HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

erentz

9,697 karma · joined April 8, 2015

submissionscomments
erentz··on Cuban: Facebook knowingly runs AI deepfake scam ads; docs say $16B fraud revenue
> Run a classified ad in a newspaper

This is not true in the case where the newspaper knows it is a scam, right? So as soon as Facebook says "we've reviewed this scam ad you notified us of, but found it complies with our terms and conditions", they're pretty clearly knowingly participating.

erentz··on Cuban: Facebook knowingly runs AI deepfake scam ads; docs say $16B fraud revenue
In theory doesn't this open them up to legal action?

Prior to being notified they could claim they were unaware it was fraud. But after being notified of it, they have confirmed back that they reviewed it. Yet they continue to show it, making them aware and participating in the distribution.

erentz··on Cuban: Facebook knowingly runs AI deepfake scam ads; docs say $16B fraud revenue
You're just responding here by saying "by law they are not thing X" in response to people who are saying "maybe the law should be different because they sure act like thing X".
erentz··on Cuban: Facebook knowingly runs AI deepfake scam ads; docs say $16B fraud revenue
I feel like whenever S230 comes up and I see people defending it I get confused because the defense doesn't seem to address what seems to be the concern of the people saying it needs removing (or more realistically reforming).

The concerned is one of consistency in how media is regulated. E.g. Facebook, is the worlds largest media company, and it truly acts and behaves as a publisher now. It acquires its content from an army of paid and unpaid providers. They may be individuals, often they are influencers, often they may be nefarious agents and companies. It then decides how to place that content in it's "publication", which just happens to be an app and website. It goes out and tells the market, "I have this great publication in which you can place ads!". It then sells ads to those people, and makes a decision on how to place those advertisements inside its publication alongside that content that it acquired.

So how is it not a publisher? And why should it be regulated to any kind of different standard from other publishers?

erentz··on US Democrats Win Enough Seats Nationwide to End Presidential Electoral College
AFAICT the distinction is if it is “in coordination” with a campaign. Same with PACs. Your super PAC can’t coordinate with a campaign. It’s part of what differentiates them and why they can raise unlimited money.

All he has to do is spend the money himself, as a private, real person, without any coordination with a campaign, and he can spend as much as he likes.

erentz··on US Democrats Win Enough Seats Nationwide to End Presidential Electoral College
That cap is what a person can give to a campaign.

CU let companies donate to campaigns and PACs. This talk about state by state changes to put a stop to that is nice (Montana, Hawaii). But Elon Musk is not a company, he actually is a person.

You can give unlimited to a super PAC. Ok, next you get rid of super PACs, which came after CU, fine.

But now still, how does that stop an Elon Musk going out and spending $100m on political advertising as a private individual? That’s what the Musks of this world can still do after you get rid of super PACs.

erentz··on US Democrats Win Enough Seats Nationwide to End Presidential Electoral College
People keep talking about citizens united. And sure it needs to go. But it doesn’t really solve more than a small part of the problem because it just reduces what /corporations/ can spend.

Wealthy people like Elon Musk can still go ahead and spend hundreds of millions on campaigns like they just did. There is no cap on that.

erentz··on Study estimates 75% of NFL players who died over 15-year span had CTE
The adult culture around high school football in the US is creepy to me. All these grown men pushing and promoting and getting excited (and aggressive) about it, with stadiums and equipment and media that would put most professional leagues overseas to shame.
erentz··on Google will turn off search for schools that reject AI
Dons tinfoil hat

Have you noticed how many people already use AI to do their thinking for them. They just ask it what to think, what to do, for everything. They want that for as many people as possible. They don’t want people going outside of Google to other websites to decide what to think. Yes they will put ads in it eventually. But in the end they will also use it to influence what the population thinks.

We already have some leaders and politicians outsourcing their thinking in this way. It will make these companies incredibly powerful.

erentz··on The U.S. Census Bureau and "Super Intelligence"
I'd go further and say that the rest of the cabinet should also be elected from the House (not just the President). This ensures a cabinet member is answerable to both the House and to an electorate. Though the two-year terms in the US House are probably too frequent for a parliamentary style system like this (perpetual campaigning).
erentz··on Medicare Will Pay $50k for Your Heart Attack. It Should Pay $100 to Prevent It
> The CAC scan, which detects calcified plaque in the arteries, is recommended for adults with borderline or intermediate risk of coronary disease for whom the decision to start preventive therapy such as statin drugs remains uncertain.

That is such incredibly bad advice. DO NOT WAIT until a CAC tells you to start a statin. You know you need to start if your LDL is high right away.

My doctor referred me to get a self pay ($100 at the time) CAC 9 years ago. It was completely clear.

However last year I had a cardiac ultrasound and it showed calcification.

In reality the CAC caused a false sense of security. My LDL had been high the whole time and not managed with any intervention despite having been tested multiple times and showing high over that time. This was a failure by my doctors IMO. (No it’s not diet or weight related before people give advice).

I didn’t need a CAC to tell me everything was fine. I needed to be on a low dose of statin that whole time.

A clear CAC doesn’t mean you are safe. And a positive CAC is already too late and is not really telling you anything useful.

What people need to do is just watch your LDL regularly starting from any age (yes even some 20 year olds need to check this). Don’t wait to middle age. And no matter your age use whatever methods you prefer to get that down as low as possible. Think of it as cumulative exposure over time that matters.

