HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

eterevsky

1,390 karma · joined August 28, 2017

submissionscomments
eterevsky··on New theory claims to unite Einstein's gravity with quantum mechanics
Previous discussion on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36667278
eterevsky··on The Dunning-Kruger effect is autocorrelation
I think this article would've made more sense if it had a title "The Dunning-Kruger effect is regression toward the mean", because that's what the author is actually showing.
eterevsky··on RFC 9498 on the GNU Name System
Yep. In 2000 when I saw "GNU" in the name, I got mildly excited.

Now when I see it, I'm expecting it to be semi-abandoned and its developers to care more about ideology than about the technology.

eterevsky··on Sam Bankman-Fried is a feature, not a bug
The author would've had a point if SBF actually donated all the stolen money to effective charities. But he didn't, he just appropriated it.

So his actions are in no way consistent with EA, and shouldn't be considered indicative of it.

eterevsky··on Optical or Digital: Minimum focusing distance on iPhone 15 Pro Max 5x camera
With the same optics the 2x picture the effective size of the sensor is 2x smaller and it receives 4x less light. This has to result in the lower-quality picture.

Also, the resolution of the photo is mostly limited not by the number of megapixels, but by optical resolution of the lens.

eterevsky··on Optical or Digital: Minimum focusing distance on iPhone 15 Pro Max 5x camera
When my cat does something funny, I usually have a phone at hand, but the camera is in another room. There's a lot of other situations in which snapping a quick photo on the phone is the only way.
eterevsky··on Optical or Digital: Minimum focusing distance on iPhone 15 Pro Max 5x camera
I also bought iPhone 15 Pro Max partly because of the 5x zoom, but I'm somewhat disappointed. The gap between 1x and 5x is just too big and includes focal lengths that are very useful for things like portraits.

I wish they had 4 cameras at 0.5x, 1x, 3x and 10x like Samsung does.

eterevsky··on The costs of microservices (2020)
1) Why is it better than wrapping it in an interface with a clear API without extracting it into a separate service?
eterevsky··on The costs of microservices (2020)
In my experience, if a piece of code is stateful and is called from several different services, then it should be its own service. Otherwise it is usually better off as a library.
eterevsky··on New signs appear to ban phones from Temple Quay
The article suggests that this land is owned by a public organization.
eterevsky··on New signs appear to ban phones from Temple Quay
What is Temple Quay?
eterevsky··on Elephants are scared around bees
My cats have been bitten by various insects more than once and are still not at all "scaredy" around them.
eterevsky··on The importance of handwriting is now better understood
The main advantage of handwriting is in the fact that it is slower, so it requires putting more thought into compressing whatever you are writing. (The article itself states it and I remember this explanation coming up in other studies.)

To me it means that you could get benefits of writing when you are typing by adjusting what you are actually doing. For instance, you could re-read and edit what you have typed after the fact. Or you could deliberately try to phrase the notes in your own words.

eterevsky··on BeagleV-Ahead open-source RISC-V single board computer
micro-USB 3.0? Why?
eterevsky··on Metric Time
This metric time goes only part of the way. "Day" shouldn't be a metric unit, since it changes over time and only makes sense on Earth.

Unix timestamp is the real metric time because it only uses seconds which is a metric unit of time.

eterevsky··on Fidonet Rules (2014)
I had a Fido node in the late 90s — early 2000s.

One thing I miss is the fact that it was possible to have civil conversations on very controversial subjects.

eterevsky··on FindMyCat – Open-Source Pet Tracker
I would immediately buy those for my three cats. We are currently using Tractive and the battery barely lasts a whole day.
eterevsky··on Turbo 8 is dropping TypeScript
I'm not sure about "spending hours". In my experience it's more like "detect an error during compilation instead of an exception during execution". Once you see the exception, it's usually quite clear what exact property is misspelled. So strong typing saves a few second of execution and reduces the need for some types of unit tests.
eterevsky··on Supporting people’s right to accurate and safe political discourse on X
I disagree with Twitter's decision on the first count and don't have a good opinion about the second.

However these examples fall far short of what other social media companies are doing. On YouTube a year ago you could be banned for suggesting that Covid could started as a lab leak.

eterevsky··on Goodreads is terrible for books – why can’t we all quit it?
Why quit Goodreads completely if you can just use the good parts of it? I use it to:

- manage my "read" and "to-read" books,

- glance through a couple of top reviews for the book that I'm intending to read

Goodreads is super useful for these features. I don't know how many times I saw a mention of a book, added it to my to-read list only to finally read it years later.

