HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ghufran_syed

2,751 karma · joined August 15, 2014

Apprentice mathematician, programmer, Emergency Medicine doctor in the SF Bay area.

Feel free to get in touch for any reason at all, it's always nice to chat to people first_name.last_name @ gmail.com

meet.hn/city/us-Los-Angeles

Socials:

- linkedin.com/in/ghufransyed

Interests:

Books, Education, Entrepreneurship, Healthcare, Hiking, Mentorship, Outdoor Activities, Science, Space Tech, Startups

---

submissionscomments
ghufran_syed··on Should a dog's sniff be enough to convict a person for murder?
Seems like the appropriate defense strategy should be to arrange their own cadaver dog analysis which shows completely contradictory evidence to that of the the prosecution dog.
ghufran_syed··on My experience of losing a friend to heroin (2020)
I work in the ER in a high drug use area - I estimate around 80% of patients who start outpatient "medication assisted treatment" in the ER (outpatient buprenorphine-naloxone to treat the withdrawal symptoms) are there because the judge in their criminal case tells them it's that or go to prison. Some people definitely can't make good decisions for themselves and need to be "forced" to get treatment - and are later often grateful for having been forced to do so if they stay clean.
ghufran_syed··on Willingness to look stupid
“What is the Apple store employee supposed to do to not make someone feel stupid when they ask for the smallest box?”

Maybe ask the customer, “can I ask why you would like the one with the smallest box?” instead of making assumptions? Although note that this might also be classified as a question where the person asking is admitting they don’t understand why someone would want this aka “looking dumb” in the wording from the article

ghufran_syed··on I once killed a $125M deal by being “too honest”
This wasn’t integrity - just bad sales technique. He had some knowledge that was potentially of value to Yahoo, but instead of seeing if Yahoo was interested in buying that knowledge, he just gave it to them for free.
ghufran_syed··on The wealthiest 10% of Americans own a record 89% of all U.S. stocks
Isn’t this logically equivalent to “The most successful 10% of athletes have won 90% of olympic gold medals”?

We’re using their wealth (which naturally includes a lot of stock because it can be held in tax-deferred retirement accounts and has the greatest growth expectation historically) to identify the top decile, then we find that they, err, own a lot of stock. How surprising.

ghufran_syed··on Joe Manchin's Dirty Empire
Don’t take my word for it, take the word of one of the founders: https://greenwald.substack.com/p/my-resignation-from-the-int...

“The same trends of repression, censorship and ideological homogeneity plaguing the national press generally have engulfed the media outlet I co-founded”

I don’t argue they are a mouthpiece for the democrat party, only that this article supports the idea of “repression, censorship and ideological conformity” being a problem.

90% of the dates and events they talk about are prior to 2018. I have no evidence that they “had this story available to them” in 2018, at least in the sense of having been investigated and written in 2018. My point is why investigate it and write it now, and not then? There seems to be no significant new information that’s come out since 2018 that might have led to this article - to quote the article,“ For decades, Manchin has profited from a series of coal companies that he founded during the 1980s.” - did the intercept only just realize coal might be bad, or was it that they didn’t realize that the (democrat) senator of a state where coal is economically important might have historical links to that industry?

[edit] I also don’t claim that this is a problem specific to democrats, though the large majority of mainstream journalists are provably democrats rather than republicans - exactly the same thing happens in republican leaning publications. My point is that we should think not just about what is written in an article, but also what wasn’t and maybe should have been?

ghufran_syed··on Joe Manchin's Dirty Empire
Funny how the intercept didn’t care about this in 2018 when Joe Manchin was running for re-election for the senate. Regardless of the merits, this is basically just a “shot across the bow” for doing what his constituents want instead of what the national party wants. But you won’t be hearing about it in 2024 when he runs for re-election and his winning might be the difference between a democrat or republican senate majority
ghufran_syed··on MIT study finds Tesla drivers become inattentive when Autopilot is activated
Because we need to define "dangerous" - the authors and you are making an assumption that what they call "inattention" is the same as "dangerous" whereas the comment you are replying to is questioning that assumption. If the link between "inattention" and accident rates is strong, then measuring that should be equivalent.

In medicine there is a concept of measuring disease-oriented outcomes instead of patient-oriented outcomes, because it's easier to show an intervention affects the disease-oriented outcomes, and much harder to show a change in patient-oriented outcomes.

So for example, a disease-oriented ourcome for hip-replacement surgery would be "range of movement after 2 weeks", patient-oriented might be "can go up a flight of stairs"

The analogy here seems relevant.

ghufran_syed··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
Hmm, that’s a good point - I’d forgotten that I used to have to leave my firearms in safe territory back in Arlington VA before visiting DC proper
ghufran_syed··on Video of Tesla FSD almost hitting pedestrian receives DMCA takedown
If your concerns are correct, shouldn’t we see a lot MORE collisions among the millions of current tesla drivers using the existing, less advanced system than we do among comparable vehicles and drivers? Wouldn’t we expect to see higher insurance premiums for tesla drivers with FSD than for comparable drivers and comparably expensive cars? That doesn’t seem to be the case for the most numerous tesla vehicles[1]. In which case this sounds like a “it works in practice, but does it work in theory?” kind of situation :)

[1] https://www.motortrend.com/features/how-much-are-tesla-insur...

ghufran_syed··on Video of Tesla FSD almost hitting pedestrian receives DMCA takedown
I think we’re missing the point that this is currently designed for a driver to monitor at all times, the driver intervened appropriately, and thereby provided another training example for the network. This is also a beta version that is being tested by humans who have the legal and moral responsibility for control of the car.
ghufran_syed··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
How many of those weapons were discharged? And how many were “seized” is not as interesting as how many were being held illegally? The government can illegally seize all sorts of things from citizens, including cash, but the process of doing so doesn’t make the original possession a crime
ghufran_syed··on Women are nearly half of new gun buyers, study finds
why? The taliban is not like a nation state army, more like a bunch or militias and tribes, each of which is a “bunch of local guys with guns”. As the war has progressed, I imagine they have got more professional, but I’m guessing around 80-90% of their strength are non ideological tribal militias who are very good at figuring out which way the wind is blowing and changing sides. That worked in the US favor in 2001-2 when the northern alliance was winning, and against US interests now, that’s why resistance collapsed so quickly back in 2001 and now.
ghufran_syed··on Nirvana sued by the man who appeared on Nevermind’s album cover as a baby
"It'd be nice to have a quarter for all the people who have seen my baby penis."

Sounds like the only issue he has with it is that HE didn't get any of the money.

ghufran_syed··on Ask HN: Any recourse for a f***ed contract?
Get legal advice straight away, from someone with experience in this area. Honestly, even if you don’t have a strong case, the company would have to disclose a lawsuit to the purchasing company. So they are likely to settle just to avoid detailing or delaying the acquisition.

Facebook settled with the winklevoss twins, and they had a pretty weak case too…

ghufran_syed··on The First Delta Force Trainee Class
Eric Haney’s book is great, another one along the same lines is “Quiet soldier” by Adam Ballinger, about a guy who did selection and trained with the part-time (Territorial Army) SAS battalion.
ghufran_syed··on Adda as a Way of Life
The subjects of this article would probably disagree with you:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/black-barber-shops-salon...

ghufran_syed··on Ex-Tesla Employee Called Racial Slur Wins Rare $1M Award
So calling a black person a “redneck” would be reasonable? I actually agree, and Thomas Sowell, a leading black intellectual would too:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Rednecks_and_White_Lib...

ghufran_syed··on Vic Health denies vaccinated woman's request to visit daughter in cancer ward
Ok...but is it correct or incorrect? Maybe you could address that point instead of the ad hominem?

Here's a similar story from 9news that describes a similar situation

https://www.9news.com.au/national/coronavirus-nsw-gladys-ber...

ghufran_syed··on Vic Health denies vaccinated woman's request to visit daughter in cancer ward
This really brings home how different the western democracies are in terms of their attitudes to personal freedom - I can't even imagine a system where an american would have to apply to a government bureaucrat for permission to travel to support a sick relative and their family.

I initially thought the denial was based on the risk to the immunosuppressed daughter, but the article says the patient was vaccinated and willing to undergo a 14 day quarantine (plus covid test I assume?), so the risk to the patient seems negligible. And, you know, maybe the adult daughter and her mom could decide for themselves?

ghufran_syed··on Swiss Ph.D student’s dismissal spotlights China’s influence
I say that jeopardizing the safety of your loved one and her family back in China after they specifically ask you not to take some action, and while you are safely abroad is not a good example of moral courage
ghufran_syed··on Swiss Ph.D student’s dismissal spotlights China’s influence
Totally agree - he is studying china, lived in china, has a chinese girlfriend in china who advised him to stop the critical tweets…and he just kept doing it anyway???

“His girlfriend was shocked when she saw some of the tweets. Talking with him on the telephone, she begged him to stop. Not because she necessarily disagreed with anything. But because she was worried about retaliation by the Chinese government. «I'm in Switzerland, not China,» Gerber replied. «I can say what I want here.»

Sorry to sound harsh, but I would argue that level of naivety / ignorance pretty much should disqualify him from a PhD in anything related to modern day China.

ghufran_syed··on Home Depot is introducing power tools that won’t work if they’re stolen
If people have learnt not to report crimes (because it makes no difference), the police have learnt to not arrest people for non-violent crimes (because the DA won't prosecute), do you think that might affect the crime rates? If so, in which direction?
ghufran_syed··on U.S. Sees Ongoing Spike in Gun, Ammo Sales: 'I've Never Seen Anything Like It'
"44 shot this weekend" in chicago

https://abc7chicago.com/chicago-shootings-gun-violence-polic...

I guess they should have applied the "You can always retreat, delegate to a specialist...etc"

You may argue about whether chicago police department is "capable" - they certainly have very strict gun laws which don't seems to be preventing this gun violence. But if they are not capable, "retreating" doesn't seem to be helping these people. Or are they doing it wrong?

ghufran_syed··on Our Tesla Model 3 Hasn't Delivered Big Savings in Maintenance Costs
Hmm, should changing the windshield and sunroof due to damage count as “maintenance costs”?

I think it’s useful to know that the cost of a new windshield looks 4-5x what it would be on a toyota corolla, but I think calling these high “repair costs” would be more accurate

ghufran_syed··on Killing Robots and Just War Theory
It seems like you are arguing that 1) The second amendment is no longer relevant and that therefore there is no legal justification for US citizens to keep firearms, while simultaneously arguing 2) no-one is “coming to take your guns”

Can you see how people in favor of gun rights might not find your second argument convincing, in light of the first?

ghufran_syed··on Thousands of scientists warn climate tipping points ‘imminent’
No, more of an existence proof - the fact that people have been saying similar things since at least the 60’s should make us at least consider the possibility that the reason for the current warnings are similar to the reason for the previous warnings. Sure, maybe all those other warnings were in good faith and happened to be wrong, while the current warnings are also in good faith and might turn out to be correct. But if you can’t even consider the possibility, then we’re in the realm of religion, not science.

Here’s a climate scientist who agrees about climate change, but disagrees about the urgency and nature of the actions justified, hopefully that doesn’t define him as “not in his right mind” -

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bj%C3%B8rn_Lomborg

ghufran_syed··on Ask a bartender a question
they are adults - why does someone else have to protect them from the consequences of their own choices?
ghufran_syed··on Finland provides housing and counseling to the homeless (2020)
Not quite true in California - being "gravely disabled" also justifies involuntary detainment and treatment: "A condition in which a person, as a result of a mental health disorder, is unable to provide for his or her basic personal needs for food, clothing, or shelter."

In reality though, the lack of funding for such people means that only the most severe are treated under this category. What's required is the funding and political will to enforce it, the necessary legal structure is already in place.

https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...

ghufran_syed··on Amazon Is Creating Company Towns Across the United States
"Double the amount of serious injuries" - using a metric based on whether you got time off or a change in duties. So if your company is better about making you see a doctor when you get an injury, and better about honoring the doctor's recommendation regarding light duty or time off, your company's number on this metric would get worse.

I see a lot of illegal workers in the ER who get injured at work but refuse to fill out the workman's comp forms - you can guarantee that their employers have a zero rate for serious injuries using that metric

[Edit - If you're looking to really improve conditions, maybe focus on the workers who don't show up in the official numbers? Reminds me of the old story about the drunk guy looking for his lost keys by the lamppost, not where he dropped them "because the light is better here"]

← PreviousPage 11 of 29Next →