1,260 karma · joined November 30, 2018
These strategies make writing less readable for the rest of us. The example paragraphs are clunky, and meaning gets lost.
"Yet these defenders focus on riots' effectiveness rather than its legitimacy. They do not defend rioting on normative grounds. The lack of normative theorizing in academic scholarship about riots is even more striking."
Given that vaccination reduces disease severity, it seems likely that vaccination decreases your viral load after infection.
Therefore, though vaccination may not help much in preventing omicron infection, it will nevertheless reduce both disease severity and your infectiousness.
> A long-held view was that birds were aided in their orientation by a cluster of iron neurons in their beaks, which interacted with the earth’s magnetic field. “But, in the past ten years, people have begun to ask if maybe it’s something else.” Gow posits that this something could well be olfaction. “If you have a colony of birds,” she says, “they can find their individual nest among thousands by smell.”
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grievance_studies_affair
Axiom 2: There are vastly more windbags and vicious people than there are knowledgeable and mature people.
Axiom 3: Online moderation / gatekeeping is imperfect.
Axiom 4: Successful moderation depends on a few keystone people.
Lemma 1: A community of knowledgeable, mature people will be under perpetual assault by entropy. The internet baseline of know-nothing gasbags and vicious, damaged people will be pounding on the gates of any community.
Lemma 2: Some of the horde will bypass any gatekeeping and moderation to land blows on the knowledgeable and mature people. They'll be repulsed, and some will leave the community.
Lemma 3: The keystone moderators are inevitably among the people subjected to these blows. After a serious blow or one blow too many, some will get fed up and leave, and moderation will get worse, increasing the rate of knowledgeable and mature people getting repulsed by their own community and leaving. A hole will form in the fortifications, and the barbarians will flood in, driving out everyone mature and knowledgeable.
Thereom: A knowledgeable, mature online community that is open to new users will eventually collapse into the internet baseline.
Corollary 1: If you're knowledgeable and mature and currently part of an open online community you love, you too will eventually get repulsed by it and leave. Enjoy it while it lasts.
Corollary 2: There are several knowledgeable and mature people here on Hacker News. They're here entirely because of dang. He is our keystone, weathering the assault of the barbarians for all of our sake. When he throws in the towel, we're done.
Tip for anyone following suit: If you're worried that they'll "catch" that they've already vaccinated you, by seeing your name and address in their database, just claim that your parent/child has the same name and lives with you.
You can search for a provider of your desired type of vaccine here: https://www.vaccines.gov/search/
With GPT-3, here are a couple generations I got for "A robin is not a":
A robin is not a bird of a thousand feathers. It is a bird of a thousand songs. – Lebanese Proverb
A robin is not a bird of prey and cannot eat a pigeon. I've never seen a robin kill one of those.
They were founded on this idea: if the CCP is the first to create AGI, there will be great harm to anyone who values personal freedom. Perhaps the open source community could instead be the first to create it, preventing this harm. Hence, Open AI.
However, the CCP making AGI is only one possibility for harm. After OpenAI made GPT, they realized that bad actors could use GPT to flood the internet with propaganda.
That would, of course, create harm.
OpenAI were naive with their plan to make the precursors to AGI open. They had picked a bad name for themselves, because they don't care merely about open sourcing AGI. They care foremost about harm reduction.
When we think of sacred things, it's hard to think logically. Many people on Hacker News hold two things as sacred: open source and unfettered freedom of speech.
Whenever these sacred ideas are infringed upon, many people here can't see nuance. They're blinded by rage.
I wish more of us could see that the OpenAI team are American programmers. They like freedom of speech and open source, just like us. They're not evil villains. Many of them read Hacker News.
To understand their decisions, we need to understand that their core value is harm reduction. When open source or freedom of speech is incompatible with harm reduction, they're going to choose harm reduction.
They're also not going to let themselves get destroyed by bad press after somebody makes a Nazi bot or whatever.
I love what they're doing, so it makes me sad to see all of this hate. I wish their projects were more open, because I really want to play with DALL-E, but I think ultimately OpenAI is moving us forward. They're an asset, and vitriol toward them is misplaced.
I guess it's kind of nifty that a computational model predicted it.
But treating the shape as being so mysterious / difficult to describe is silly.
Are you sure it's not you who's in the dark about what Brexit represents, about how it fits among similar movements throughout history, and about what the ongoing list of catastrophic consequences will be, as itemized by a host of analysts, scientists, and economists? [1]
I think maybe you're trying to pin me as a political tribalist with your union question? I don't have a political tribe, and I don't care about unions. I believe in evidence-based policy, wherever that policy points, irrespective of surrounding political narratives. I believe in a rational-legal political model grounded in the veil of ignorance.
Can you tell me how authoritarianism relates to populism?
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predicted_impact_of_Brexit
And of course utterly evil they'd try to manipulate him by using his ex-wife they'd disappeared.
If the CCP wanted to give themselves the worst look possible, they succeeded.
It claims that people historically have seen strongmen as the "legitimate" authority. As a corollary, authority from anything other than strongmen was illegitimate.
We've managed to get many people to believe in systems and organizations instead of strongmen. But for various reasons, we've recently regressed.
Per the article, a fungus can somehow remember where it previously found food. That degree of spatial awareness/memory is surprising.
Thus, in the way that biologists use the word "intelligence", fungi are intelligent. They'd be pretty dumb on any intelligence scale, but they have intelligence.
Yeah, hippies get a little too excited about the mind of the fungus or whatever when they hear the word "intelligence" applied to fungi. Who cares.
As it happens, I was a histrionic and narcissistic dick. Sometimes more mature people exploited my weakness, as you're suggesting, making me look foolish and getting their way. They'd win the battle, but they'd start a war. I'd make it a mission to do damage to them for embarrassing me, and I'd generally succeed. I'd often take damage myself in this war, but a pyrrhic victory was fine. I'd get my revenge.
I didn't change until my 20's, largely steered by someone who fully understood my limitations and less than prosocial proclivities. They showed me some compassion, gently guiding me toward being a decent person.
One can claim it's unfair that dicks should be treated with greater empathy and kindness than they give others. But they're not going to change otherwise. And underneath, they're indeed damaged. I'd rather live in a world where we help damaged people, instead of just kicking them out of the way.
We have limited capacity to save the humans around us, of course. If you truly can't help, such as with strangers or coworkers, the best practice against unhinged narcissists is called "tactical empathy" [1]. You can cool them off without creating a war.
I can guarantee that some of the people you "enraged" were subsequently plotting against you. Maybe you have a high tolerance for that, but I don't want people plotting to hurt me; that's scary. To avoid that, you can use tactical empathy to gracefully cool them off, while still giving them nothing. It's more humane, and it's safer.
[1] https://discord.com/moderation/360060487093-443:-Ban-Evasion...
-Jesus