HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gjmulhol

281 karma · joined May 19, 2013

NC State, Cambridge, Stanford grad. Materials Scientist, Computer Engineer. Founder, CEO of Citrine Informatics (citrine.io). There is nothing better in this world that working daily with smart, motivated, honest people, and I am lucky that I get to do that on a daily basis. @gregmulholland on Twitter.
submissionscomments
gjmulhol··on Ditching Scrum for Kanban - The best decision we’ve made as a team
I love this. We briefly flirted with scrum but now just have a much more Kanban-like system now, too. The only issue I foresee long term is that the sprint mentality of Scrum might recharge people and get them to, well, sprint, at product goals. Kanban, because it is never ending, might start to feel like a slog. There is never a way to have that feeling of "wow, we crushed it and cleared out our list. We are awesome." The list just extends forever. We have put measures in to help with this: primarily just having our engineers say at the beginning of the week what they hope/plan to get done this week (or two). Sometimes that is just noting subtasks in pursuit of a larger feature, but at least it borrows some of what is a very powerful part of Scrum: the social commitment that comes from standing up and saying "this is what I will finish this sprint."
gjmulhol··on NASA Moves Closer to Building a 3-D Printed Rocket Engine
One cool part about this is that once they prove that current engine designs can be replicated using additive manufacturing, then totally new engine designs, different from anything possible with traditional manufacturing techniques, can be developed. It would likely mean higher thrust per unit fuel and generally more efficient systems.
gjmulhol··on Hard Truths about Equity
Rule of thumb from someone who has been through it (not me):

Employees 1-20: "never have to work again money" 20-200 (or so): "buy some nice stuff, live a great life, still have to work" >200: nice payday, buy a house, car, something, get back to work

And this is at a, now public, company where the founder had and has tons of control so got good terms for employees.

gjmulhol··on Hard Truths about Equity
Number 1 rule of working at a startup: really trust the founders and everyone you work with. Look out for yourself, but at the end of the day, if you are working with someone scummy, they can change the rules at basically any time. So work with people committed to transparency and honest dealing.

Also, while it is nice to think of your particular startup succeeding, it probably won't. And even if it "does" it will likely not be worth >$1b.

One of my proudest moments was hearing from one of my early employees that even if the company tanked tomorrow that she would not regret it for a moment. I hope that for every person I work with, because while I cannot guarantee that the world won't collapse or something unforeseen to happen, I can work really hard to make sure that as we grow and succeed, our culture is one of making sure that everyone is learning and growing and going to excel in their careers and lives no matter what happens to this company. Side note: I am also committed to making sure that people here are compensated well when we succeed, if for some reason our initial compensation structure, which I think has been generous, has holes.

gjmulhol··on Q-Carbon, a substance harder than diamond
Here they are talking about surface quenching, where the amorphous carbon thin film is heated then rapidly cooled on the surface. Instead of forming smaller precipitates, like in an alloy, it just forms very small crystals that happen to be extremely hard. They are embedded in amorphous material. The key phrase that capture this is: "This Q-carbon has amorphous structure with some embedded nanocrystalline diamonds the number density of which is determined by the nucleation time available for growth." Hopefully this clears things up somewhat.

Pure carbon is actually metallic at sufficiently high temperatures, as reported in this paper and in this citation: [1].

1. F. P. Bundy , W. A. Bassett , M. S. Weathers , R. J. Hemley , H. U. Mao , and A. F. Goncharov , Carbon 34, 141 (1996).http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0008-6223(96)00170-4

gjmulhol··on Q-Carbon, a substance harder than diamond
The carbon is amorphous before it is heated, then it forms various crystalline structures it appears (you can see that in the Raman, EELS, and other measurements, though the quick way to identify that is all the discussion of various crystalline planes).

EDIT for clarity: *forms various crystal structures that are embedded in the amorphous layer.

gjmulhol··on Q-Carbon, a substance harder than diamond
In case you want to see the original paper: http://scitation.aip.org/content/aip/journal/jap/118/21/10.1...
gjmulhol··on Q-Carbon, a substance harder than diamond
There won't be an independent take until someone can try to reproduce the results which, given how simple the experimental setup seems to be, might not take long but hasn't happened yet. I have read the paper, though, and it appears to be a fairly complete study with good detail. It is a slightly surprising result, but I would not characterize it as obviously challenging the laws of physics or anything, it is just a manifestation of structural changes on a nano-scale that yields pretty nice properties.

