HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

gribbly

367 karma · joined May 27, 2016

submissionscomments
gribbly··on How to program an NES game in C
As I recall, Nintendo (eventually) had an official NES devkit which had a special ram cartridge and was linked to a pc running ms dos with an assembler and other programs to make graphics and sound, but there were NES devkits from third parties as well.
gribbly··on Mongoose OS – An Open Source Operating System for the Internet of Things
That's an odd phrasing for sure.

I assume what they mean is that you can purchase a special license which allows you to use moongoose without GPL (typically for proprietary use), for example, x264 and x265 (well known GPL licensed encoders for h264 and h265) does exactly this.

gribbly··on 832 TB – ZFS on Linux
>>But Canonical's lawyers are not canonical.

Hmm... not sure what you meant by this statement ?

gribbly··on 832 TB – ZFS on Linux
Well obviously Linux devs would love having ZFS in the kernel, Linus even half joked that he'd consider trying to relicense Linux to GPLv3 if it meant he could use ZFS and DTrace (this was back when Sun was considering GPLv3 as the license to use when going open source).

But the problem remains, CDDL and GPL are likely incompatible, and Linus has said that no CDDL licensed code will be merged, most likely per advice from lawyers.

So unless something drastically changes, ZFS is off the table, and thus work will continue on with alternatives, Stratis is one such alternative, bcachefs is another, and of course btrfs will not die just because Red Hat isn't supporting it anymore, as they barely did to begin with.

gribbly··on 832 TB – ZFS on Linux
But obviously Canonical's lawyers don't think shipping it separately is the same as shipping it in the kernel, because if they did they would not ship it separately to begin with.
gribbly··on 832 TB – ZFS on Linux
>One theory is that Canonical has essentially forced Oracle to decide whether it wants to crack down on inclusion of CDDL-licensed code being shipped with Ubuntu's stock kernel

Huh? Are Canonical is shipping ZFS in their kernel now ? I thought they just distributed it as a separate module.

gribbly··on 832 TB – ZFS on Linux
Red Hat has never spent any real resources on btrfs, they've been all about XFS when it comes to enterprise needs.
gribbly··on 832 TB – ZFS on Linux
As I understand it, the license incompability between GPL and CDDL is that CDDL adds a restriction regarding patents, and GPL does not allow for additional restrictions to be added.

So to distribute CDDL licensed code is a breach of BOTH licenses as I see it, ignoring the 'patent peace' requirement of CDDL which would be the case if distributing it as GPL does not sound legal to me (IANAL).

I can certainly understand why Linus has stated that no CDDL code will be mainlined (brought into the Linux kernel tree), it all seems very ambiguous.

gribbly··on GPL Violations Related to Combining ZFS and Linux (2016)
>Oracle does not own the the copyright to all of OpenZFS

True, but I don't think the OpenZFS developers would be against relicensing their code to be GPL compatible,they are offering a Linux version of OpenZFS after all, so if Oracle would re/dual license their part of the code in a GPL compatible manner I'm sure the OpenZFS devs would do the same.

gribbly··on Linus: “I no longer feel like I can trust ‘init’ to do the sane thing”
I haven't used PulseAudio until very recently when Firefox started requiring it for audio (chrome/chromium still support plain ALSA), that said I haven't come across any problem, what should I be looking out for ?
gribbly··on Go and Simplicity Debt Redux
It's also a MUCH younger language than those you listed, that said I don't think Go or any other of the 'new languages on the block' will reach anything near the wide use of languages like C++ or Java, atleast not in my lifetime.
gribbly··on Sweden drops Julian Assange rape investigation
They were offered video link interrogation, which swedish authorities have done many times before, but Marianne Ny refused.
gribbly··on Sweden drops Julian Assange rape investigation
What on earth would they need DNA for ?

Assange has already stated that he had sex with both women.

gribbly··on Sweden drops Julian Assange rape investigation
>Assange spent 26 more days in the country and then flew out hours after his arrest warrant was signed.

You are spreading many falsehoods here, first of all, it was NOT a junior prosecutor who dropped the case, chief prosectutor Eva Finné was the one who first handled it and immediately dropped it due to there not being any grounds for a case.

It was a junior prosector Karin Rosander who then suddenly brought the case up again, at this point (20/10 2010) Assange WAS questioned by the police.

The day after this, senior prosecutor Marianne Ny decided to restart the preliminary investigation.

At this point Assange left the country, three weeks later, Marianne Ny filed an arrest warrant on Assange for further questioning.

Assange agreed to be interviewed by video link, something Swedish prosecutors have done many times before, by Marianne Ny refused and demanded that he'd return to sweden for further questioning.

This for accusations which even well known feminists working daily against rape say are laughable:

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/naomi-wolf/interpol-the-worlds...

https://www.theguardian.com/media/2010/dec/08/wikileaks-rape...

gribbly··on Sweden drops Julian Assange rape investigation
Who knows, the accuser, Anna Ardin left Sweden for Israel shortly after making the accusations and has not made a single comment since then as far as I know.
gribbly··on Vancouver bans whales and dolphins at aquarium
Wait what ?

'The aquarium suspects' with no evidence whatsoever to back them up.

And you then claim: 'the unproven truth is that...'

Is this a joke ?

gribbly··on The great British Brexit robbery
>Millions of people decided they know better than facts. That's it.

I don't think people voted for Trump because they think he was spouting facts (when did facts ever factor in a US election ?).

I think they voted for him because they felt that between him and Hillary it was a bad choice either way, so why not go with the 'new kid on the block' this time around.

gribbly··on Lumina Desktop
Is Lumina different from say Xfce in this regard ?
gribbly··on Is the GPL Really Declining?
True, but this is typically a good thing in my opinion, the code remains fully open all the same and the developers/userbase will determine which project is the better.
gribbly··on Is the GPL Really Declining?
>I could be inclined to use GPL if I made some end user application rather than library code.

This very much mirrors my own preference.

For popular end user applications there is a clear motive to do proprietary forks with extra features, which would lead to the original open project either lagging in features or having to spend effort in recreating the features of the proprietary fork while the latter can continously take any new features from the open project.

For libraries/frameworks however, there is little if any real incentive for proprietary forks since it will be hard get developers buying into that.

gribbly··on HardenedLinux: The way to the Ark
The 'hardened' kernel he mentioned has recently (~40 hours) appeared in the Arch repos:

https://www.archlinux.org/packages/community/x86_64/linux-ha...

Not a replacement but at least an alternative.

gribbly··on ESPN Can't Afford to Go on Like This
Comes close to what my father-in-law says about porn, 'why watch other people having fun ?'
gribbly··on Why Mir
Because they had Mir under a CLA which meant Canonical (and only Canonical) could offer it under different terms, which included proprietary licences.

They can't license Ubuntu any way they want, because Ubuntu is 99% software which comes from (and are owned by) other sources, not Canonical.

gribbly··on Why Mir
No one prevented Canonical from making Mir, hence it's existence.

Likewise no one outside Canonical bothered to support Mir, because it offered no advantages over Wayland.

If you want to use Mir, go ahead, that doesn't mean anyone owes you support.

gribbly··on Why Mir
I'd say nothing, Wayland is used on mobile and embedded, the reason Canonical made Mir was so that the had full control/ownership of the display solution and thus could charge a license fee to proprietary vendors who wanted to use it.

Nothing inherently wrong with that, but for someone outside of Canonical it's hard to be interested in a competing solution which only exist in order to pad Canonical's bottom line.

Which was also the reaction from the rest of the Linux ecosystem.

gribbly··on GCC 7 Release Series – Changes, New Features, and Fixes
>On the other side, one of the problems people have with GCC is that it's run by people who actively want to make worse software for political reasons.

Well, for an end user those 'political' reasons are often practical benefits.

Having features only available as proprietary add-ons or through proprietary forks, or being locked out of running the code of your choice on hardware you've bought, are things I find very unappealing.

Of course there are downsides with copyleft as well, because there is no perfect solution to this problem.

Personally I'm favoring permissive licensing for projects where there is little or no incentive for commercial proprietary forks, and copyleft for projects where there is (typically end user targeted).

gribbly··on GCC 7 Release Series – Changes, New Features, and Fixes
Maybe, maybe not.

I've been seeing this comment for the past 7-6 years, and GCC still delivers better performance on the majority of real-world programs I benchmark (mostly compression).

What I find very strange though is that some people seemingly want one of these projects to die.

As is evident from many of the replies in this thread, having two great compiler toolchains with which to test your code is a great advantage.

Secondly, looking at how GCC development picked up greatly when Clang/LLVM came on stage, it shows that GCC was stagnating with the lack of direct competition, should one of them disappear now, the same thing is likely to happen to the surviving project.

On the contrary, I would prefer having even more competition in this field.

gribbly··on NESticle, a classic NES emulator for DOS, is 20 years old today
>I think it was the first jitting nes emulator.

I'm certain it did not use JIT or any kind of recompilation, I believe it's speed came from not being very accurate and also written in hand optimised assembly.

gribbly··on Android overtakes Windows as the internet’s most used operating system
I also had this happen 'live', one of the major problems as I recall was that Windows XP (and earlier) had the bad habit of enabling a ton of internet facing services by default, and these services contained lots of vulnerabilities so you didn't even have to manually 'go online' using a browser or some such in order to be infected.
gribbly··on Why Isn’t OpenBSD in Google Summer of Code 2017?
Eh, GSOC is working for a ton of projects, which is why so many projects happily apply each year, and are bummed if they aren't picked.

You seem to draw a conclusion solely based upon GSOC not being a good fit for the OpenBSD devs.

← PreviousPage 2 of 5Next →