5,521 karma · joined February 19, 2011
Here are some well-written examples by Matt Taibi:
https://taibbi.substack.com/?sort=search&search=censored
Here is Glenn Greenvald explaining why he moved to Rumble:
https://rumble.com/vl268j-welcome-to-glenn-greenwalds-system...
Note that he doesn't claim he was censored. He just doesn't want to support a platform that censors in general.
...
The latest example I've seen directly was a strike against Dr. Mobeen Sayd's channel because he interviewed Pierre Kory. To put it into context, it's a channel from an MD with 10 years worth of educational content. It got a confirmed strike last week because he interviewed another doctor several month ago. There were also 50+ other videos deleted from the channel.
This is the video in question:
https://odysee.com/@DrMobeenSyed:1/dr.-pierre-kory,-ivermect...
Here is YouTube search confirming it does not exist on the original channel anymore:
https://www.youtube.com/c/USMLEOnline/search?query=Dr.%20Pie....)
It's time-consuming to provide these examples and it's impossible to know when people are asking for proof in good faith and when they are just play-acting ignorance.
I no longer feel this way. They got heavily partisan in the last few years and their statements on online censorship are weak and incoherent.
Why is their website on censorship (https://onlinecensorship.org/) abandoned and only contains examples from one side of the political spectrum?
Why are their lawyers participating in pro-censorship industry panels?
Where was EFF when New York Post's reporting on Hunter Biden laptop was censored by Twitter and Facebook? That was completely unprecedented, probably the biggest case of big tech censorship ever. (And yes, that reporting was accurate, contrary to what many here probably have heard: https://rumble.com/vmteq5-new-proof-emerges-about-the-hunter... .)
Where is EFF when YouTube relentlessly deletes educational videos, congressional testimonies and interviews with doctors when they say something "prohibited" about Covid-related topics?
Reddit is a great example. Its front page now reliably has some story where people cheer on deaths of conservatives from Covid or muse on how wonderful it would be to deny healthcare based on political views. With tens of thousands of upvotes and thousands agreeable comments. The likes of The Atlantic egg the whole thing on.
Where do you think this will lead in a few years?
"We recognize that this is a change to long-accepted practice and is substantially more rigorous than the standards that are typically currently applied"
Meta-analyses generally follow certain pre-established standards. That's the whole point of such studies.
It's one thing to claim that authors of a particular meta-study broke the standards. This is not being claimed here. It's an entirely different thing to claim that the standards themselves are broken and need to be changed generally. This is a huge claim that casts doubt on tons of prior research.
Maybe we do need more rigorous rules for meta-analysis. However, if that's the case, it should be true for all research of this type, not just papers examining "interventions for COVID-19" (as the article suggests).
Hence, my take on this. It's reasonable to question scientific standards if you are willing to demonstrate that they are really broken. (This was done with p-hacking, for example.) It's not reasonable to say that a specific subject in research should have different evidentiary standards because of controversy around one drug.
What is the problem to which this technology is a solution for?
Whose problem is it?
What new problems might be created by solving the original problem?
Which people and what institutions will be most seriously harmed by this new technology?
What sort of people and institutions gain special economic and political power from this new technology?
What changes in language are being forced by these new technologies?
Big picture:
user <-> something <-> ... <-> something <-> action
You give the permission system the starting point and the ending point, asking it whether this user can perform this action. The system loads or generates the graph in the middle and tries to find a path from one side to the other....
More details follow.
API for checking permissions was implemented as a boolean function of the following form:
CanDo(user, action)
Action was represented by a string of a particular format, e.g. "articles.edit.987". This is semi-arbitrary, as long as you stick with your convention.The function expanded user into a list of appropriate "roles".
Roles were handled in such a way that they could represent real users (user.12434) or groups (group.admins) or virtual groups (virtual.loggedIn).
The database stored information about what various roles could do in a table that had two essential columns: role id and permission pattern. This can be done in a variety of ways, depending on what storage mechanisms you use.
The resolution was as follows.
1. Find all rules for all the roles the user is in.
2. Take each pattern and match it against action supplied to canDo() function.
3. If there is a match, return true. If you exhaust the list, return false.
This setup is surprisingly flexible, as long as you understand how to use it. The trick is that you can add more entities between "user" and "action" and that will not change the API, just the resolution process. Moreover, since you effectively searching for a path in an acyclic graph between user and actions, you can search in any order and in any direction. And you can store permissions in all kinds of formats, again, without changing the application API.
All the business logic unrelated to authentication is handled in user code. E.g., if you want to allow someone to post articles on Tuesdays only, you write something like the following code:
if (TodayIsTuesday() && CanDo(currentUser, "articles.editOnTuesdays")){
//do stuff
} else {
//error
}
Technically, "pattern" for permissions could be anything. You could use a regex, but I would advice against it. If you use a simple hierarchy, you could expand it and run the match in a single DB query.Yes, they are. Anyone who is saying otherwise is either gaslighting you or speaks out of their ass. The way science is funded right now is incredibly broken. This is admitted both by people who worked in research during 60s-70s (when funding worked differently) and by honest people who worked in modern academia.
Alan Kay speaks about this often:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdHtYW_wcAs
Dark Horse podcast spoke at length about the current system:
https://odysee.com/@DarkHorsePodcastClips:b/corruption-in-sc...
It's routinely used for propagating smears:
https://odysee.com/@AlisonMorrow:6/how-wikipedia-decides-if-...
Even one of its co-founders says it's failing as an accurate source of information:
https://odysee.com/@TimcastIRL:8/former-founder-of-wikipedia...
Just like Jaron Lanier predicted in 2006:
https://www.edge.org/conversation/jaron_lanier-digital-maois...
I never understood why so many technologists vehemently defend a website that was obviously prone to a form of "regulatory capture" and groupthink.
From engineer's perspective the difference between a free tool and a "small fee" (in most companies) is not money. It's the fact that you now have to jump through provisioning hoops and ask for permission to use the tool. The difference in flexibility is enormous.
Yes, and most of the idiotic complexity on the web today is the result of people insisting that instead of clearly defined execution and communication models all we needed was a document with some "extra features". Admit it. Alan Kay was right. All the web developers were wrong.
I like simple HTML. I even design most of my web stuff so that it works without scripts. However, the idea that documents are always simple and programs are always complex is wrong on the most fundamental level.
The idea of having a generic interface to widely different types of entities is a very powerful concept and it is very unfortunate that so many web developers today don't seem to get it.
https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/03/17/2020-05...
The Secretary must also state that liability protections available under the PREP Act are in effect with respect to the Recommended Activities. These liability protections provide that, “[s]ubject to other provisions of [the PREP Act], a covered person shall be immune from suit and liability under federal and state law with respect to all claims for loss caused by, arising out of, relating to, or resulting from the administration to or use by an individual of a covered countermeasure if a Declaration has been issued with respect to such countermeasure.”
...
The PREP Act states that a “Covered Countermeasure” must be a “qualified pandemic or epidemic product,” or a “security countermeasure,” as described immediately below; or a drug, biological product or device authorized for emergency use in accordance with Sections 564, 564A, or 564B of the FD&C Act.
https://esolutions.shop/shop/e-os-teracube-2e/
Anyone used this thing?
A lot of what's being currently said about "disinformation" is completely incoherent and makes little sense if you just track it over time. As late as in 2014 social media was presented as a force for good. ("Wisdom of the crowds", etc.) Just couple years later it was rebranded as some kind of machine where evil people brainwash idiots into becoming evil people. Who are the idiots? Well, given that YouTube and Facebook have billions of users, it seems most humans on the planet are shoved into that category now. Everything they see and say needs to be carefully curated by professionals, lest the crowds go mad.
Meanwhile, what are the incentives to, say, post an intelligent and comprehensive YouTube comment? There were none in 2014 and there are none right now. The UI, the up-voting process, the very (lack of) structure in how comments are displayed and sorted all encourage verbal vomit, and that's exactly what YouTube gets. In general, social media structure usually provides zero incentives to engage in real discussions and deep thinking. I don't see this being addressed, let alone changed, no matter what the executives say.
I recommend everyone to read Marshall McLuhan's Understanding Media. Despite being written in 1964 it presents a much more useful analytical framework to really understand social media than anything I've seen published in the last few years.
Couple month ago I bought Lateral Thinking and was somewhat surprised and somewhat encouraged to see that de Bono's observations overlapped my own. Except his book was written in 1970 and didn't deal with IT. Moreover, his analysis was comprehensive and systematic. I wish I learned about his work earlier.
Bingo. When people from US tech culture say "hard problems" they really mean "hard puzzles". A lot of those people are very proud of their puzzle-solving skills acquired at school (what Edward De Bono calls vertical thinking), while being absolutely awful at dealing with ill-defined open problems (lateral thinking). Instead of counteracting this tendency in some way most Silicon Valley companies actually amplify the problem by running puzzle interviews and structuring their work around glorified paperclip maximization. This is why so many systems we have to use today are extremely complex, highly optimized for some specific criteria, but ultimately designed like shit.
Why do we need to imagine something that actually takes place? Phase 3 trials of vaccines relied on self-reporting of symptoms by participants. E.g:
https://cdn.pfizer.com/pfizercom/2020-11/C4591001_Clinical_P...
See section 8.13. COVID-19 Surveillance (All Participants).
A lot of other medical research relies on self-reporting of symptoms as well.
2014: Sharyl Attkisson worked for CBS for two decades, heavily criticized Obama administration and yet left on "amicable" terms (according to that article).
2020: Bari Weiss (who isn't exactly a pro-Trump Republican) faced "constant bullying" from colleagues at NYT, attacks from them on Twitter and on internal Slack. Less you think it's her personal problem, James Bennet was forced to resign from NYT for allowing a republican senator to publish an OP-ED.
Does it not seem like there was a shift of some sort? Well, apparently Attkisson herself published several books claiming that things have changed:
https://www.amazon.com/Sharyl-Attkisson/e/B001IYXCFM/ref=dp_...