesting stuff about humanity stems from the same problem...