HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

e63f67dd-065b

1,891 karma · joined September 14, 2019

submissionscomments
e63f67dd-065b··on Magicians less prone to mental disorders than other artists, finds research
The paper mainly concerns itself with a sample of magicians vs another of the general population (with matching age, sex, etc). The second part compares magicians with artists, actors, comedians, poets, musicians, and a general population.

Personally the most suspicious part about this is the O-LIFE questionnaire; it tests for things like "unusual experiences", "cognitive disorganisation", "impulsive nonconformity", "Introvertive anhedonia", and a bunch of other things that are reminiscent of all the non-replicable personality research from a decade ago.

O-LIFE was developed in 1995, well before replication crisis questions started popping up, so who knows.

e63f67dd-065b··on Magicians less prone to mental disorders than other artists, finds research
Direct link to study: https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/c...

I skimmed through the paper, and I wish there was a nicer way of saying it, but this is the kind of bullshit non-replicable study that got kicked off the replication crisis in psychology. It really reminds me of the significant xkcd (https://xkcd.com/882/, if you test every colour of jellybeans/creative profession for p<0.05, eventually you'll find a jellybean colour/profession that's associated with acne/disorders).

Select quotes:

> A sample of 195 magicians and 233 people from the general population completed measures of schizotypal traits (Oxford– Liverpool Inventory of Feelings and Experiences) and autism (Abridged Version of the Autism-Spectrum Quotient), as well as the Short Scale of Creative Self. Magicians were also compared with other creative groups with respect to schizotypal traits, based on previously published data.

One of the co-authors is a magician:

> All magicians’ contacts were made by the third author, who served at the time as the Resourceress of the Society of American Magicians

I couldn't find where they found the same statistics for other creative professions. Did they pull it out of another study? I can't tell.

> Our study demonstrates that not all creative people are created equal. Magicians scored significantly lower than the general population and other vocational creative groups on most psychopathological traits, particularly those related to schizotypy

e63f67dd-065b··on Steam Deck OLED
We like to joke about The Year of the Linux Desktop, but it's already been here for half a decade: ChromeOS.

As far as non chromeos/steamos based linux desktops, yeah it's not gonna happen, not unless microsoft in a fit of insanity breaks backwards compat, OEMs stop pre-installing windows, and even then the users will probably migrate to Apple, not linux.

e63f67dd-065b··on Seeing like a bank
My impression of what he wrote is that it's an explanation of the status quo, not a denunciation of it. In his conclusion:

> Although it certainly doesn’t feel like it to people who hit edge cases, the tiered support model is a technology which took us decades to popularize and which made the world much better. It brought down the cost of financial services and supported product innovation which would have been impossible under the mid-century bank staffing model. We could not have credit cards or discount brokerages without the tiered support model. The biography of Charles Schwab makes this point persuasively at considerable length: competent telephone operations were instrumental to bringing equity ownership to the middle class. You should prefer a world with credit cards and discount brokerages to one which doesn’t have them, even as you listen to hold music occasionally

Tiered support is here to stay because tiered support is cheap and resistant to the "unintelligent customer DoS" (my words, not his). As he points out, you can have professional troubleshooters with the capability, authority, and expertise to troubleshoot the problem, but their labour costs in the hundreds of dollars an hour.

I personally think there is a reasonable model of the world where customers explicitly pay a hundred dollar fee to have a highest-tier escalation to the office of the CEO/equivalent troubleshooting team and have them take a look at your case, but this is a model that has not yet been developed or in wide use anywhere.

e63f67dd-065b··on I Got the Fed to Release Its 2011 "Treasury Default" Playbook
The memo itself can be found here: https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/files/FOMC2011...
e63f67dd-065b··on Dengue rates plunged after release of lab-altered mosquitoes
This is great news. Dengue was a constant problem in my home country of Malaysia, and remains a problem to this day. I still remember all the public education campaigns about it that I saw when I was young (random ads on TV about making sure there's no stagnant water, seeking medical help if you notice <symptoms>, etc), I'm very glad that there are easily implementable solutions to these problems.

As a side note, I wonder why this kind of research is not more popular in university labs of tropical countries. Malaysia, Singapore, India, etc are home to plenty of university labs that should have the expertise and motivation to do this kind of thing, but they're really dropping the ball if they're not working on it right now. Every time I read about new mosquito fighting innovations it's out of an American or European lab, far away from where it's most impactful.

Is it a problem of funding? Somehow the Malaysian government funds less mosquito disease research than the US? Political will? I would hope that the health ministries of tropical countries are willing to throw some money at the problem. Institutional knowledge? Plenty of the professors are educated in Australia/UK/US, so that can't be it. Coverage? Western media covers western labs, and don't notice when labs elsewhere do the same thing?

e63f67dd-065b··on Subtle ways Microsoft Word has changed how we use language
I remember reading somewhere that some systems use a 26 hour clock in that it's literally valid 00:00 to 25:59, or 28 hr for 00:00 to 27:59. 24:30 10/1 and 00:30 11/1 mean the exact same thing, it's a notational convenience to not have to worry about date boundaries between days.

Trying to find the source again but not having success.

e63f67dd-065b··on Max is taking 4K away from its legacy ad-free subscribers
Nah, don’t use TPB, moderation is lax and selection is meh. On the public side, these days it’s all 1337, TG, maybe RuT. They’re all fairly well moderated and have good selections, even if some stuff has just the one guy seeding from his dialup in the middle on the ocean.
e63f67dd-065b··on The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 days
Just plain day number as the calendar is worse than weeks imo. We want to optimise for the common case, and wanting to know the day of week and number of weeks from today is much more common than day of year.

For example, “our next meeting is w48.3” is much more understandable than “day 339”.

e63f67dd-065b··on The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 days
Not sure if you’re serious, but the 7-day week as so entrenched that no system that breaks it will see any adoption. Maintaining the 7-day week and the 365 day year is non negotiable for any kind of calendar reform.
e63f67dd-065b··on The world nearly adopted a calendar with 13 months of 28 days
I think the best backwards-compatible calendar that we should adopt is the ISO week date calendar, commonly used in finance: forget months, every day is a week number + a day. So today is 44.7, which means week 44, day 7. This also gets you a nice almost even 13 weeks/quarter, and easy calculations (that report is due w48.5, aka Friday in 4 weeks). We used a worse version of this calendar in Intel and it was great (we callled them work weeks instead and iirc it was not iso8601 aligned).

This way, people can play with legacy dates for their birthdays, religious observances, etc but use a sane system at all other times. This already happens with Chinese/Islamic calendars anyways, Chinese new year is a date I have to look up every year, and that’s OK because the calendar is used for literally nothing else outside traditional festivals. Optimise for the common case, after all. Christmas is w52.1 this year, w52.3 the next, etc, just as CNY is 22-jan and 10-feb this and next year (but 1/1 on the Chinese calendar).

The only trouble is that some years have 52 weeks and some 53, but such is the price to pay for backwards compatibility.

e63f67dd-065b··on Right turn on red? With pedestrian deaths rising, US cities are considering bans
The first time I was in the US I was shocked to see a car go straight through a crosswalk when it was red and I was crossing. I was very surprised when a friend later told me that this is normal in the US, it seems sensible that this should be banned.

I also wonder how traffic routing works with right on red; since you cannot prohibit right turns under any circumstances, how do you direct traffic on T-junctions and 4-way junctions?

e63f67dd-065b··on Mint is shutting down, and it's pushing users toward Credit Karma
> The app has to be capable of generating millions a month in revenue at the least. Who is on the leadership team for mint, so I know to never work or partner with them in the future? This is so insanely incompetent its just.. shocking.

I have the opposite perspective: management made the right call pulling the plug on Mint. The problem with Mint is that it most likely loses a huge amount of money; from what I've read, most data aggregators charge a fixed amount per account + a fee per API call, so they have to recuperate their costs by selling ads.

That's why Credit Karma makes money: credit card/loan/insurance referrals are worth insane amounts (I've heard numbers like $100+ per sign up for premium cards, even more for insurance/mortgage), so it only makes sense to shuffle customers over to Credit Karma where the sales funnel is much more effective. If one credit card referral can pay for the customer's API calls for a few years, it only makes sense to aggressively push for it.

e63f67dd-065b··on Starlink has achieved breakeven cash flow
With Tesla stock as overvalued as it is, he'll be really dumb to not sell issue more. Tesla is the original meme stock: if people are willing to pay much more for AMC/BBBY/whatever meme stock than it would otherwise be worth, you should get in front of the money printing machine and issue more stock. Good for him.
e63f67dd-065b··on Slack: Our biggest redesign yet came to be
> However, redesigns usually fall into the “high effort, high variance, questionable benefit” bucket that businesses try to avoid at all costs. Unless something is absolutely broken, not many companies are willing to invest.

I have no idea what kind of feedback they received, but Slack was not absolutely broken; it was not great, and the redesign made it worse, not better. If you already know that redesigns should be avoided at all costs, why did you still do it?

Also as a sidenote Slack's notification system is still hopelessly broken; I will regularly respond to a DM on my phone, get back to my laptop, click on a notification, only for it to bring me right back to the message I literally just responded to on my phone!

Discord handles this beautifully, the moment I look at a message on my phone it's marked as read on the desktop client. I can't believe a feature as core as notifications in a chat app can be this broken compared to Discord's beautiful implementation.

e63f67dd-065b··on Microsoft is removing Maps and Movies and TV from Windows 11
I think there's a good case for an OS coming with a good suite of pre-installed apps, like a decent calendar, mail client, notes, todo, etc. The same way that macOS has very nice pre-installed apps that are used by a significant portion of their customers (the Apple notes app is really good, and I see plenty of people using Apple mail, calendar, etc).

The problem is that Microsoft's implementations suck. Apple's are thoroughly mediocre and that's ok, people who want more can easily get more, but Microsoft is too afraid of cannibalising Outlook and what not to really commit to it.

The TV/movies apps though are bordering on bloatware territory, and that's on both macOS and Win11.

e63f67dd-065b··on Even a laptop can run RAM externally thanks to CXL
Yeah optane seemed like it had so much potential -- with the right abstractions, it neatly dealt with the eternal problem of the separation between RAM and disk. Much of DB and storage system engineering comes down to decisions around when to persist what, and optane was very promising in allowing for new architectures that had much better performance at lower complexity.

Alas, optane's dead now. I do know people actively working on resurrecting a lot of pmem work on low-latency flash, however, and it seems like this is one area with a low of momentum behind it.

e63f67dd-065b··on Nokia to erase up to 14,000 employees from payroll
They don't even make phones anymore, that division got sold to Microsoft (we all know how that went), and is now owned by HMD Global, who funnily enough has their HQ across the street from Nokia HQ, and has a funnily high number of former Nokia phone execs in their leadership.
e63f67dd-065b··on Nokia to erase up to 14,000 employees from payroll
The thing that went bankrupt, afaik, were the phones division that got sold off. Nokia phones, after their short stint at Microsoft, are now manufactured by HMD, who conveniently has their HQ right across the street from Nokia HQ. Nokia, the rest of the non-phone company, makes telecom stuff, and I don't think ever went under, just suffered quite badly.
e63f67dd-065b··on Even a laptop can run RAM externally thanks to CXL
CXL is useful for many more things beyond just memory expansion (which is a "type 3 device").

The purpose of CXL is to allow for memory coherency between different CXL devices. To quote the spec on type 2 devices:

> CXL Type 2 devices, in addition to fully coherent cache, also have memory, for example DDR, High-Bandwidth Memory (HBM), etc., attached to the device. These devices execute against memory, but their performance comes from having massive bandwidth between the accelerator and device-attached memory. The main goal for CXL is to provide a means for the Host to push operands into device-attached memory and for the Host to pull results out of device-attached memory such that it does not add software and hardware cost that offsets the benefit of the accelerator.

There's some cool things you can do with CXL, like resurrecting the whole persistent memory idea with low-latency flash, making hardware offload devices more capable since you now get free cache coherency, and a whole bunch of other stuff.

But yes, it's really not for consumer use-cases. The applications I've seen colleagues work on are mostly enterprise stuff like cool RDMA integrations, cache-coherent flash, and more I can't talk about here.

e63f67dd-065b··on Apple plans to update iPhones in-store without opening the boxes
Apple also writes iOS, so you already have to trust them to buy and use their phones. I don't really see the difference here.
e63f67dd-065b··on YouTube is cracking down on consumers' favorite loophole
> I'm convinced that by now after decades of bandwidth improvements etc we'd have free videos in the same way.

If you can figure out a way to serve petabytes of video every day for basically free, then you'd be rich.

The simple truth is that bandwidth is not free. The numbers are, of course, not public, but Cloudflare published some stuff here https://blog.cloudflare.com/bandwidth-costs-around-the-world... that we can use to guesstimate. Google likely has more peering agreements, but it still costs money.

