HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

goatinaboat

2,889 karma · joined May 23, 2019

Welsh and proud 󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿
submissionscomments
goatinaboat··on Have I Been Facebooked?
Sure, but if the cost of paying the fines for that is less than the expected loss of revenue

GDPR allows for fines of up to 4% of global revenue. Unfortunately the agencies that are supposed to enforce it are too feeble to do so.

goatinaboat··on Netflix Made Record Profits in 2020, Paid a Tax Rate of Less Than 1 Percent
You just reinvented VAT.

VAT is passed “through” a company, I mean for this to be charged to the company on what is normally considered income. Essentially, since corporations are supposedly people, they can pay income tax like people.

goatinaboat··on Amazon illegally fired activist workers, Labor Board finds
Unions not having an abundance of good will is a pretty sad excuse for bad policy

Thatcher was voted in for one reason: that taxpaying voters had just experienced the Winter Of Discontent and wanted something doing about it once and for all. Whether that's good or bad is a matter of perspective but that's the context in which it happened.

goatinaboat··on Uber ordered to pay $1.1M to blind woman refused rides
I think you are giving service providers way too much leeway.

The problem is that Uber is getting work from the driver in order to meet Uber's obligations but without compensating the driver. The extra work required to e.g. clean the interior of the car after a service dog has been transported should be paid by Uber to the driver.

goatinaboat··on The Economics of Falling Populations
Resources is something we invent and use not something we deplete.

Rainforests are marine biomass and ozone and ice caps are things we invent and not deplete?

goatinaboat··on Amazon illegally fired activist workers, Labor Board finds
Again, you're buying into nonsense anti-union propaganda.

I'm not buying into anything. I see Germany with strong unions and a strong industrial sector and I want that here. Just there is something in the British union movement that makes it destructive instead.

goatinaboat··on Netflix Made Record Profits in 2020, Paid a Tax Rate of Less Than 1 Percent
Like, there's definitely questions to be had about international accounting, but some of the complexity is because national subsidiaries rarely operate in isolation, and valuing much of what they get from their parent organisation is exceptionally hard.

The very, very easy solution is for every corporate entity to be taxed on revenue in each jurisdiction. E.g. if I am in the UK and I spend £4 on a coffee in Starbucks then their legal entity in the UK now owes the taxman £0.40 (for example). How they pay their operating costs and internally transfer the remainder of £3.60 to their parent company is up to them.

goatinaboat··on Amazon illegally fired activist workers, Labor Board finds
But the Thatcher government made a point of starting the closures at the worst possible time, "effective immediately", and then made a point of pointedly ignoring the economic collapse of entire towns and districts whose lifeblood had been the coal mines.

That is true, but the context at the time was the Winter Of Discontent. The unions had squandered all the goodwill the voters might otherwise have had.

goatinaboat··on Amazon illegally fired activist workers, Labor Board finds
you seem to think that the mines would have lasted longer had unions not been against shutting mines?

At the time, the average ton of coal was costing double to extract than it was worth. Closing the loss making mines was inevitable but the viable mines could have remained open, and would have as there was still the demand for coal.

The Germans do this right, their unions want their workers to have fair share of the rewards and understand that the company must be profitable in the first place for that to happen. British union leaders simply play workers against management for their own gain, then leave both workers and management worse off, but workers get the worst of it.

goatinaboat··on Amazon illegally fired activist workers, Labor Board finds
I'm hard-pressed to think of any example where a unionized labor force killed a viable industry (or even a single company).

Look up the British car industry, specifically the antics of "Red Robbo" at British Leyland. Carmaking is a viable industry in the UK and is doing well now that it is all foreign-owned with minimal union interference. There would probably still be coal mining in the UK if it were not for the NUM, we import coal now.

Then again this is specific to Britain, German unions are completely different, and I would be pro-union if ours were like the Germans.

goatinaboat··on What was Marx right about?
The stratified model of classes, however, is absurd. I work as a developer, with some developers under me, with some stock in the company I work at. Am I labor, managerial, or capital class?

If you have to ask then you are, like me, middle class. The working class and the upper class know quite clearly what class they are in and what class others are. In Marxist terminology you would be one of the petit-bourgeoisie, so you do actually fit into his model.

I would recommend reading some Marx, don't worry, you won't turn Communist, just to understand a) where some of these ideas originally come from and b) how what passes for Marxism these days differs and how few self-proclaimed Marxists have ever read it themselves

goatinaboat··on What was Marx right about?
Marx was right about the way that a population stratifies into classes being a useful lens to study history through. His conclusion that communism/socialism was both inevitable and desirable has been thoroughly disproven of course, but that doesn't mean that you can't use class conflict to understand things that happen. Brexit for example didn't fit neatly into a left-vs-right model but it does fit into working-class-vs-bourgeoisie.
goatinaboat··on The Economics of Falling Populations
It only require one person to come up with something that transforms society completely

I hear this a lot, in the context of, we must keep growing the global population on the off chance that someone may be born who comes up with a way to live on an over-populated, polluted, resource-depleted planet. It's nonsense.

goatinaboat··on String theorist Michio Kaku: 'Reaching out to aliens is a terrible idea'
I’m with Barry Kripke when it comes to string theory
goatinaboat··on I can only think that modern front end development has failed
CSS can do layout with grids and flexboxes just fine

I never bothered to learn CSS is why. Bootstrap looks good and consistent with what users expect and requires almost zero effort to use.

goatinaboat··on Tesla owners asking what happens if 'full self driving' isn't real
a classic example of smart person in some domains believing they are smart in all domains

That describes every user on this website...

goatinaboat··on I can only think that modern front end development has failed
You write some simple HTML, style it with CSS, and write vanilla JS for the parts that need it, and everything feels solid.

