1,260 karma · joined November 30, 2018
My take: Yep, if the model is used a high stakes situation, this is absolutely the case. The model should be required to undergo rigorous testing / peer review before it's released into the wild. In a high stakes situations, we have to ensure that a model is good before people get their hands on it, because people can be reliably depended on to treat the model as an oracle.
The metaphor of a "crumbling foundation" is a bad one, though. It's just unregulated; models aren't leaning on one another, and there isn't a risk of wholesale collapse.
NPD is a tool to protect yourself from mind-shattering degrees of shame. You latch onto something that makes you feel special, and you hold onto it for dear life. All of your decisions will stem from a desire to validate or protect that sense of being special. You'll seek admiration to validate it, and you'll seek to destroy critics to protect it. You might be capable of empathy, even great compassion, but you'll remain utterly cruel and self-absorbed, because you're a drowning man. You're desperate, and you'll see people as objects you can push underwater to get a gasp of air, and you'll treat someone who snubs you as someone actively stepping on your head to drown you: your anger will know no bounds.
That's what fragile narcissists actually are. They're not wired differently; they're drowning men.
If a narcissist is strongly motivated, and if they have a decade to devote to schema therapy for their underlying intense shame, then they can slowly morph into a normal prosocial human.
However, that doesn't happen often, for a variety of reasons.
But to reciprocate, although nuts and bolts have informed my opinion, I was indeed writing about broad patterns, something I'm aware that low empathy people on the autistic spectrum struggle with. My comment wasn't for you, Jared.
Anyway, if it's true that you're tribeless, then you're on my side of the line. You're a humanist. Maybe a humanist with some bizarre ideas about weapons and human nature, and maybe a humanist who's flirting with favoring abstractions over actual human lives, but a humanist nevertheless.
On the other side of the line is nativism and xenophobia and fundamentalism and Grand Solutions -- the things that lead to genocide. Those are the ideologies I suggest we squash. If you wouldn't, then you're consistent, but you're unwise. When a wave of extremism rises, you either join in, you flee, or you get summarily executed. Your guns won't save you. You have to stop the wave from rising in the first place.
Counterpoint: QAnon, incel terrorism, Plandemic, other fully-internet-driven extremist ideologies.
You need look no further than religions, often invented by single charismatic individuals, to see how powerful isolated claims of Truth can be.
I think that societal / institutional problems has indeed created a powder keg. But disinformation itself, its presence, lights the fuse.
With disinformation's "answers", it provides targets for people's pent up rage. Whether it's police officers or liberal elites or billionaires or Muslims or Chads, people learn who the enemy is, as well as their evil deeds. If you defeat this enemy, your problems will go away.
The concrete result is wars, interpersonal violence, riots, hamstrung governments, and insurrections. All stirred up because of explicit falsehoods.
Ideally, we'd fix both the powder keg (societal and institutional problems) and the lighting of its fuse, disinformation.
I think we, as the intellectual "elites", need to accept the following ugly reality:
1) A huge portion of the human population is highly susceptible to propaganda.
2) Exposing them to nuanced reality doesn't help them. In fact, anything complicated turns them off. They want simple truths.
3) This subpopulation is never going to change, and they're always going to be with us.
Given this reality, the only realistic option to protect our interests, aside from totalitarianism, is to feed this subpopulation counter-propaganda. To provide an alternative, easy-to-digest narrative that's aligned with humanism / Enlightenment values, but that is extremely dumbed down: The Voltaire Factor for the Hopelessly Credulous. The irony here isn't lost on me, but I see no gentle alternative.
Comment quality improves over time. As your own comment reassuringly demonstrates.
To qualify, you must be:
* A U.S. citizen or permanent resident.
* A non-smoker, age 30 to 55 years old, and proficient in English.
* A viable candidate as an actual astronaut. For this, you usually need a master's degree in a STEM field, or you need to be a pilot or doctor or military officer.
It's a given that you do not want to contract COVID-19. Vaccination and wearing a mask will help.
You also do not want to give COVID-19 to others. Again, vaccination and wearing a mask will help.
So this article is just pedantry over a statistical quirk.
Anyway, now that we're at the bottom of the comment thread and just talking to each other, thanks for vouching for me. You probably saved me from being hammered even deeper into the downvote pit.
The narrative is that a student tweeted something critical about China, and the CCP pressured his advisor into dropping him.
The reality is that the student published a tweet that "depicted a comic character that had been altered and had stereotyped Chinese features, with yellow skin tone and slit eyes". This understandably was perceived as racist by a Chinese student in Canada, who complained to the advisor. The advisor agreed and dropped her racist-seeming doctoral student.
The CCP wasn't involved. Nobody cared about his criticism of China. It was his racist-looking tweet that got him dismissed.
Edit: But yes, the CCP can have a chilling effect on free speech. See the Blitzchung controversy. This article is just a non-story.
But to address your criticism you've written between the lines, the vaccinated might not die, but they're still at risk for long term complications, were they to contract COVID. And ultimately, the longer this lasts, the more strains will appear, some of which might indeed prove adequate to kill the vaccinated.
A thorough campaign of vaccination, on the other hand, would put an end to this disease, just as vaccination put an end to measles, polio, whooping cough, mumps, etc. etc.
These are least delusional anti-vaxxers. They know that vaccination helps society at large, but they still won't get vaccinated, since they consider themselves young and healthy and at minimal risk from COVID.
(They are still delusional, since the risk of COVID infection even in the young and healthy is still greater than vaccination risk. However, at least they don't believe in microchip conspiracies.)
These people wouldn't sacrifice the smallest thing for the rest of us. So tell me, why should we respect their notions of personal liberty? Why give them anything, when they'd give absolutely nothing to the rest of us?
If they want the freedom to not vaccinate themselves, for their own selfish interests, then we should deny them access to public venues, likewise for our own interests.
We're a society. When our government is doing its job, we don't let people pollute the commons, whether it's with toxic waste or with deadly pathogens. Vaccination should indeed be compulsory.
Any other tips or strange adaptations you've had to make, in order to make good writing work in academia?
What a bizarre characterization.
They're walking off because they're working in hellish conditions, watching people die with no resources left to help them.
"In 18 months, she saw more patients die than most nurses before COVID saw in a career."
"Among practicing physicians, 96% have been vaccinated. The rate drops to <50% among nurses"
Arkansas, where this story is taking place, has only a 37% vaccination rate among the general population.
The public that they're supposed to serve was spitting on them and demonizing them from both sides.
Add a pandemic to the mix, and anybody's mental health would be flatlining. Suicide among some of them is tragic but not surprising.
I don't know how effective counseling services are, but if they do anything, they should be made available to the Jan 6 officers.
If anybody reading this is in a dark spot, the suicide lifeline is 800-273-8255, and it's available 24/7.
I think company founders are often great, idealistic people. People who genuinely want to make the world better.
When they step aside, however, the people who take over after them tend to be terrifying: zero empathy creatures who favor profit maximization over any and all human cost. Does anyone know why this happens?