That's just bandwidth, serving video also costs compute (re-encoding the video in a bunch of resolutions is not free), and running the software to serve the video is also expensive, memory, storage to store said video, and generally just hundreds of datacenters around the world. You can serve a million RPS of static HTML on a crappy server in a closet for a few thousand dollars, but you absolutely cannot do the same for video.

e63f67dd-065b··on YouTube is cracking down on consumers' favorite loophole
> Regarding the distribution of content: Google has been more than happy to carry YouTube's operating cost from their quasi-monopoly on internet ads. In return, users gave them more detailed advertising profiles through the use of YouTube.

Ad data is not worth that much money, especially if you adblock all their ads. Every time you watch a Youtube video, Google loses money, why on earth should they serve their videos to you for free?

I use adblock, but I'm not under the delusion that I'm not freeriding off everybody who's not blocking ads.

e63f67dd-065b··on YouTube is cracking down on consumers' favorite loophole
Genuinely asking, how do you expect peertube to serve terabits-petabits of video every day? Who's gonna pay for this? Bandwidth is not free, nor are servers; Mastodon works because text is relatively cheap to serve, but video is not.
e63f67dd-065b··on Two years of raising a bilingual daughter
It seems very cruel to the child to force bilingualism for the sake of being bilingual. I was raised speaking 5(!) languages, and over time that has attritioned into speaking only 3, but each language had its purpose: mainly in speaking to a different group of people in my home country, for official documents, or was the language on all the interesting TV shows.

The hard part about a new language, if you intuitively understand the grammar, is vocabulary. The author himself admits that his own vocabulary is not expansive enough, foisting than upon a child can't possibly help. The inability to have deep conversations is deeply harmful: there are many Chinese couples in my home country that raised their children only on English, much to the detriment of their Chinese/Hokkien/Cantonese, and the parent and child are now unable to hold deep conversations about important topics, which led to big disconnects in familial relationships.

I don't think that this will cause long-term harm, but I do think it's a massive waste of time.

There is this obsession with language learning that I've never quite understood in the US. The supposed cognitive benefits have, to the best of my knowledge, mostly failed to replicate, so it only lives on as a popular myth.

e63f67dd-065b··on Microsoft completes $69B deal to buy Activision Blizzard
Well, King makes almost twice as much money as Blizzard iirc, so I would say that they're focusing their resources in the right places.

Making $60 desktop games is just a horrible business to be in, the development costs are too high, and the return is too low. Why would you make a AAA title when you can make Candy Crush? It only makes sense to divert resources where the ROI picture is prettier.

e63f67dd-065b··on Microsoft completes $69B deal to buy Activision Blizzard
There are many such markets -- real estate, construction, financial services (banking, mortgages, credit cards, etc), agriculture, retail (no, walmart is not a monopoly), oil, automotive, air travel, I can name many more.

The only big national industries that are dominated by monopolies I would say are telecommunications, utilities, silicon, pharmaceuticals, rail, and even most of these have a few more companies than two. Granted, 3 telecoms is not much of an improvement over 2, but nevertheless your claim is broadly speaking false.

Are there private equity firms trying to consolidate? Sure, but in any of the above they haven't really met with much success.

e63f67dd-065b··on Microsoft completes $69B deal to buy Activision Blizzard
Where is the corruption here? I agree that there are many corrupt parts of government, especially in procurement, and especially in regional and local governments, but in this specific case it's pretty clear that the law is on the side of Microsoft here.
e63f67dd-065b··on Microsoft completes $69B deal to buy Activision Blizzard
And? Laying off 200 employees isn't really that much, Activision-Blizzard employs 17k people after all, and he is creating a lot of value. Boards want to incentivise CEOs to take moonshots -- for institutional investors, a 50% chance to make $100 million is better than a 100% chance to make $30m.

Keeping employees around for the sake of keeping them around is just bad business. A 1% layoff isn't a cost cutting exercise, it's just organisational reshuffling. Employee churn is a fact of life, no need to get too hung up over it. The optics might be not great, but that doesn't really matter.

e63f67dd-065b··on Microsoft completes $69B deal to buy Activision Blizzard
He's being rewarded for growing net income roughly a hundred fold between 2010 and now. I think it's fair that he gets a huge chunk of the value he's created for investors.
← PreviousPage 4 of 11Next →