Bootstrap + jQuery on the front end, Flask or similar with CherryPy on the backend. SQLite or Postgres if you need it. That will handle 99.9% of websites, it will be cheap and easy to develop and host, and deliver a great experience to the end user.

goatinaboat··on Egypt demands over $1B in damages after Suez Canal blockage
When does it become piracy?

Never. The Egyptian government could simply issue itself a letter of marque. But a country impounding a ship while it is within its sovereign territory over unpaid fees would never be considered piracy anyway.

goatinaboat··on Egypt demands over $1B in damages after Suez Canal blockage
what's the value of the cargo onboard?

According to the article, $3.5Bn.

goatinaboat··on [dead]
A lot of math is based on word problems and has ambiguities from language. E.g. "Alice gives Bob half her apples and Bob gives Alice half his apples". The number of apples each of them has depends on whether the actions were simultaneous or sequential and whether "his apples" refers to the apples Bob just received from Alice.

That's a great example and teaches about race conditions too! But there's still a finite set of correct answers, and without showing working there's no way to teach them. And for all I know, this question might not work in languages other than English and isn't that one of the points of this whole exercise...

goatinaboat··on The Norway Problem
virtually nothing actually uses these characters for these purposes.

Right. Which is why we have all these hilarious escaping and interpolation problems. Any why programmers will never be taken seriously by real engineers. It's like we have cement mixed and ready to go but we decide to go and forage for mud instead and think that makes us cleverer than the cement guys.

goatinaboat··on [dead]
I would be really interested in seeing a concrete example of a maths question at this level that has more than one correct answer. I can conceive one at a slightly more advanced level, say a curve with several equal "minimas" and finding any one of them is a valid answer. Or finding one of several equal shortest paths through a graph. Both of those have real-world applications. But either way there is still a finite set of "correct" answers.

I would not want to drive over a bridge designed by, or in a car designed by, ethnomathematics.

goatinaboat··on Loot boxes linked to problem gambling in new research
With my product hat on, I could see so much to improve in the computer-driven games like slot machines.

Everything about these machines has been painstakingly A/B tested to maximise their intended purpose - there was nothing that you saw that would be considered an improvement by those machines owners.

goatinaboat··on A joyless trudge? No, thanks
It’s a fun read but I concur with other commenters about it being a sarcastic rant about something the author doesn’t enjoy

It's the Guardian. The thought that anyone, anywhere might enjoy something means they want it banned.

goatinaboat··on The Norway Problem
This is one of those great ideas that sadly one needs experience to realize are really bad ideas. Every new generation of programmers has to relearn it.

It's a bad idea because ASCII already includes dedicated characters for field separator, record separator and so on. These could easily be made displayable in a text editor if you wanted just as you can display newlines as ↲. Anyone who invents a format that involves using normal printable characters as delimiters and escaping them when you need them, is, I feel very confident in saying, grotesquely and malevolently incompetent and should be barred from writing software for life. CSV, JSON, XML, YAML, all guilty.

goatinaboat··on On the Decline of Perl – external factors
they love to use stupid terminology like helm with charts and salt with pillars and all this other childish shit

Chef is the worst for this

goatinaboat··on 'Fake' Amazon workers defend company on Twitter
The problem is previous generations who don't really understand this.

No, this isn’t the reason, you’re missing some crucial context about the early to mid 90s Internet - most people were using institutional accounts. It was very clear that someone with a whatever.ac.uk or .edu or .mil or even most .com that weren’t ISPs were who they said they were, and anons were explicitly anons. Many people even had phone numbers and addresses in their .sig blocks posting on Usenet, or on their homepages. There was a pretty high degree of trust, it was comparatively civilised!

The problem is that people got stuck in that assumption.

goatinaboat··on U.S. Strategic Command response to FOIA request regarding gibberish tweet
Psychology study needed.

My favourite is when people reply-all with “please remove me from this list”

goatinaboat··on AI skills are worth less than you think (2019)
This mirrors what I see - domain experts using models to validate hypotheses trump p-value fishers without that domain knowledge every time. The only risk the former take is getting trapped in a local minima but that trap can largely be avoided simply by knowing its there.
goatinaboat··on Suez Canal says traffic in channel resumes after stranded ship refloated
Egypt is in no position to handle and armed threat from the US, China, or even most European nations

A little history https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suez_Crisis

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →