HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gabrielroth

2,651 karma · joined February 20, 2007

submissionscomments
gabrielroth··on How to destroy your business with one email
I think there's a slight difference between an intrinsically public matter, like the Comcast issue, and a relationship between, say, a business owner and a customer. In political fights, people on all sides make their best case to the public. Sometimes that best case is deceptive or manipulative and that's a problem, but the fact of activists trying to shift public opinion just goes with the territory and long predates the Internet. We're used to it; we have filters for it.

The other thing is more complicated. If a business owner rips me off, that's bad. In the past, my only redress was the courts, which is a slow, cumbersome, expensive process. Now there's this new avenue where I can try to make the Internet hate the business owner. This can be a useful corrective, but it's very vulnerable to abuse.

gabrielroth··on How to destroy your business with one email
I had a similar feeling about the recent Cook's Source episode. It's very likely that, in both cases, the charges against the business owner are accurate, and if so I feel fine about them losing their businesses, if that's the outcome. But how long will it be until some savvy internet user successfully riles people up against an innocent competitor or a personal enemy?
gabrielroth··on Make Your Mockup in Markup
I disagree on both the specific and the general points.

General: The idea of separating presentation from content is useful in some contexts (including much of the web) where you need to be able to pour the content into multiple different containers. In other contexts, particularly the design of physical objects, presentation and content should be tightly connected. (You use the example of a booklet, but a booklet should be designed in a way that's well adapted to its use, and its use will depend on its content. There's no one-size-fits-all ideal booklet design.)

Specific: Even if you do want to learn to better separate content from presentation, learning the box model, or the different kinds of positioning, won't help in any but the narrowest way. There's no reason to learn CSS unless you're designing for a context that renders CSS. CSS has too many intricacies and perversions to be valuable in the abstract.

gabrielroth··on Ask HN: My lifetime mentor died. How to move on?
I'm glad it was helpful.
gabrielroth··on Ask HN: My lifetime mentor died. How to move on?
My condolences.

I can think of two pieces of advice, from my experience, that stand a chance of being helpful.

(1) Don't expect yourself to respond differently from how you're responding. At various moments in a single day you may be miserable, numb, and surprisingly cheerful. None of these is the wrong response, especially when the loss is so fresh. If you're still feeling perpetually distraught in two years, talk to a shrink. (Talk to a shrink now if you think it might be helpful, but don't do it because you think your response is somehow disproportionate or invalid. It isn't.)

(2) Get used to the fact that this event will place a layer of friction between you and most other people. Hopefully you have one or two people in your life who you have talked to, at length, about what you're going through. Others, even good friends, will regularly say things that feel callous and unsympathetic. Try to be patient with them.

gabrielroth··on Ask HN: awesome web-based documentation?
Agreed. It would also be worth considering using Stack Overflow-style voting for comments.
gabrielroth··on CSS Positioning 101
For CSS, I've recommended "Learning Web Design" by Jennifer Niederst Robbins to several people. It's a bit out of date now (doesn't cover HTML5 and CSS3) but you shouldn't be learning the latest additions before you have a solid grasp of the basics anyway.

I've been unable to find a good introductory Photoshop book.

gabrielroth··on HTML5, Flash and Silverlight. Which one is dead?
This. Skate to where the puck is going to be—especially if you're making something cool and ambitious. Take your best guess as to what the installed base for Flash, Silverlight and HTML5 will look like in two years. Two years! An eyeblink!

I think the word 'dead' can be confusing, because the hackery meaning differs from the ordinary meaning so much. None of those technologies is 'dead' in the sense of 'defunct.' But 'dead' meaning 'on a road whose only endpoint is obsolescence'—I'm gonna say Silverlight and Flash are dead.

gabrielroth··on [dead]
I think you have to define your terms a bit more. I love many Apple products and have strong feelings of self-identification with the company. They've also made products I don't like, I've criticized some of their decisions, and I can nitpick their features like nobody's business. Whether the above makes me a fanboy or not is a question of semantics.
gabrielroth··on TextMate finally gets an update
Or, uh, Stickies <blushes, hides head in shame>
gabrielroth··on TextMate finally gets an update
Yes, non-chunked undo is the dealbreaker for me as well. I remember reading Allan saying he was surprised that people cared about this, but that it would be implemented as an option in Textmate 2.
gabrielroth··on I'm Tired of Creating Your Content
http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2006/08/09.html
gabrielroth··on I'm Tired of Creating Your Content
I want direct benefits....free parking, a free night, coffee for free or dessert, discounts and so forth.

I'm pretty sure that small rewards (free coffee) would make people less likely to post reviews, and large benefits (a free night's stay in a hotel) wouldn't be cost-effective.

gabrielroth··on Meet The Team
Not sure what Goethe and Beethoven might have to say about that ...
gabrielroth··on Meet The Team
Yup. I find the 'our-whole-office-is-staffed-by-fun-people-who-love-(office-admin|client-management|sales|.+)' trope really grating. These are people going to an office to do their jobs. Maybe they're good at their jobs, and maybe it's a nice place to work, but it's not summer camp, it's not a four-year liberal arts college, and it's not a heist movie in which a crack team of experts come together for one last big score. It's a software company. Get a grip.
gabrielroth··on Things You Should Do Immediately After Launching a Website
OK, to everyone who read this list and said, 'That stuff is all obvious': What would you add to the list?
gabrielroth··on Ask HN: UK parcel delivery service prime for disruption?
It's a whole different problem when the range of possible delivery addresses is within a square mile.
gabrielroth··on Why Apple can’t beat Android
There is a cage match, and it is for developer mindshare.

But that too is non-zero-sum. The number of hours spent on phone software development is increasing rapidly. If Apple continues to sell a substantial number of iPhones, and Android users start buying apps for their devices too, there's no reason there can't be two viable markets for phone-app developers. (I'm not saying it's inevitable that Android will become a viable platform—I'm just saying that, even if it does, its growth won't necessarily come out of Apple's hide.)

gabrielroth··on Ask HN: UK parcel delivery service prime for disruption?
When I wrote 'What would a startup do that they couldn't?' I wasn't asking 'What services would a startup provide for end-customers that aren't provided by existing couriers?' I was asking 'How would a startup make a profit in this hard-to-enter market when Amazon, with all its advantages, has apparently decided it can't?'

Do you think Amazon couldn't provide realtime tracking or SMS notification? Those things are frills. They'd be nice. Maybe a few end-customers would pay slightly more for them. But they don't help you with the real problem, which is setting up a hub-and-spoke delivery network that's fine-grained enough to get a package from a central warehouse to any individual house in the country within three days for less than five bucks.

You, the person waiting for your package at home, are not the customer. The customer is Amazon. What the customer wants is delivery that's sufficiently reliable that it doesn't cost them business, and sufficiently cheap that it doesn't interfere with their efforts to undersell traditional retailers. Can you make them a viable offer on those grounds? If not, SMS notifications aren't going to change their mind.

gabrielroth··on Ask HN: UK parcel delivery service prime for disruption?
People have had similar problems with A1, a courier service Amazon has begun using in New York City.

Last-mile delivery is a notoriously difficult market to enter, for reasons that are obvious when you think about the logistics. I think it's telling that Amazon hasn't chosen to get into it themselves. They've got a ton of cash, relevant expertise, and orders everywhere that they could use for pilot programs. One has to assume they've considered the idea and decided to keep sending money to UPS et al. What would a startup do that they couldn't?

gabrielroth··on Why Apple can’t beat Android
The problem is the word 'beat' in the title. Markets aren't zero-sum. Apple has thrived over the past decade by focussing on rich margins and on expanding markets, rather than by competing for a bigger sliced of a fixed-size pie.

There's no reason Apple and Android can't both "win" in the phone market. But we'd need to define "win." For Apple it would mean selling a lot of devices and making a good profit on each device. For Google it would mean, uh, some kind of complicated bank shot where more people click on AdSense ads from their phone. (It's hard to see how they'd even know if they won.)

But note that Google would be fine with a future in which the iPhone is still very popular, as long as it doesn't completely dominate the market. (People do a lot of Google searches from their iPhones.) And Apple would be fine with a future in which Android owns the low end of the phone market, i.e. the low-margin commodity devices that are given away free or very cheap with low-end plans.

But of course, stories like "It's X versus Y in a cage match to the death!" are very appealing, even when they're wrong.

gabrielroth··on The Mac App Store isn’t for today’s Mac developers
> All of these decisions had the effect of reducing Apple's support and maintenance overhead while strengthening their control over the direction of their platform.

Yup, plus the effect of improving user experience.

The most developer-friendly thing a platform vendor can do is attract users. Apple's done that in spades.

gabrielroth··on What We Look for in Founders
Scores high on chutzpah, obviously, but it lacks the element of self-interest that I think was part of what Sam Altman was going for.
gabrielroth··on Apple Has $51 Billion and a Shopping List. Is Facebook On It?
I agree that the Facebook idea is implausible. I think dividends are unlikely too. There's no reason anyone at the company would be worrying about the stock price right now, so the question is whether Steve Jobs thinks he might be able to find a use for $50b at some point in the future. That might be to buy something he has a use for, or it might be just to intimidate any potential partner or competitor.

Has it made a difference to Apple's recent history that everyone knows it could buy Adobe? Do the CEOs of AT&T and Verizon have to face the possibility that Apple could buy Sprint and run its own network? I say yes, and I say Jobs likes it that way, and his comments should be interpreted in that light.

gabrielroth··on OS X 10.7 “Lion”: The King Of The Apple Jungle, The Last Of Its Kind, Or Both?
The speculation should be pretty easy to avoid, if that's what you want to do.
gabrielroth··on Tell HN: Read Maxim and other trashy "guy" rags.
Whatever you do, don't take sex advice from them.

A female friend of mine was hanging out with a bunch of guys who had a lot of Maxims in their bathroom. She wound up reading an article along the lines of "Seven Ways to Drive Her Wild in Bed."

That night she hooked up with one of the guys. To her amazement, she realized midway through that he was trying every one of the techniques in the article.

gabrielroth··on Django core: Improving our decision-making and committer process
I don't know enough about the specifics of the case to assess the new policy on the merits, but I will say that as a piece of writing this is a model of how to change policy gracefully: clear, forthright, and non-defensive.
gabrielroth··on Thanks for the feedback. I've closed the service
We can't know what was in the guy's head, but it doesn't make sense to me that you'd feel like shit. You suggested he change the copy a little. Someone else asked if he'd consulted a lawyer. Someone else pointed him to the Wikipedia page for Flooz.com, which includes the sentence, "In 2001, Flooz.com was notified by the Federal Bureau of Investigation that a Russian organized crime syndicate was using Flooz and stolen credit card numbers as part of a money-laundering scheme, in which stolen credit cards were used to purchase currency and then redeemed."

My guess is that it's the realization that he was in way over his head, rather than your suggestion that he edit the copy on his site, that led him to change course.

gabrielroth··on Classic Fonts That Will Last a Whole Design Career
Gotham has been used so much in the past couple years that I'd be very wary of using it for anything. In ten years it'll immediately scream '2009'.
gabrielroth··on Style Your #NewTwitter Profile With Themeleon From COLOURlovers (YC10)
Why 'COLOURlovers' with a 'u' in the British or Canadian style, rather than 'COLORlovers'? They've got the colorlovers.com URL ...
← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →