HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

genezeta

1,671 karma · joined September 1, 2010

Just a random person who failed.
submissionscomments
genezeta··on Why wouldn't Reddit charge end-users for the API access?
I guessed you would disagree. It's a bit sad, though, coming here asking "what am I missing?" and then making every effort to discard anything anyone says.

Don't mean to antagonize; just think it's sad.

genezeta··on Why wouldn't Reddit charge end-users for the API access?
> Vast majority of users understand perfectly well that the company needs funding to go on and if it collapses, their online communities will go down with it.

The vast majority of users understand about funding but largely prefer having some ads. That is the price most users are willing to pay. The exact benefit premium membership gives you is hiding ads, which is at the core of the discussion here. And as I said, it accounts for only 3% of what ads make.

And again, you underestimate the feeling of participation as "contribution". Particularly for those users willing to "go further". The people that most invest on the community do so because it gives them as much of a feeling of belonging as one of "ownership". No, those feelings don't mean users "like Reddit", much less as a company; people have strong feelings towards "their" particular subreddits.

genezeta··on Why wouldn't Reddit charge end-users for the API access?
Note that Reddit already has some "premium membership" in place and yet from those reddit makes about 1/25 times what it makes from advertising (2021).

So what you're missing is that, in general, people are not that willing to pay just because "you ask them to pay" as you assume. The premium subscribers are already subscribed. So... should they include the "third party app API key" as part of that subscription? Then they would be making no money from it. Should they charge an additional amount? How would they justify that to people already paying?

Also what you mention as people being "very firmly hooked in Reddit" actually means that redditors feel intensely that they already contribute, that it is their submissions and comments which brings value to reddit. When that's the prevailing feeling, making them pay is hard.

It all indicates that this is a much harder sell than you make it appear.

genezeta··on Google no longer automatically indexes websites?
In 2004 IE had 94% share of the browser market.

There were "tiny upticks" but, going slowly and steadily, in August 2008 Firefox had gained about 30-33% and IE was down to about 60%. And then (September 2008) Chrome happened.

genezeta··on Am I the Unethical One?
These days I find it fairly risky to think that it's reasonable to believe just anything you read on the internet because a website says so.
genezeta··on Arianespace CEO: Europe won't have reusable rockets for another decade
ESA -and Europe in general, sure, but particularly ESA- also has a massive bureaucratic problem.
genezeta··on The money spent on lotteries doesn’t go to the park
There are two payments.

First you pay to participate in the lottery. This is money you've lost no matter what.

Then if you win you pay a second amount for the permit itself.

genezeta··on Show HN: Niui 3.0 – lightweight, rich, accessible front end
That scroll snap -or something- is messing up.
genezeta··on Show HN: Niui 3.0 – lightweight, rich, accessible front end
Please, do not hijack the page scroll that way. It makes using the scroll-wheel really difficult, even unusable.
genezeta··on Ask HN: Is there an open-source HN forum clone?
FWIW some years ago Salvatore Sanfilippo (antirez) wrote Lamernews [0][1] with the goal to create such a clone. AFAIK Lamernews, as a site, is long gone, but the code -Ruby, Sinatra, Redis- is still there.

There have also been some forks. EchoJS [2] made a few modifications through the years and is running still today. Mostly about moderation and some related tasks like blacklisting and others. Can't say much about pros/cons but at least it's still used and somewhat maintained.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3146051

[1] https://github.com/antirez/lamernews

[2] https://github.com/echojs/echojs

genezeta··on Ask HN: Is the LLM craze real? Or are companies just hyping it to fish for CVs?
It doesn't necessarily mean it's evil. I mean, they could hire people to work on the idea they present. I don't know.

But, yeah, it's unlikely you'll ever know.

genezeta··on Ask HN: Is the LLM craze real? Or are companies just hyping it to fish for CVs?
Did your acquaintance provide "a specific prompt engineering project on LLMs that you’re proud of in your application"? Was that project interesting in a particularly innovative way?

I mean, I don't really know but an alternative explanation to "CV fishing" can be "idea fishing". You have a startup with something they call a "product", their generic assistant Claude. They've invested in feeding and growing a LLM. But while they claim this assistant can be integrated "anywhere" to solve "multiple tasks", that is all pretty generic. Which means -maybe; again I don't know- they lack actual practical scenarios where the application of a LLM will provide direct and visible benefits. That is, they got something they think can be useful but they still need to find how to make it so, how to provide interesting use cases. And so, they would be interested in getting all these small, experimental ideas to read and think about.

genezeta··on There is no A.I.
> many things ... a 2000 word essay written at a 10th grade level

That is one thing, not many. And it's also a fairly specific thing. I don't know about the general population but personally my need to acquire such an essay is fairly low. I haven't had the need to buy one in the last fifty years, probably never.

genezeta··on Make the future bright again: On building a new philosophy of progress
I don't know but... make the future bright again?
genezeta··on FBI is warning people against using public phone-charging stations
Probably meant "IoT cameras".

Though apparently the "Internet of Cows" is something.

genezeta··on Ask HN: How do I get out of the “new project” loop?
To get out of a loop, break unconditionally. Literally. At any of the steps you have described, just don't follow it.

So, got an idea? Don't build a skeleton. Just leave it there. I would suggest you do write it down somewhere, maybe take a few extra notes, but that's it. Leave it there for a while. Another idea? Same thing.

Not only will you have gotten out of the loop you're in, but in a short time you will probably have a bunch of ideas written down. Now you can review, compare, relate them. And still don't start building on them yet. Just sort them, prune them, refine them, discard many, remix a few, join others, modify a few more.

Avoid getting started on any idea too soon. Only after this process, when you do find one idea which particularly calls your attention and it's fleshed out enough to convince you that you are actually interested in following through, only then, I repeat, start working on it.

And still, don't just jump into building it. Again, before building: think, plan, find the hard parts, find the easy parts, ponder, evaluate, refine it further.

The thing is... implementing the idea is not that creative. It is, but only to a certain point. The creative part is the idea itself, shaping it, refining it, making it consistent, solid, interesting, useful... But if you start building it right away you don't leave room for the idea to grow, to take it's correct shape, to become actually interesting or be revealed as the opposite.

genezeta··on [dead]
Up for me.
genezeta··on Ask HN: Hypothesis on Post-GPT-4 Future Demand for Software Developers
> with the right prompting

So... If you say the correct words, they will understand them correctly? That seems hardly an achievement, if I may say so.

genezeta··on Solar Staff
Cloudflare says my access to the site is denied.
genezeta··on YeSvelte: Svelte UI Component Library
Unfortunately, it seems like the trailing slash is significant and, being present, makes the URL return a 404.

Use https://www.yesvelte.com/docs for the correct link.

genezeta··on Beta Testers required for my book-recommendation website
The idea is interesting. However I'm afraid the current state of the site would benefit a lot more from some dedicated testing (i.e. one or two people, putting time and effort) rather than a bunch of strangers looking at it casually.

I understand you're the sole developer of the project and that you need to get help in any way you can.

But there are some really basic problems.

Many have already commented about the continuous reload thing. It can be fixed, apparently, by closing the tab and reopening. Apparently. That's what I did and it worked. But it's a big enough problem that needs a deeper look. That's why someone specifically trained to test would help you much better.

There seem to also be a bunch of bad-loading problems. Sometimes stuff doesn't load. This is so bad that you even have a message asking the user to reload or re-type the query until it works. Yes, I understand about the money restrictions, but throwing that against a whole community will hardly be productive.

I mentioned "bad-loading" and not simply not loading because sometimes the wrong cover loads for a certain book in the results and you hover over it and it's a different book, click it, and it gets the correct cover.

Again, I understand that you want help and are alone. But these problems are big enough to be showstoppers. In the sense that it will be much harder to get anyone interested if thing don't even load correctly or at all, or reload infinitely.

Now...

The mind-map seems like a nice feature. But it lacks links between the bubbles (at least in my browser) which feels weird. It makes it look more like a bunch of bubbles randomly thrown in there than an actual mind-map with a structure or relationship between nodes.

Also, it frequently features duplication. Just use the given example of The Great Gatsby and you'll get a second "The Great Gatsby" bubble as if it was a different book. I tried randomly "Neuromancer" and there were 2 extra Neuromancer bubbles. It doesn't look like they are duplicate entries in the dB but more like a problem building the mind-map.

I also get some random bubbles missing their title.

As for the "Book-genie" recommendations I can say very little. I tried the "Inspiring books with aliens" example and I got "Seven Brief Lessons on Physics" along Cixin Liu. Are these results good? I really can't say, but I don't feel like a physics book matches the mood. But in any case, one would have to test this much more deeply to actually evaluate if the recommendations are any good, or even simply any better than a keyword based search.

There's also more general design and UX comments that I could say. But again these are hardly specific details. It feels like you'd need someone to dedicate some time exclusively to that part and re-do things in general.

----

In any case, I do hope you get the help you need to make this work. I just don't think putting this up in its current state against a large audience will do much good.

genezeta··on Solar panels on cars make no sense at this point
Western Europe city resident for more than 30 years. Medium sized capital. "Sunny" is what they call this place.

