HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

giantg2

23,205 karma · joined October 4, 2019

I'm the programmer equivalent of a Yugo (car)
submissionscomments
giantg2··on France needs to read my paper
Most states tax land at the time of sale and annually. It's just that the millage is low for raw land.

Taxing something based on hypothetical value is an extremely dangerous proposition. Why not tax people an imputed income tax based on what we thing a person's labor is worth? It makes more sense to tax money when money is actually made.

Land value taxes are fundamentally opposed to freedom and liberty by implicitly forcing an owner to do use the land for use that others want based on hypothetical uses.

giantg2··on Woman faces six years in prison over Cash App account she never opened
This doesn't look great. https://www.nhpr.org/nh-news/2026-09-21/nh-newhampshire-supr...

But they do tend to have better speedy trial definitions and such. Although it seems they are rolling back bail reform (which may have been too lenient, but they didn't find a middle solution). And it seems they still have ex parte protection from abuse orders, which are notoriously abused in divorce cases.

giantg2··on Woman charged with computer fraud due to scam CashApp account being in her name
You'd be better off assessing that via analysis of laws and policies. That would show what could be abused and to what degree, even if it's abused by the people in power now. That's really the whole point of the analysis - to create laws and policies with better protections, so we should measure what we're looking to change.
giantg2··on Where Wealth Is Moving in America (2023)
"where you can gain incredible wealth benefitting from the infrastructure and economy of one state"

With internet sales, it seems like the benefit from local infrastructure and economy is increasingly small. Especially when we are talking about CA and NY, known for tech and finance, which are very geographically unlinked. Even physical products tend to be shipped using infrastructure from receiving states.

In general, the incredible wealth is mostly luck.

Taking more on the income (including cap gains) side would be the better solution than wealth or exit taxes. This would also be more impactful on inequality than an exit tax.

giantg2··on A robot I didn't expect to build
"However, we don’t do this because it is much more scalable to drive massive machines over flat, unimpeded land."

It's just that it's cheaper since we're talking about land and other physical constraints. With humanoid robots we're talking about labor. Many processes done by humans are designed to be possible by humans. As soon as you remove the ability constraints of humans, you can design more efficient processes. This is evident is all jobs pre- vs post-mechanization.

For example, do you need lights in a warehouse without people? Do you need maximum shelf height or forklift speeds for safety standards? Do you even need forklifts if the bots are stronger enough; if not, aisles can be narrowed and density increased. Etc.

Even for in-home assistance, you might be better off with multiple smaller bots tailored to different tasks. A bipedal robot designed for cleaning gutters or shoveling snow sounds like a poor design decision.

giantg2··on Where Wealth Is Moving in America (2023)
People vote with their feet. This shouldn't be a negative. Some people don't want to be over taxed and over regulated in places like CA and NY, so they move to states they see as fitting their needs/culture better.

What we really need is a federal law that says states can't entice businesses to move or stay in some place using monetary bribes in the form of company-specific tax cuts. Reducing this manipulation could help tax revenues instead of states competing to be lowest bidder.

giantg2··on A robot I didn't expect to build
Most tasks would me more efficient if not using a drop in replacement for humans. Rethinking the existing paradigms and redesigning the processes to be more efficient with non-humans would be more valuable.
giantg2··on Woman charged with computer fraud due to scam CashApp account being in her name
There's no functional difference in this context - the legal system determines legal issues.
giantg2··on Woman charged with computer fraud due to scam CashApp account being in her name
In theory, if crimes exceed prosecutions, then number of convictions being closest to the number of prosecutions should indicate an effective use of resources. The real problem is that thorough investigations are rare for most crimes and it's just and industrial-scale process to show the elements of an offense were met by a preponderance of the evidence.
giantg2··on Woman faces six years in prison over Cash App account she never opened
The closest thing is probably a mistrial due to a hung jury. That allows a retrial.
giantg2··on Woman charged with computer fraud due to scam CashApp account being in her name
"It’s impossible by design to distinguish between a clearly innocent person and a very suspicious person whose guilt couldn’t quite be proven"

Oh, you mean another innocent person? (Emphais mine)

giantg2··on Woman charged with computer fraud due to scam CashApp account being in her name
"Is it possible US prosecutors give so few shits about justice?"

If you are part of a system and have power in it, you believe the system is good. You believe that everyone else in that system is also good. That's why you have prosecutors and judges just believing the police automatically. Nobody wants to be in a job that ruins innocent people's lives, so everyone must be guilty or the cognitive dissonance will run you out (if the others in power don't first).

giantg2··on Woman charged with computer fraud due to scam CashApp account being in her name
It's good this is seen as big news, but to anyone paying attention this is an everyday occurrence.

All you need to charge someone is to show by a preponderance of the evidence that the elements of the offense were committed. Account being in your name and used in the crime meets that criteria. The problem is that many times a "thorough investigation" was not performed. There's nothing in law requiring a thorough investigation, but it's usually included in department regulations. You can file a complaint, but they won't do anything about it. There is no accountability anywhere in the system. The judges who are supposed to be neutral are severely biased due to the structure of the system and lack of training.

giantg2··on Woman faces six years in prison over Cash App account she never opened
Source?

I think we would need to quantify "better", but there aren't any states that are good.

giantg2··on Woman charged with computer fraud due to scam CashApp account being in her name
"If a legal system in a red state is this dysfunctional, you can't simply hide away in a blue state with better-run systems."

These sorts of abuses or dysfunction are rampant in all states. I can't think of a single state that actually has a good system (properly staffed, no overreach, etc).

giantg2··on Ask HN: Financial Audit of DuckDuckGo?
It seems highly unlikely that the ads from a single search would cover the tokens for the AI summarization of that search.
giantg2··on The No Kings Takedown Is Why You Shouldn't Rent Your Megaphone from Zuck
"Deportations under Obama may have been approximately equal to under Trump. Obama did it without nearly so much violence, though."

Is there good data for that or is it observation bias?

I'm not saying scale is the same. I'm saying that these abuses will continue to happen without accountability. The scale argument is not an excuse, merely a manifestation of cognitive dissonance.

Plenty of lies and corruption on any president if you care to look. https://lists.grabien.com/list/complete-guide-scandals-obama...

giantg2··on The No Kings Takedown Is Why You Shouldn't Rent Your Megaphone from Zuck
Yes, but have any of those ideas come out of the No Kings or actively promoted by the movement?
giantg2··on Sixteen years after Deepwater Horizon, deep sea life shows few signs of recovery
"Perhaps the costs of an accident should be increased to the point that it makes sense to have the oversight."

Not the cost of an accident, but the cost of preventing them. The cost to consumers is something people wouldn't tolerate.

giantg2··on The No Kings Takedown Is Why You Shouldn't Rent Your Megaphone from Zuck
"No kings is a reminder that he and all other elected officials are not kings."

It would be great if the "other elected officials" part turns out to be true, but my in my experience I don't see that happening. Have there been any policy proposals out of No Kings that would create better oversight and accountability?

giantg2··on The No Kings Takedown Is Why You Shouldn't Rent Your Megaphone from Zuck
Most political movements (and arguments) in the US use hyperbole. No Kings is hyperbolic to show disapproval of Trump's actions. This single-sided bias on a conceptual is also a hall mark of most political movements in the US. It's fine if someone takes a similar action that I see as good, but it's bad if I think it's bad.

Before I get hated out of existence, please note that I don't like either party or political tactics in general because they've devolved into politically commercialized populism without any empathy or critical thought. Just as an example, deportations under Trump are roughly on trend with Obama, Trump targeting activities are similar to Obama targeting conservative groups with the IRS, Obama lied in the SoTU about the gender wage gap, Obama was hard on journalists (highest prosecutions?) Like Trump has been, and Obama ignored court orders such as issuing immigration permits in violations of a order similar to Trump ignoring orders. I could sit here and hope that any of these abuses results in better oversight, but that would be naive based on the history.

Edit: if you're going to disagree, at least contribute to the discussion.

giantg2··on The No Kings Takedown Is Why You Shouldn't Rent Your Megaphone from Zuck
"There is absolutely no good reason why the different platforms should disallow communication with each other."

Maybe aside from the increased attack surface and trust issues...

giantg2··on Patch the Planet: global response coordination as agents uncover vulnerabilities
Why limit only to the US?
giantg2··on The Other Epidemic: Trying to get off benzodiazepines
Even if he's carted around as a show pony that's a lot more than I will be doing at 80. The real take away is that we need an upper age cap for holding federal office - 61 or younger to run/appointment and mandatory retirement at 70. We could try to say that office holders shouldn't have an age limit but be subjected to mental fitness tests, but those will end up being gamed or the results won't be released properly for national security reasons.
giantg2··on Sixteen Years After Deepwater Horizon, Deep Sea Life Shows Few Signs of Recovery
Wow, lots of people disagreeing with the comment without stating why. Pretty meta when you consider the cognitive dissonance aspect haha.
giantg2··on Ousted Savannah police officer gave ICE agent husband access to Flock system
So one district judge vs a myriad of circuit and Supreme Court judges. Typically ehen you have a lower level judge making a decision that goes against higher level decisions it's considered an error.
giantg2··on Ousted Savannah police officer gave ICE agent husband access to Flock system
Not even a group, but just as an individual I was able to change a law enforcement practice. A local police force was posting misinformation about a new law that was going into effect and stated they planned to charge people with an M3 vs what the law says was a summary offense. I contacted the county DA and the local police pulled the misinformation and hopefully avoided incorrectly (maliciously) charging people.
giantg2··on Sixteen years after Deepwater Horizon, deep sea life shows few signs of recovery
Is it a solution if the masses refuse to trade cheap convenience for more expensive and burdensome products/processes? Theoretically yes, but realistically no.
giantg2··on Sixteen years after Deepwater Horizon, deep sea life shows few signs of recovery
Scale matters. When you have the scale that we do, you will have accidents because of the sheer number and the lack of oversight due to cost pressures. These accidents aren't going anywhere. They have been around since industrial times and will continue to be so. Please tell me how you would ensure 0 accidents - the world would be interested to know since it hasn't been discovered yet. Now please explain who's position is baseless.
giantg2··on SimCity, but with Permits
"But yay, democracy? We can do anything as long as no one is subjectivly harmed."

Seems more like a flaw of high density than democracy if you look at democracy in low density areas and citizen happiness in other types of government in high density areas.

← PreviousPage 4 of 34Next →