259 karma · joined December 5, 2011
The benefit they derive from the increased flexibility that $20k could easily exceed $20k by itself - you've probably seen the research on how people make bad decisions when they are financially unstable. And all that benefit is raw positive.
For a BI to be bad from the perspective you're talking about it has to actively make people less productive. Simply giving them $20k doesn't count as a 'cost' in itself - it all comes full circle.
Don't let me grinch your day.
And if grinch is actually a poorly defined term that's slipped into common usage and I'm applying here incorrectly... irony.
And someone who says "Exponentially better" rather than "much better" is the kind of person who might have a button marked "proactively validate" rather than "confirm".
At the same time, it's hard to get enthusiasm across in emails. I'm no poet. I just get put off when I'm reading a pitch and mentally trip on some out of place phrase.
It doesn't detract from the product I'm sure. But he could just as easily have said 'vastly superior', and so doing not made me go 'Danger, danger, casual disregard for meaning ahead'. Especially since disregard for meaning is a bad thing in UI design.
If someone tells me their thing is 'exponentially' better than something else, I tend to put them in my 'hype merchants who use words without worrying what they mean' box. Whic isn't a good box.
Consider the following:
a) The maximum amount of energy you can get from some wind is a function of the velocity and density of the air and the projected area of your generator. You can't go above 59.3% of the original kinetic energy content. Conventional three axis turbines get pretty damn close to this limit (80% or so).
b) That being the case, getting cheaper or better power is a matter of getting a large projected area for a low cost while still keeping pretty good efficiency.
c) If you cover a large projected area with a small amount of material, and can point your projection to face the wind... you will do quite well. This is what conventional turbines do.
d) If you cover a large projected area with an even smaller amount of material you may do VERY well. This is what Makani power acheived before they were absorbed into GoogleX.
e) If you cover a small projected area using an astronomical amount of material, which doesn't turn but is rather built for every direction, you can expect to do really really badly... no matter how many bullshit mystery air acceleration tubes you include.
It's bullshit.
*edit: I know nothing about the people who are proposing it. They may be doing so in good faith and not realize it's a terrible idea. But it's still a terrible idea.
The minimum bend radius they allow for the 300mph segment is 3.67km. If you made a complete circle it would have a circumference of 23km, and comprise 769 30m segments. Each segment would need to contribute 0.46deg of the 360deg curve.
To achieve this over 30m you need to deviate the end of the pipe by 24cm from where it should be... which actually sounds like a hell of a lot to me, especially if it's flexed through this range regularly (as it would be if constantly switching places with a truly straight segment).
A tube that slides through the pylon joints won't work either. Some of the sections will be cast straight; others curved. They're not interchangeable... to say nothing of trying to keep the overall assembly true to within millimeter tolerances while taking up the slack and extra length over the 360mi length. There's another solution though.
I don't know why you're so negative in tone though. I'm doing other work on the Hyperloop, and I've found some other aspects which I think need addressing, and I absolutely plan to get in touch with the Hyperloop team and try to work with them. Why? Because I want this thing to be built, and I want it to work. I'm sure as hell not going to be able to raise funding for a fundamentally new technology and billion dollar transport project off my own bat. Musk, on the other hand, probably can.
Ease up on the scorn; these aren't a bunch of talentless hacks. Tesla and SpaceX have disrupted two transport industries. They deserve a bit of respect. Have you never made a mistake?
Something else to consider though - those prices are for ridership levels that you could expect by connecting SF and LA. If you start to link up more points (Vegas, San Diego) the utilization of ALL the lines increases, which means you're amortizing the capex over more passengers... which helps a lot given the small fraction Opex will constitute.
To your second point, are you sure it'll be prohibitively expensive to integrate it into the city transit systems? As an elevated system I don't think it'll necessarily cost that much. I suspect it was omitted as much because it'd be expensive in concept evaluation time to sort the details of the integration as because they're just crazy expensive. Is it really that hard to get 2 x 3m tubes on stilts with a foundation every 30m out of a city? It's a very different proposition to putting in a new ground level rail line.
I think the main thing needed to prevent motion sickness would be a virtual 'view' with horizon, which isn't hard to create.
Where the author really gets it wrong though is in saying "Maybe he can resolve that by using larger pods. But of course, a larger pod will weigh more. And that will probably mean using stronger steel for the tubes, which means that the cost will go up". That would be true, but if you're happy to resolve the issue with larger pods then you should be equally happy to resolve it with groups of smaller pods travelling at smaller separations. A 737-800 seats around 150 people. Hyperloop passenger capsules seat 30. So no one should have any conceptual issue with running 5 hyperloop capsules in convoy with separation of a couple of seconds. This 'couple of seconds' still means almost 1km, so they're certainly not sharing the same segments of tube, so you don't need to scale the tube design at all. It's still dirt cheap, and you have plenty of capacity, and it's still MUCH safer than a plane because if one capsule has a fault the others following can still likely stop in time (given they're all decelerating at roughly the same speed).
But yeah, screw those guys. Much more fun to solve the problems.
It gets even more attractive once you link up the dots between areas. If you built a hyperloop between NYC and Chicago, for example, you'd probably route it through Detroit... which means you also capture the NYC-Detroit and Chicago-Detroit traffic.
The main problem with the xpresswest train is that it basically went from nowhere to nowhere. Still needed a car at both ends. That and its being grossly expensive.
I totally agree though. The g limit acceptable, especially in a reclined couch, is much higher than is applied. Would be a trade off with speed and curve radius. Regarding stopping I agree even more (yes, even more than totally). Trying to limit the design 'emergency' G to 1g lateral (so 1.4g net) is about as reasonable as trying to limit the design g in a plane crash to 1g lateral. As a passenger my main concern in an infrequent emergency is that I a) don't die and b) am not significantly injured. If it happens once in a hundred thousand journeys and I walk away with light bruising from the harness, I couldn't care less.
Another big benefit of an ET3 type system that you don't mention is the tube fill factor. In ET3 you can take up basically the whole tube, because there's so little air that you don't need to worry about the Kantrowitz limit (I think). In Hyperloop, you can only take up 30%. This means that ET3 can either have much smaller tubes (big cost saving) or much larger capsules (same cost... but TOILETS!!! ;-)).
But again, I'm pretty sure they if we can surmount the rest of the barriers we can solve the toilet one...
I tend to agree with the "it's not that big a deal" sentiment. Usually you're not allowed to go to the toilet for 30min before landing on a commercial jet either. And on a smaller regional jet it's unlikely there's any serious medical help available. Help is only 30min away, and that's assuming you got sick right at the very START of the trip. I think allergic reactions and choking are probably the biggest risks. One to think about, but probably not a reason to write off a game changing transport method!
I do think it's funny that the most common question when someone proposes a super efficient super fast transport solution is "How will people go to the toilet?".
I guess people who have real trouble can still take the bus or a plane. I'll go before departure, and cross my legs if need be :-)
So the question is not whether projects like this can happen, but rather whether politicians in the USA can be beaten into allowing them to happen there.