HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gitrog

395 karma · joined April 15, 2019

submissionscomments
gitrog··on Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and climate damages in US
If he did it on purpose, he's a supervillain, if he did it due to negligence, he's a hypocrite. No need to split hairs.
gitrog··on Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and climate damages in US
Pray tell, which part is it that you find fault with?
gitrog··on Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and climate damages in US
You could say that to GP who just dismissed a published study without actually taking on any of the claims made therein.
gitrog··on Every $1 of BTC value responsible for $0.49 in health and climate damages in US
Is this bait?

Of course it's just about profit... the point is that he should be aware of its environmental impact and the hypocrisy of his investment therein.

gitrog··on Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more reasons than ecological
How is it the fault of an ideology that decentralised solutions are required? Is there something inherent in Socialist ideology that you can point me to?
gitrog··on Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more reasons than ecological
No I took you to mean "country" as I'm also not American, I just don't understand how you expect governments to foresee and restrict every possible new technology that affects energy consumption to such a large degree.

I also think that these kind of insights are what would be needed for states to act on technologies that pose these threats, though I believe if regulation is applied there will be a lot, and I mean a lot, of backlash.

gitrog··on Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more reasons than ecological
There is a subtheme about crypto, in that he kind of argues it isn't really useful enough as a financial instrument to warrant the ecological cost (my words, not his).

That's an opinion - one I tend to share - so feel free to disagree.

gitrog··on Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more reasons than ecological
Why is that a failure of the state? Which state?
gitrog··on Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more reasons than ecological
The article has a strong focus on the environmental impact, but a subtheme exists questioning the real value in cryptocurrencies at all.

The author addresses the existence of Po[X]:

""" I’m sure you’re seeing the problem here- there is not a schema that doesn’t reward those who already are already wealthy, who are already bought in, who already have excess capital or access to outsized computational power. Almost universally they grant power to the already powerful.

This is also a climate issue. """

gitrog··on Crypto and NFTs are a absolute disaster for so many more reasons than ecological
No they certainly need solving, that is, if we are able to justify them causing any environmental impact at all.

If can start on the agreement that we need to curb our environmental impact, then any new technology we embrace surely needs to be very useful to as many people as possible in order to justify any significant affect on the environment.

gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
> I don't believe that games are inherently immoral otherwise I wouldn't make them.

Neither do I, maybe you read my reply incorrectly. I said, feel free to extrapolate the criticism to all game devs who explicitly try to make the games addictive and hook people with micro-transactions. So your whole line of reasoning there kind of falls flat.

gitrog··on Beyond Meat signs global supply deals with McDonald’s, KFC and Pizza Hut
I understand, believe me, I do, I guess I just brought it up as a warning not to do what every new vegetarian (including myself) has done:

Use moral arguments to try to convince people that being a vegetarian is a more ethical choice.

I think the sentiment applies to vegans as well, even if the impact isn't as direct. If everyone started consuming non-meat/non-dairy products, the socio-economical and agricultural effects of things like soy, almonds, etc will be egregious as well.

We need to look at non-cruel and sustainable sources of food, but at the industrial level, not at the individual.

gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
I'll skip right over the conversation about how the world is run. I read some of the article you sent (it's quite long), and let's just say that so far I'm not convinced.

> I don't believe mobile games are any worse than other types of games when it comes to addiction. Just because mobile game addiction focuses on certain traits, games that are addictive but focus on other traits are not any better. To assign a negative moral character to mobile games alone is a mistake that people currently make that I disagree with.

If your biggest issue with the statement is that it unfairly focuses on mobile game devs, feel free to extrapolate the sentiment to all game devs who do this, I think most people do this extrapolation.

I re-read the rest of your responses to this thread, seems like your only issue is with how appropriate a joke is in technical documentation.

I am interested, given your world view, to know why you think a tutorial on encrypting saved game states isn't also inappropriate? In fact, isn't the technical documentation inappropriate in its entirety? Why should I be told how to use the game engine? Just because these "elitist" developers built the engine, doesn't mean they can tell me how I should use it?

gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
I'm aware Godot doesn't actually use ECS, it doesn't make your joke any more coherent though.

If you want to go down the route that everything is subjective, we're not going to be very productive here. The mention of "capitalist oligarchy" is hyperbole, of course, though I don't know how you want to argue that the world isn't mostly run by capitalist forces. Again, if this is something you want to question I'm not sure we're going to get anywhere.

The factoid in the piece is that a lot of mobile games are built with the intent of being addictive and getting people to spend a bunch of money on micro transactions. Is this another thing that doesn't fit in your view of reality?

Most importantly though, if they added your joke instead I still wouldn't rally to have them take it down. I'd just think it's awkward and embarrasing.

gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
Sorry, one can read "just that" in two ways there, "it at all" or "only".

To carry on with your intended meaning, what is the problem if the technical documentation is more than just technical documentation? We're talking about a paragraph here, maybe 0.1% of the documentation. Are you making a claim that at some percentage of non-technical content the documentation becomes illegitimate?

I'm honestly just trying to understand what you're getting at.

gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
Not sure why you're being down-voted, you're spot on. Hope one of the down voters will come and explain.
gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
That is such a huge stretch, wow.
gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
The weirdest thing for me here, is that most of the noise against the piece seems to have been made on twitter by people who probably identify as "leftists", solely because it punches down on some demographic. I'm still trying to ascertain which demographic that is, it's really not clear.
gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
No, it doesn't "stop being that". You're going to have to provide some sort of justification for that statement.
gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
And he's not arguing whether the joke is funny, he's saying the joke is relevant.

The content of your joke isn't as relevant (which also makes it less funny). You used an anti-science sentiment and threw in ECS to try to make it more suitable, but it isn't analogous with the original statement at all.

How exactly do you think a cynical take on something that occurs widely in the industry is equivalent to conspiracy theory level science denialism?

gitrog··on Godot maintainer removes controversial satirical piece from documentation
Why are you making normative claims about technical documentation? That seems to me more preposterous than anything written in the mentioned piece.
gitrog··on Beyond Meat signs global supply deals with McDonald’s, KFC and Pizza Hut
I'm not trying to criticise you here at all, but since you don't eat meat mainly to reduce animal suffering, why are you okay with dairy? The dairy industry arguably abuses and mistreats animals far worse than the meat industry.

Full disclosure: Vegetarian for 10 years, eat fish occasionally and have recently been trying to cut out dairy (but it's tough).

gitrog··on Beyond Meat signs global supply deals with McDonald’s, KFC and Pizza Hut
The dairy industry is arguably worse with regard to animal abuse and mistreatment than the meat industry.
gitrog··on Shopify says remove Stripe billing or get booted from their app store
I've been really enjoying SpreeCommerce (based on Rails). You can get away with very little coding if you're happy with the current feature set (which really covers all the basics and then some) and your Payment Gateway of choice is supported by them already or within the ActiveMerchant Payment Gateway options. And then writing your own Payment Gateway integration (like for offsite payments) is really easy too.
gitrog··on The Database Inside Your Codebase
Although I understand what we're trying to achieve here is easier code navigation and manipulation on a much broader scale with preferably a single tool, I couldn't shake the feeling that some of the examples you gave have existing solutions.

The `run_config` one stood out the most. Isn't it perfectly feasible to have a `jobs` and a related `run_configs` table, instead of them only being objects? You could even put them in a separate database, much like one does with the auditing tables in a Rails application, or with reporting tables that need to be accessible by the likes of PowerBI. That separate database could have it's own light-weight GUI, something that just plugs your data structure into the interface, like Django's admin back-end.

gitrog··on Robinhood, in Need of Cash, Raises $1B from Its Investors
They forced sale on stocks at an earlier (lower) price. Some people were literally forced to make a loss.
gitrog··on A minimalistic site to vent and see others doing the same in realtime
Sorry, would you mind explaining what this will do?
gitrog··on Select a muscle and it provides the exercises to workout the selected muscle
Decline push-ups also work on your forearms.
gitrog··on Select a muscle and it provides the exercises to workout the selected muscle
On another note: technically, for forearms you'd want to have your hands facing away from you when doing a chin-up. Hands facing towards you is better for biceps.
gitrog··on Parler App delisted from Google Play; Apple threatening same within 24h
I hope this is sarcasm, but I'm really not sure.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →