HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ewjordan

2,337 karma · joined July 7, 2008

submissionscomments
ewjordan··on Judge the value of what you have by what you had to give up to get it
Unfortunately the title is misleading, and it makes sense that some would interpret it as supporting the sunk cost fallacy - the author is actually advocating for judging how much you should give up to get something by how much you'll value it, whereas the title has it flipped the other way.
ewjordan··on Darwin: a genomics co-processor provides up to 15,000x acceleration
The miner's identity (more or less) has to be one of the inputs to the problem, so that everyone is actually working on a different problem and you can't "steal" a block just by broadcasting another person's solution faster and wider.

Maybe there could be useful problems with this property, but it's not trivial to find them.

ewjordan··on Science Is Getting Us Closer To The End of Infertility
Ok, but...is there any particular reason to think IVF is not safe, other than a superstitious ookiness about the methodology of the thing?

40 years without any such indication is fairly strong evudence, IMO.

ewjordan··on Protecting GDPR Personal Data with Pseudonymization
Most lawyers seem to be advising the opposite, though, and say that backups are ok - do you have some knowledge here, or are you arguing the spirit of the law?
ewjordan··on Ask HN: Strategies for database reliability when I have no control over the DB?
If you need to write to the DB, you're hosed, and caching locally will only make things more of a headache. If not, you might be able to improve read uptime, but at a high cost. It's not easy to keep a local DB in sync with a remote that's only got 90% uptime, especially since it sounds like you have no support from the DBAs (they'd ideally need to set up replication permissions for you, and with that much downtime it's going to be a mess).

As others have said, this is an organizational issue and the best way to handle it is to dig into the human politics.

ewjordan··on The Most Common Type of Incompetent Leader
Avoiding this kind of "leadership" is especially crucial for product owners on interdisciplinary teams, like game teams. There you might have 20-50+ people across engineering, design, planning, art, QA, analytics, and business development, all of whom have separate and conflicting goals and incentives. At bigger companies you'll also have partners and stakeholders outside the team. Balancing all of these interests means that you have to be saying "no" most of the time, and you have to be able to do so in a way that doesn't alienate people. Being wishy washy in those situations leads to an unfocused product that can't ship on time, and a team that becomes disengaged and increasingly bitter as conflicts begin happening one-on-one without any mediation.

Being effective at that level is really difficult, and as easy as it may be to criticize leaders who are bad at it, it's really a rare leader that excels across the board. Keep that in mind when judging failures, it's always easy to point out when people mess up when you don't truly understand the scope of the problems they're facing. There's a reason good leaders are paid so well.

ewjordan··on Managing database schema changes without downtime
Significantly altering an active table without downtime is a problem that will not, and should not, ever be solved by a library. It's too fraught with peril and special case fun for any competent devops person to leave it up to external code.
ewjordan··on Evolution Is the New Deep Learning
Wait, I'm confused...you're saying genetic approaches fell out of favor because they're basically just stochastic gradient descent? Most of modern DL relies heavily on SGD at various points during training.

My impression is that they fell out of favor precisely because don't actually use any gradients, and end up converging on good maxima slower than you could if you used the gradients from the net. Am I off base here?

ewjordan··on Eldar Black Holes
+1 for Wald - MTW is great, but it's really dense, and takes some odd approaches that are not really common in the field. Wald stays lean and tight, while still covering the important stuff.

You'll probably find MTW a lot more approachable after working through a few less beastly texts.

ewjordan··on Preparing for Malicious Uses of AI
> We don't even know if or to what degree 'super-intelligence' is possible. For all we know, there may be fundamental trade offs between the different skills necessary for general intelligence that may provide functional limits to the degree to which intelligence can be super human.

While this is true, it would be extremely surprising if evolution's first stab at higher intelligence (humans) came anywhere near the theoretical limits of what intelligence could be if directly selected for.

Just remove the size and energy consumption constraints imposed on the human brain by what the human body can support, and you should be able to get a significant improvement without changing the base architecture much at all.

Digitize and allow for copy/paste of "brains", and now you've got 30,000,000 copies of Einstein working together on problems but each specializing in their own pursuits, each of which doesn't get tired and lives forever, and can open very high-throughput direct neural communication channels with the other Einsteins whenever they need to share knowledge.

Start tweaking the virtual brain's "chemical" environment, and you can probably supercharge them by doing all sorts of stuff that would kill a real human but is fine when all you care about is making a simulated brain work better (virtual megadoses of Ritalin, massive tweaks to neurotransmitter behaviors, etc.).

These are just a few obvious ideas, but it's hard to imagine that together they couldn't scale intelligence up at least past the point where we could ever hope to keep up, as long as we got it into digital form in the first place. You're correct that there will be an architectural "wall" somewhere, but chances are that human intelligence is more in the "vacuum tubes and punch cards" regime than the "Moore's law is done" one. Whatever is there when that wall is hit would be so far beyond us that it might as well be called super-intelligent, even if it can't improve further.

ewjordan··on Facebook plans to use U.S. mail to verify IDs of election ad buyers
Facebook leans left AF, as do most places in the Bay (whether people like it or not) apart from special cases like Palantir. From the bottom to the top of the chain of command they are as upset as anyone that they were used to nudge things to the right.

They want the news story to go away, but they also want to stuff it all down Putin's throat, and Trump's as well. Russian trolls did not make up even a small percentage of their ad profits last year, I wouldn't assume they're protecting them in the name of a very small amount of money.

ewjordan··on Fired Google Engineer Loses Diversity Memo Challenge
Keep in mind that this ruling doesn't say it's a crime. It merely says, it's not covered by an exemption to the at-will employment rules that let a company fire you for any reason.

If my boss doesn't like the fact that I put horseradish on my nachos, they can fire me for that. It's only exceptional cases where I'm protected from arbitrary and nasty and capricious actions.

Also, put horseradish on your nachos, it's a good thing.

ewjordan··on Fired Google Engineer Loses Diversity Memo Challenge
I have sympathy for what you're saying here; I think it would be a totally valid interpretation of the law to say that point 3), however clumsy it may have been, was made in support of point 2), and therefore under protection.

But the way this played out, the board ruled the other way, and I think this is a clear warning to future employees seeking protection under this rule: the NLRB will interpret things as tightly as possible, and be very deferential to employer's internal policies even if they hinder the ability to back up a labor conditions complaint with arguments.

Whether that's okay or not is a political fight, and I see how there's a slippery slope here that could theoretically be used to squash many legitimate labor complaints - if a company imposed rules against making people feel politically uncomfortable, would they be able to fire people for wanting to unionize and backing that up with political arguments that might offend capitalists? I'd be surprised if the board didn't act in that case.

But let's be honest. Damore was trying to score a backdoor win through a legal exception that pretty clearly was not in spirit carved out to protect people in situations like his. That's why I also expect him to fail in any CA civil suit, though I'm less certain about that one, political views are more protected in CA than elsewhere.

Just to be clear, I'm not personally in favor of Damore's firing over this memo, it sounds like Google tends to encourage vigorous internal debate about this sort of thing except when it goes public (as witnessed by the inaction until the memo was leaked and the outcry began). Despite his poor sense of what the response would be, I think he was engaging in good-faith argument, at first, at least, pre-Goolag and that nonsense. From what I hear, people on the left are pretty offensive and vitriolic on internal boards at Google without being disciplined [0], so I'd have loved to see management manage the situation and internally broker some peace between the offended parties rather than turn the thing into a classic alt-right recruiting talk-point by firing him. But I'm very much in favor of a company's right to fire anyone, for almost any reason, and I'm glad that was not interfered with here.

[0] Edit: from the memorandum, a Google employee was reprimanded for responding harshly to Damore over email: '“You’re a misogynist and a terrible human. I will keep hounding you until one of us is fired. F[*] you.” The employee was issued a final warning for sending this email. '

ewjordan··on Fired Google Engineer Loses Diversity Memo Challenge
Damore has basically 3 points in his memo, in increasing order of disputability:

1) Conservatives are discriminated against at Google, which is a problem for working conditions

2) Google pushes an aggressive voluntary affirmative action policy which aims to hire women and underrepresented minorities at rates much higher than they appear in the relevant sector of the workforce, and the way this is pushed internally is a problem for working conditions

3) The reason women are underrepresented in the tech job market is biology

Notice that 3) has nothing to do with working conditions, it's just an elaboration on why 2) upsets Damore so much; it could have been left out and he would have been covered under the exemption, while still making his point about working conditions and hiring policies.

People within Google are totally free to disagree about whether a 50/50 gender ratio is an appropriate goal, and they are protected under this law as far as protesting those goals as they relate to working conditions. But the ruling says that the specific arguments you bring into play may still be in violation of company policy, and such arguments are not automatically protected by virtue of being connected to a working conditions complaint. Especially when they could be construed as hurting a company's ability to abide by laws regarding hostile work environments.

There's probably room for disagreement about the correct interpretation of the law, but I don't see it as a matter of removing the right to discuss freely, it's merely a tight technical interpretation of where the at-will exemption ends.

ewjordan··on Learning to program is getting harder
I remember when I was first learning Java, whacking my head repeatedly against all these sorts of problems - WTF is a JRE vs. a JDK, why is it asking to install a browser toolbar, WTF is Eclipse and why doesn't it just let me run the file that I'm working on without going through half an hour of researching "Run configurations" and classpath BS first, etc. It was doable, but as a new person to the whole ecosystem, it was seriously painful to even get to the point where "Hello, world!" would run. Then I tried to get OpenGL working (I wanted to do games), and I probably blew an entire week futzing with configuration just to draw a rectangle on the screen. TBH it was harder than getting the same thing done in C++.