I also happen to know Jay Narayan's previous work (and have debated him on a few occasions). I would say as a scientist, he is well respected and his results have been verified over a long career, so there is more than likely something here—even if it is more than meets the eye.

gjmulhol··on Ask HN: How to stay fit?
Set a performance goal. Don't focus on weight loss, focus on finishing a half marathon, swimming a mile, or something else you might like to do. Then set up a training plan 3-5 days a week and keep a calendar where you get to cross off every day where you follow through (off days are freebies). Don't Break the Chain: https://www.writersstore.com/dont-break-the-chain-jerry-sein...
gjmulhol··on Data Saved in Quartz Glass Might Last 300M Years
You are indeed correct. This article uses quartz and quartz glass interchangeably, so I assumed the author was making the sapphire/"sapphire glass" error (because sapphire is never a glass) but upon checking out the original article, you are right, they are working on fused silica.
gjmulhol··on Data Saved in Quartz Glass Might Last 300M Years
Quartz is not glass. Quartz is a crystal.
gjmulhol··on Scientists develop 'unbreakable' glass almost as tough as steel
Alumina is Al2O3 generally, and usually it is polycrystalline. Sapphire is specifically Al2O3 in a certain (very hard) crystal structure.
gjmulhol··on The Article on Diversity in Tech That Forbes Took Down
Hard work is important, but the implication here that pure meritocracy created highly homogenous companies is asinine. I am one of the privileged few that gets to live in this magical place, be told great all of us are, and how we worked hard to get here. We all are great, and many of us did work hard. But that does not mean that being great and working hard are enough. When I look around me, I see almost exclusively people that look like me. This should not be the case.
gjmulhol··on How Software Will Change Venture Capital
I will caveat this and say that I am speaking from an entrepreneur's perspective, and OP obviously has more experience investing than I do, but I am skeptical of taking this line of thinking too far.

There is a problem with this model—and I am not saying it won't work—that VC firms get the best deals by having high deal flow and have a reputation for working supporting entrepreneurs (or in some cases firing the CEO and making the company extremely successful). If you treat the VC market like the stock market, with quant trading firms, you will: (1) miss deals because oftentimes once a company has any visibility it is too late to get in their investment pipeline, (2) make bad decisions because it is hard to extrapolate from very little data.

To your point about no management fees, unless you are independently wealthy, how do you cover costs? I ask not as a rhetorical device, because it is not possible to propose such a thing without a plan, I am just interested to know how you think about it.

gjmulhol··on Apple and Samsung caused this $104B company to cut 15% of its workforce
This title is misleading and clickbaity. Takeaway: Both Samsung are choosing to bring chip design in house as a differentiator, Qualcomm is getting its margins crunched because both Apple and Samsung are only buying low cost modems from them.

It is not Apple and Samsung that caused this, it was Qualcomm's inability to stay ahead of their own customers in chip development. If Qualcomm had the best chips, Apple and Samsung would not bring chip design in house.

gjmulhol··on Ask HN: Companies That Use Take Home Projects for Interviews?
After an initial screen, we do a paid project for hires. 2-4 weeks (or longer or shorter as appropriate for us and the candidate) at a fair rate that we all agree on -- usually equal to or at a slight premium to what the FT salary of that person would be. Our goal is to get something somewhat useful out of it, and more importantly for our engineering team to see what it is like to work with the candidate, what kind of questions the candidate asks, and to have the candidate demonstrate that s/he can deliver a fully formed package. It has been a great screening mechanism. It is slow, but so far it has been worth it.
gjmulhol··on Google: Security questions aren't secure
Totally agree. Also, if someone asked me "What street did you grow up on?" or "What was your first pet's name?" I would probably just answer it. Neither of those are terribly threatening on the face of it.
gjmulhol··on Ask HN: How much equity should I ask for?
There is an argument to be made that it is better for a company to make a fair offer and not negotiate. There have been long patterns in many industries that people who negotiate harder get better results, leading to large wage gaps (particularly between genders). A fair, open, honest, and frank discussion about the position of the company is best, but I think a hard negotiation creates a norm that can be toxic.
gjmulhol··on ​How Do Psychics Survive in New York City?
They way they survive anywhere...by seeing the future.
gjmulhol··on In Defense of the Midwest
Not arguing that it is cheap, just saying that the generalization that everywhere near the coast is fast moving is incorrect. Cheaper options include Wilmington, NC, Raleigh, NC, and Asheville, NC -- I skew NC because I lived there for several years and loved it (and I am now based in the Bay Area).
gjmulhol··on Always Get/Give Interview Feedback, It Matters
Could not agree more. At my company, we have rejected people only to have them become huge advocates for us and send us even more good people. We usually look for a special mix of talents (some balance of CS + chemistry/materials), and we always look for a great cultural fit, and sometimes that means we turn down pretty great people who totally get why the fit isn't right. This is painful because we have had a couple open positions and rejected people that would might have done a fine/decent job in the short term, but because we are small (5 people), we are looking for the right people to grow our company with us.

