HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eganist

5 karma · joined June 18, 2024

I'll largely use this account for talking about advice subreddits and forums specifically.

[ my public key: https://keybase.io/bryant; my proof: https://keybase.io/bryant/sigs/-R8Ky9MLcrIhyNpFXZWTI6B6qQdfdG5dt89OuG-Jxv4 ]

submissionscomments
eganist··on Tell HN: Eid Mubarak
I see where the confusion is coming from. Other hadiths in the same book seem to suggest this is moreso because blood itself is considered unclean. For instance:

> Sahih al-Bukhari 325 (Book 6, Hadith 30) #322

> Narrated 'Aisha: Fatima bint Abi Hubaish asked the Prophet, "I got persistent bleeding (in between the periods) and do not become clean. Shall I give up prayers?" He replied, "No, this is from a blood vessel. Give up the prayers only for the days on which you usually get the menses and then take a bath and offer your prayers".

"Assume good faith" would suggest that at the time the holy texts were written, bleeding was frequently associated with infection and disease. Germ theory came over a millenia later.

eganist··on Tell HN: Eid Mubarak
> By the way, I'm in my period, I'm impure. I can't Eid Mubarak :(

Hey, I'm having a hard time finding a reference for this. Can you source this claim that someone on their period can't celebrate Eid al-Fitr?

eganist··on Tell HN: Eid Mubarak
Please don't use scarequotes to demean a religion and its adherents. Being welcoming of others with varied backgrounds is wonderful and something I'm hopeful more of us can do on HN; it's a great way to give broader perspectives a home and give us all more opportunities, both to connect as well as to build.
eganist··on Explore Washington DC through the eyes of a spy
There was a time when Rosslyn was a great stop, even if it was for just one reason, the Newseum.

...back when the Newseum was there anyway, before their poorly-decided move to DC and subsequent closure.

eganist··on VW, Rivian, Nissan, BMW lose access to U.S. EV tax credits
> Oh, and cut them off from international banking.

How do you propose?

eganist··on de(ep)tangle: Detection of Overlapping Splines
Is the next step reticulating splines once we're able to detect them?
eganist··on NYT/Bellingcat investigators find Pentagon leaker through Instagram photo
Do you have other charity or non-profit recommendations aside from your own personal one? Only asking because I have no measure[1] of how effective yours has been, and I figure in your capacity, you likely don't mind who the intermediary is just so long as it gets to the right place.

[1] https://www.charitynavigator.org/ein/881848788

eganist··on Top neural net engineers are getting paid $5-20M annual compensation packages
For now, up until the models can effectively maintain themselves, and then the money goes to whichever AI companies said engineers helped entrench unless there's a new taxation scheme on AI based on displaced labor.

So, if you do it and clear 5m a year for 3-5 years, at least you know you can retire peacefully in the new hellscape.

eganist··on Deploying key transparency at WhatsApp
Matt, we had this conversation in person at a bsimm conference years ago when we were talking about how best to focus energy during threat modeling exercises. And while your position has become more nuanced, it still reconciles with our original agreement that time is the finite resource.

Unless I'm missing something specific? I imagine the reason why an agency would avoid said hostile battles is specifically to preserve time or perhaps to also buy time. (Being noisy is a great way to lose time quickly)

Agree to disagree on the money component, though. Maybe my comment is best clarified as "infinite from the perspective of [defender]"

eganist··on Deploying key transparency at WhatsApp
Sorry, I didn't communicate my point well.

Agencies, the ones you'd care about, don't spare expenses.

If your threat model includes agencies, making an operation expensive isn't your goal because money might as well be infinite. So you target a different resource:

Time.

It would've taken more time to convince Apple to let the FBI into the San Bernardino shooter's phone than it took for the FBI to use a vendor with a crack for that device and OS. Hence.

---

I'm not disagreeing with the value. I'm merely pointing out that if your goal is to tamper with attack economics, you need to target resources that are finite for the adversary. With many state actors, that resource is time.

eganist··on Deploying key transparency at WhatsApp
> Key transparency makes standard MITM much more detectable, and so it will significantly dissuade agencies and private actors from investing in those capabilities.

Just the private actors. Agencies would just spend more on it, or investigate side channels that achieve the same ends.

eganist··on HTTP Response Header Field: Carbon-Emissions-Scope-2
As I understand it, this doesn't factor in whether the response contains a payload that'll force the client to churn through power.

Given the current rate at which we're outsourcing calculation to e.g web browsers etc., it sounds like keeping this header value low will only perversely accelerate this trend, where work will be duplicated client-side and draw even more power.

eganist··on Seattle's new airport terminal can’t fit planes it was designed to handle
Checks and balances failed. People phoned in the work. I can imagine it.
eganist··on TSMC sales miss for second straight quarter on tepid demand
Seems you're commenting more on the feasibility of surgical taxes rather than the effectiveness of them.

Which is fine; no disagreement there from me. But I'd also posit that government spending on the administrivia is a positive - it's yet another way to keep money moving and likewise keep momentum in the economy.

I guess my point is: the ideal would've been to surgically tax money out of the system, but since we can't (for all the reasons you and I both mentioned), the alternative was rates. And while I hear your point re: cutting spending, you're arguing its merits on the likelihood of it happening, not so much whether one's better than the other. And neither spending cuts nor surgical tax hikes would happen anyway, hence...

...rates. lol

tl;dr: we're saying the same thing. You're talking about which one's more feasible, I'm talking about which one would've probably been more ideal to maintain momentum.

eganist··on TSMC sales miss for second straight quarter on tepid demand
> Inflation was already high when the last large spending package passed and succeeded in over stimulating the economy.

The others answered you pretty well. My comment speaks instead to this recital, which is incorrect and thus undermines the rest of your argument.

Inflation in the US was averaging around 2% since 2008 (https://www.worlddata.info/america/usa/inflation-rates.php), and 2% is generally considered healthy (https://www.federalreserve.gov/faqs/5D58E72F066A4DBDA80BBA65...).

"less government spending" doesn't address the pooled-up liquidity in the economy; it just addresses government spending. Hence the need for the scalpel (finely targeted taxes)... or in the absence of such, the blunt instrument (broadly-impactful rates).

They both extract money, but one's specific to things such as luxury goods, gas-powered vehicles over a certain weight, homes over a certain size or cost relative to local income, a tax per stock trade, whatever makes sense, whereas the other... not so much. Targeted taxes without an increase in spending would result in a net reduction in the budget deficit or even potentially a budget surplus, which then is essentially how the money is removed from circulation. And without using the mallet, businesses can continue to grow in a cheap-money environment.

I'm not an economist; I've just absorbed a lot from working in FIs in the past. But there's probably an economist here who can affirm or debunk what I just put forward.

eganist··on TSMC sales miss for second straight quarter on tepid demand
> The Fed is limited in their toolset, so in order to do that they can raise the federal funds rate basically causing any loans given to have a minimum APR

The Fed is limited much the way a surgeon would be limited if they had to manage a tumor with a mallet.

The solution here would've been targeted taxes to extract the excess liquidity that pooled up in the economy after all the loans and grants, but with a deadlocked legislature this was not going to happen. So, mallet it was.

eganist··on Apple store robbed of $500k in iPhones after thieves tunnel through coffee shop
parts
eganist··on Brave launches self-serve ads program
> This sounds like a desirable group of features, but might this tread a bit too closely to making Brave a money-transmission service and put them under the scrutiny of far more complex regulations?

If it can be made clear that you're paying for content you're consuming, that might waive it to an extent? Who knows.

eganist··on Tesla ordered to pay more than $3M to former worker in racism suit
> The race of Workman seems to bear no relation to the story itself, so why the callout?

I imagine the relation and relevance are apparent from the title of the article and submission:

"Tesla ordered to pay more than $3M to former worker in racism suit"

eganist··on Starlink internet is going from rural savior to unreliable luxury
Not sure where they got that figure; I just spot-checked a few rural homes in reservations and got back the same 120 figure you did.

Fingers crossed something exists for you though.

eganist··on The day Windows died
Microsoft has a habit of flipping settings back to stock, but so far as I know, this has never happened for group policy. I've been using GPOs to reliably flip things off in Windows 10

Can't speak to 11 but I imagine it's the same; GPOs are one of the few things Microsoft wants to make sure never break with an update given the market that uses them.

eganist··on TikTok Ban Bill Is Patriot Act 2.0 Trojan Horse [video]
The issue is that you're not debating this topic in good faith.

This act exempts all information relevant to the act from disclosure, and unlike taxes of individuals, everything that this act would be concerned with is a potential risk to both security and individual liberties of every person in the United States as well as many people abroad.

"Any information" submitted that's relevant to the law ("by a party to a covered transaction in accordance with this Act") is exempted from disclosure. The law's purpose is to enable regulation of covered entities and their covered transactions; that's what determines what's relevant to the law.

Likewise, "Any information" generated by the government as required by the law is exempted from disclosure.

This would mean not only is any submission to the federal government in accordance with the act excluded from FOIA, literally everything the government does in regards to the act, including creating procedures, refining and operating those procedures, and even matters such as OIG reviews of procedures, would be blocked from disclosure.

Which renders true the point I made earlier ("The language exempts everything pertaining to this act") which you so glibly dismissed.