And compiling it all into a Real Executable that would run on Windows like a normal program? Forget about it...not even to get into Web Start, applets, Maven and JavaFX (remember that disaster?), oh my!

Then I discovered Processing, which bundled everything (Java runtimes, libraries, etc.) together in a nice tidy package, and its own IDE where you could just open up the thing, type in some code, and hit the big obvious "Run" button. Want a library? Download it from the nicely curated set that are guaranteed to work! Wanted to create an executable, click "Export", and it just works! All the nastiness of linking native dependencies, bundling the JRE, handling classpaths and linker flags, it was handled once by the devs working on that project, and end users could just focus on code.

Things are getting better with other technologies these days, but it's still rare that I see an environment as zero-config as Processing, apart from web-based Javascript playgrounds. All it takes is a pure focus on usability, which I think is something that as devs we often overlook because once we've gotten over the installation problems that we're familiar with ("well of course brew is better than MacPorts, and you'll need to install nvm and pick the right version before this library will work, except for this one dependency that's only available through RubyGems, and this other one that") we forget that they can be confusing and really off-putting to newbies.

Python environments are particularly bad, IMO because of screwy webs of dependencies that more often than not fail to install cleanly and the Python 2 vs 3 split.

ewjordan··on Ask HN: Best project management practices in 2018?
Oh, there's a ship party built into the Process, alright. It's called the sprint restrospective, and everyone sits around and argues for an hour about what went badly during the sprint.

Even more fun is the sprint retrospective retrospective, where everyone argues for two hours about what went wrong in the sprint retrospective.

I wish I was making that up.

Edit: it's not that I don't get the point of retrospectives, I do...but I've seen them taken to comically absurd levels, and in any sizable team it always seems to be the three people that care the most about their particular flavor of Scrum that sit around arguing about how much better it was the way they did it at their last company, meanwhile everyone else just wants to leave and get back to work. A small number of loud people will always have strong but completely arbitrary and anecdotal opinions about process, and in my opinion it's not healthy to give them a regular spot on everyone's schedule to complain about it.

ewjordan··on GrubHub Drivers Ruled Contractors
But most of the driving-giggers that I know do not have single relationships, they're working with both Uber and Lyft, or GrubHub, Seamless, Doordash, etc, as each one rises and falls in profitability for them.
ewjordan··on Why Toys?
The theory that non-capitalist societies can have thriving long-lasting economies that produce new innovations and lift their people up is pretty questionable so far.

I can't think of a single example where there's not at least a core nugget of capitalist incentives driving things.

Sure, let's layer on some socialist policies, I'm all in favor of turning that dial quite a bit further, but that's turning a dial, not blowing up the whole machine because it's not working quite as well as we'd like it to.

ewjordan··on Facebook User Growth, Time Spent Fall on News Feed Changes
I understand the fear, though - when you're data driven, you can actually numerically measure the contribution of every feature that's tested, and in a lot of cases figure out the exact impact on revenue. In a culture where everything is tested, it's a very small step from there to stack ranking your product designers based mostly on how the features they designed did.

I'm not necessarily against that as a valid way to measure job performance if it's done intelligently (for one, realizing that there's a lot of blind luck and variance, and it takes time to smooth out) - I mean, if you're in sales and you're not booking any sales, you don't get to hide from that. But it's also really easy to get ranking and evaluation schemes wrong, so I understand why people would be nervous about it and prefer soft-skill-based evaluations instead.

ewjordan··on Facebook User Growth, Time Spent Fall on News Feed Changes
A/B testing won’t ever get you a Tesla from a horse.

Right. But if you were already selling Teslas, and along came a smooth-talking product designer with a dream to "improve" it by building a horse instead, A/B testing would make sure that change never saw the light of day.

A/B testing is not a way to get out of having to come up with good ideas yourself. It's a way to validate that your ideas are any good in the first place before betting the whole company on them.

A/B testing is most critical when evaluating big changes to a product, because those are the changes most likely to completely blow up the business. Otherwise it's left up to the opinion of the highest paid person in the room, and people are notoriously bad at guessing how customers will respond to change.

ewjordan··on To Save Drowning People, Ask “What Would Light Do?”
You're definitely correct, this article overhypes the mysteriousness. It's a shame, though, and a missed opportunity to go deeper, because it is a surprising fact that almost all of physics is most elegantly expressed in terms of least action principles, where it really does seem like the universe conspires to minimize some quantity.

In classical physics, the Lagrangian formulation is merely useful for some calculations, and can be fairly viewed as a mathematical trick that is equivalent to using Newton's law directly; similarly in E+M it's a compact and often useful way to express Maxwell's equations, but not particularly fundamental.

When you reach quantum field theory, though, it's all but impossible to do anything without a Lagrangian/action, and theories are almost always described in that form. String theories are the same. General relativity is not always presented that way, but gravitational dynamics are stunningly simple in that form: in a vacuum, nature abhors curvature.

Principles of least X are fascinating and incredibly useful, and the ex-physicist in me believes that they describe the actual universe so concisely that they are truly fundamental in some sense. But you have to really dig in to get any sort of appreciation for that, and I agree that this article didn't go anywhere near deep enough.

ewjordan··on YouTube Drops Online Star Logan Paul from Premium Advertising
Being disrespectful, while supremely offensive to me and a very good reason not to watch Logan Paul (or let your kids watch him), does not meet my personal bar of "should be banned". Mainstream media routinely gives the mic to people acting far more offensively, and with actual malicious intent rather than mere youthful stupidity.

Free speech is not something that private companies need to protect as far as the law goes, but I think it's an ideal that they should try to hold dear nonetheless, as much as possible. "Acted disrespectfully towards a group" is way too wiggly and subjective as an offense to start banning people over.

Edit: just to be clear, I think the suicide video is clearly over the line. I'm only talking about his general shithead-ness the rest of the time.

ewjordan··on Why Is 'Affordable' Housing So Expensive to Build?
Not following you.

Sounds to me like if land, not construction, is the dominant factor in cost, luxury and affordable units should cost about the same amount. Unless the affordable units were higher density.

ewjordan··on The case against GDP: time to change the way we measure the wealth of nations
If you live paycheck to paycheck, then you have the same amount of money at the end of the year as you did at the beginning.

Does that mean you didn't participate in the economy?

ewjordan··on NSA’s top talent is leaving because of low pay, flagging morale, unpopular reorg
His claim was the leak, and it was huge, and I'm not going to dig through it for you for quotes just because you're a contrarian. The NSA did a shit ton of surveillance that was not justified under known US law, and that's pretty well accepted at this point.

What claim don't you think is true? Was the NSA not indiscriminately scooping up and querying communications between US citizens?

ewjordan··on Apple acquires Buddybuild
React Native is great for apps, and if it's a game, just use Unity. They're building up their internal CI infrastructure and it works better every month.

Tbh, I'm not sure how many use cases don't fit either React Native or Unity, I'd practically never choose to do an app another way these days.

ewjordan··on NSA’s top talent is leaving because of low pay, flagging morale, unpopular reorg
Snowden let that cat out of the bag years ago in voluminous detail. You absolutely do not need to cite sources re: illegal NSA surveillance anymore.
ewjordan··on The Long-Term Stock Exchange Comes to Life
Sure, that might be true.

Or, as is more common, the people working on a game have way more of a perfectionist streak than is worthwhile given the audiences.

What I always say in these situations: if two weeks worth of work would be the difference between a smash hit and a bomb, then who the fuck screwed up so bad to prioritize those work items to the last two weeks before launch?

If someone really messed up that badly, they should be called out. More often, those last few features really don't matter, and shipping is better than waiting. My experience is all with games that have digital updates, to be fair, shrink wrapped stuff may have different constraints (but similar questions about prioritization).

ewjordan··on How I went from programming to consulting (2012)
I think a clearer way to say what a lot of people are bothered by with that example is that in order to sell those recommendations you need:

a) to have a lot of marketing expertise

b) to be known well enough for your marketing expertise that people will take your suggestions as valid

Most tech people have neither one. Hell, most marketing people have neither one, half of the rest on my have b) but are actually incompetent in their recommendations, and only the last little bit have both.

ewjordan··on Overcoming Us vs. Them
You're right, reading occasional blog posts doesn't do anything for anyone, on pretty much any topic. I'd argue that anyone professing to be a rationalist on those grounds is lying to themselves.

Also worth pointing out that the rationalist community has a lot of issues and biases that mostly spring from focus problems - like any group, they tend to hyper-analyze a few pet issues that draw their attention and then ignore the rest of the world. Even if they're correctly analyzing those issues, the social problem of biased community focus ends up thwarting the goal of overall rationality. I don't think this is a problem specific to rationalists, rather a general failure of human communication (for any -ism, you'll find that people have tunnel vision and tend to force everything they see and hear through the lens of that -ism), but it is rightly criticized more there because the movement claims to be better at seeking truth than others. I have no idea how to solve that problem, it's really an emergent result of what gets people hot and bothered and draws their attention and analysis, which is an innate human irrationality and extremely hard to think your way around.

← PreviousPage 2 of 18Next →