(There are new oral PCKS9 inhibitors out now which is cool, but the reality is all the misinformation about statins has been bullshit, don’t be afraid of them.)

erentz··on Newborn girls and boys show different attention patterns within hours of birth
The differences observed are at the population level. That means there is HUGE overlap between the two populations and you can’t distinguish any data point as being a girl or a boy. Only that the populations have a different average or range. For a visual representation check out [1].

This kind of thing shows up all over the place in all fields of research. It’s why for example although you can see immune system differences at a population level between patients with disease X and healthy controls, you can’t in any way use it as a biomarker for an individual who might have disease X.

[1] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s13293-026-00976-9...

erentz··on Asana cleared 5 years of engineering work in 2 weeks with Codex
> An engineer checked progress twice a day and reviewed every proposed change.

It doesn’t sound like that much changed. If one engineer can really review all the changes in under two weeks, the original estimate of 5 years of engineering work has to be waaaaaaay off.

erentz··on Treasury Orders Erasure of Domestic Ownership Records
I think the genesis was the Panama papers release way back. Turns out the US is one of the better places to launder money through.

I don’t understand though: Why would any company find it difficult to register their owners? That seems like a pretty basic thing any company should know and it’s a perfectly normal thing in most countries.

erentz··on Chicago Mercantile Exchange will list futures contracts for GPU costs
This all feels like when Enron started talking about making a market for trading /bandwidth/.
erentz··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
See: “benefits in terms of capital spending + the few ongoing jobs created”
erentz··on Irish datacenters now guzzle 23% of the country's electricity
> There IS value being created, or people wouldn't use the tools.

But for who and where is it realized? Ireland’s massive data centers aren’t there to serve Ireland’s tiny population. The value is exported overseas and profits realized overseas.

So what really matters for Ireland (and any country/region hosting these data centers) is whether the benefits in terms of capital spending + the few ongoing jobs created outweighs any increased electricity and environmental costs faced by everyone else.

erentz··on New York City to ban deceptive subscription practices
> Americans really do get screwed in so many ways.

Absolutely. I assumed the parent was talking about the US because that's the only place in the world I've encountered this.

erentz··on New York City to ban deceptive subscription practices
It’s not your property they care about. They usually want this because it includes liability insurance if you damage their property or someone else’s, or your negligence causes harm to someone.
erentz··on Virginia bans sale of geolocation data
What is the rationale for going to the trouble of such a law but only banning sale, rather than all sharing?
erentz··on Danish privacy activist Lars Andersen raided by police
What makes it giving up sovereignty? I understand it creates the potential for separation in future but not yet. The devolution of Scotland and Wales happened peacefully a couple(?) of years later, and Scotland may also separate in future.
erentz··on Danish privacy activist Lars Andersen raided by police
How can we know the IRA “won”? The country changed a hell of a lot over the course of the Troubles and by the time of the GFA in 1998 I don’t see how it is so clear that the reforms wouldn’t have also been achieved via other peaceful and democratic means.
erentz··on Tesla allegedly in autopilot mode crashes into Texas house, woman killed
You’re extremely confident about this just based on your experience of it not happening to you. It’s good that it hasn’t driven you into a house but that doesn’t mean it can’t fail in a way that does drive someone else into a house.
erentz··on Norway imposes near ban on AI in elementary school
Your example would call more to create an "information technology" subject in schools, that updates its curriculum to include changes like the development of AI. Thus, you go to that class, some of your coursework in the year is going to involve learning about AI and how it works, what it can and cannot do, using it for some project, so on. Not using AI for doing your homework in every other subject.
erentz··on Bernie Sanders unveils plan to give the public direct ownership of AI companies
It’s a tax. So the government wouldn’t be buying anything. OpenAI (for example) would need to issue 100% new shares and give them to the government to hold in this new sovereign wealth fund. This the new sovereign wealth fund holds 50% of the company.

I don’t know how you decide what companies are targeted though. OpenAI/Anthropic are pure AI plays. But what about an AMZN or AAPL that have AI as only a part of their business.

erentz··on Vance: Iran can have access to $300B reconstruction fund
This would be an incredible $1,800 from each taxpayer sent overseas to the Iranian regime. On top of what’s already been spent and the inflation caused. In any other time in history just this alone (ignoring all the other scandals) would lead to something like a landslide 100 seat swing in the house. The fact polls show we’ll be lucky to see 10 seats switch shows how incredibly broken our information environment has become.
erentz··on EY Canada published a cybersecurity report and most citations were hallucinated
It looks like when you sum up: the cost to generate information using an LLM + the cost to actually verify the information, the result on average is the same as not using the LLM. That does not mean some times it isn’t faster and cheaper. It just means other times it’s slower and more costly. This along with different people’s tolerance for accuracy explains why we see such diverging experiences with it.

So in order to make it pan out the forces at play are trying to make everyone believe we now have to accept wrong, even dangerous results.

erentz··on The four-day workweek in Australia: insights from early adopters of 100:80:100
NZ is even worse than Australia on the housing tax vs shares tax front. No housing taxes. Yet they have what is effectively an annual wealth tax on shares (FIF) even on their pitiful retirement savings schemes. This discourages saving in shares and encourages putting money in real estate.
erentz··on Meta's embrace of AI is making its employees miserable
But now even this is just producing more information and requires more work both of you and of the original sender.
erentz··on Meta's embrace of AI is making its employees miserable
Seems AI has made it cheap to produce information but now you have to spend more time parsing the information. And it’s now the less competent/useful people spending less time producing more information with the more useful people spending more of their valuable time parsing that information. This is why I’m skeptical of LLMs ever becoming a net benefit in most organizations.
Page 1 of 34Next →