HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

depr

900 karma · joined July 19, 2011

submissionscomments
depr··on Open letter to the NixOS foundation
The commit bit isn't about security, it's about control. There is no way open source projects can never give out commit bits again due to xz. And xz doesn't have an active team with multiple people in it so it doesn't really make sense to compare them.

Not sure what you are talking about wrt the dates. Why did you ignore the Meson example? And here is another example: https://mastodon.delroth.net/@delroth/112310645064859357 This is a guy who has implicit authority to veto anything. Sometimes he does so, and sometimes he just comments on something perhaps not necessarily intending to veto it but that is what happens anyway.

depr··on Open letter to the NixOS foundation
I don't see how forcing someone out means you lack the majority? I would say generally the opposite is true. The majority wants someone out and they are able to force them out.

>If you have the majority and leadership will not cede to your will, you fork the project and break away.

It's more likely that there is a majority BUT leadership does not cede and they hold the keys to the castle. It makes more sense to first try to remove the leadership. I would say this is in fact direct democratic action.

Some uses of "majority" can be disingenuous, because there is probably a large group of people that is indifferent to whether current leadership is forced out. They could be counted as not part of the majority that wants change. But they can just as well be counted for the other side.

depr··on Why I recommend Renovate over any other dependency update tools
When I tried it with Elixir around a year ago, it was pretty bad. Issues seemed to be caused by the fact that it parses the lockfile format, which is in Elixir, with Javascript. Dependabot doesn't have issues that (can) stem from that because it parses with Elixir code (so it doesn't have to reinvent reading Elixir maps).
depr··on How to found a company in Germany: 14 "easy" steps and lots of pain
As Weber observed, the free market requires a lot of bureaucracy.
depr··on Tool Use (function calling)
Funny how they all used millions (?) of texts, without permission, to base their models on, and if you want to train your own model based on theirs which only works because of texts they used for free, that is prohibited.
depr··on TinyMCE (also) moving from MIT to GPL
Do you mean CLA?

I said the same thing about the recent Redis change. Apparently, the old contributions are still under the old license, and new contributions will be GPL. Because the old license is MIT, those contributions can be incorporated in the new GPL version.

So there the old contributions are not relicensed and there is no need for it. If the old license were GPL and they wanted to move to e.g. BUSL, then they would have to ask all the contributors because GPL doesn't allow that.

depr··on Fundamentals of Object Storage in Elixir
I agree though I wouldn't say I hate Mox, rather I hate working with it (the things it does do it does well). As you say it forces you to do stupid stuff, like creating an interface for something with one implementation, but also the way you have to then add that to your configuration. I've also seen people only add "@callback" to modules, without any behaviour, because then it works with Mox.
depr··on Redis adopts dual source-available licensing
Can they do this? Open source contributions to their codebase were under a different license. They don't have the copyright for those contributions without a CLA (I can't find one). So how can they relicense those contributions?
depr··on Rolldown: Rollup compatible bundler written in Rust
One of the authors has contributed to SWC. I wonder what caused them to build an alternative.
depr··on The Erlang Runtime System
Erlang/OTP doesn't handle leader election, and by itself is bad at handling netsplits.

There is https://github.com/rabbitmq/ra which is a Raft implementation in Erlang that is Jepsen-tested. You could use it to build "etcd in Erlang", or https://github.com/rabbitmq/khepri which is built on top of Ra.

depr··on Mozilla names new CEO as it pivots to data privacy
Didn't Netscape create Firefox?
depr··on JetBrains CEO Transition
If job is job then you might as well stay at one
depr··on Jazelle DBX: Allow ARM processors to execute Java bytecode in hardware
Then it would be great if the existing conversation could be posted instead, similar to what 'icegreentea2 suggested.
depr··on Jazelle DBX: Allow ARM processors to execute Java bytecode in hardware
I think I've adequately explained what it is that bothers me about it, and it's not them getting points.
depr··on Jazelle DBX: Allow ARM processors to execute Java bytecode in hardware
Because this is a community and I care about what goes on in it. I think this is precisely not a thought-tangent, it is taking the tangent that occurred elsewhere and posting an article about it to score internet points. If we keep doing that, this becomes even more of an echo chamber and a very boring place.
depr··on Jazelle DBX: Allow ARM processors to execute Java bytecode in hardware
Popular content is not necessarily good content (very boring to say this, but just look at reddit). And posting articles to get upvotes, which I'm not saying this post is necessarily doing but at least _some_ are doing, leads to lower quality. HN barely has any methods for maintaining overall quality of the website and it will automatically degrade as it gets larger.

To simply allow these posts and having them hit the front page when they get upvotes is a valid position. But I think it contributes to a website that is less interesting.

I don't think these posts should be removed, but they should at least be frowned upon, and/or linked to the original comment thread.

depr··on Jazelle DBX: Allow ARM processors to execute Java bytecode in hardware
The trend of posting a page here based on some detail from a comment, that was posted in another thread ("What's that touchscreen in my room?" in this case) a few days ago, has become quite frequent and a bit annoying.

To everyone who wants to write: but I didn't read that thread and I find this quite interesting; you are free to find it interesting, but I did read about it 2 days ago and to me it looks like karma farming.

depr··on FAQ on Leaving Google
Doesn't that system of interviewers just bring different biases? Even if they use a standardized scoring method or something, the bias would be built into that. And everyone would indeed be held to the same, biased, standard.
depr··on You've just been fucked by psyops [video]
>There is something in psychology called the blue dot effect where people primed to find blue dots will start identifying purple and green as blue as well.

I am sure this is well-researched and reproducible, and generalizes to other concepts, like all the other biases "discovered" by academic researchers.

depr··on Figma and Adobe abandon proposed merger
>They involve the wealth of nations

Do they though? People often compare rich people or companies to a country GDP's, but GDP is based on a single year. The size of a company's bank account is not. A year is pretty arbitrary. In some sense it's like saying the distance between New York and Washington is 200 miles which is not that long, because a Ferrari's top speed is 200 mph.

depr··on What is meant by AI "safety"?
That is based only on what Altman himself says, I don't think that is sufficient for optimism.
depr··on I kind of killed Mercurial at Mozilla
Have they? It seems there's only one Google employee working on it.
depr··on OpenAI's employees were given two explanations for why Sam Altman was fired
What I meant is:

>I don't think we should be assessing pros or cons of economic systems based on whether people get to keep their money.

but earlier you said:

>They are also, for everything they buy, and everyone they employ, paying tax.

So if we should not assess the economic system based on whether people keep their money, i.e. pay tax, then why mention that they pay tax? It doesn't seem relevant.

depr··on OpenAI's employees were given two explanations for why Sam Altman was fired
>I don't share the assumption that people should only exist if they're a benefit.

Well it's not a matter of the people existing, it's whether they are rich or not. They can exist without the money.

Anyway, if you don't think it matters if they are of benefit, then why did you bring up the fact that they pay taxes?

depr··on OpenAI's employees were given two explanations for why Sam Altman was fired
What is your rule of thumb based on?

In, for example, the Netherlands the richest people pay less tax [0]. Do you think this is not the case in many other countries?

> They are also, for [..] they employ, paying tax

Is that a benefit of having rich people? If companies were employee-owned that tax would still be paid.

[0]: https://www.iamexpat.nl/expat-info/dutch-expat-news/wealthie...

depr··on OpenAI's employees were given two explanations for why Sam Altman was fired
So what is your belief about why they exist?
depr··on Sam Altman, Greg Brockman and others to join Microsoft
Changing stuff requires power. So as far as I can tell we agree. Executing objectives just sounds nicer.
depr··on U.S. agency declares 21 species now extinct
>suggests an individual who is pushing an agenda

>rationally appraising the current state

both are an agenda. You can't escape ideology.

depr··on Sam Altman, Greg Brockman and others to join Microsoft
"This guy doesn't care about money y'all...

He needs money to do big things and execute. He gets high on making big stuff happen."

So what you're saying is he cares about power.

depr··on Terraform Cloud Pricing Changes Sticker Shock
Did you end up running the free version, or some alternative?
← PreviousPage 3 of 10Next →