A very large part of the parking space in the city is underground. Almost all housing with parking space have it built under the building. Here "regular housing" is apartment buildings and there are only a few smaller areas with single-family houses.

Most recent shopping malls have underground parking too. Only a handful have open surface level parking and that's the ones outside the city. Not just shopping malls, the trend for smaller supermarkets currently being built is having inside parking. As for parks... most just don't have any parking space. The two or three that do, it is indeed open surface level parking. But most parks in the city just don't have parking space. You walk there or take public transport.

There is, sure, parking in the street. And this is generally a sunny city, as I said. And yet, a large part of street parking space available is under tree shade and/or under a building's shade for most of the day. A street where you can park and that is wide enough to get more sun will very likely have trees planted.

So... yes, there is a lot of sun here, there's no discussing that. But the city is just not built to let parked cars get those sun rays.

----

On the other hand, yes, it's not feasible for a large part of the population to put solar panels up at home. That is undeniable. Some companies are trying to come at this from a different angle: they are promoting installing solar panels as a shared resource for the whole building. The downside is that usually you don't use it, but just sell it back to the network. But it does produce an extra source which, at the end of the day, is what counts. It may not be the best solution, but it's what you can do.

genezeta··on Summer Afternoon – A WebGL Experiment

  s/for/from
genezeta··on You don't have to engage with people on the Internet
FWIW: For people not reading tfa, note that while the title is wide and general, the actual concern expressed in the text is much more specific: It's about not needing to argue in favour of your employer in public.
genezeta··on Summer Afternoon – A WebGL Experiment
The sloth is fairly small compared to some other secrets. It's also the same colour of the tree's trunk so it's kind of hard to see for afar.
genezeta··on Ask HN: Is TypeScript worth it?
> You can't really decouple JS libraries from TS. Most JS libraries still maintained support TS these days. My point is that many of them are still documented using JS with JS examples, and don't fully document the types that go along with all their methods.

Ok, but... what you're saying here is that, while you're not convinced by TS yourself, you expect all JS library creators to be convinced. Why should they be?

genezeta··on Ask HN: Is TypeScript worth it?
I won't defend TypeScript. Mainly because I'm not interested in doing such a thing; I don't like it that much, clearly not enough to care.

But even so, I will say a couple of things about your arguments.

Regarding i), no, it's not a framework. But then again, I don't think that's what your argument expresses anyway. You seem to be saying "it's yet another dependency you need to keep up with". This would be correct and a valid argument. But it's unrelated with "being a framework" (which, again, it is not).

As for ii)... I'm afraid this argument could be valid for any large group you want to pick in software. Are you arguing JS libraries at large are better documented? Sounds highly dubious. From a different angle, is this a problem with the language itself or is it a problem with the libraries?

Finally, regarding iv), there is no "progress including TypeScript in a browser" and you should never have expected it. Not saying it will never happen because some person somewhere might do it, but you shouldn't expect it.

genezeta··on Ask HN: What sub $200 product improved your 2022
I simply stopped pairing socks 30 years ago. I have experienced no ill effects wearing unmatched socks.
genezeta··on Ask HN: Did Chamath Palihapitiya coin/invent the 'data scientist' job role?
From [ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Data_science ]:

> Early usage

> In 1962, John Tukey described a field he called "data analysis", which resembles modern data science. In 1985, in a lecture given to the Chinese Academy of Sciences in Beijing, C. F. Jeff Wu used the term "data science" for the first time as an alternative name for statistics. ...

> The term "data science" has been traced back to 1974, when Peter Naur proposed it as an alternative name for computer science. ...

> Modern usage

> In 2012, technologists Thomas H. Davenport and DJ Patil declared "Data Scientist: The Sexiest Job of the 21st Century", a catch-phrase that was picked up even by major-city newspapers like the New York Times and the Boston Globe. ...

> The modern conception of data science as an independent discipline is sometimes attributed to William S. Cleveland. In a 2001 paper ...

> The professional title of "data scientist" has been attributed to DJ Patil and Jeff Hammerbacher in 2008. ...

> There is still no consensus on the definition of data science, and it is considered by some to be a buzzword. ...

---

You can also read [ https://www.forbes.com/sites/gilpress/2013/05/28/a-very-shor... ] which mentions quite a few previous references to the term.

---

But of course any random "Entrepreneur - Businessman - Venture capitalist" can claim to have invented anything and if he repeats it a number of times, he can end up building a strong enough perception of it being true.

genezeta··on Show HN: Dog API
Ah, ok. Great :)
← PreviousPage 11 of 19Next →