HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

discostrings

1,129 karma · joined February 26, 2012

submissionscomments
discostrings··on The Cold-Medicine Racket
The information asymmetry and confusion factor are worst in that all these products have just a few ingredients, in my opinion. While the branded/generic price difference is an important issue, I think a larger one is that the huge volume of products takes attention away from the fact that there are only a few basic components, leading many to buy inappropriate products or products with too many components that can cause side effects that could easily be avoided.

People without some prior knowledge of the basic drugs must have a very difficult time walking into a store and choosing the product with the drugs they need without some of the ones they don't. I imagine many people are totally overwhelmed by the product selection and they just pick something, which they then turn to each time they're feeling sick. It's more difficult than normal to perform an assessment of products at the store when you're sick, and the store presentation only makes things more difficult. Even knowing something about these products and knowing exactly what I want, I sometimes find it time-consuming to locate the single-ingredient products among all the endless combinations, especially when they're out of stock.

Things would be so much simpler if stores posted some type of reference. I'm not an expert in the field, but it's such a pet peeve of mine that I've memorized the basics. Here's a start:

  Fever/pain -> Relieve:
  ibuprofin
  acetaminophen [avoid if you have liver problems]
  naproxen
  aspirin

  Nasal congestion -> Reduce:
  pseudoephedrine [quite effective, but the pharmacy must be open; prepare to provide identification, sign, possibly be questioned / receive a dirty look, and have your purchase be entered into a federal database]
  phenelyphrine [of questionable effectiveness]

  Coughs -> Make more productive at clearing congestion:
  guaifenesin

  Coughs -> Suppress:
  dextromethorphan

  Trouble sleeping / allergic sensitivity -> Relieve:
  doxylamine [slightly better for sleeping than allergies]
  diphenhydramine [slightly better for allergies than sleeping]
The store could have a nice section of the products that contain just one of these drugs, making it easy to mix and match, with reference to the list.

I don't think there's anything inherently wrong with the combination products, but it really seems their general effect confuses rather than clarifies, which seems to me to be part of the reason for the design and proliferation.

The author of this piece seems to have similar feelings:

> ...I can't see myself using it, because I usually keep generic single-drug products around. A family, or a sickness-inclined person living alone, could very reasonably keep the five aforementioned individual generic medications in their medicine cabinet and address the symptoms as they arise. I think that's easier than messing with combination products, and usually cheaper. Especially if you consider that you're not taking medications you don't need.

> I tried to convince Angelotti that's the way to go, but she was adamant that many or even most people really like to take one pill that addresses all of their symptoms. "I don't know if people will be likely to have their own inventory of generic over-the-counter medications in their homes," she said.

I think a simple list like this, preferably easily visible in the store, and some better organization in stores would do people a much greater service than the app the article discusses.

discostrings··on After California decriminalized pot, teen arrest, overdose, dropout rates fell
> We legally mandate airbags, abs, esr, and a host of other safety features in cars ... you simply don't have the option to turn off ...

That's incorrect. New cars can't be sold without some of these safety features, but as far as I'm aware, there's no law preventing a buyer from dismantling them. I think that's an important difference--it's one thing to regulate what a large industry can sell, but a completely different thing to regulate someone's activities with their own property.

discostrings··on The Surveillance Engine: How the NSA Built Its Own Secret Google
I had suspicions of foul play involving surveillance-related stories getting buried in the past, but after a discussion with dang, I think it's quite plausibly just a difficult topic to moderate with the tools that are available on HN. [0]

If no automatic moderation was applied, the front page would be filled with surveillance stories--many of which contain no real new information. So there's an automatic penalty. And it appears there's not a moderator who's following the surveillance story closely, so it can be difficult for them to determine what's newsworthy.

The system is clearly somewhat broken, but I don't think it's due to bad intent. You can help by flagging stories that add no value, and you can email hn@ycombinator.com if you see a major story that is being penalized unfairly [1].

