HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

giantg2

23,205 karma · joined October 4, 2019

I'm the programmer equivalent of a Yugo (car)
submissionscomments
giantg2··on Hackers expose the identities of more than 40k DHS employees
I get the concept, but the question then is if it's ethical to release those names when most of DHS has nothing to do with ICE. The age old question of how much collateral damage is acceptable. It seems most of the praise being given casts DHS as being similar Nazis, but doesn’t consider who is actually involved or not.
giantg2··on The Grid, a factory-scale robot in Massachusetts that builds PCBs on demand
"...supply chain you can count on"

Except the components are mostly coming from China anyways, so the same disruptions are potentially in play.

Still, cool to see domestic options.

giantg2··on Ask HN: What are your career plans in the age of AI?
SS will be "saved" as it's too political not to be. But I'm guess is they'll do that by increasing taxes and the money supply, causing the benefits to be worth little.

Also, the limit isn't weird when you consider it is intended to be a single payer system with a cap on the benefit.

giantg2··on Ask HN: What are your career plans in the age of AI?
I have no career plans. I will work my job until I die or am fired. If I'm fired I'll end up working at walmart or something similar, at least until the cost of robotic replacements is low enough for them to layoff most workers. The future is bleak.
giantg2··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
This is the opposite of what your prior comment said. Your prior comment says that exemption requests require approval regardless of the merits.
giantg2··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
Can you provide an example? The undue burden, safety issues, etc tend to strike down most requests that are unusual.
giantg2··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
That might not be reasonable to you, but that's completely different from the reasonable standard under the law.
giantg2··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
Please provide some evidence for your claim. There are plenty of cases out there to show the opposite of what you claim.

https://wp.nyu.edu/compliance_enforcement/2026/01/21/ninth-c...

giantg2··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
We haven't been offloading thinking. We have been offloading the calculation. Someone had to think to implement a system in the past. The system abided by those constraints, or could be checked against them as it was deterministic (vast majority). AI is non-deterministic and presents a shift to where people are using it like a magic 8-ball to think for them, even if the mechanism is probablistic calculation of word patterns.
giantg2··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
This is not true. The accommodation is only possible if it doesn't present undue hardship, safety concerns, etc. Plenty of accommodations can be denied on those grounds.
giantg2··on Kentucky man becomes the first humanist granted religious exemption from AI
Lots of strawmanning going on with comments about where the line gets drawn and talking about driving stick, heating his home, etc.

If you read the article, you will see that the concern is with his direct actions concerning ethics and moral, especially with interactions with others (as an admin).

There is plenty to unpack with this as it is a new concept. I'm hoping we can have a real discussion about this. For example, will this religious exemption become moot if productivity is sufficiently higher with AI giving employers an easy out? If that does happen, do we think we'll see adverse effects such as baked in biases in a hidden process?

One thing I am concerned with with AI is that everything will follow Google and Meta when it comes to things like appeals and fair treatment. There area ton of stories about people getting banned/deleted with no recourse and no insight into why. I can see this same sort of totalitarian activity spreading to other aspects of life, like finance, medical billing, etc.

giantg2··on US Government is hiding a secret court ruling about how it spies on Americans
I'm surprised so many people miss this dynamic on so many topics. It's politics 101 to flip flop based on who gets credit, what the news cycle is pushing at that moment, which specific right/topic it applies to etc and then blame the opponent for the same action they themselves took or will take at another point in time. All the while the constituents argue about how their representative or party is somehow superior.
giantg2··on Viral Polls Are Not Representative Polls
Isn't this the main concept of the Cambridge Analytica story - targeting people in the swing areas, and even based on personal information?

We're already here and I think personal informantion, behaviors, etc collected from social media and corporations would be the bigger threat than the polling itself.

giantg2··on Viral Polls Are Not Representative Polls
They don't really check anything, do they? When there is a discrepancy between official results and polling, the general response was that the polling missed something, not that the official results were wrong.
giantg2··on Virtual and Real World Combine at LAN Party (1998)
It doesn't seem like there are as many. Maybe it depends on location. Most of the ones I would go to were small, friends of friends type of things. I don't hear about anyone doing that sort of thing anymore. I'm sure most of the large organized ones are still around.
giantg2··on Virtual and Real World Combine at LAN Party (1998)
'As critics tout dark visions of computers driving people apart, these hard-core gamers prove that communities--even virtual ones--need physical interaction in order to flourish. As the slogan of the Bay Area Network Gaming Group proclaims, “A scream should be heard, not typed.”

“The best game experience is not on the Net, and I think people are starting to realize that,” said Cliff Bleszinski, a lead game producer with Epic MegaGames. “You can’t look over at the person you just beat. You can’t go out to get a beer afterward. You rarely get to actually talk to the people you’re playing against. You may as well be playing against the machine.” '

The best part of this article. LAN parties seem almost extinct with the convenience of online gaming today. That's both a good and bad thing. I remember lugging a CRT TV and Xbox or a laptop to small parties. Usually with a case of mountain dew in tow. I miss the joy and adventure of playing in person. But I also enjoy connecting with people who have moved away in the comfort of my home. It makes me sad that the current and future generation won't get to experience this.

giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
It seems you have already made up your mind. Good luck in life.
giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
Might want to edit that wiki article then
giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
"You can go ahead and do the whole "all taxation is theft" song and dance if you want."

Nice strawman. Where did I say that?

The link you sent also states that it's alloidal title only to distinguish it from feudal title. The mechanisms are essentially the same - you must pay a sum to keep the land. There's still things like eminent domain and eschet. Don't forget that tenurial rights are roughly equivalent to zoning laws in concept. Similar mechanisms are there, but they're just named differently.

giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
"No, people should own property that they created or that someone else created and willingly sold to them. Land values are by definition neither of those things."

Seems irrelevant as real property needs land to exist on and is just a vehicle for use. In the vast majority of the cases, the property is sold with the land and is preserved, meaning the land value is mostly inconsequential when already built on except in a small number of cases.

"Physical coercion is much more common to enforce evictions than nonpayment of taxes."

We were talking about seizing property. Renters do not own the property, the landlord does. That's an important distinction when talking about seizing property.

"2) the surroundings of that land (nearby amenities, infrastructure, employers, etc)"

Based on what people made it, just like I said.

"They are not entitled to upside they did not produce."

We live in a world with other people. Their tax dollars produced that infrastructure. They maintained their property. It's so odd to think that someone's else did your work for you, as if you never maintained property or paid taxes.

giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
"You don't need to impute anything. There are ways to get the valuation of land without imputing."

It's based on market value now. The LVT schemes usually talk about deriving it from the potential usage. This specific LVT talks about differentiating between "good" and "bad" uses even further. So it does seems to be imputing value based on potential usage.

"The land value tax is the same no matter what you do with the land. Land value taxes don't care what you use the land for."

Their whole point is to force higher density usage because the tax is high.

giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
That's typically where needs-based determinations come in - direct the resources to those who qualify based on needs instead of universally.
giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
Even in the US the government owns the land. You just have title of deed. Failure to pay your fealty (property tax) results in seizure.
giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
That's only true for this one implementation. But that gets messy when you have home buessiness that may involve some rent-seeking aspect. This is especially true once businesses figure out you can home office people instead of paying the land tax.
giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
Is LVT funding UBI or reverse mortgages? Seems like supporters think it can fund anything and everything.

"Near-zero regulatory complexity, paperwork, enforcement burden, or economic distortions."

This isnt true in the least. Land value calculations would be require all sorts of regulations and appeal processes to set true land value and prevent gaming the system. Just want until private equity figures out they can drive up property values in a residential area so they can use the tax on existing properties to force the owners to sell to them.

giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
The only interest people will have in politics would be be around their UBI and other benefits. The old saying of once they know they hold the keys to the treasury they vote to direct it to themselves thing.
giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
Yet people have to vote for the policies, and it's highly unlikely they would vote for tax policies that so forcefully reduce freedom.
giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
This makes no sense at all unless you believe that nobody should own property. The government is much more likely to be the one using threat of force to take your property for lack of tax payment than anyone else is for any other reason.

The value of land is only what people make of it. It's mostly hypothetical as to what you could use it for. The driving factor in land "value" is location, which is an artificial factor created by humans. That same empty lot in a city that everyone complains about needing to have a land value tax assessed against it is pennies on the dollar our in the county. Perhaps we should look at efficient use of resources and population distribution policies rather than focusing on the symptoms rather than the problem.

giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
Holding raw land doesn't become a rent-seeking activity until it is sold. The owner could be waiting to accuse capital for development, waiting to purchase an ajoining property to expand, etc. A transfer tax fits this better than a land value tax.
giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
Even though this paper has scarcity in the title, it doesn't seem to investigate how UBI affects scarcity of resources that are not labor. Natural resources and production volume are essentially finite when looking at a current timeframe. A UBI will increase prices as demand for finite resources stays the same or increases and the money supply to consumers increases.

Wasn't there another post a week ago talking about how UBI won't save us from automation? I was much more inclined to believe that one.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →