HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gabrielroth

2,651 karma · joined February 20, 2007

submissionscomments
gabrielroth··on Facebook is a Ponzi Scheme
So you know FB doesn't solicit funds or provide them

Facebook does, in fact, solicit funds -- from advertisers, and from users who want to send virtual gifts to their friends.

but you expected proof that FB was literally a ponzi scheme in the article?

No, I expected some argument to that effect.

Libel is written defamation, as opposed to slander which is for transitory statements.

No, defamation is one of the conditions for libel, but there are others: falsity and malicious intent being the most important.

I disagree that it's clearly defamation.

Allegations of criminal conduct are among the clearest categories of defamation.

Shrug indeed.

gabrielroth··on Facebook is a Ponzi Scheme
I use Facebook, and I did in fact assume from the headline that the author was going to argue that it is a Ponzi scheme. It didn't seem like one to me, but one reason I read articles on HN is to be informed or persuaded of things I didn't initially believe.

By the way, I never called the author's accusation libelous. I called it defamatory, which it clearly is.

gabrielroth··on Facebook is a Ponzi Scheme
I think you are right that I should have used "like a" Ponzi scheme throughout the post, but the writing and the point would have lost a lot of its effect in explaining that.

Yes, describing things in an overheated, sensationalistic way has a more powerful effect than describing them in an accurate way. Congratulations on figuring that out.

By the way, referring to a business as a Ponzi scheme is prima facie defamatory. I don't think you have much to worry about, since I doubt Facebook will bother to sue you on the basis of a blog post, but you might write differently if you were more conscious of the fact that you're accusing someone of a crime.

gabrielroth··on I Think Facebook Just Seized Control Of The Internet
AOL also did a lot with 'buddy lists' and offline friendships. They didn't have social networking figured out, but they definitely tried to own communication and relationships as well as content.
gabrielroth··on Out of the loop in Silicon Valley
"Another potential backer invited her for a weekend yachting excursion by showing her a picture of himself on the boat — without clothes." [emphasis mine]

Sounds like the creep was smart enough not to give her the picture.

gabrielroth··on Out of the loop in Silicon Valley
Even if the source told the reporter the names, all she's got is her word, and that's not enough evidence for the New York Times to print something like that. (And for good reason: it shouldn't be possible to smear someone without evidence, not to mention that the paper would be vulnerable to a libel suit.) You mention 'documentary proof,' but there's no suggestion in the story that she has any.

To be clear, I'm not suggesting that she's not telling the truth -- just that reasonable journalistic standards sometimes result in important information being withheld.

gabrielroth··on Hacker News for Education
The first two sentences are fine. I'd rethink the third sentence: Also, up voting and commenting is how you can help every reader uncover the best of the best by pushing those articles to the top of the list.

Problems: (1) Most people have no idea what 'up voting' means. (2) The syntax is needlessly tangled.

What about: "Vote for the articles you find most useful, and they'll rise to the top of the list."

gabrielroth··on Bill Gates Bans iTunes From Windows
Yes, of course! Every platform is exactly the same, and any statement that applies to one also applies to all the others in exactly the same way!
gabrielroth··on Hacker News for Education
Maybe you're already planning this, but you should consider putting some explanatory 'what-is-this-site' text somewhere prominent. Much of your potential audience has never seen HN, Digg, or Reddit.
gabrielroth··on Sorry, Adobe, you screwed yourself
Boy, that's a terrible analogy. What we're beginning to see in smartphones is a competition between different business models: one (Apple) that exercises a lot of control over the platform, and another (Android) that exercises very little control. We'll get to see how that plays out. That's the free market for you.
gabrielroth··on [dead]
I don't get it. The piece quotes Jobs as suggesting that Apple will exercise the same amount of censorship as a broadcast-TV network. The broadcast networks seem to be reasonably good at not allowing really extreme stuff without getting in trouble for first-amendment violations. (Controversies crop up every few years, like the recent one about abortion and the Super Bowl, but no one suggests that they pose an existential threat to the networks.) Why would this be any harder for Apple?

Given the failure to address this obvious question, I found the self-satisfied tone of the piece pretty obnoxious.

The question is, will it take all of Apple down with it?

The answer is, No, it won't.

gabrielroth··on Twitter Acquires Atebits, Maker of Tweetie
I downvoted you because meta-discussion of when and how downvotes should be used is irrelevant and boring.
gabrielroth··on New iPhone Agreement Bans Flash-to-iPhone Compiler & Others
I sympathize with your economic plight. But the fact that you're having a hard time making a living using Flash doesn't give Apple the obligation to provide you with a development platform.

Since the iPhone has less than 20 percent of the smartphone market, it seems unlikely that the Monopolies Commission will be interested.

gabrielroth··on Indie Dev Rants About App Store at GDC, Apple Pulls Game
Agreed. The price-raising is an interesting experiment but you can see why Apple might object to their store being used for an experiment.

It would be nice if they'd also (a) tell the guy why they kicked him off, and (b) set a new policy on pricing that prevents stuff like this. Even better would be (c) allowing him to reapply on the condition that he keep to the new pricing policy.

gabrielroth··on JQuery plugin to create rich animations ( works on iPhone )
This looks cool with the Hacker News Chrome plugin ... the blackbirds are flying over HN as I type this.
gabrielroth··on Teal and Orange - Hollywood, Please Stop the Madness
I don't mean the T-Pain style 'AutoTune-as-an-effect' -- I mean the subtler use of AutoTune to correct minor fluctuations in a natural-sounding performance.
gabrielroth··on Are Amazon Seller Ratings Trustworthy?
I'd like to see more than one data point before coming to any conclusions.
gabrielroth··on Teal and Orange - Hollywood, Please Stop the Madness
Sometimes technology makes it easier to do something, and then people do that thing more than they did before, to the point where they're doing it too much.

It's like AutoTune in music: people have always tried to sing in tune, but now they can sing even more in tune, and so current pop music has almost lost the naturalism and emotional effects produced by subtle variance in pitch.

gabrielroth··on Dreaded Favors Asked of Web Designers
Yes, licensing regulations also serve a useful purpose. But having the details of those regulations determined by the guilds themselves (rather than external authorities) is a lousy way to achieve that purpose. Why do I have to visit a dentist to have my teeth cleaned, rather than a dental hygenist? Why can't registered nurses or nurse practitioners provide basic medical care except under the auspices of a doctor? Because the rules are set by groups that represent the doctors and dentists.

It's also worth remembering that plenty of indigent people in this country are effectively represented by 'that guy,' including in murder trials. Look at the cases of Calvin Burdine or George McFarland, both of whose court-appointed attorneys slept through their trials. Are those barriers really doing what you want them to do?

gabrielroth··on Better HN - Google Chrome extension
Thanks for continuing to improve it.
gabrielroth··on Dreaded Favors Asked of Web Designers
they have officially-recognized bars, certifications, and boards to ensure they are paid what they are actually worth.

Or to put it another way, to artificially erect barriers to entry that ensure they get paid more than they would in a freer market.

gabrielroth··on Better HN - Google Chrome extension
Very useful. It would be cool if there was a way to disable it for links that are dead on HN: there's no reason for an HN tab on the Facebook homepage ...
gabrielroth··on “It turns out”
In the pet-lizard case, aren't you using the phrase with mild irony? Something like, "After painstaking analysis coupled with a few brilliant flashes of insight, I managed to deduce this totally obvious fact"?
gabrielroth··on The iPad: It's about control systems, not eBook reading
This seems to me like an example of a particular kind of myopia: because the author has been involved in the control-panel industry, he perceives that industry to be a more important part of the world than it really is.

the touch screen on the iPad is remarkably sensitive. Do you really think they did that just for gaming?

Well, no, I think they did it for the user experience of the device as a whole, but even if it was just for gaming: Videogames take in $10 billion a year. Crestron and AMX together make about $0.7 billion.

gabrielroth··on The Story the New York Times Won't Touch
Well, Felix Salmon is a Reuters employee. Just because he's a blogger doesn't mean he's independent of big media companies and their conflicts. (I'm not pointing to any wrongdoing or turpitude on Salmon's part, just observing that an inflated claim is being made for his independence.)

If bloggers play a useful role in this kind of situation (and I think they do) it's not because "they are often more free of conflicts of interest" but because they're building a personal brand rather than contributing to an institutional brand, and that gives them a higher risk tolerance: they get more payoff from a big scoop, and they don't answer to editors whose incentives tend toward minimizing embarrassment.

gabrielroth··on Why there’s no such thing as "the music industry"
OK, so for 'the music industry' read 'the recorded-music industry.'
gabrielroth··on Microsoft’s Creative Destruction
Look closer. It's a link to a chart that compares the share prices of Apple and Microsoft over the past five years. Apple, driven by innovation, has increased by 400%. Microsoft, with its consistent profits, has remained almost perfectly flat.

This makes the previous poster's claim that investors have responded positively to Microsoft's approach look pretty weak.

gabrielroth··on Microsoft’s Creative Destruction
Just a little thought experiment here: in the eyes of shareholders, which is more important at the end of each quarter -- innovation, or profit? So did the profitability of the Office division suffer from not engaging the tablet?

And yet shareholders are not, in fact, rewarding Microsoft for its consistent profitability: http://www.google.com/finance?chdnp=1&chdet=126531720000... msft&ntsp=0

gabrielroth··on IPad: an Apple for Mom - The uncomputer for the people
Costs: developing and supporting a new version of the OS, introducing confusion into their famously stripped-down product lines, complicating the product's reputation as an easy-to-use consumer-oriented device.

Benefits: sales to the tiny minority of people who won't buy an iPad now, but would if they were more 'sandboxy.'

Doesn't sound 'very tasty' to me.

gabrielroth··on Geek behaviors present during conversations
It carries the presumption that you and nobody else is the Educator of Audiences and the Guardian of Validity of Discourse.

Not necessarily. Preserving accuracy in a complex system with a lot of data flowing all over the place requires multiple checks throughout the system.

← PreviousPage 5 of 11Next →