HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

el_nahual

2,300 karma · joined December 14, 2017

submissionscomments
el_nahual··on Why income share agreements did not work out
This is such an attractive yet mistaken way of looking at the situation.

The more accurate framing is "100% of people pay for 100% of people to have the opportunity to go to college".

A good analogue is insurance: even though 99% of people might never file a claim, it's not 99% subsidizing the 1% the do-- it's 100% paying for protection from financial ruin that 100% receive.

Your framing would apply if there somehow were a group--people with blue eyes, people born in May, whatever--to whom access was limited.

el_nahual··on Are there limits to economic growth?
We have the technology, it's called "taxes", but nobody seems to want to use it.

I suspect that it's actually because nobody has actually find the legwork to go beyond that: how much in taxes, levied how, the money goes where, what are the penalties for non compliance?

And of course the sci-fi elements: what are the unintended consequences? How does life change? Who loses, who wins?

el_nahual··on Wet-Bulb Temperature
A fan works by speeding up the rate of evaporation from your skin, which cools you off. At these wet bulb temperatures the ratio of heat/humidity is so high that blowing hot air over your skin just heats you up faster. Kind of like turning on the convection feature in an oven.
el_nahual··on Wet-Bulb Temperature
The humidity is the issue. Wet-bulb temperatures exceeding body temperature means sweating no longer cools you off.

That's why steam rooms peak at ~110 and saunas at ~150. A steam room at 110 is almost unbearably hot, it's hard to last more than 5 or 10 minutes in one.

Think about a human having a fever of 108—that's the temperature at which you'd start to have convulsions.

el_nahual··on Wet-Bulb Temperature
This is the key part:

> A sustained wet-bulb temperature exceeding 35 °C (95 °F) is likely to be fatal even to fit and healthy people, unclothed in the shade next to a fan; at this temperature human bodies switch from shedding heat to the environment, to gaining heat from it.

The important thing is that passive/evaporative cooling simply stops working. In fact, sitting in front of a fan would actually speed up your death. You'll also die shockingly quickly (20 or so minutes, even for healthy, fit adults).

The only thing that can save you is:

- air conditioning

- getting in a cold tub

- going somewhere cooler (obviously) like a basement or parking structure

There are two thing that make this frightening:

1. We have already, for the first time in history, started seeing spikes of wet-bulb temperatures that exceed these values. Fortunately so far they have been in uninhabited areas.

2. If we ever see these temperatures in a city, odds are that the electrical grid would fail on account of the strain by A/C units.

So picture this: a heat wave of this magnitude hits a large city. Bangkok, Phoenix, Melbourne. It lasts for 48+ hours. The grid fails on account of the strain. We're looking at a mass casualty event with millions of dead in a matter of hours/days.

el_nahual··on Ask HN: What caused the Olympics to become so terrible?
> The problem is that US audiences only want to watch American competitors

I think there's a [citation needed] here. This is what people think is true, but I'd argue is wrong--as evidenced by a collapse in viewership!

People want entertainment that is fun and emotional, and the US coverage isn't providing that, perhaps because they are constrained by thinking that US audiences only care about US athletes.

el_nahual··on Ask HN: What caused the Olympics to become so terrible?
US coverage is less fun because they focus on US athletes all the time, even when they are not participating. So if there's no swimming on, instead of watching some random-ass sport--which is fun--we have to watch a random human interest story--which is not fun.

Obviously they should cover US athletes when they are participating but they cover them all the time. It's just more boring.

el_nahual··on Ask HN: What caused the Olympics to become so terrible?
I don't know where you live, but my experience is that in the US, the network coverage just ruined the Olympics because they don't "get it."

I grew up in a different country--not the US, China or Russia. We typically hope to get a half dozen medals and a gold would be a Big Deal.

As a result, if you turn on the TV, you get random coverage of any of the hundreds of individual competitions. Modern pentathlon! The one where they jump on a trampoline! Handball!

There are so many sports that it's non-stop coverage. Also, because it's live, whenever someone from your home country has a chance to medal it's a big deal: everyone stops doing what they are doing to watch TV. Collectively. It's an "event".

It's really fun and--this is key-- emotional. Not just to watch your country medal but all of the other sports, winners, losers, etc.

In the US the TV coverage is garbage. It's 100% US-centric, which would be excusable (if shortsighted, because it's less fun and emotional). Worse, it's not even live, which makes it less special. And they don't show any sports where the US isn't competitive, which makes it less novel and fun.

el_nahual··on New Zealand's bid to become a dark sky nation
Unfortunately it's also:

1. Much blue-er and so WAY worse for people's circadian rhythms 2. Much "sharper" in it's shadows, so you go from blindingly bright to pitch black without your eyes having a chance to adapt, making it unsafer, and making the shadows "darker" 3. Much harder to filter out for astronomers

It's only advantage is really that it's a lot more energy efficient, but it seems like white LEDs are a net decrease to human welfare as opposed to yellow sodium lamps.

Anecdotally, I used to live in front of a park that had yellow lamps and it was never an issue at night, but when they switched to white LEDs my entire house was illuminated with very blue, daylike-like light, really messing up my sleep.

el_nahual··on How the Soviets put a lander on Venus
There's a funny (?) joke about this:

First satellite: USSR

First animal in space: USSR

First person in space: USSR

First woman in space: USSR

First space walk: USSR

First space station: USSR

First photos from another planet: USSR

First person on the moon: USA

Stop the count!

Winner of the space race: USA

el_nahual··on Ask HN: What to do instead of drinking alcohol?
I have no idea if there are any studies. It's a very subtle difference. I would describe it as a certain... crispness.

A mild hum of well being in the back of the brain.

Like lifting the very light blanket of an endless hangover; a blanket so light you don't notice its presence, only its absence.

Of course--and as usual for this sort of thing--lots of confounding factors, N of 1, YMMV, etc etc

el_nahual··on Ask HN: What to do instead of drinking alcohol?
I went from moderate (weekends, social, never alone) drinking to _zero_ drinking for about five years. This was during peak "social" life of after university and before marriage.

I did the exact same things I used to do except with no alcohol: bars, clubs, parties, whatever.

The toughest thing was realizing how...boring...some of these activities can be. There is, by default, an enormous amount of "down time" at a bar or club or young person's party; down time that people tend to fill by going to the bar for a drink, or sipping on a cocktail, or eventually by being drunk and letting the time pass.

The second toughest thing was realizing how irritating drunk people (and yes, this includes your friends) can be when you're sober.

But I stuck with it, and after a few months I learned different strategies for enjoying a night out--usually revolving around talking to other sober people, or dancing--and my life is much better for it.

Lastly, in my experience i didn't feel the full mental benefits of no alcohol until after about four or six months without a drop.

el_nahual··on IRS: Stolen property must be reported as income on taxes
It's also a disincentive to steal instead of paying taxes. Otherwise one could choose to steal money (say, embezzling from a family business instead of paying oneself) with the idea of "I'd rather go to jail for 5 years than pay X million in tax"
el_nahual··on Swedes were fooled by one of the biggest scientific bluffs of our time (2020)
I must have not done a good job explaining. Of course depression is a biological condition (because the mind emerges from the brain). That doesn't mean it's a single condition with a single cause or even a group of pathological causes, the way cancer is, or MLS.

But yes, of course it's biological. What an intellectually honest psychiatrist would say is something like "look, you're not doing well. Here are some things we can try to shift the playing field a bit. We don't know exactly how they work or why, but we know they do work, somewhat. Want to try? Here's the side effects: "

That would be intellectually honest. Saying "you have A (single, diagnosed) disease, caused by "a chemical imbalance", and the root cause of that disease is treated by this medicine" is dishonest.

el_nahual··on Swedes were fooled by one of the biggest scientific bluffs of our time (2020)
This is just wrong. Depression is a descriptive condition, not a prescrtive one.

Many psychiatrists--the quack ones--will use the language of "chemical imbalance" as a sort of "appeal to authority" fallacy. It should be obvious that this is a fallacy because:

A) at no point have they actually measured the patient's brain chemistry (and it's not obvious what it would even mean to do this? an imbalance where? compared to what?)

B) the doctor diagnosed the depression doing exactly what TFA did: matched a set of symptoms to a list.

One of the harshest criticisms of the DSM-V -- the latest version of this descriptive manual--is that it grossly expands the symptoms that qualify as depression (to include things like bereavement, for example).

The "chemical imbalance" theory was based on the success of SSRIs to treat depression. These are chemicals that inhibit the reuptake of serotonin, which results in overproduction of that neurotransmitter. "Ah, so depression is a lack of serotonin"

Counterfactual evidence is conveniently ignored. For example, the fact that antipsychotics, which block the reception of serotonin (and so are basically the opposite of SSRIs), are also powerful antidepressants!

It's also a nonsense theory to anyone with an undergraduate knowledge of neuroscience. There is no "happiness" neurotransmitter. Serotonin is simply an inhibitory neurotransmitter, which reduces the odds of a neuron 'firing'. Which neuron? Part of what network? Wait, what? In the immortal words of Paul Dirac "it's not even wrong."

In fact, most of the most promising new therapies for depression have nothing to do with serotonin: psylocibin (many orders of magnitude more effective than SSRIs), ketamine and transcranial magnetic stimulation are examples.

Of course, the mind is a side effect of physiology: there must be some biological explanation to depression. But that doesn't mean that it's the same explanation for everyone, or that it has anything to do with a "chemical imbalance" of one neurotransmitter vs another.

el_nahual··on James Webb Space Telescope launch [video]
"In God We Trust" was added to currency in the mid 1950s as part of the "Red Scare" and anticommunist sentiment.

Before 1957 the national motto was E PLURIBUS UNUM - One From Many. Too commie!

This was the same time that "under god" was added to the pledge of allegiance, which before just read "... One nation, indivisible"

el_nahual··on James Webb Space Telescope launch [video]
The skillset required to do Difficult a Thing, Fast is independent to the skillset required for being a smart scientist.

Moving quickly requires very specific managerial skills & risk appetites.

Legacy scientific institutions (like NASA, or most universities) have basically succumbed to extreme Peter Principle: everyone has been promoted to their level of incompetence. Excellent thinkerw can make catastrophic managers.

This is a known issue in startup land, and mitigations have a been learned. Examples: independent, deep career paths for mangers and contributors. A funding model that is milestones based with minimal barriers to entry.

SpaceX of course being some sort of proof in this regard.

It's not just NASA of course. Look at ITER--a fusion project started in 2007 with an expected completion date of 2025. Or the Second Avenue Subway, or any number of infrastructure projects.

If you wrote a company manual designed to maximize the odds of failure, you'd end up with something pretty close to the way academic and govt projects are run.

el_nahual··on The sea people: Alexander the Great trod in the footsteps of forgotten Greeks
The linked article is about the bronze age: which to people living in biblical times was as far back in time as biblical times are to us.
el_nahual··on Searchable flight logs from Jeffrey Epstein’s plane
How about a LinkedIn integration that cross-references your contacts with the flight logs. That would be interesting.
el_nahual··on Scattered thoughts on why I waste my own time
Thought experiment:

Imagine that a flaw is exposed in a cheap slot machine that slightly shifts the odds in the player's favor. Because of the low bet value in the slot machine, the rewards ends up being something like $10/hour.

Case A: The bug neutralizes the slot odds and adds a constant $0.005 usd that accumulates every pull. Times 30 pulls per minute times 60 pulls per hour = 9 bucks an hour.

Case B: The reward neutralizes the odds but adds a random $600 drop with 1/126,000 probability (ie, once a week).

The expected value of both games is the same, but I feel like people would get addicted to the second while the first would feel like a job.

el_nahual··on I once killed a $125M deal by being “too honest”
I've heard it as "don't sell what has been sold."
el_nahual··on “If You Are Not Drowning in Demand, You Don’t Have Product-Market Fit” (2017)
There is actually a very good reason why a VC-backed/VC-backable business shouldn't take 100M from Softbank at a 1B valuation:

Because it removes the possibility of exiting for tens or hundreds of millions--the preference stack will eat up all the equity.

Most VC backed companies that exit do so for far less than a B; if the startup has been responsible about fundraising then a 50M, 100M, etc exit can be life-changing for the founders. Raising too much makes this impossible and turns the whole venture into much more of an all-or-nothing affair.

Of course, the VCs don't care: they make money from the big winners, so they could care less about a 50M exit, but the founders should not.

el_nahual··on Cloudflare's Disruption
Correct, edited my comment to show revenue. I'm old enough to remember a time when an "undefined" P/E ratio would have raised eyebrows.
el_nahual··on Cloudflare's Disruption
Kind of. It's undervalued in the sense that it's a growing business that will probably track "the growth of the internet" (so, will continue growing for a long, long time).

It's not undervalued in that quarterly revenue are $152.4 million, on a market cap of $35 billion dollars, for a staggering multiple of 57 times revenue.

Edit: Had quarterly earnings instead of revenue.

el_nahual··on Pausing “Instagram Kids” and building parental supervision tools
> Take their phones. Put them in a box. Sit on the box and guard it. Maybe buy a Faraday bag or something.

A family member tried this. The kid's bicycle was stolen (no it wasn't, the kid traded it for a "secret" phone he used during no-phone hours).

This reinforces the "Give up now" point. You won't control access for your kids, but you can try to give them better emotional tools to cope with the world they live in.

el_nahual··on Chery QQ Ice Cream goes on sale in China – a modern electric car for $4,600
Yes, those commercial vehicles are on the road but they don't have to be on the road at the same time most people are on the road.

The idea that most Americans live in some sort of farm is actually wrong. Over 80% of Americans live somewhere urban. And yes, trucks, deliveries, etc should not be allowed to drive in urban areas except at night and in the early morning: for traffic and safety.

This should be regulated in Manhattan as well as Des Moines, and even in cities like Houston where the interstate is used for local trips. Driving a truck? Take the detour that skips Houston entirely during the day.

el_nahual··on MIT-designed project achieves major advance toward fusion energy
Aren't fast decay times harder to handle?
el_nahual··on Simulator of digging a tunnel through the earth
Why wouldn't the passengers survive? Even though they will reach terrifying speeds, at no point will their acceleration exceed a relatively gentle 9.8ms^-2
el_nahual··on Actual impostors don't get impostor syndrome
This reminds me of my favorite joke about impostor syndrome.

A young grad student is suffering from a bout of impostor syndrome.

One day, the student (after weeks of mustering up the required courage) walks into their professor's office.

"Professor, may I ask you a question?" says the grad student.

"Of course" says the professor, barely looking up from their papers.

"What do you think about impostor syndrome? I...hear that most grad students have it at some point."

"Balderdash! I can tell you the vast majority of students here do not have impostor syndrome!" says the professor.

"Really?"

"Of course. For it to be impostor syndrome, they'd actually have to be good"

el_nahual··on Does Oil Come from Dinosaurs?
It's just a Fermi estimate. Feel free to multiply/divide by ten (or even 100!) in either direction. The main point is that we're not going to carbon capture our way out of this--at least not with anything resembling modern technology.
← PreviousPage 6 of 9Next →