---

I'm not reading replies to this thread, so feel free to get in a last word.

eganist··on TikTok Ban Bill Is Patriot Act 2.0 Trojan Horse [video]
I go into more detail on my thoughts here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35363138

The context in the thread is modestly useful.

eganist··on TikTok Ban Bill Is Patriot Act 2.0 Trojan Horse [video]
The language exempts everything pertaining to this act. If there's intel informing a ban, that's one thing. But everything, even unclassified information? That's too much.
eganist··on TikTok Ban Bill Is Patriot Act 2.0 Trojan Horse [video]
> (2) Inapplicability of FOIA.—

> Any information submitted to the Federal Government by a party to a covered transaction in accordance with this Act, as well as any information the Federal Government may create relating to the review of the covered transaction, is exempt from disclosure under section 552 of title 5, United States Code (commonly referred to as the "Freedom of Information Act").

How is this even remotely acceptable? I'm generally in favor of a TikTok ban, but this bill is so ridiculously onerous that they handed the PR advantage to TikTok and made a necessary national security measure almost entirely unsalable.

eganist··on Senate Bill to Ban TikTok
Speaking at least with my background:

Foreign adversaries have learned exactly how to weaponize our free and open internet against our own people. Regardless of the fact that our kids are most vulnerable, China's seemingly made a point of outsourcing their most polarizing algorithmic decisions to the rest of the world but not to their own population, which is essentially a tacit admission of their awareness of the dangers of social media to their own people.

At this point, I'd venture that politicians in the US are trying to grasp at whatever they can to mitigate the risk while still maintaining their election chances. Easier to "blame China" and get re-elected than it is to dump on their own constituents for not monitoring their kids' social media habits.

And frankly, I'm okay with that. Even if a parent does their best, there'll be second-hand influences through all the kids raised irresponsibly through their parents, and nothing can be done about that aside from homeschooling or going off-grid, which is unsustainable for nearly everyone.

I'm fine with a combination of the bill introduced + bills like the one passed in Utah placing curfews on kids since parents have proven to be so bad at parenting their own kids as to present the nation with an emergent aggregate risk to national security.

eganist··on Treat your to-read pile like a river, not a bucket
In fairness, I think the allure of an app is to act as a forcing function for actually reading the content before it disappears.
eganist··on Keeping up with the overwhelming pace of AI innovation
> 1. Why doesn't every company try to hire contractors then? Making firing employees expensive beyond reason, always seems to significantly increase unemployment rate (Eg France)/drastically increase informal employment (Japan)

This doesn't make firing expensive beyond reason, it makes it only modestly cheaper as opposed to absurdly cheap. Napkin maths:

* Per annum 200,000 spent per employee (100,000 plus benefits, perks, infrastructure, etc.)

* Per annum 25,000 spent per AI agent (10,000 per license plus infrastructure)

* Without tax, 175,000 savings.

* With tax of 70,000 per displaced employee (approximate 2x federal withholding of a Single employee in the US), 105,000 savings to use AI.

This isn't rigorous math, but it should help get the point across.

---

Now, if you just make it a salary conversation:

* 100,000 per employee

* 10,000 per license

* 90,000 savings based on salary v. license alone

* 20,000 savings after that tax.

Either way, AI comes ahead. This just makes sure some of that savings goes into the common welfare rather than upstream to investor pockets.

eganist··on Keeping up with the overwhelming pace of AI innovation
Another comment talked about the need for legislative controls, but mostly to account for the risk of societal breakdown.

I have the same comment but a different domain:

> After that, focus should then shift to dealing with the obsolete worker population in the maximally economical way.

Tax companies at 2x the single-taxpayer withholding amount lost per employee displaced.

So if an employee normally makes 100,000 per year and the average withholding is ~35,000, if 10 jobs are displaced, the tax charge is 700,000. Company still saves 300k, and the AI displacing those ten heads probably Costa 10k per license anyway, so there's still room for AI to make economic sense while backstopping the sociological consequences.

Put that tax revenue directly towards social services or minimum monthly reimbursement for everyone (UBI, just with a different name)

eganist··on Keeping up with the overwhelming pace of AI innovation
> After that, focus should then shift to dealing with the obsolete worker population in the maximally economical way.

Tax companies at 2x the single-taxpayer withholding amount lost per employee displaced.

So if an employee normally makes 100,000 per year and the average withholding is ~35,000, if 10 jobs are displaced, the tax charge is 700,000. Company still saves 300k, and the AI displacing those ten heads probably Costa 10k per license anyway, so there's still room for AI to make economic sense while backstopping the sociological consequences.

Put that tax revenue directly towards social services or minimum monthly reimbursement for everyone (UBI, just with a different name)

← PreviousPage 8 of 34Next →