I think the mods are trying, but the system here wasn't really built to gracefully handle a topic that the community is so passionate about like this. Or even to communicate what's going on with moderation. I know a lot of us here naturally speculate about systems and like to get into them and improve them, but I'm fairly convinced that the best approach, at least at the moment and outside of new moderation tools, is an email to the moderators when stories shouldn't be penalized.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8059068

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8065601

discostrings··on Visualizing language usage in New York Times news coverage
Mrs. vs Ms. is even better with "Miss" as well: http://chronicle.nytlabs.com/?keyword=mrs.miss.ms
discostrings··on Visualizing language usage in New York Times news coverage
Perhaps non-mathematical usage of "equation" in phrases like "entered the equation" and "wasn't part of the equation" has been increasing?

I certainly hear it in conversation often enough, but I've never taken note of how frequently it's written.

discostrings··on Ask HN Mods: Why Do You Completely Change What Users Submit?
Thank you for the detailed explanation of what happened to the post and your thoughts on the topic in general. I'm happy to hear that what's been going on with some of the bigger surveillance stories is the result of the difficulties of moderation and not external manipulation. I now have a greater understanding of why efforts to stop the topic from dominating the site end up supressing it.

As it seems you noticed, my main frustration is that surveillance stories with new information, and other particularly insightful pieces about the topic, often aren't staying on the front page, which essentially means that no one sees or discusses them at any level of depth. HN is generally so good at what it does that for most topics of interest to the community, it can be one's daily news source for an overview of what's going on. Readers come to expect that topics that interest HN will be covered well and that important developments will be posted. So it's particularly jarring after reading tech-related news only from HN for a few days to see you missed a major surveillance story, especially one that deals with the tech or tools. When you search HN and see you missed it because it was submitted but probably buried before anyone discussed it, you start feeling that moderators are parting ways with the community or that something sinister is going on.

I think a number of other difficulties arise as a result of the major stories not showing up. I imagine users start getting the sense that an important topic isn't being discussed, so they submit and upvote even more "me-too" stories. On the stories that do make it, people don't bother writing long and substantive comments because of the risk of the post dropping to oblivion at any moment and no one ever seeing the comment. Those who know a lot about the topic become less likely to write about it insightfully here, increasing the noise further and giving the topic a worse reputation for quality.

How to improve things is a difficult questions, as this topic's scenario really doesn't play to the site's strengths. It seems there's really no feature for "best-of-a-type" other than penalties.

Never-the-less, here are a few ideas (some of which are assuredly overly vague or simplistic, but since I don't know which might be helpful...): - Consideration could be given to how many surveillance stories are currently on the front page. Very few people want an entire front page filled with these stories every day, but given the level of interest and the continuing developments one would still expect to see a number of stories every day or two. Maybe only resort to giving a penalty to an article that isn't obviously low quality / blogspam if there are already surveillance stories on the front page?

- Using heuristics concerning novelty, and whether the particular novel issue has been discussed on HN, could supplement length

----- A quick check of whether the article claims it's new information, the date of the article, and a general search for the main claim of the article

----- Less scrutiny of publications with a history of breaking stories or that have access to documents, like theguardian.com, firstlook.org, washingtonpost.com, and spiegel.de

- A way to know a topic isn't going to quickly disappear after investing time in writing a comment would be nice. Some indicator that a topic has been "blessed" by a mod and won't receive a penalty would be helpful for this.

- Having a moderator who follows the topic might be helpful. I definitely understand that not every moderator does, and that it's probably really hard to make judgments if you're not following it. Someone a bit more familiar with the topic would be a good resource and could keep an eye out for sub-optimal penalties being given out.

- In general, visible transparency about what's going on would be helpful. I'm not sure how to achieve that because the site's not really designed for it. Talking to you here is great. Having other people with the same concerns get the information is important too.

- The root issue isn't really that interest in the topic is too high--it's that there's a low signal-to-noise ratio in the stories that are submitted and the passion for the topic is so high that even the noise is upvoted. Some users probably want to make sure everyone knows what's going on. Once a normal level of the best stories are making the front page and there's an outlet for that passion, perhaps the submission problem will decrease and a virtuous cycle will begin.

I'll email first in the future for anything I'd like a response about or if I have more suggestions--I took the comment approach because in the case of a forum or many other online communities, it would be better to have the conversation publicly, but I agree that HN's not really set up well for that (as evidenced by my multiple requests for a response).

Again, I'm grateful for your response, and I greatly appreciate the work you're doing here and your commitment to addressing users' concerns.

discostrings··on Ask HN Mods: Why Do You Completely Change What Users Submit?
Could you comment about how the item was buried shortly after the changes?

If it wasn't buried by a mod, then either the penalty that's applied to surveillance stories is incredibly enormous, or the story was flagged into oblivion by users. Did flagging only start after the title and link were changed? Isn't that quite suspicious? It really looks like someone's doing title/domain/url monitoring for stories to flag, and this story is a good candidate for examination.

I guess I'd just like confirmation that 1) mods didn't bury the story, and 2) it doesn't look like flagging suddenly increased after the change. If flagging did suddenly increase, it would be strong evidence of flagging abuse. There's no explanation for flagging the second story and not the first, other than failure to detect it automatically. In fact, you would expect the exact opposite pattern if the story were being flagged legitimately.

Thanks.

discostrings··on Ask HN Mods: Why Do You Completely Change What Users Submit?
The title was "U.K. Intelligence Agency's Ability to Manipulate Online Polls, Etc.", which notably doesn't include words that would trigger automated alerts if someone with an agenda that involved flagging surveillance stories had set them up somehow.
discostrings··on Ask HN Mods: Why Do You Completely Change What Users Submit?
If would also be great if you could provide some information about whether the link change set off a flurry of user flagging. From the outside look of things, the change of domain appeared to set off someone's alert to have a bunch of accounts flag the story. Either that, or a single flag is extremely powerful. I suppose a lot of people could be extremely prejudiced against certain domains, but it appeared something more organized was going on. Some insight into how flagging suddenly started and buried the story shortly after the change would be nice. Thanks in advance.
discostrings··on Ask HN Mods: Why Do You Completely Change What Users Submit?
It's probably people flagging it and not the mods, yes. But are the people flagging it actual users?

The story in question here had 200 upvotes when it was a link to an NSA story at Slate. The link was changed to the same, source NSA story at First Look and it was quickly flagged to oblivion. I think there're likely some monitoring scripts and flag alerts at play, not just NSA fatigue by actual users.

discostrings··on Ask HN Mods: Why Do You Completely Change What Users Submit?
No one cared because it was quickly buried, which could quite possibly be due to a flag ring or automated monitoring for flagging of the firstlook.org domain. Here's my other comment on the topic [~]:

It would be incredibly easy to use this sort of program to game visibility on HN.

This story itself serves as the perfect example. When it was submitted four days ago [0], it quickly took a huge ranking hit and dropped off the front page. When a story drops off the front page this quickly, it's nearly impossible for it to get the upvote momentum required to gain any additional visibility. And the same URL can't be submitted again, so the opportunity for discussion of the article has essentially been removed.

Then, we're left discussing a breaking story as the top item four days later, when a summary report about the original story that contains no new information is published on Slate.

One might be quick to blame moderators, but in the discussion of another recent First Look story, dang said most of the penalty came from users flagging the story. [1] How many users flagging the story does it take to produce this outcome? Does GCHQ just need three accounts with a little karma to seriously diminish visibility here for days? Safeguards should be developed to prevent this sort of malicious activity. Maybe some sort of collusion penalty, where if the same users are flagging the same stories, the effect is diminished? Or a greater restriction on the maximum penalty?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8031791

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8008472

EDIT: And it's happened again! This story was #1 when the link was to [3]. About a half hour ago, the link was changed to firstlook.org, and within minutes, the story fell to the center of the main page. Now, thirty minutes later, it's at number 47 (with 200 points after six hours). It was at the top for hours, then dropped to 47 within thirty minutes of the link being changed. The fact that flagging happened right after the link was changed seriously suggests that some someone has automated monitoring for First Look links to flag.

[3] http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/07/15/documents...

[~] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8053852

discostrings··on Ask HN Mods: Why Do You Completely Change What Users Submit?
I think the penalty levels for flagging seriously need to be looked at, and some measures to prevent flag rings and other malicious flagging should to be put into place.

The story this thread refers to is the perfect example: it was #1 with 200 upvotes after just a few hours. The link was then changed to a different domain that covered the topic in more depth, and the story was suddenly buried within a half hour--apparently by flagging. How was the first link so popular and the second link inappropriate for discussion when the topic was the same? Either some users are just very prejudiced against certain domains, or there are some users and/or organizations that have automated systems in place to detect certain domains or links and send alerts to bury them.

discostrings··on Ask HN Mods: Why Do You Completely Change What Users Submit?
Here's a comment of mine from that thread explaining what he posted, how it changed, and what happened [~]:

This story was in the first position on the front page less than an hour ago. It was there for hours. The link was then changed from [0] to [1], and within thirty minutes, it was on the second page at number 47. (It first took a drop to around 17, hovered there for a while, then hit 47.)

Could we have an explanation of what's going on here? How can penalties from flagging be this steep for a story with 200 upvotes and 90 comments? Why did the position suddenly change shortly after the link was changed, but not right away?

[0] http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/07/15/documents...

[1] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/07/14/manipulating-o...

[~] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8054173

discostrings··on Hacking Online Polls and Other Ways British Spies Seek to Control the Internet
This story was in the first position on the front page less than an hour ago. It was there for hours. The link was then changed from [0] to [1], and within thirty minutes, it was on the second page at number 47. (It first took a drop to around 17, hovered there for a while, then hit 47.)

Could we have an explanation of what's going on here? How can penalties from flagging be this steep for a story with 200 upvotes and 90 comments? Why did the position suddenly change shortly after the link was changed, but not right away?

[0] http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/07/15/documents...

[1] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/07/14/manipulating-o...

discostrings··on Hacking Online Polls and Other Ways British Spies Seek to Control the Internet
It would be incredibly easy to use this sort of program to game visibility on HN.

This story itself serves as the perfect example. When it was submitted four days ago [0], it quickly took a huge ranking hit and dropped off the front page. When a story drops off the front page this quickly, it's nearly impossible for it to get the upvote momentum required to gain any additional visibility. And the same URL can't be submitted again, so the opportunity for discussion of the article has essentially been removed.

Then, we're left discussing a breaking story as the top item four days later, when a summary report about the original story that contains no new information is published on Slate.

One might be quick to blame moderators, but in the discussion of another recent First Look story, dang said most of the penalty came from users flagging the story. [1] How many users flagging the story does it take to produce this outcome? Does GCHQ just need three accounts with a little karma to seriously diminish visibility here for days? Safeguards should be developed to prevent this sort of malicious activity. Maybe some sort of collusion penalty, where if the same users are flagging the same stories, the effect is diminished? Or a greater restriction on the maximum penalty?

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8031791

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8008472

EDIT: And it's happened again! This story was #1 when the link was to [3]. About a half hour ago, the link was changed to firstlook.org, and within minutes, the story fell to the center of the main page. Now, thirty minutes later, it's at number 47 (with 200 points after six hours). It was at the top for hours, then dropped to 47 within thirty minutes of the link being changed. The fact that flagging happened right after the link was changed seriously suggests that some someone has automated monitoring for First Look links to flag.

[3] http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_tense/2014/07/15/documents...

discostrings··on Has goto fail been fixed yet?
> unconscionable makes it sound like it's more irresponsible than the industry standard - when in fact it is less.

> Yes, I agree that's a stupid call to make, but most smartphones have far worse unpatched vulnerabilities.

That's why Apple's response here is so interesting: it's much more common for smartphones to have serious and known unpatched vulnerabilities than it is for desktop and server operating systems to have them.

It's expected that a smartphone might go unpatched for a while, but the industry standard is that a desktop or server operating system should receive a patch for an extremely severe security vulnerability almost immediately.

Why Apple has chosen to ignore and invert that expectation is unclear. Was there an active, seriously damaging attack against iOS that they thought needed to be stopped right away, despite the cost to OS X users? Did they look at the install base and decide patching iOS first would have a larger impact? Is their development process for OS X not up to the task? Do they just care a lot more about their consumer electronics than their computers?

Then there's the question of why they published the details of the iOS patch before publishing a patch for OS X. Perhaps they rushed to patch iOS when they discovered the vulnerability without realizing that OS X is affected as well? The situation raises a lot of questions--while I'm not sure that what has happened is unconscionable yet (rather than merely extremely incompetent but well-intentioned), it's still an open question, and it's certainly possible.

discostrings··on Samsung announces Galaxy S5
I'm happy to see that Samsung has stuck with the design philosophy of its previous Galaxy S-series flagships.

In a world where other manufacturers of high-end mobile devices have adopted a unibody, no-replaceable battery, no-storage expansion approach, it's nice that Samsung sees the value of a device that works for users who like expansion possibilities and who don't really care about the added expense of shiny metal. They're serving a huge market that other mobile device designers are increasingly ignoring.

discostrings··on U.S. now bugging German ministers in place of Merkel – report
> Bild am Sonntag said its information stemmed from a high-ranking NSA employee in Germany and that those being spied on included Interior Minister Thomas de Maiziere, a close confidant of Merkel.

So it looks like, according to Bild am Sonntag, this information was provided by a new, non-Snowden source from within the NSA itself. The report even goes so far as to indicate the source isn't an entry-level employee.

Courage is contagious?

discostrings··on Telecom firms mine for gold in big data despite privacy concerns
My initial thoughts were about combining web browsing history and internet usage with location information, but you're right--a lot of analysis could be done purely with your location history and your personal information that the telco has on file. That analysis is much less preventable, short of not using mobile telcos.

This sort of thing really should be opt-in--otherwise, the by-product (personal data) will become the business, and the mobile service will move towards being merely a means to that end.

discostrings··on Telecom firms mine for gold in big data despite privacy concerns
Without regulation or a sudden increase in awareness, this sort of activity will only increase in the near future. Internet service providers who measure their success solely by profit are not going to forgo this revenue opportunity otherwise. It's just where their incentives are aligned (other than in places like Germany perhaps, where people tend to give more thought to information privacy issues).

Any thoughts on the best way to use the Internet while exempting oneself from this sort of analysis, without significantly degrading the experience? VPNs are the first obvious answer, but what's the best approach? Are there others?

discostrings··on I'm completely demotivated to work; what can I do?
The weakness of the advice isn't that it might not be helpful and mind-expanding. It falls short in that most sixteen-year-olds probably don't really have the option to do it:

1) The plan takes more than a trivial amount of money. Most sixteen-year-olds cannot afford this sort of plan.

2) Many parents, if not most parents, are unlikely to support this idea. There's of course a spectrum of what parents might do to stop it if they're not supportive, but it's easier to just save up money and wait until you're done with school.

3) It can only be done in the summer without causing a lot of problems, and perhaps not even then.

It's a potentially helpful suggestion for someone who's over eighteen, but for many sixteen-year-olds it's probably a pipe dream or something that may bring more problems than benefits. The suggestion assumes a certain type of parents and a certain level of privilege that I would estimate are the exception and not the norm. I would have been extremely frustrated if someone gave me advice that presented this as a serious option when I was sixteen.

Advice that makes these sort of assumptions may end up decreasing motivation. I think more universal advice that addresses the actual question is a lot more helpful.

discostrings··on I'm completely demotivated to work; what can I do?
> Open a map, close your eyes and point randomly. Pack you backpack, buy tickets and go there without any reservation. Spend at least 1 month away from home, comfort and routine.

This sounds like an interesting and exciting life-changing plan and everything, but I don't think it's particularly actionable advice for most sixteen-year-olds in today's world, and I don't think it's likely to help with the question at hand. The submitter isn't asking /what to do/; the submitter is asking /how can I be more motivated in what I'm doing/!

I think better advice is to focus on how the things you're learning relate to the things you like to do. So try to focus on how math can improve your programming, research, and other interests. Also, keep in mind that you're building a foundation--things are more interesting once you get to the stage where you're building on top of it. Even if you decide not to use it in a few years, it's a really nice thing to have that will give you a lot of flexibility.

discostrings··on Project Tango
Part of the problem is that privacy, at least in this context, is framed as a "debate" at all, rather than as a matter for individual choice.

Some people would gladly share medical information for the greater good if asked. You'd have to pry it from the cold, dead hands of others. The problem is that we currently don't separate those who would like to provide their information from those who would like to refuse because we're greedy for as much information as we can get, or we don't trust people to make the "right" decision.

A system that worked well and that accomodated both views would be one that really respected a user's choice--one that could handle data in a centralized or individual fashion, accordingly. Data that was willingly given could be used under the terms of the agreement without risk of angering people who don't want their data to be analyzed. It would ultimately provide the same benefits while respecting individuals and not creating controversy.

In the medical records situation, you'd have a group of people at one end that would be quite pleased to contribute their information, a group at the other end that would immediately decline, and quite a few people in the middle who would likely fall somewhat evenly to either side. Sure, some people would probably be fear-mongered out of sharing, but I imagine there'd be a lot less of that going on if people knew they could actually make a meaningful individual choice for privacy if they chose to do so. When opt-outs are buried, hidden, and it's not clear that they actually work, skepticism and fear grow. In a system that doesn't try to railroad people to sacrifice their privacy--a system that actually respects the individual's choice--fear would be reduced.

The only way to cast questions around this type of privacy as "a debate" involves changing the issue to compelled sharing of personal information. In a debate over forced participation, I think it's pretty easy to see why thoughts start to drift towards totalitarian concerns.

I think a system that offered real choice for each individual may drastically reduce the current problems from both perspectives, at the price of some engineering overhead.

discostrings··on Project Tango
> This is a very myopic view that has already caused many deaths. Privacy concerns around medical records have prevented any central database of them from being built, and thus prevented us from saving all of the lives that could be saved by analyzing that data.

This line of reasoning seems similar to arguing that, by not creating a society in which 95% of people live in sanitized hospital rooms and the remaining 5% of people are doctors and nurses, we have "already caused many deaths".

Yes, the fact that people value things like "privacy", "being in large groups where others could be ill", and "moving from place to place" will "cause deaths". But that doesn't mean individuals should be forced to abandon these things for better health outcomes. While some benefits could certainly come from centralizing medical records, I tend to think that benefit cannot justify compelling people to keep their records in a centralized database, in the same way I don't think the health benefits of not traveling justify banning travel. You may not value privacy, but I think that in a truly inclusive society that values the individual, privacy should remain a real option for those who value it.

> There are plenty of concerns about data, and plenty of ways of mitigating those concerns, but a blanket condemnation of any centralized data would hold humanity back immeasurably (and in fact, already has.)

I agree that a blanket condemnation of centralized data is also not a good approach. Each individual should be able to make this choice in a meaningful way, with respect by default that any given person might care about it.

discostrings··on Project Tango
> if you're worried about the information Google collects on you and so choose to plaster that all over message boards every time Google is mentioned - exactly what are you accomplishing?

If you're worried about the information Google collects about /everybody/, and you're posting in /relevant topics/, I think you're accomplishing quite a lot. I think it's really important that when new technology is announced, interested parties discuss both "here are some exciting new possibilities" and "here are some areas for concern". In an impartial discussion forum, a product announcement shouldn't just be an excitement-fest.

> Do you think the people reading your comment don't already know what information Google has available?

This technology will likely result in Google and others collecting and having access to new sources of information about people. I think that many people reading the announcement might not immediately think about some of these implications, and I think it's a great time for review and examination of the topic.

> Do you think Google's going to change its practices because you complain?

I think some engineers and others working on this project and other projects at Google probably read HN, and I think comments here could have an effect on how they build this product and what data is eventually sent to the company. Reading these concerns might be a good reminder to reflect on these things from time to time as well.

> I think the grandparent's point is to focus on things that are actionable.

Action without reflection is a dangerous formula. Google is taking action by building this and announcing it. What we do at HN is learn, reflect, and discuss.

discostrings··on Project Tango
> Good god I am so sick of reading comments like this. This view of the world is just lazy.

I think your view of the world is the lazier of the two--you're basically saying "let's not worry about the negative implications of the things we create as long as our intentions are good".