What I don't do on Goodread:

- look at the average score (it's meaningless),

- engage too much with social features.

eterevsky··on Supporting people’s right to accurate and safe political discourse on X
I don't really see Twitter banning users for "incorrect" political speech. Moreover, their Community Notes work very well for fact-checking.
eterevsky··on NASA officials sound alarm over future of the Deep Space Network
Aren't missions paying for the usage of DSN? How come a small cubesat gets the amount of time on the network comparable to JWST?

Could this be commercialized? If there's high demand it should be profitable to build new dishes to increase bandwidth.

eterevsky··on Consciousness in AI: Insights from the Science of Consciousness
Descartes' and Spinoza's view as you are describing them are purely philosophical and don't have any bearing on the empirical science.

I don't see how your description Hume's contribution extends beyond basic scientific method, developed by Francis Bacon, Galileo et al

eterevsky··on Consciousness in AI: Insights from the Science of Consciousness
1. I think most traditional approaches to epistemology disagree with you.

2. Doesn't the same logic apply to basically everything else? It doesn't rely on any specific properties of the brain.

3. Replace an arm by a car. Would a person sitting at the steering wheel of a car be different from the same person outside of it? If no, then what's the salient difference between an arm and a car?

eterevsky··on Consciousness in AI: Insights from the Science of Consciousness
I don't quite get your arguments about requiring us to be "external" to reality to be able to understand brain. First of all, I don't see why you can't study something of which you are a part of. Secondly, even if you accept this supposition, Alice is external to Bob and Bob is external to Alice, so Alice could study Bob's brain and Bob can study Alice's brain.

> We can't perceive the "roads not taken" in terms of development, nor can we know if there is "something we're missing" in terms of understanding the brain.

What do you mean "we can't"? Of course we do know that "something is missing", because we can't build a good predictive theory of how consciousness work.

> Self includes the body, which implies that merely copying the brain, no matter how perfectly, is not an accurate copy.

So you consider a person with an amputated arm a different person, not just the same person, who just can't use their arm anymore?

eterevsky··on Consciousness in AI: Insights from the Science of Consciousness
Could you elaborate? In my view the current empirical consciousness research is built on top of neuroscience and cognitive science. I don't see any connection between them and the works of Hume, Descartes and Spinoza.
eterevsky··on Consciousness in AI: Insights from the Science of Consciousness
> I don’t think full-brain simulation is possible

We clearly aren't close to implementing them, but why do you think they are outright impossible? Brain is a physical object. Why isn't it possible to simulate its behavior?

> That doesn’t mean it would be okay to “torture” the simulation

So it would mean that they are ethically significant, even if they don't have the same rights as a human being. If you agree, then would this also apply to synthetic conscious AIs?

> it would be a different ethical situation from real humans.

I agree. Their way of living would be very different: you can speed up or pause the simulation, fork it or archive it. Questions like "is it ok for an individual to clone themselves and then kill the copy?" don't even make sense for regular humans, but can apply to simulations.

That said, if for some reason my brain gets scanned one day, I would like my virtual copy to be treated humanely.

eterevsky··on Consciousness in AI: Insights from the Science of Consciousness
... and is pretty much useless.

Could you name any pre-20th century theory about consciousness that would be remotely relevant today?

eterevsky··on Consciousness in AI: Insights from the Science of Consciousness
Consider full-brain simulation. Do you think that it shouldn't be afforded the same way as a flesh-and-blood human?

If not, would you be ok with torturing simulated individuals to make them work?

If yes, then how would you draw a line between a full-brain simulation and a "synthetic" AI?

eterevsky··on Consciousness in AI: Insights from the Science of Consciousness
> Consciousness and attendant concepts have been active research problems for thousands of years.

In the book "Consciousness and the Brain" neuroscientist Stanislas Dehaene writes that up until 1980s or 90s studying consciousness was basically out of scope for empirical science, since conscious seemed very difficult to define. So we have been seriously studying consciousness for only 30-something years.

Furthermore, there is no scientific consensus regarding how exactly consciousness works. For that reason the authors of the paper apply several different theories of consciousness.

← PreviousPage 4 of 16Next →