HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

guitarbill

4,311 karma · joined January 6, 2016

submissionscomments
guitarbill··on Germans decry influence of English as 'idiot's apostrophe' gets approval
It's pretty crazy how quickly it happened/happens. The Deppenapostroph is maybe less problematic; I see it more as a simplification just like the dative replacing the genitive. But Denglish really just makes everything harder to understand; even if you are fluent in both English and German the "switching" is tiresome. Still, maybe we should get rid of "handy" and "beamer" first...

Ironically, even British English has the issue of Americanisms sneaking in, see e.g. the IT Crowd episode: "How hard is it to remember 911?" "You mean 999? That's the American one".

guitarbill··on Britain buys semiconductor factory for defence purposes
Had, until July 2011. This isn't unique. Austria, Denmark, Finland, Estonia, Greece, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, and others have something similar, varying in details. (I think it's more commonly called military service or equivalent.)
guitarbill··on The first release candidate of FreeCAD 1.0 is out
If you like OpenSCAD but want a fillet or two and STEP export, Build123d is great also.
guitarbill··on Swift is a more convenient Rust
Not just you. Best case the tracing ecosystem is weird and the documentation is lacking, but all of the weirdness makes it very performant. Worst case it is weird and badly documented and over-engineered.

Since rustc uses tracing I really hope it's the first...

guitarbill··on Long-term unemployment leads to disengagement and apathy
> If an American loses their job for any reason

This is incorrect, it's "for limited periods of time under certain circumstances" [0] (and citizenship is not required).

> they can always keep their current insurance through COBRA. [...] needs to pay the full premium

This is true but vastly underplays the cost. It isn't unusual for "the full premium" to be over a thousand dollars per month [1] (!). They even get to charge you an "administrative fee". Oh, and there's also tax implications.

> For people who don't want to stay on their previous employer's plan, the loss of the job is a "qualifying event" which allows them to immediately do things like join their spouse's plan or sign up for an individual "Obamacare" plan through healthcare.gov.

More likely for people who can't stay on their previous plan because it would bankrupt them. Or if their spouse is not working. What happens if the employee has children/dependents on the plan? Etc, etc.

None of this is easy. Switching insurance changes which doctors are "in network", so at minimum it's significant hassle. At worst, their or a family member's current treatment is only partially or not at all covered.

So, in practice, parent's description is accurate enough.

[0] https://www.dol.gov/general/topic/health-plans/cobra

[1] https://www.investopedia.com/cobra-insurance-cost-7486539

guitarbill··on Replacing Liquid Metal on an Asus Zephyrus G15's CPU
Well, they may be cheap, but that alone doesn't seem enough to me. I guess different people look for different things.

I had a Asus ROG Zephyrus G15, and I'd rank it as one of the worst laptops I've ever owned (edit: don't even think it was that cheap). Including the awesome "feature" that it can't be run in clamshell mode, otherwise it will overheat and shut down. That took a while to debug.

I also know of at least 2 other people who were not happy with the thermal performance. They were able to mod it, which is cool (pun intended), but it's disappointing that's even necessary.

guitarbill··on Rust for Filesystems
> Rust kids need to quit tricking other entry level aspiring OS devs into wasting their time learning this language.

In that case, C/C++ developers need to quit tricking the rest of the world that C/C++ is a suitable language for anything security related and - for commercial products - take responsibility for the economic and social impact for the data breaches due to memory safety issues.

(I really don't care if it's Rust, Java, C#, whatever.)

guitarbill··on Low salary likely to cause exodus of European tech talent
Not everything makes the news. Could be small town "politics", sheriff or judge elections, police unilaterally deciding not to enforce laws, etc. Maybe you also count healthcare racket as corruption.
guitarbill··on PSA: If you're a fan of ATmega, try AVR Dx
I'm a bit torn. While there's something nice about the simplicity of an 8-bit device and DIP packages, I've come to enjoy ARM's Serial Wire Debug, and ARM tooling. Definitely don't miss avr-gcc and avrdude.

In a way, it's ironic. The AVR tooling back in the day was just so much better than PIC (for a novice hobbyist, pre-Arduino).

guitarbill··on Loongson CPU that performs like 2020 Core i3 makes its way to Chinese mini PCs
Chips and Cheese reviewed it quite favourably, worth a read: https://chipsandcheese.com/2024/03/13/loongson-3a6000-a-star...
guitarbill··on Wrong couple divorced after computer error by law firm Vardag's
It seems like the husband was quite ok with the accident, hence the ruling:

> Mr Williams' legal representatives argued a final order of divorce is a "once-and-for-all" order, which cannot be set aside by the consent of the parties and may only be rescinded by the court if found to be either void or voidable.

It isn't like two other random people that didn't want to be were accidentally divorced.

guitarbill··on Tech Debt: My Rust Library Is Now a CDO
You don't discuss why they do it or the downsides. "Google does this" is not good enough of an argument.

For the why, could be that the build would be dog slow if a network requests was made for every one of a bajillion dependencies. Or to avoid breaking the build if something is janked externally. Could be because C++ has no modules/libraries. Could be for the lawyer's sake.

Is any of that applicable? There are also other ways of vendoring Rust crates, e.g. mirroring them to an internal registry. That can have fewer downsides.

guitarbill··on Filling Nuclear Power's $5T Hole Is Beyond the Banks
Let's keep things in perspective. The avg share of renewables for each month in 2024 has been about 60%. Some weeks have been as high as 75% or as low as 43% [0].

That's all great, no doubt. But nowhere near close to 95% renewable mix.

[0] https://www.energy-charts.info/charts/renewable_share/chart....

guitarbill··on Nix is a better Docker image builder than Docker's image builder
> It's not actually unreadable - you just have to learn convention on top of the Nix language. For instance, what mkDerivation does. Actually, the Nix language usage here is somewhat minimal. Mostly let bindings (aka lambda calculus).

> I wouldn't expect a layman to be able to grok that file. That's fine though - it's not for laymen.

This is the kind of comment that makes me want to stay far, far away from Nix and the Nix "community".

guitarbill··on YouTube dominates TV streaming in US, per Nielsen's latest report
It's just annoying, and by no means unique to YT. Companies forcing changes upon users, it's going to be adversarial - especially for people who do use it a lot.

People do watch shorts, of course. I can see it can be a good fit on phones, even if it isn't for me. I can also see not wanting to shaft creators who put effort into shorts.

Where it falls down is the heavy-handed, passive-aggressive thing of "ok, we'll hide shorts for 30" (in this view only though). My UI criticism is more that for "normal" videos, you'd use home and subscriptions the most, right? So sandwiching stuff between that just feels like they're trying to make you mis-tap on purpose. Maybe Google engineers don't use bumpy public transport? (Or other one-handed scenarios.)

Possibly, this is all a projection of the main worry - especially for paying users: If they are willing to degrade the long-form video experience, or at least show little consideration, what does the future of that look like?

guitarbill··on YouTube dominates TV streaming in US, per Nielsen's latest report
My experience is much closer to parent than yours, and I don't use any third party app. Yes, I have paid. And no, I'm not "just a sufficiently light user". That's pretty dismissive actually.

The official app sucks, and the desperate Shorts push is annoying at best.

Shorts are injected into the search, and search is otherwise as bad as discussed. On the bottom menu/bar, the five things are "Home", "Shorts", the plus/capture/upload button (why would I ever want to use this on mobile? oh yeah, I don't and only accidentally press it, but Youtube wants people to upload Shorts), "Subscriptions" and "Profile". This is the same on iPad.

At least with YT Music, seems they realised that the UX of the main app was so bad, they just needed a separate one. But with Shorts, the desperation for those sweet Zoomer ad views was too high, so into the main app it goes.

guitarbill··on 46% of Americans didn't read a book in 2023
Come on, that's a lame argument and completely subjective.

What makes LotR a "great artistic work"? What makes Stardew Valley not a "great artistic work"?

Just like some books, films, or other art can resonate and have a profound impact on a person, so can video games.

guitarbill··on Kayak's new flight filter allows you to exclude aircraft models
> But repealing the second amendment now won’t make things better. We made drugs illegal, how’s that going?

People aren't (physically) addicted to guns. If only there were data from other countries...

> I think you’re also getting confused between population and population density. The US has a population density of 1/12th the Netherlands.

Few people are demanding public transport spanning entire sparsely populated states.

There are enough cities in the US with comparable population densities to e.g. Amsterdam.

guitarbill··on Apple tells EU it has five different App Stores, not just one
Android is quite a bit more popular than iPhones in the EU (roughly 66% vs 33%). And the iPhone app store is likely the most lucrative one for Apple. So it makes sense to try and isolate it. It will be interesting to see how the iPad affects this.

I'm not sure about the wearable/smartwatch market. That could be more skewed towards Apple Watch. Doubt anybody cares about Apple TV. macOS store is likely exempt as - for now - Macs can install software from anywhere.

guitarbill··on New U.S. immigration rules spur more visa approvals for STEM workers
Not only is this unnecessarily hostile, but also easily refuted. Here's the process for software patents, which by the way some countries do not grant because it's such bullshit. Software "ideas" get written up and then transformed by a lawyer into incomprehensible legalese. Often to the point the "inventor" cannot understand them anymore. Sometimes, managers get added as "inventors". Then, the patent is submitted and iterated on until it gets accepted.

So the hard part is having enough money to pay a lawyer. And being morally opposed to patents, especially software patents, is a valid position.

guitarbill··on Police get medical records without a warrant
Why would you make the government pay out? Make the police unions provide that insurance.
guitarbill··on Becoming a go-to person gets you promoted
Unfortunately many people listen to terrible advice and get exploited by companies before learning the lesson the hard way.

I'd be more inclined to believe your advice if your other comments on this topic was... realistic or actionable I guess? Caution = cynicism, and companies are either "good" (reward hard work) or "shitty" (??? not good?).

guitarbill··on Paris mayor plans to triple SUV parking tariffs to cut air pollution
Could also be because police actually enforce (traffic) laws in some countries, and less so in others
guitarbill··on Interview: Epic CEO Tim Sweeney after Google antitrust win
> Steam is an absolutely crushing monopoly

Origin, U-Play, EA Play, etc. Blizzard titles are not on Steam. Microsoft Game Pass, and before that Games for Windows Live. Some physical releases require Steam, many do not. GOG. Edit: itch.io. So it's easily disproven. The other option sucking (e.g. not allowing reviews) does not a monopoly make.

guitarbill··on Okta says hackers stole data for all customer support users
Some companies are also happy to be able to blame a third party. And there's safety in numbers. A risk mitigation of a different kind.
guitarbill··on Python errors as values: Comparing useful patterns from Rust and Go
That's what makes it good :) Well, that and the fact you have to unpack/destructure the result somehow to get at the value (or the error), so you're forced to handle it.
guitarbill··on Python errors as values: Comparing useful patterns from Rust and Go
> Rust returns returns errors using a "wrapper" type called Result. A Result contains both a non-error value (Ok) and an error value (Err)

A `Result` can contain either a non-error value (Result::Ok) or and error value (Result::Err), never both.

guitarbill··on Are we doing this again? Yes, we're doing this again
Nothing to do with disagreeing with the court. That case does not seem particularly relevant to the bill, but is excellent flame bait. And the smug North American comment does nothing to further the discussion either.
guitarbill··on Microsoft Azure CTO Headhunted for SDE II Position at Amazon
It's tough. I've also seen what you describe, and it's kind of mind-boggling. The only red-ish flag seems to be overly long tenure at a single place. But at some point in the career progression, it doesn't matter.

I think the difference is this. Some people I've worked with were excellent coders but have now moved on to e.g. director roles. If you asked them to write code, they'll flat out say that they haven't coded in years. They know it isn't important for their role, and it isn't the value they provide. The bullshitters will never admit they can't do something.

guitarbill··on Giving a Shit as a Service (2022)
That is the literal translation/interpretation, "you ain't shit" = "you are not shit". It could mean that, "i expected you to be shit, but you are unexpectedly good", depending on tone/context.

But the much more common interpretation "you ain't shit" = "you are less than shit" = "you are worthless/nothing". See also "it don't mean shit".

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →