HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eganist

5 karma · joined June 18, 2024

I'll largely use this account for talking about advice subreddits and forums specifically.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/bryant; my proof: https://keybase.io/bryant/sigs/-R8Ky9MLcrIhyNpFXZWTI6B6qQdfdG5dt89OuG-Jxv4 ]

submissionscomments
eganist··on FCC launches inquiry to increase minimum broadband speed [pdf]
> Ironically roads should also have caps and/or tolls, so this take is strange.

We'll set up electronic tolls on your cul-de-sac and every light and stop sign, or toll you by mile driven using an odometer beaconing out to the tax authorities per drive and registered to your tax ID number (US) or equivalent. And then cap you on the number of miles you're allowed to drive per year on all cars unless you pay an additional fee.

Older cars must be retrofit at the driver's expense.

Also the auditing and anti-fraud infrastructure must be instituted for all of this.

---

Or we can just do flat taxes and chill.

eganist··on Google to invest up to $2B in Anthropic
Explains why Google tried (or is trying) so hard to push WEI though. If they can't programmatically evade adblockers, might as well programmatically prevent them.
eganist··on Europe's largest copper producer is the victim of metal swindle worth $198M
A timed cut won't matter when you refresh with reader mode enabled before the refresh. None of that logic can execute in reader mode.

That's why it works.

eganist··on Fish skin can heal other animals' eye injuries
> (To be clear, this is nothing like skinning beavers — it's tilapia after all, one of the most heavily consumed fish on the planet, skin and all. But the thought tickled the brain for a moment)
eganist··on Fish skin can heal other animals' eye injuries
Tangent: I appreciate that the only glancing mention of the ethical weirdness in harvesting skin from one animal to heal surface injuries on other animals is in the beautifully crafted teaser graphic.

(To be clear, this is nothing like skinning beavers — it's tilapia after all, one of the most heavily consumed fish on the planet, skin and all. But the thought tickled the brain for a moment)

eganist··on FCC moves ahead with Title II net neutrality rules in 3-2 party-line vote
> Did you catch the part about "give the FCC more authority"?

The FCC ceded authority as a way to get around having to make a damning call not to assert net neutrality under the last administration. Unless I'm misreading, this is just a return to form.

eganist··on Leaked Microsoft pay guidelines – salary, hiring bonus, stock awards by level
From the article:

---

Level 70:

    Base pay: $231,700 to $361,500
    On-hire stock awards: $310,000 default to $1.2 million with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $945,000
Level 69:

    Base pay: $202,400 to $316,000
    On-hire stock awards: $235,000 default to $1.1 million with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $750,000
Level 68:

    Base pay: $186,200 to $291,000
    On-hire stock awards: $177,000 default to $1 million with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $490,600
Level 67:

    Base pay: $171,600 to $258,200
    On-hire stock awards: $168,000 default to $700,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $336,000
Level 66:

    Base pay: $157,300 to $236,300
    On-hire stock awards: $75,000 default to $600,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $160,000
Level 65:

    Base pay: $144,600 to $216,600
    On-hire stock awards: $36,000 default to $300,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $90,000
Level 64:

    Base pay: $125,000 to $187,700
    On-hire stock awards: $24,000 default to $250,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $60,000
Level 63:

    Base pay: $113,900 to $171,500
    On-hire stock awards: $17,000 default to $200,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $44,000
Level 62:

    Base pay: $103,700 to $156,400
    On-hire stock awards: $11,000 default to $125,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $32,000
Level 61:

    Base pay: $92,600 to $138,100
    On-hire stock awards: $6,500 default to $75,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $24,000
Level 60:

    Base pay: $83,500 to $125,000
    On-hire stock awards: $4,500 default to $50,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $16,000
Level 59:

    Base pay: $74,400 to $110,800
    On-hire stock awards: $3,000 default to $30,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: $0 to $12,000
Level 58:

    Base pay: $70,300 to $92,600
    On-hire stock awards: $2,500 default to $20,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: "By career stage"
Level 57:

    Base pay: $63,800 to $83,000
    On-hire stock awards: $1,500 default to $10,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: "By career stage"
Level 56:

    Base pay: $60,700 to $77,900
    On-hire stock awards: $1,500 default to $10,000 with approval
    Annual stock award range: "By career stage"
Level 55:

    Base pay: $55,200 to $71,300
    On-hire stock awards: N/A
    Annual stock award range: "By career stage"
Level 54:

    Base pay: $51,600 to $67,000
    On-hire stock awards: N/A
    Annual stock award range: "By career stage"
Level 53:

    Base pay: $46,600 to $59,700
    On-hire stock awards: N/A
    Annual stock award range: "By career stage"
Level 52:

    Base pay: $42,500 to $54,600
    On-hire stock awards: N/A
    Annual stock award range: "By career stage"
eganist··on How Big Pharma reaps profits while hurting everyday Americans (2019)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_health_insurance_option for those missing the connection.

NHS comes across to me as government funded healthcare rather than a gov-kickstarted not-for-profit insurance option. Am I missing a nuance? Not familiar with NHS so I could have a wildly wrong impression of what it is.

eganist··on How Big Pharma reaps profits while hurting everyday Americans (2019)
Pharma strikes me as one of the industries that would benefit heavily from a few congressionally chartered nonprofits being booted up. Same employee comp (with cash substitutes for stock), same general structure, same incentives, but with a mandate to recycle profits back into new drug development rather than paying out to shareholders through buybacks, dividends, etc, all audited by a dedicated regulatory body to ensure that comp and waste don't go into excess. Perhaps with a requirement that some percentage of reinvestment is towards cures rather than treatments.

You see similar models with co-ops and credit unions.

The hope would be that the industry doesn't actually profit off of human suffering but still maintains incentive to continue development.

eganist··on The FTC sues to break up Amazon over an economy-wide “hidden tax”
> Amazon isn't a monopoly by any definition.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/monopoly "For instance, the term monopoly may be referring to instances where: [...] There are many buyers or sellers, but one actor has enough market share to dictate prices (near monopolies)"

---

I'm not replying to anything you might reply with because the rest of your comments in this thread have clearly been in bad faith. But this was one of the few smoking gun comments betraying either a biased position you hold or your lack of background on the topic, so it was easy enough to just post a link to an authoritative source + definition and just move on.

eganist··on Amazon used algorithm to test how much it could raise prices: FTC
> Since when was 37.8 percent a monopoly?

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/monopoly "For instance, the term monopoly may be referring to instances where: [...] There are many buyers or sellers, but one actor has enough market share to dictate prices (near monopolies)"

> And it was also predicted by analysts that Windows Phone would overtake the iPhone by 2017

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Straw_man

eganist··on Amazon used algorithm to test how much it could raise prices: FTC
> Is everyone forgetting just how small Amazon is when you consider all of retail?

https://www.statista.com/statistics/274255/market-share-of-t...

June 2022, 37.8% of all ecommerce market share.

Not sure why you're comparing to physical retail considering the antitrust practices alleged are in the ecommerce space. And even if we were to compare all retail in the US, Amazon is likely to overtake Walmart across all retail come next year. https://www.ascentialedge.com/press/ecommerce-shakes-top-5-r...

eganist··on Wegovy, other weight-loss drugs scrutinized over reports of suicidal thoughts
For what it's worth, that just means 3 more people disagreed than agreed. But what you described at least lines up with my experience, which is worth a smidge at least.
eganist··on Wegovy, other weight-loss drugs scrutinized over reports of suicidal thoughts
This would be an interesting hypothesis to test—especially in cases where obesity may have been an outcome of people self medicating with food. Fits my own experience too (keto is basically the only intervention that worked for me, and only after I've been able to peel myself away from carbs for a few weeks)

I've been doing a good job avoiding GLPs just because I want it as a last resort option. But still, it wouldn't at all surprise me if this turns out to be one of a few explanations for the link.

eganist··on LinkedIn forcing me to disclose my phone number to log in? No thanks
lol, this inspired me to try to opt-out of LN and I got this beautiful and intimidating warning.

https://consumer.risk.lexisnexis.com/img/State_Use_of_Indivi...

eganist··on Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear Power Plant in Poland
> Curious what Poland's anti-nuclear neighboring country will think about this?

> AFAIK Austria was also suing Hungary and Slovenia for going nuclear.

---

> Did my point fly so high above peoples' heads? The question was whether Germany will sue Poland the same way Austria does to it's neighbors, not whether Austria will sue Poland.

It did, yes, because based on what you wrote, you assumed most people on HN know that:

1. Germany has a large anti-nuclear presence

2. Austria is not bordering Poland.

eganist··on NASA’s Webb finds carbon source on surface of Jupiter’s moon Europa
> Can Webb image Europa?

The implication by the presence of "Europa Carbon Dioxide Distribution" (NIRCam and NIRSpec IFU) images on the NASA release is that yes, it can.

eganist··on Facebook is blocking Canadians’ posts on the assassination of a BC Sikh leader
> That's exactly it, isn't it? Claiming you have rule of law while being unable to secure prosecutions makes it a farce.

Seems like that's exactly what rule of law should entail: laws so strictly enforced that people can't be prosecuted when the prosecution is botched because doing so would... violate the rule of law.