I truly believe that the way a company treats those who don't make it through the process is a stronger indication of their culture and their long term treatment of people than how they treat their employees today.

gjmulhol··on In Defense of the Midwest
I guess I find it a bit off-putting that a blog post trying to dispel stereotypes about a geographic region stoops to saying things like "On both coasts, the pace of life is really, really high: you just go, go, go and work constantly." This might be the norm in New York and Silicon Valley, but the south isn't this way, and I have been to towns as far east as MA that have laid back cultures — visit the town of Wellesley, MA if you want to see that. I am not disagreeing that there are great things about living anywhere, but trying to overturn stereotyping by stereotyping doesn't ring very true to me.
gjmulhol··on A Brief History of Databases (2014)
The key thing to remember is that MongoDB is web scale. MySQL is not web scale.
gjmulhol··on Ask HN: How does it normally go when one Founder invests the initial money?
My company did this. I fronted most of the money as a loan to the company (in total I want to say it was <$10k) and the company paid the loan back interest free when we had the money in the bank. I was okay with it, and my 2 cofounders put in what they could (also as a loan). Haven't looked back. Never caused an issue.
gjmulhol··on At Harvard, Wharton, Columbia, MBA startup fever takes hold
If current investors weren't satisfied with current income, they would sell. Facebook's margins are excellent, and while I will agree their P/E ratio is high, Google's is quite near that of GE (which should have a much lower multiple considering their return on assets is MUCH lower). I'm sure it will happen eventually, but tech companies are making money right now, and they aren't built on broken economics like the dot com bust in 99.

I guess while I agree there is a bubble in startup valuations, I do not think Google, FB, and friends are at huge risk of going bankrupt or losing a substantial portion of their enterprise values.

gjmulhol··on At Harvard, Wharton, Columbia, MBA startup fever takes hold
So how does this market crash? This is something I have struggled with for some time. Markets have typically crashed because public investors buy at very high prices and then the market loses faith that the future cash flows of the business will pan out. But IPOs aren't happening like they were. Facebook buying Instagram for $! billion is crazy, but Facebook continues to grow and generate revenue (because of or in spite of Instagram) to exceed investor expectations. If these acquiring companies continue to grow and succeed, then how does the bubble collapse? We have no idea whether Nest can justify the $3.2 billion Google paid for it, we just know that Google continues to beat estimates and the Nest guys continue to afford nice cars.

I also do take exception to the fact that MBAs are all vultures. I am trained as a computer Engineer, practiced as a materials scientist, and got an MBA. Now I am one of those exact vultures you speak of with a startup of my own that I, by the way, believe is going to contribute meaningfully to society.

gjmulhol··on Ask HN: How do you discover new music?
Maybe this is terribly unindy, but I actually really value All Songs Considered on NPR. They have wide coverage, and I usually find a least a track or two each week that exposes me to an excellent new album that I would not have found otherwise.

I also share a Spotify playlist with a friend.

gjmulhol··on OS X Yosemite
Link is working now. Download away.
gjmulhol··on A startup who just presented in TC Disrupt Battlefield refuses to pay for design
This is why, despite all the flak that MBAs/managers/product managers take around here, you need to have people who can and will take the time communicate clearly, set expectations, and iterate on a result.
gjmulhol··on Ask HN: When will we say “We used to have to charge phones with a wire??”
Hopefully between now and then (or whenever it happens) we find a way to wirelessly charge things that does not waste 90% of the transmitted power. Maybe some variant of this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magne_Charge. Even a 10% loss is bad, though, and a total waste of power. Every watt counts.
← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →