Amazon is a beast. I'd be nervous if I was in any market that Amazon has its eye on.
442 karma · joined September 1, 2010
Amazon is a beast. I'd be nervous if I was in any market that Amazon has its eye on.
I'm very much looking forward to moving our manually managed cross data center MySQL replication/admin to RDS. But I also don't have to scale MySQL to ridiculous levels either, I just need very high availability.
http://www.democracynow.org/2013/7/1/was_deadly_benghazi_kil...
The fact that we can't be sure that he wasn't being blackmailed with something even more scandalous demonstrates the problem perfectly. There is no reason to believe that he was, but you can't say it is impossible now that we have documentation proving their capabilities. That is why this sort of dragnet mass surveillance is so dangerous to a democracy. It undermines the legitimacy of the political process.
He was interviewed in January just after being sentenced:
http://www.democracynow.org/2013/1/30/ex_cia_agent_whistlebl...
Just *who* came to the residence beyond some scary
looking guys in SUVs who said they were FBI.
The Guardian report, which was referred to in the comment I replied to, answered that question with quite a bit of specificity.That comment also had the complaint about downvotes for asking for evidence before I replied.
I agree that there is no concrete evidence that the police showed up as a direct result of them searching for specific keywords. There probably never will be. But how would she prove it? Could anyone prove it in public? Would any investigation that looked into the matter ever be declassified? Could Congress hold a hearing in open session and get answers about the incident?
Unless her husband had a recording of the conversation she claims happened here:
"Have you ever looked up how to make a pressure cooker
bomb?" My husband, ever the oppositional kind, asked them
if they themselves weren’t curious as to how a pressure
cooker bomb works, if they ever looked it up. Two of them
admitted they did.
https://medium.com/something-like-falling/2e7d13e54724Or unless one of the officers involved in that conversation confirms the conversation happened as she reported, we'll never know.
It is completely reasonable to be skeptical of her interpretation of the event. But it is also reasonable to wonder about the consequences of living in a society where her interpretation is a reasonable one, even if it is unlikely. Before Snowden's leaks many people would declare her a nut for even thinking her searches could be related to the investigation. Now we have evidence that the story could happen as she presented it, even if it didn't in this case.
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/aug/01/new-york-police...
Members of what she described as a "joint terrorism task
force" descended on Catalano's home on Wednesday. A spokesman
for the FBI told to the Guardian on Thursday that its
investigators were not involved in the visit, but that "she
was visited by Nassau County police department … They were
working in conjunction with Suffolk County police
department."Why is it that a private citizen is automatically doubted when they make a claim that is easily verifiable but when the government makes a claim that has been repeatedly contradicted by multiple people over the span of years, including at least two sitting US Senators, the government's claims are taken at face value?
Shouldn't her story get a minimum benefit of doubt until some independent reporting can be done on the claims? Especially when everything she claims is plausible given what is known about the government's capabilities.
Notice how he wore his uniform this year instead of something more casual like he did at last year's Def Con. I agree, this was very carefully orchestrated to help discredit his detractors.
I haven't actually seen the Black Hat talk yet, but I can imagine the audience does not compare favorably to another recent PR event:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fawN4OZEt-Y
This kind of thing helps build up the conscious and unconscious associations in the minds of many that favor the NSA a great deal.
And the purpose of Tor might be different than you imagine:
https://www.torproject.org/docs/faq.html.en#WhatIsTor
Or are you just trying to discredit Appelbaum, Assange, and/or Wikileaks?
Also, is that your article? Should you disclose that? And is there any reason you linked to it rather than the original New Yorker article here:
http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2010/06/07/100607fa_fact_...
There is good independent media that has been covering the story for years though. Here's a Democracy Now story from February 2005:
http://www.democracynow.org/2005/2/10/no_place_to_hide_award...
Democracy Now has an incredible archive on this subject too. Right now it starts here:
http://www.democracynow.org/topics/nsa/7
Specifically, they've done some great interviews with previous whistleblowers:
http://www.democracynow.org/appearances/william_binney http://www.democracynow.org/appearances/russell_tice http://www.democracynow.org/appearances/thomas_drake http://www.democracynow.org/appearances/jesselyn_radack
Other interesting guests:
http://www.democracynow.org/appearances/jacob_appelbaum http://www.democracynow.org/appearances/laura_poitras http://www.democracynow.org/appearances/james_bamford
One of the slides literally says that users must be careful to and their query with another parameter to avoid running afoul of the law.
Granted, Snowden is an important part of the story, and he will be remembered very favorably by history. But for people who are predisposed to buying the administration's fear mongering, he has been easily dismissed and used as a distraction in the short term.
It is hard to say if we'll see meaningful reform come from this, but it is encouraging see the reaction so far. The hearings in the House this week are going to make for very interesting TV too.
http://www.ted.com/talks/lawrence_lessig_we_the_people_and_t...
And Sensenbrenner, a principal author of the Patriot Act, is outraged by the secret interpretation being used to justify these programs:
http://sensenbrenner.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?Docu...
Glenn Greenwald says that he has hundreds (if not thousands) of documents, including NSA training manuals, that prove Snowden's claims about NSA analysts having the technical ability to listen to and read the contents of "billions" of phone, email, and chat conversations. See his response starting at 19:51 in this interview:
http://www.democracynow.org/2013/7/18/glenn_greenwald_growin...
Senator Wyden's recent comments support the idea that there is much more coming in this story.
http://www.americanprogressaction.org/events/2013/07/16/6975...
It is incredibly hopeful that there is this much support for an amendment like this before the full story has been told. I hope the Senate is forced to take up a similar vote (less likely for sure) before the full details are published because it would be very valuable to get the position of every Senator on record before November 2014.
For example, some businesses are at capacity because they have some bottleneck that they can't break through with their existing processes. Often you can create software that helps them eliminate some of their bottlenecks and thereby make it possible for them to capture money that they know they have been leaving on the table. They'll value this much higher than a product that would just save them money on labor costs in my experience. And if you can figure out a way to tie the cost of your product directly to their profit, you'll create a feedback loop that will be very valuable to both you and your customers.
I watched the entire Judiciary Committee hearings and they were more than just the normal political posturing. There was a lot of that of course, but there is an undercurrent of deep concern that congress has been had by the executive and judicial branches. That is a good thing. The more documentation that comes out, the more likely there will be real change. Especially if Congress becomes convinced that thousands of analysts across the intelligence community have the technical ability to bypass any legally required procedures and do what Snowden said they can do, and that the technical auditing of that access is less than complete. Looking at the architecture of the system that the NSA has built, and hearing that the number of system administrators with access similar to Snowden's is in the "hundreds", then I suspect the truth is that there are hundreds of people who have total access to all the data the NSA has and that they can access that data in a way that would be very hard to detect unless someone in command was looking for a specific case of abuse. And even then, how could you trust the audit trail when at some level at least some system admins have to have full access to that data too?
But that will not really solve the global problem for the tech community since Congress will never prevent the NSA from monitoring foreign traffic. It will be interesting to see how Google handles encrypting Google Drive. The only hope they have of gaining back the trust of international users in the long term is to make it easy to ensure that this sort of wholesale surveillance is much less likely to bear fruit. Google has conflicting incentives in this area though since they want to be able to read the content to serve relevant ads.
I still think it is highly unlikely that we'll get any real reform. But I have more hope than I have in years, and that is great.
At the end of the day, we need more tech like Tor. And we need the tech community to actively resist restrictions that governments will always want to place on the effectiveness of such systems. I personally would like to see a requirement that data centers in the US must allow users to host Tor relays and exit nodes on their networks without hassle or restriction. That is unlikely to ever happen, but that would go a long way in really protecting users since it would allow users to fund a network that would actually protect their privacy. At a minimum, there needs to be legal protection for users who do choose to host relays and exits. Short of a requirement that all DCs allow Tor exit nodes, as a community we need to actively support companies that allow users to host Tor exit nodes. And we should set up a legal fund to fight any battles that result from the hosting of relays and exits.