[0]: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/hbm.20028
624 karma · joined March 15, 2015
-- Jane Jacobs, the Death and Life of Great American Cities
ex3xu at pm.me
[0]: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1002/hbm.20028
What Shane calls slack, you could also call the margin of safety.
I'd be curious to see if that intuition holds up in practice, though I have my doubts about whether IQ or EQ would necessarily be the right quantitative metric.
The better I got to know Nagasawa, the stranger he seemed. I had met a lot of strange people in my day, but none as strange as Nagasawa. He was a far more voracious reader than I, but he made it a rule never to touch a book by any author who had not been dead at least thirty years. “That’s the only kind of book I can trust,” he said.
“It’s not that I don’t believe in contemporary literature,” he added, “but I don’t want to waste valuable time reading any book that has not had the baptism of time. Life is too short.”
“What kind of authors do you like?” I asked, speaking in respectful tones to this man two years my senior. “Balzac, Dante, Joseph Conrad, Dickens,” he answered without hesitation.
“Not exactly fashionable.”
“That’s why I read them. If you only read the books that everyone else is reading, you can only think what everyone else is thinking. That’s the world of hicks and slobs. Real people would be ashamed of themselves doing that. Haven’t you noticed, Watanabe? You and I are the only real ones in the dorm. The other guys are crap.”
This took me off guard. “How can you say that?”
“’ Cause it’s true. I know. I can see it. It’s like we have marks on our foreheads. …”
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_North_Korea#Heal...
Similarly, if Semigroup should be called Appendable, what would you call Monoid? And is there a consensus on Monad as well?
Names can't transmit the complete meaning of a concept, but they can still transmit a partial or ballpark representation of that concept. In the world of linguistics it's easy to see how many names come from the composition of Greek or Latin roots, prefixes and suffixes, or Chinese composition of radicals. I don't find it particularly compelling to try to make the case that names cannot transmit ANY meaning at all -- therefore let's choose some other arbitrary criteria for judging names.
If you think about the concept of affordances/signifiers from HCI and interaction design, people do draw upon their past experience when encountering new, unknown concepts, and in the PL space a good name can streamline the process for learning a new concept. It's just that Functor has affordances from category theory and, well, most people haven't taken enough advanced math to access those affordances before encountering Functor.
I think Matt would have been better off calling this article "New Concepts Deserve New Names", rather than try to say that all names transmit no meaning whatsoever. I think I would agree that it's not a huge price to develop new affordances for Functor, Applicative, Monad, Semigroup, and Monoid, in comparison to the potential pitfalls of choosing a name that points to a potentially vague or incorrect meaning. And I personally like the names because although they were poor pointers to meaning, they were good pointers to their mathematical roots, and that makes me curious to learn more category theory.
In terms of long-term jobs, I think learning concepts from statically-typed functional programming language will improve your code quality (read: chance at sustainable employment) in general, but actual prospects are probably area dependent. I am lucky enough to live in a tech hub so there are many Angel List jobs here for Haskell and Scala, but this may not be the experience for every city.
After going through an introductory resource to learn syntax and concepts, other good beginner resources I have used are the Functional Programming Discord [1], the free Data61 course that Brian McKenna goes over [2], and the Tsoding series on YouTube [3]. The Practical Haskell book I mentioned is good too, but I found it a bit higher level than these other resources.
[0]: https://www.amazon.com/Functional-Programming-Scala-Paul-Chi...
[1]: https://discordapp.com/invite/FvT2Y5N
Currently falling, albeit very slowly, down the rabbit hole of FP -> category theory -> HoTT.
> Graham was not the only one who had to put up with Erdös's kitchen antics. "Once I spent a few days with Paul," said Janos Path, a fellow Hungarian emigre. "When I entered the kitchen in the evening, I was met with a horrible sight. The floor was covered by pools of blood-like red liquid. The trail led to the refrigerator. I opened the door, and to my great surprise saw a carton of tomato juice on its side with a gaping hole. Paul must have felt thirsty and, after some reflection, decided to get the juice out of the carton by stabbing it with a big knife."
Or is Rachel talking about a situation where you have an SLA in place, but you can't even prove downtime to the vendor because their monitoring software is inadequate?
> [The constructivist method] avoids the basic problem with the axiomatic problem. You can’t have something ridiculous like the set of all sets that don’t include themselves, because the only way to show that a set exists is to show a process to create it – and there’s no way to create a paradoxical set! You don’t get nonsense like [the Banach-Tarski paradox], because the division of the spherical topological space into the non-metric subspaces is impossible: you can’t show a process that produces it. In the world of intuitionism and constructivism, existence proofs that don’t produce concrete examples don’t exist!
[0]: http://www.goodmath.org/blog/2014/08/18/the-constructivist-r...
> The problem of finding a constructive interpretation of the rules of the Martin-Löf type theory that in addition satisfies the univalence axiom and canonicity for natural numbers remains open. A partial solution is outlined in a paper by Marc Bezem, Thierry Coquand and Simon Huber[17] with the key remaining issue being the computational property of the eliminator for the identity types. The ideas of this paper are now being developed in several directions including the development of the cubical type theory.
I'm getting confused because Martin-Lof writes at the end of this paper:
> I shall construct an object of this type, an object which may at the same time be interpreted as a proof of the axiom of choice...
Thus (Az)((..tx)p(z(x)), (lx)q(z(x))) is the sought for proof of the axiom of choice.
I'm also curious if someone can weigh in on the fact that this paper by Martin-Löf finishes with a proof of the axiom of choice -- isn't that a bit of a controversial axiom? Does all of constructivist mathematics still depend on the axiom of choice to this day?
[0]: https://www.gog.com/game/irony_curtain_from_matryoshka_with_...
Take a look at something like Chomsky's political speech attacking NAFTA and neoliberalism in the 1990s, which Graham briefly alludes to. NAFTA was and remains a fairly popular initiative for the liberal establishment, but the principles under which Chomsky's justification stands can be imagined to hold up under scrutiny decades in the future, whereas exploitation of cheap Mexican labor -- probably not so much, I'd wager.
Another recent example -- Raghuram Rajan's 2005 paper [0] criticizing the financial innovations that would go on to destroy the world economy in the 2008 crash. This example satisfies the two "conspiracy-theory-esque" conditions that you cite from Graham, as he certainly made Kohn, Greenspan, Summers, and other major figures in the economic establishment angry enough to call him a "Luddite" with views that would qualify under Graham's "unsayable" criteria. At least, before he would be proven right just a few years later.
So you're certainly correct in pointing out that not every instance of taboo carries ideas worth considering -- and for some ideas, this is indeed a dangerous understatement -- but I don't agree with you when you imply that Graham is wrongheaded in every instance, and no taboos should ever be considered. To give another example, Joyce's Ulysses was banned as obscenity across the world in the 1920s [1]. As far as I can tell, Graham is more concerned with scientific innovations rather than political speech, anyway.
[0]: https://www.nber.org/papers/w11728
[1]: https://www.theguardian.com/books/2014/jul/04/most-dangerous...
The problem with following fashion, as far as I understand, is that you accept the tacit assumption that the value of an idea is correlated with its popularity, and I'm all in favor of smiting the very dangerous contrapositive to that assumption: that unpopular ideas therefore must also lack value. I support this author as far as he is attempting to raise awareness of this trap -- lest someone else have to go through the same fate as Ignaz Semmelweis, Guglielmo Marconi, or James Allison.
But I felt like this article did little to present valid mechanisms to mitigate the risks of fashion, and instead spent most of the text attacking fashionable ideas simply for being fashionable, operating under the assumption that fashion itself necessarily lacks substance and causes problems on its own. I think this sort of hipster approach is as big of a risk as blindly following fashion -- both premises assume that popularity is necessary and sufficient to determine the value, or lack of value, of an idea.
But maybe I'm just a blind fashion follower myself, since I felt so personally attacked when the author criticized MOOCs as just another fashionable fad -- despite the valid criticisms he linked to, I felt like I got a lot of value out of them, after all.
If you are sure you want to read some fiction, you can try the Quantum Thief series, Cixin Liu's Three Body Problem series, or the Goodreads shelf on "Math Fiction": https://www.goodreads.com/shelf/show/math-fiction
> When is an area overpopulated? When its population can't be maintained without rapidly depleting nonrenewable resources (or converting renewable resources into nonrenewable ones) and without degrading the capacity of the environment to support the population. In short, if the long-term carrying capacity of an area is clearly being degraded by its current human occupants, that area is overpopulated.
I agree with you that it is questionable set of assumptions, though I think when considering some of issues humanity is facing in the realm of climate change and water shortages, it's not an entirely untenable hypothesis.
If anyone wants to check for themselves, hopefully it's not against HN rules to link the paper: https://sci-hub.tw/10.1038/363315a0
If this article's point appeals to anyone and they are looking for a modern researcher on the topic, I'll gently push them in the direction of Brene Brown's work on embracing vulnerability as a driver of personal growth: https://www.ted.com/talks/brene_brown_on_vulnerability?langu...
True, very good point in favor of user control. Linux has the added benefit of teaching the discipline and foresight to understand that "Hey... maybe I shouldn't run sudo pacman -Syu and reboot until I have some time set aside". Though in recent years I've found Arch to be way more stable with very few updates causing major problems.