So if anything, this further reinforces the idea that Canada hews closely to its laws than not.

eganist··on One in 10 Japanese Now Aged over 80, Population Report Shows
Not OP, but ostensibly Japan considering they even have a name for death from overwork.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karoshi

Though given the political climate in the US, it wouldn't surprise me if the US suffers from a bit of it.

eganist··on 90% of companies say they’ll return to the office by the end of 2024
It's just so poorly managed too. A lot of these companies are heavy on engineering. The returns would likely be stronger if buildings were converted to dedicated offices for engineers; they'd pull those in who want their own office to work, let those who want to stay home keep working from home, maintain that physical presence they want for incubating junior talent, and get better productivity out of everyone.
eganist··on 90% of companies say they’ll return to the office by the end of 2024
Does anyone have a running list of cited reasons for why this is happening? The few people I've asked in executive decisionmaking circles have all chalked it up to judgment calls, but I'm inclined to believe that there's a more coordinated effort going on to backstop CRE.

Even the article blames emotions, and while I know people can be fickle, I find it hard to believe that there isn't some kind of data informing the move, whether it's data describing something that should be obvious (productivity) or something opaque or irrelevant to most employees (coordinated effort to prop up investments)

eganist··on Chronic fatigue syndrome may have a post-viral infection origin
> As someone who used to be on the track to academia, this is something that more people should do.

You're right, and akdor1154 already addressed this in the same breath:

> I don't think that level of dismissal is fair or respectful unless you accompany it with a relevant criticism of the research itself.

Emphasis mine.

eganist··on Microsoft has not stopped forcing Edge on Windows 11 users
I remember when we first found out that IE could be "uninstalled" from Windows 7 (it was a checkbox in an early build's programs list that let you have it removed, basically).

Interesting seeing the about-face over a decade later.

---

for those not aware, Rafael's almost a two decade long authority on the topic of smashing Windows internals to bits to see how it all works.

eganist··on Ask HN: I’m an FCC Commissioner proposing regulation of IoT security updates
Indeed, this is awesome.

Not sure if you're able to comment on this, but is there anything in place to mitigate the risk of automated astroturfed commentary e.g via LLMs in this and other cases?

Edit: on the fcc docket specifically, not on HN

eganist··on Recursively summarizing enables long-term dialogue memory in LLMs
You're 100% right, no one knows how the brain works. And all the elements you described are probably relevant — including things you didn't mention, such as personality changes tied to heart transplants, etc.

But that's probably reading a little too deeply and seriously into what I said.

eganist··on Recursively summarizing enables long-term dialogue memory in LLMs
> rather than as some hacked on process of continually regenerating summaries.

incidentally, this isn't far off from how the human brain is believed to work (at least with long term memories).

https://news.northwestern.edu/stories/2012/09/your-memory-is...

eganist··on Past Covid infection protection against re-infection: a systematic meta-analysis
> as a base assumption and leaves no room for individual choice and risk-management decisions.

We're still having this dance in 2023? Businesses can likewise reject people for increasing the risk profile of the business provided such rejections don't touch on suspect classifications. And even that last bit is less likely to pose regulatory risk to businesses now that businesses in the US have been enabled by the Supreme Court to reject clients for things like sexual orientation.

> Ditto on "designing policies that mandate vaccination".

Workers under mandates can just as easily quit the job that has the mandate, or they can be terminated at will. Or rather, such is the typical argument I hear from the a certain crowd when workers complain about employers doing silly things that workers disagree with. If you're concerned that these workers should bargain for a right (to reject a vaccine) without fear of termination, maybe they should form a structure that can collectively bargain for said right for them.

I'm inclined to agree with others who say that your own biases are tainting your interpretation, but your biases are also particularly revealing.

eganist··on Minimum Viable Secure Product
True as it is, not a thing you list here addresses the security of the product. Except for IaCs. And the site describes securing the product.

Will edit with commentary in a moment.

Edit: alright, fair criticism re business security controls given that the checklist's first section is specifically about business controls.

And the rest should be focusing on automating those outcomes rather than just what the outcomes are. I agree that manually creating DFDs is just going to slow teams down, though it's definitely a capability that more security-mature or regulation-burdened organizations will need. When you're this early though, better to harden IaCs based on secure reference architectures up front and lint the heck out of code than to encumber all of ones processes with manual controls.

eganist··on The elite's war on remote work has nothing to do with productivity
> people take a 20% haircut on converting the buildings to condos and/or just selling for the value of the land?

Leverage and derivatives completely turn this assumption on its head.

eganist··on Seattle becomes first in U.S. to protect gig workers from sudden 'deactivation'
> [Ubers] are as unreliable and untrusworthy and they could be - unpredictable prices, you never know if it will actually come even if company accepted your request etc.

Seriously, the number of times I've seen cancellations because the Uber didn't want to go in that direction or that neighborhood... or had unreal surge pricing applied, etc.

And that's today, so I doubt the Seattle change will make much of a difference. Many (not necessarily most. I don't have that data) drivers game the system in its current state.

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →