HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hailwren

704 karma · joined August 14, 2019

submissionscomments
hailwren··on The Prestige Trap: finance, big tech, and consulting
Yeah, tech has a starting salary advantage but FAANG just doesn't compare on the upside. What's the top 10% of FAANG outcomes (for Harvard grads) after 5 years? 500k, maybe? The jump to MD in finance makes 1M+ something like 10-20% of outcomes (for Harvard grads) after 10 years. I'd be very surprised if it were that common in tech (over the next 10 years, I know that it was better in the 2000s). I think quickest to MD at Goldman was 4 years.
hailwren··on The Prestige Trap: finance, big tech, and consulting
5 year EV is much lower in tech than finance for Harvard grads. I'm not sure ab consulting.

Consulting and tech have similar starting salaries, but consider finance/hedge fund engineer starting tc is about 3-4x tech for top 3 grads rn.

hailwren··on The Prestige Trap: finance, big tech, and consulting
Yes, and pairwise multivariate comparisons make the gap even larger. (i.e. considering two engineering students or two visual arts students etc)
hailwren··on The Prestige Trap: finance, big tech, and consulting
Yes, and the gap grows even wider when you normalize for per-professional degree percentages (i.e. STEM/pharm/premed/prelaw/military inflating the bottom half of the curve)
hailwren··on My Resignation from the Intercept
This argument is specifically, and repeatedly, addressed by Greenwald in his article. [1]

> The Hunter Biden documents have at least as much verification as those other archives that were widely reported. There are sources in the email chains who have verified that the published emails are accurate. The archive contains private photos and videos of Hunter whose authenticity is not in doubt. A former business partner of Hunter has stated, unequivocally and on the record, that not only are the emails authentic but they describe events accurately, including proposed participation by the former Vice President in at least one deal Hunter and Jim Biden were pursuing in China. And, most importantly of all, neither Hunter Biden nor the Biden campaign has even suggested, let alone claimed, that a single email or text is fake.

1 - https://greenwald.substack.com/p/article-on-joe-and-hunter-b...

hailwren··on Image Scaling Attacks
You're looking for section 3.1 in [1] where they analyze the effect of scaling width and kernel size for any abitrary downscaling kernel.

> Any algorithm is vulnerable to image-scaling attacks if the ratior of pixels with highweight is small enough.

1 - https://www.usenix.org/system/files/sec20-quiring.pdf

hailwren··on The Fall of Silicon Valley
I was reacting the specific 'decentralization' mantra that is a linguistic artifact of cryptocurrencies.

> how well does economic value align with our human values? I couldn't begin to define what 'our human values' even means.

> one of their new interns was, until recently, a practicing medical doctor

Is your argument that there is no person practicing medicine who would produce more utility for society by writing software at Amazon? Because that seems like a pretty extreme position.

hailwren··on The Fall of Silicon Valley
The problem with most of this crypto-anarchist rhetoric is that it establishes a value system that does not reflect the realities of the real world.

decentralization, democracy = good and the opposite = bad runs up against fundamental value propositions of economies of scale and specialization

hailwren··on Delete Facebook and You'll Lose All Oculus Games for Good
> What I don't get is, why does Facebook want me to have a single friends list, under my real name?

It's a neat solution to the multi-device problem (i.e. When I serve an ad to this device, is this a new user or the same one?)

Also, I get the view that Oculus is just a video game console -- but I don't think that's how Zuck views it

My impression is that he thinks Oculus/VR will eventually surpass 2d interfaces. So, if they can get away with linking all of their ad targeting information now, in the early stages, then it won't seem weird if they do it later.

To be fair to FB, this is exactly what they're doing with integrating IG and FB messaging. It's just that no one is really complaining about that.

Doing this in the middle of an anti-trust investigation seems ... bold, but it is consistent with their financial incentives.

hailwren··on Down the ergonomic keyboard rabbit hole
You have to build it by hand, but check out the Dactyl or Dactyl Manuform. I think they're about the pinnacle of the erg keyboard world. 3d shape like a Kinesis but with more optimization for wrist angle and allows you to customize wrist rotation and split.
hailwren··on How Big Oil Misled the Public into Believing Plastic Would Be Recycled
Probably poverty and industry. Germany has more industry and has historically had a stronger economy. So, that probably leads to lifestyles that promote more energy use.
hailwren··on AI slays top F-16 pilot in DARPA dogfight simulation
The fifth generation of fighter aircraft marked a significant departure from the idea of a fighter jet being anything like what we think of as a fighter jet.

They're now designed and employed as fighter 'platforms'. Instead of zipping around the battlefield guns and missiles ablaze in 1-on-1 combat, they're low observable long-range systems designed to understand and disrupt the battlefield by employing their electronic and long-range missile systems.

These AI are a natural extension of that. I imagine the 6th generation of fighter platforms will be commanding swarms of fighter drones to do the fighter part of their role.

hailwren··on YouTube bans Stefan Molyneux, David Duke, Richard Spencer for hate speech
I'm sure it was done in coordination with the advertisers that pulled their ads. Probably a group coordination between the companies and groups like the Anti-Defamation League, the NAACP, Sleeping Giants, Color of Change, Free Press and Common Sense that spearheaded the original advertising blackout.
hailwren··on Officer of China’s People’s Liberation Army Arrested at LAX
This argument was specifically addressed in the source.

'According to court documents, Wang was still employed by the PLA while he was studying in the United States and he made false statements about his military service in his visa application in order to increase the likelihood that he would receive his J1 visa.'

The allegation is that he would not have been on a scientific exchange program had it been clear that it was a scientific exchange with the PLA.

hailwren··on The yuan has been one of the world’s most stable major currencies
Right, you just rephrased the question to 'for whom does it matter' but otherwise the original question remains unchanged
hailwren··on Tacit knowledge is more important than deliberate practice
This is interesting. Wittgenstein argues that this idea of 'tacit knowledge' has no meaning. What the article describes is practice.

'My point is that their explanations would not lead me to the same ability that they had.' is a very Wittgensteinian thing to say. See i.e. the parable of the wayward pupil in the Investigations on what role understanding/practice even play in the context of a statement like 'would not lead me to the same ability that they had'

'But the more I pushed, the more exceptions and caveats and potential gotchas I unearthed.' W argues that this is a result of our concept of what it means to understand. Can you name an idea where this doesn't hold? W uses a great example of your knowledge of the Natural Numbers. Just because you hadn't thought of the number 10324 beforehand, does that mean your knowledge didn't encompass it? Before you attempt to foist the problem onto mathematical logic (it doesn't work, but the answers become longer than an HN comment) consider your concept of the color 'red'. What shape is it? Did you a prior have in your mind the shape of red? Is there a color that I could show you which you might consider red and someone else would not?

The core problem is this idea that 'explanations' in the source are implicitly able to be fully specified or that any knowledge exists without practice. See i.e. W's theory of language for a mind blowing explanation.

I think the real question I would pose to the author is, what knowledge do you think qualifies as 'explicit'? I think you will find your answers supremely unsatisfying. If you don't, try Kripke's 'Wittgenstein's Paradox' and Goldfarb's (admittedly much more dense) 'Rule Following'

hailwren··on Show HN: Puree – Password-based Uniform-Random-Equivalent Encryption
I laughed.
hailwren··on Oil plunges below zero for first time with May contract ending
I think you've mixed up your logic a bit. A slow visual reaction time means that surgeons are already reacting slower in the real world. Any latency added (!!) by a network further adds to the delay between surgeon reaction and real world stimulus.

You argued that when we compare the average VRT additional latency is not large. But you should have argued that there was enough buffer between average VRTs and the time needed for a surgeon to react to allow adding to average VRT.

i.e. If we imagine driving a car with a video camera, we don't really care about latency vs reaction time. We care whether latency + reaction < accident threshold.

hailwren··on Boeing 787s must be turned off and on every 51 days to prevent 'misleading data'
I worked in aviation for a while. This is super common. There isn't a pilot on the planet who hasn't turned avionics off in flight (there are always redundant and backup systems). There probably isn't a working pilot in the world that hasn't had to cycle a circuit breaker in flight this month.

Edit: Well, if this was a normal month.

hailwren··on Taiwan's new 'electronic fence' for quarantines leads wave of virus monitoring
They wouldn't use the IMEI. Your phone also reports the IMSI which includes country code, network, and an identifier number. They'd only have to differentiate you from the other people from your country. By the problem statement, you didn't go straight to your hotel -- so you're probably going to be the only one.

And sure, you could leave it on airplane mode -- but you have to keep in mind that you are eventually going to be found, and I'm not really clear why we're even evading quarantine but when you are found the punishment is going to be much more severe if the government believes that you were intentionally avoiding detection. Keep in mind, Taiwan still punishes drug trafficking with death -- I can't imagine they'd look kindly on intentionally endangering their entire population.

Although upon further thought, IMEI should be fine too. Consider that international travel is mostly shut down right now. I'd be surprised if there are more than 500 international travelers at the airport within 30 minutes of you. They would just check every one against their quarantine reporting status (hint: EVERYONE else will be where they're supposed to be and checking in as part of the procedure) Then all you have to do is remove IMEIs that are at their correct reporting location one by one. I'd guess less than a hour's work given that the reporting is already being handled.

hailwren··on Taiwan's new 'electronic fence' for quarantines leads wave of virus monitoring
They'd follow you from the airport. You could maybe evade if you were a trained expert who looked like a local national, but otherwise they'd just check CCTV (Taipei is covered in it) and follow your trail. I've never taken public trans out of TPE, so they'd probably just call the cab company and track you down that way. Otherwise, they would check the public trans cameras.

Also lack of local sim doesn't mean you aren't transmitting. It just means the towers are choosing not to provide you with service. A SIM's only purpose is to link your usage to a billing account and phone number.

hailwren··on FDA issues first emergency use authorization for point-of-care diagnostic
Instead of open-sourcing, shouldn't we just give them as much funding as possible to manufacture as quickly as possible? This isn't software. You can't just `git clone` their repo, and random indie hackers 3D printing things that seem to work might do more harm than good.
hailwren··on Honk more, wait more: Mumbai traffic police introduce the ‘punishing signal’
Doesn't it incentivize honking when the light is green for you?
hailwren··on A Graduate Course in Applied Cryptography
NewHope has not been proven to be quantum resistant. I think researchers generally believe that NewHope will be proven to be quantum resistant, but there is the problem of adapting Micciancio's regular lattice proof to ideal lattices.
hailwren··on A Graduate Course in Applied Cryptography
I think, generally, the concern with quantum resistant cryptography is that, like homomorphic encryption schemes, it’s unworkably slow right now.
hailwren··on Apple AirPods: iPhone accessory or the next big thing?
It’s already a meme on college campuses that you aren’t cool if you still have the ‘long stems’. I’d say pros are doing well.
hailwren··on You can't just rename your IT Ops team and call it DevOps
Ehh, a software engineer is a programmer. The name evolved, but I don't think there is any organization that has software engineering and programming roles separated.
hailwren··on Reasons Why Job Seekers Are Not Given Feedback
It's sort of complicated. I did a boot camp, 100 applications 3 interviews 0 offers, went back to school (Harvard, the real one not the extension school) and am currently doing the summer internship grind (30 applications 3 interviews 0 offers). But I'm CS.
hailwren··on Multipass 1.0 – Mini-cloud on Mac or Windows workstation
Wouldn't that make it MultiPaaS anyways?
hailwren··on Reasons Why Job Seekers Are Not Given Feedback
> Many job seekers take the not-recommended approach of submitting their résumés for dozens of jobs

I wish I only had to apply for dozens of jobs.

← PreviousPage 5 of 6Next →