2,946 karma · joined October 29, 2011
Security researcher residing in New York.
However, that's a distinction you're making, gruesom. The OP doesn't say it's not worth doing as a startup, he says it's not worth doing in general. There's no qualifier. Had there been, I wouldn't take the same issue with it. This is something other commenters have pointed out down and upthread as well.
Obviously Google has been doing this for years. But it's a slow news day and we need a sexy headline, so let's go with a recent favorite: "<insert BigCo here> is violating your privacy! What are you gonna do about it?! Get angry!"
The idea of a brilliant government agent who understands science, math, and law and who frequently has to skirt the murky waters of government intrigue is kind of a sexy zeitgeist in America.
I read Malcolm Gladwell's book. I'm paraphrasing here, but I distinctly recall his champion example being that of musicians - future music teachers at an elite school had accumulated ~3000 hours before graduating, while the elite musicians had at or over 10000 hours total.
I think it's important not to take these things too literally. I mean, come on, it's not like Gladwell actually believes life is essentially an RPG where you grind for 10,000 hours until your skill xp is "maxed" - there's no magical moment of mastery.
You practice a lot. Take it at face value. Putting all this science into it obfuscates the process and distracts you from practicing.
That Wired article is similarly ridiculous - I find it exceedingly hard to believe that people who spend $6000 on alcohol in one night and have to replace this inane habit with equally obscene in-app purchases aren't just outliers. They're also not indicative of any real substantial user-base.
What I'm trying to get at here is that your favorite theory is completely unsupported as written. It's a gross oversimplification, generalization, and it's potentially insulting.
Different strokes for different folks and all that.
I'm also disappointed by everyone succumbing to the usual flame war-ish ideologies surrounding iOS and Android. One does not need to be better than the other. You can develop for both. Developing on either one has strategic advantages and disadvantages, and you can always port to the other later (okay, almost always).
It's so annoying that people attempt to crunch all the arguments for and against each operating system into a binary response to using either one. It's childish and uninformed.
Oh. That's all we need to do? That's a Goldilocks fallacy.
It's reasonable for you to question my "credentials" for critiquing startup advice if it's accompanied by an analysis of my critique. Then it's relevant and valid. However, alone the comment becomes reduced to an ad hominem dismissal of my point without any real weight beyond it.
I'm not going to engage in the trolling further with you.
That's not to say your rebuttal isn't valid, but that I think there's confusion of what really constitutes a startup. Was Instapaper a startup? It sold for an exit, but on the face of it I don't see how it inherently scales differently from something like Tarsnap.
I would define any budding tech company as a startup, though it might not be accepted by VC's or Y-Combinator because it couldn't scale. That's my own opinion.
I understand you didn't intentionally mean to be dogmatic, I probably could have worded that more appropriately. But I think it comes across that way because it's unintentional. That said, it's not as though every piece of advice came across that way. And again, I want to emphasize I'm attacking the advice stated in that way, not you, because you didn't apply this blanket to every piece of advice.
If you believe Tarsnap fits into your own definition of augmenting the human condition, then I suppose I can't argue that. But taken at face value, the original statement appeared to strike a chord with a number of commenters and myself because of the implicit scale - if you ask which companies augment the human condition, I believe most people would respond with companies on the scale of Apple. Small, almost boutique-level startups are very successful without this level of grandeur.
But again, I revise my original criticism if the definition of impact is broadened, like you just clarified.
As for pizza shops - I can see how your advice encourages appropriate behavior, and I agree to that. But I also believe that (and this wouldn't be your fault) it can also encourage "easy exit" mentalities where people just copy a fad and tweak it for success.
But to be fair, there are plenty of examples of companies (Microsoft, Google, Airbnb, Dropbox) which arguable have legitimately augmented the human condition for huge numbers of people. There's just plenty more that didn't, and that's okay.
I'm not a founder of a startup, but I don't think a lot of these are good advice because Slava comes across as so condescending when he states them. That's not to say I'm attacking his tone instead of the advice, but I don't think the advice is valid because it comes from a place of dogmatic declaration (I understand he has a lot of experience, but I don't think some of these subjects can have absolute statements said about them).
Take this one, which other commenters have mentioned already:
>"If it doesn’t augment the human condition for a huge number of people in a meaningful way, it’s not worth doing."
I'm going to say this is not only blatantly false, but just bad advice and nothing but discouragement.
'cperciva's startup, Tarsnap, is not something I'd say "augments the human condition for a huge number of people in a meaningful way" - it's Colin's full-time job, and I personally think it's fantastic, creative, and genuinely useful to his client-base.
But apparently, it's not worth doing because it doesn't "augment the human condition." (I don't mean to involve you, Colin, it's just a relatively well-known example on HN).
Let's see...'patio11. His most recent startup, Appointment Reminder, might fall into the category of augmenting the human condition. Does Bingo Card Creator? Maybe I'm reaching here...but no, probably not. Was it not worth doing? Absolutely not. (Again, same to you Patrick).
Then we have this tidbit:
>"Pick new ideas because they’ve been made possible by other social or technological change. Get on the train as early as possible, but make sure the technology is there to make the product be enough better that it matters."
This encourages the stream of, for example, crappy camera apps that currently saturate the app store. A lot of developers got on the train, but giving this kind of advice will probably (as history suggests) make founders believe they have the technology to genuinely make a difference in a highly saturated market.
On the other end of the extreme:
>"Don’t build something that already exists. Customers won’t buy it just because it’s yours."
If you do get on that train early, and you can genuinely innovate, or just plain reverse-engineer at a lower manufacturing cost, by all means do it. That's a good starting recipe for profit.
>"Pick implementations that give 80% of the benefit with 20% of the work."
The 80/20 ratio has cropped up everywhere and grown in popularity for a while now, but I think it's too vague. In particular, I believe this advice would encourage the wrong kind of behavior. It could be interpreted as being efficient, or it could be interpreted as foregoing the more rewarding, effort-filled path with the one that's only marginally useful but exponentially easier. Risky absolutes for advice.
Finally:
>"If you can’t get to ramen profitability with a team of 2 – 4 within six months to a year, something’s wrong. (You can choose not to be profitable, but it must be your choice, not something forced on you by the market)."
Maybe Slava successfully did this, but I don't think it's fair to hold all startups to this bar.
I also don't think things like being a "final say" CEO are fully compatible with evenly splitting stocks. This is a very highly debated part of startup financial management. So, yes, this is my opinion, but equally importantly, the opposite advice is also Slava's opinion.
Now, on the other hand, a lot of these statements are really good. I'm not flaming the entire post. In particular, I liked:
>"Product sense is everything. Learn it as quickly as you can. Being good at engineering has nothing to do with being good at product management."
Yes, very true, and something you have echoed before as well, pg. Running a company in any sense of the term is completely different from engineering a company's product.
>"Learn the difference between people who might buy your product and people who are just commenting. Pay obsessive attention to the former. Ignore the latter."
Often stated, definitely true, also applies to investor courting.
My personal favorite:
>"Morale is very real and self-perpetuating. If you work too long without victories, your investors, employees, family, and you yourself will lose faith. Work like hell not to get yourself into this position."
This is one of those murky, non-actionable truths of startups that you don't really get until you've tried it. Judging from the "I failed" Ask HN: posts, I think this might be one of the least expected but extremely true ones. I might even say that for personal well-being, this might be the most important piece of advice.
I'm sure I'll be downvoted for this, but I would ask people to at least explain why they disagree so we can have productive discussion. I respect the OP, I'm just expressing my disagreements here.
This:
>"Assume the market is efficient and valuable ideas will be discovered by multiple teams nearly instantaneously."
That's just irresponsible and unrealistic advice.
Splitting stock evenly and governing yourself as a "final say" CEO seems a bit self-contradictory, to say nothing of whether or not you should be a "final say" CEO in a startup (debatable).
This is also deplorable:
>"If it doesn’t augment the human condition for a huge number of people in a meaningful way, it’s not worth doing."
Yeah, it's wonderful to "augment the human condition...", but don't be a condescending prick about it. Things are perfectly worth doing even if they don't impact a large number of people.
The trouble with this is, Slava inherently claims superiority to his audience when he declares (not suggest, declares) that things are not worth doing just because they aren't up to his self-defined standard of ambition.
Such a statement is not for him to make; it wouldn't sound right coming straight out of one of Paul Graham's essays, so on what authority does he get to make this statement?
[1]: http://www.google.com/loon/#utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc...
And if you scripted a time limit for images, e.g. only within a few hours, you'd heavily limit the amount of usable images you had.
With "agents in the field" Google could potentially update its feeds whenever and as often as it needed. The difference would be having an in-house image-generating infrastructure or...well...tag-searching Instagram.
EDIT: I reread it twice and laughed each time. This is literally the funniest serious comment I've seen on Hacker News in weeks.
EDIT2: Yes, I thought it was funny enough to make this comment, and no I'm not being sarcastic at all.
If you could speak a bit softer with this, maybe throw in some noise-cancelling headphones, I could totally see this being useful even in an office situation.
I could see a potential pseudo-language developing out of this to abstract a lot of the individual characters, functions and common invocations used while coding.
In terms of threat-level to privacy, this isn't all that egregious. The term "shadow profile" is not one that Facebook itself espouses, it's just added for flair. Clearly, this is making a lot of noise about something that's actually fairly harmless.
I would place more blame on the people sharing my data with Facebook than I would blame Facebook for "mapping" interpersonal data. It's really not that big a deal people.
Education was far less prevalent for minority groups, who, as an unfortunate side effect to class-wide limited incomes, don't have the same access to the kind of education which would give this sort of examination to an 8th grader.
Now, if you attend a private grammar school in a Westchester suburb you can expect a lot of your children will have exams like this...
Yeah...no they don't. Both my parents are career teachers, and both have worked in both public and private school systems. You start out at ~$30,000 in major metropolitan areas and can reach $100,000 after close to a decade, with a graduate degree.
And the trolling begins...