> Who cares? If you don't like these services, don't use them. Nobody is forcing you to use this device . . . If you don't like modernity, stop using modernity. Move to a homestead in the pacific northwest, never use a telephone, never use grid power, grow your own vegetables, grow your own cattle, and keep away from the evil, scary spies at gooooogggllleeee who are trying to...uh...give you better targeted advertisements? Or provide you with better search results?

Here's how your entire comment reads to me: "If you're interested in thinking about the future implications of the new things we're creating, please shut up and go live in the woods, because you obviously hate modernity. I'm really sick of people thinking about the future and how we might be creating things that will eventually hurt us. The market comes before foresight, and commentary isn't welcome; when you have potential concerns for the future, the only acceptable response is voting with your feet. Please do that and don't ruin our fun."

What you miss is that one can object to a single, potentially dangerous aspect of recent developments (personal information collection and exploitation) while embracing technology in general at the same time.

In creating new technology, it's essential that we examine the paradigms we're creating. If no one's doing that, we're almost sure to run ourselves into serious trouble sooner or later. There's a reason you look before you leap.

Which is lazy: choosing not to use awesome new technology because it has some potentially dangerous implications, or just using any new and seemingly convenient thing that people come up with and assuming it's got to be okay?

discostrings··on Project Tango
> All your doing is slippery sloping your way into a cynical Utopian future which exists only within your own psyche. Your comment reeks of paranoia and baseless conspiratorial fear. If all you can think of in relation to the uses of cool and new technology is someone taking advantage of you than this is most likely the wrong industry to be participating in.

What you label as "paranoia" and "baseless conspiratorial fear" is better described as "examining the potential consequences of the things we build". You are advocating that we examine only the positive potential uses of the technology we develop and that we ignore the potential consequences, because "we'll work it out and everything will be awesome!", or something.

Perhaps the potential consequences will never come to fruition--but it's still very important that we examine them. There's a real shortage of that going on, which is why some people post negative reactions to these developments rather than something more balanced. Stop trying to dismiss those concerns and that conversation--if you're not interested in hearing it or taking part in it, this is likely the wrong discussion forum for you to be participating in.

discostrings··on How I was able to track the location of any Tinder user
> For instance, your proposed solution of just rounding the distance to the tenth of a mile is scarcely better.

I didn't propose rounding the distance as a solution--I mentioned it as an example of the kind of thought that should have started taking place in the mind of someone who was looking to fix the real location issue rather than making a quick change to stop complaints.

> but it's not always easy to see every possible security issue

The quality level of the original fix, in which they sent extremely precise distances, indicates that they put approximately 0 thought into analyzing the issue. It may not be easy to see /every/ possible security issue. But seeing many of them at all requires looking, and it appears they weren't doing much of that. They were getting some serious bad press in July, and their solution was a band-aid rather than an examination of their practices.

The solution may not be obvious, but the problem, especially once brought to one's attention, should have been. It's built into the nature of what they're doing, which makes it especially disturbing that they didn't care enough to put some more thought into it. Their response to the person who reported the problem reflects that as well.

discostrings··on How I was able to track the location of any Tinder user
The exact-coordinates debacle should have been a wake-up call to examine and put some thought into the data that the service sends to users. In fixing the issue, someone should have asked "should we send a ridiculously precise number, or should we perhaps send an approximation to a mile or a tenth of a mile?". In that review, they should have decided not to send the DOB as well. It wasn't a small, new service at that point.
discostrings··on How I was able to track the location of any Tinder user
It's a horrible shame that many developers don't think through the consequences of their implementations before publishing services that trade in personal information. The technique published in this disclosure, as well as the fact that the service sent users' exact coordinates before July, should have been some of the most obvious concerns in building a service that shares one's picture while purporting to keep one's identity and location hidden.

Is Tinder still sending date of birth instead of a calculated age, like in the API example? It seems that no one there has given any thought at all to this topic other than to splash some water at the earlier fire. (IncludeSecurity, could you let us know whether Tinder is still sending the birth date data?)

I can understand that many people don't think through the consequences of sharing personal information, but it's hard to believe how many developers dealing with other people's information give it so little thought as well.

← PreviousPage 2 of 6Next →