HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gbhn

920 karma · joined February 11, 2010

submissionscomments
gbhn··on Andy Grove’s Warning to Silicon Valley
If its true that such jobs would reduce unemployment substantially, then a number of potential workers might already be recipients of other government programs, meaning the marginal cost is not nearly as much as the salary.

Implementing such a program in that way though requires a fair amount of attention. If it ends up not reducing unemployment, that means it is diverting workers from other industries, which doesn't necessarily mean it is a bad program, but it's a different kind of thing.

gbhn··on Artificial intelligence: Ten things you need to understand
How about this:

For the hundred thousandth time, a generation of humans will be confronted with the necessity of incorporating into their society a group of beings which they created and which they love, hate, fear, trust, and, most of all, barely understand. For a million years, that group was "their own biological children," but over the next few decades, that group might also come to include "their mental children: AIs."

In other words, we're damn good at this. We'll make it. :-)

gbhn··on Investigate switching away from GitHub
There's an API for the github issue tracker. I'm kind of surprised that with all the other tooling built around github that there aren't really nice issue trackers that would provide better management and triage workflows and would then condense to github issues that would work well with dev workflows and conventions.
gbhn··on Caltech Researchers Find Evidence of a Planet Beyond Pluto
No, this is just about right. The evidence they have points sharply to there being a ninth planet. Now they're saying "here's where it might be, we need help finding it!"

Once someone has a photo and an orbit, that'll be the >>3.8sigma you want, but I don't think anyone is saying anything like that yet. What they're saying is "dedicating 5 years of the pinnacle of your planetary astronomy career to looking for this thing is probably not a waste." They directly compare this to the theoretical prediction of Neptune, so I think the authors have this same interpretation of what they are doing.

gbhn··on SpaceX Falcon rocket explodes on landing after delivering satellite to space
For weight, the sides of a rocket are very thin. Think tin can. Vertical is OK but horizontal can't work.
gbhn··on Scale Invariance: A Cautionary Tale Against Reductionism
Isn't the other side of the coin, though, that in these types of systems you can actually get a lot "wrong" and they still work? That is, in the example of a sand pile, if you get the rate of adding sand "wrong", it doesn't really matter: much the same thing happens. That's kind of the whole point.

Whether that means that in simulating the brain it may turn out that you can get a lot wrong and still have a successful outcome is TBD, but I'm not sure the expectations are as solidly negative as the article suggests.

gbhn··on An open letter to Paul Graham
Many people think Musk is in the top percentiles of "using money well." While I think it is always appropriate to want the government to run better, it's probably not fair to set such a high bar for it.

One might just as easily say "no VC should invest money in any company whose founder has a poorer track record than Elon Musk" which is of course a ridiculous posture.

gbhn··on Valuing time over money is associated with greater happiness
I think it's even more dramatic than that. Wealth conveys the ability to explore alternate experiences with more efficiency.

What I mean by that is the ability to either fund "vicarious" experiences. ("If I worked on this project, I'd do about the same thing as that person, so I'll hire them to do it.") As well as the more conventional kinds of acceleration like finding it easier to more frequently have more peak and different experiences like travel.

gbhn··on Instagram's Million Dollar Bug
Agreed. To me as an outsider, this escalation bug looks a max bug, definitely dwarfing any particular admin console vulnerability, and that the processes the researcher claims to have followed were pretty much necessary to show it. Whether or not this followed the letter of the policy, by responsibly reporting the escalation in the spirit of the policy, the researcher has fulfilled the spirit of the goal.
gbhn··on Why Go Is Not Good (2014)
To me, a lot of the more interesting areas of type research basically involve embedding logic into types. So types for sequencing of operations, types that constrain the data in them, etc. Those are awesome in that they enable static analysis to detect more sorts of logic errors in a digestible way, but my impression is that they end up encoding constraints in the type system that are then harder to change as the demands on the system evolve.
gbhn··on The first person to hack the iPhone is building a self-driving car
But this is a fundamental problem: The learning approach might need 100s of examples of drivers reacting to a bicycle on a sidewalk while turning right into a parking lot to get the right training input. Or perhaps it can learn from examples of bicycles and sidewalks and driveways to do the right thing. The point is, there are millions of edge cases, so getting examples of them all for training or verification is a very large task. The alternative is to build a more general world model where it's possible to work from the other direction and gain confidence that yes, the car senses all other obstacles correctly, and yes, it has algorithms that attempt to eliminate collisions in any circumstances. That's a fairly different approach, which ends up being much heavier in terms of effort and investment.
gbhn··on The High-Stakes Race to Rid the World of Human Drivers
Or just do what a driverless car would do: call the authorities or turn around and proceed by another route.
gbhn··on Why Go Is Not Good (2014)
My (inexpert) opinion is that the kind of computer language researcher or practitioner interested in exploring how far you can go with type systems is dissatisfied with Go.

But there are many types of static analysis which accomplish similar (or more dramatic) goals than what can be down with type analysis, and the simplicity of a language makes those kinds of analyses more reachable. Examples: gofmt and gofix.

I think it's amazing what kinds of magic can be encapsulated with the type system, but my experience doing software is that complex types often end up being a hairball which is very change-resistant. Go's emphasis on lifecycle support for large programs may point us to new kinds of tools and methods. Whether those tools and methods end up being able to be encompassed by type theory is an open question, but it looks to me like Go is aimed in a great direction to raise the questions.

gbhn··on Chernoff's Faces
Thank you! :-)
gbhn··on The Space Doctor’s Big Idea
Math is a great example of how notation is sooo important. Doing math with roman numerals is.... possible, sure. But for pretty much any math that's worth anything, it's just a bad notation. It obscures what's going on and makes it harder to mentally deal with. Notation is a critical tool of thought.
gbhn··on 18F's Micro-Purchase Experiment: Why I Bid $1
I think this is the most apropos objection: 18F is trying to trial a reliable source of contracting for small-scale IT work.

If it turns out that volunteerism is reliable, then awesome! 18F just discovered that by spending time to nail down detailed reqs the govt can let patriotic citizens contribute to their society by helping on projects! Everyone wins and things are awesome!

If on the other hand your intuition is that volunteerism is unreliable, then this just short-circuited an early experiment by 18F to figure out a reliable piecework system for doing IT development.

My intuition matches the second case, but there's an existence proof that the first might actually be correct. It'd be a totally awesome story if it was, so I have a hard time being sad. And even if it isn't, it may give 18F folks a think, as in "hmm, perhaps some of these projects are appropriate for volunteerism; is there a context where we can develop tools for that use case? universities? job training?"

gbhn··on Socialist millionaire protocol
Perhaps a good intuition pump is this: after every guess the person claiming to have found Waldo gets to position three things: the book, the waldo mask, and the covering cardboard.

This then means the subsequent trials don't reveal any side channels about Waldo's location in the book. (And of course in practice the "pieces of cardboard" are big enough to obscure all book information.)

gbhn··on Winner Takes Most
My perception is there's dissatisfaction with Chinese trade in many parts of American politics. So that there's an eleven-figure (or so) protection system in place seems like it would trigger howls of outrage and condemnation, and doesn't.

(I'm not sure it should, but "should" doesn't seem like a big obstacle to political outrage, normally. :-))

gbhn··on Winner Takes Most
"The Chinese have dealt with that issue by protecting their market."

Can anyone explain why this ends up not being a bigger international trade issue? It seems to me like it would be a giant flashpoint, but it seems not to be.

gbhn··on Why Do High-Frequency Traders Cancel So Many Orders?
Something this article ignores, and which is ignored by most articles on HFT, is that the process is ilegible to the public. "No no we're doing you a favor!" is not reassuring when the activity consumes a bunch of resources on zero sum activity.

Ultimately investing runs on trust. HFT is consuming public trust in the financial system at a prodigious rate. Is it a trillion dollars a year? A billion? Hard to be sure. But it certainly isn't clear the tiny market-making improvements are worth it.

gbhn··on How Do the Yellow Pages Still Make Money?
The article addresses this: some cities attempted laws against YP deliveries, but they were thrown out on free speech grounds.
gbhn··on America's Military Supremacy Is Fading
It's also worth noting that power projection is also different because of different balances of other interests. The kinds of things other countries want to do is different, and the lengths to which the US is willing to go to affect them is different. In my opinion, these factors might be just as great or greater than relative military superiority.
gbhn··on The story behind Jar’Edo Wens, the longest-running hoax in Wikipedia history
This was my first reaction too. :-)
gbhn··on Science Fairs Aren't So Fair
I felt like the author not only decried projects where the kids have access to parental help, but projects where the kids have access to good facilities. And motivation. I'm not sure what's left to measure if we attempted to remove support, facilities, and motivation.

The author seems to support the idea that schools should provide more support and facilities. That sounds good, but the outcome of some schools doing this (the infamous ones near New York, apparently) seems to be the focus of criticism. I'm left not understanding the thrust of the article.

gbhn··on You Can Spend $750 in International Data Roaming in One Minute on AT&T
I think what he's suggesting isn't that the logs don't line up, but that AT&T may be purposely switching the phone to use the data roaming opportunity. Even though carriers gouge each other horribly on roaming, the marginal profit may be even more to the consumer. If this is true, it would be a scandal.

OP sounded pretty sure, but I'm skeptical.

gbhn··on The Reading Level of the State of Union Address Is in Decline
My understanding is that early SOU papers weren't delivered as speeches, but were mostly technical reports intended for what today would be regarded as people like the OMB and similar congressional bodies.

More recently they're vehicles for delivering messages to the public.

gbhn··on The problem of fake gold bars (2012)
I don't know anything about this case, but it could be there's a bunch of air trapped inside the bar with the tungsten, assuming the forgers didn't alter the outside dimensions of the bar.
gbhn··on Confessions of a Congressman
I'm interested in reactions to this idea: a virtual "shadow Congress."

The plan would be to get broad participation in an unofficial election process which would elect representatives to "shadow Congress." They'd at least start out by addressing the same agenda as real Congress, and be forbidden from introducing new agenda. The idea would be to generate a template of what a broad-participation representative group of citizens would like to see happen from Congress.

The theory is that if this shadow Congress is representative enough, it becomes hard for real Congress to ignore. The compromises it comes up with are a template for real compromises. When the national media starts writing stories like "Why can't real Congress do what shadow Congress can?" or "Here is the Senator unilaterally blocking the rest of Congress from following the shadow Congress' lead on this issue." the idea will have worked.

gbhn··on The Art World’s Patron Satan
I'm certainly no art high roller, but my understanding is that the art world has a long history of patrons like this, who have eclectic tastes, large networks of trusting collectors, and an eye for the new. Everyone hates them, until eventually they build the Guggenheim museum and then everyone thinks they were awesome.
gbhn··on U.S. ends TARP with $15.3B profit
Except politically if course, where returns were abysmal.
← PreviousPage 3 of 11Next →