HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hcknwscommenter

1,715 karma · joined November 7, 2017

submissionscomments
hcknwscommenter··on Soluble ACE2 shows promise for treating severe Covid­19
I know it seems hard to believe, but (IMHO) the existence of a patent will in no way encumber (and will actually help) the production, distribution, and administration of this drug if it works.

Entities that actually have expertise and capability in clinical development of such complicated biologics get through this process by burning billions of dollars. These billions are provided by investors who must have some reasonable chance at making a profit (or at least not losing a lot of money). Non-profit enterprises simply don't have the money or the expertise. The government has no expertise in the development path. The U.S. gov't (through the FDA) has vast amounts of expertise in analyzing clinical trial proposals and data, but not actually running them.

hcknwscommenter··on Voyager 2 is back online after eight months of radio silence
That's a pretty amazing comment to me. Perhaps I am biased because of all the blood sweat tears and life I spent publishing papers in academia. Generally, with the exception of certain low quality publication venues, certain fringe areas of humanities, and of course review papers, each academic paper is a new contribution to science that has never been made before. Heating and cooling something to unjam it? That's been done since the dawn of modern engineering. A neat story (and I mean it), but hardly an astounding level of innovation and creativity.
hcknwscommenter··on Waymo and Daimler Trucks partner on the development of fully autonomous trucks
My guess is that there is so much technical debt that adding LIDAR is a tough choice for TESLA. They would need to throw out all the visual only data they have to-date and start over.
hcknwscommenter··on Fund manager: ‘Nightmare’ US stock valuations driven by ‘young, dumb’ investors
Good for you, but your FIRE goal either explicitly or inherently assumes both an inflation rate and an expected return rate. It is crazy to ignore both as you seem to be doing with your statement that you are safe from failing to meet 12-15% returns simply because you are assuming a 3.5% withdrawal rate. In addition to inflation and expected return, you also should consider max draw down potential.
hcknwscommenter··on Telecom auctions have failed India
You will find in any rev-share agreement, a requirement that the Co. actually make "best efforts" or the like towards actually generating revenue or they lose the license rights. Best efforts is not some fluffy term, but basically requires the company to move heaven and earth if necessary otherwise they are in violation of the agreement.
hcknwscommenter··on Do Masks on Plane Flights Really Cut Your Risk of Catching Covid-19?
The last part is very true. The first part is not true. It's one of the surprising things we have discovered about this unusual pandemic. Unvented, even single layer, masks do offer some degree of protection to the wearer against COVID-19. Perhaps it just keeps your hands out of your face. Anything that lowers R0, even a little is beneficial. Masks work. Better masks work better.
hcknwscommenter··on Telecom auctions have failed India
>"The new system brought in twice as much in fees as the auction bids would have.”

If the new system brought in twice as much in fees, then by definition it was more burdensome on the telcos no?

hcknwscommenter··on Telecom auctions have failed India
I mean, maybe? It is a huge stretch to tie a specific event (auction and the related debt) to the ensuing 20 years worth of telecom infrastructure investment. This implies (incorrectly) that there are no other significant reasons Germany might lag in mobile network investment.
hcknwscommenter··on Telecom auctions have failed India
>Governments gets 2x revenue from revenue sharing than from auctions so govts do lose.

Citation needed.

>there is a counter factual for which empirical data exists

And yet you provide none.

hcknwscommenter··on Telecom auctions have failed India
1. Many telecom companies in other countries that use auctions have pretty decent returns. See, e.g., ATT and VZ among others.

> other solutions exists - e.g. revenue sharing - which work very well

The terms of the revenue sharing need to be worked out somehow. That "somehow" is typically via some sort of competition for scarce resources (spectrum), e.g., an auction. Sure, the gov't could just set a price, but the inefficiency and lack of price discovery inherent to that approach is precisely the issue the auction seeks to address.

hcknwscommenter··on Fund manager: ‘Nightmare’ US stock valuations driven by ‘young, dumb’ investors
You can still plan for a 3.5% withdrawal rate and be way off of what you need to retire if you are assuming a 12-15% return rate.
hcknwscommenter··on First Bitcoin “mixer” penalized for violating anti-money laundering laws
No. Accepting US dollars, "converting" those dollars into bitcoin, performing a mixing operation for the express purpose to make it difficult to track where those dollars went, and then sending back something worth the U.S. dollars you accepted (minus a fee), is money laundering.
hcknwscommenter··on Updating Herd Immunity Models for the US: Implications for the Covid-19 Response
We could basically live a normal life with massive testing and tracing in place. Korea and Taiwan have strong testing and tracing measures and life there is basically back to pre-pandemic behaviors except you need to scan a code on your phone (to enable tracing if a later detected infection is traced to that location) before you enter a bar/restaurant/night club, etc. China had an outbreak in Qingdao (6 total cases), so they tested all 9 million people in 5 days. That's isn't even that hard to do.
hcknwscommenter··on Fund manager: ‘Nightmare’ US stock valuations driven by ‘young, dumb’ investors
>Look at any long term chart. I'll take the risk.

There are 30 year periods where US stocks (spy 500 or a close proxy thereof) posted a negative total return. Are you prepared for that?

My larger point is that 12-15% return assumption is absurd. There are very few long-term periods where that has ever been achieved in the US market, most (but not all) of which were followed by a deep and long-lasting correction.

The alternative is to assume a lower return like 5% and plan accordingly.

hcknwscommenter··on Fund manager: ‘Nightmare’ US stock valuations driven by ‘young, dumb’ investors
I've had a Vanguard account since 1997. 500 index. Put the minimum in at the time and never touched it since. I do not have 12% annualized returns.

Indeed, I just checked portfolio visualizer, which gives a 1997-2020 return of 8.5% CAGR for the 500. My guess is you started adding in 2007 (so your principal was very small during the great financial crisis) and you've been adding during the entire recovery. You don't know how lucky you are. Of course, maybe you just bought QQQ in 1997. Again, you don't know how lucky you are.

The number of fallacious assumptions embedded in your syllogism is difficult to unpack. I'll start with one, past returns are not indicative of futures results. I'll add another, the relative expensiveness of stocks at a given point in time are negatively correlated to long-term future returns. Someone won a nobel prize by illustrating the last one.

hcknwscommenter··on Fund manager: ‘Nightmare’ US stock valuations driven by ‘young, dumb’ investors
> 12-15% per year

That seems unreasonably optimistic.

hcknwscommenter··on Fund manager: ‘Nightmare’ US stock valuations driven by ‘young, dumb’ investors
>Is GDP really that far down?

GDP is down. Bigly.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GDP (click on the 1yr timeframe to see it better).

hcknwscommenter··on Updating Herd Immunity Models for the US: Implications for the Covid-19 Response
I cannot fathom how your link could possibly support your contention that 0-4 and 5-17 are "definitely" a 99.99% survival rate (IFR of 0.01% or 1 fatality out of every 10,000 infections). I suspect you are misreading the table? Care to elaborate?
hcknwscommenter··on Updating Herd Immunity Models for the US: Implications for the Covid-19 Response
Because no demographic has been demonstrated to have a 99.99% survival rate?
hcknwscommenter··on Updating Herd Immunity Models for the US: Implications for the Covid-19 Response
The healthcare industry (and the CDC) and (almost?) every qualified expert is arguing that we are not doing enough testing. And we aren't. Part of the reason we are not doing enough testing is that we simply don't have the capacity and Dr.s' are being told that capacity is restricted and tests should be carefully considered on a case by case basis. The above is non-uniformly distributed in that there are some areas of the country where there is sufficient capacity and others where capacity is woefully deficient. Some sort of competent federal leadership on testing capacity/distribution would help tremendously.
hcknwscommenter··on Almost 90 percent of NYC bars and restaurants couldn’t pay August rent
Landlords were/are bailed out in US. Landlords are businesses. MY LLC got a 30 year very low fixed interest loan, first 10K of loan automatically forgiven, based solely on the LLC's income from last year. The loan amount was roughly 60% of last year's revenue. Oddly enough, actual lost revenue was about equal to the loan amount, but the gov't had no way of knowing that and didn't even ask. I'm sure every landlord in the country signed up for that or one of the several other coronavirus relief options. Any wonder why the stock market is up? That's a lot of free money sloshing around.
hcknwscommenter··on SARS-CoV-2 positivity rates associated with circulating Vitamin D levels
"One interesting thing is that the Russian vaccine tests were criticized for not sharing raw data"

I'm sure that, if one searched hard enough, one could find such a criticism. However, most of the criticism centered around the fact that the vaccine was "approved" on the basis of nearly zero actual human data.

hcknwscommenter··on Tesla Model Y Owners Find Cooling System Made with Home Depot-Grade Fake Wood
"Compressive strength of wood . . ."

I guarantee you that the materiel is not "wood" and is indeed much weaker in all relevant parameters. And I suspect that no one at TESLA has any real handle on the compressive strength of this material.

hcknwscommenter··on Tesla Model Y Owners Find Cooling System Made with Home Depot-Grade Fake Wood
"slapped this together overnight"

IMHO, I doubt they spent even that much time on it, and that is what worries me.

hcknwscommenter··on Tesla Model Y Owners Find Cooling System Made with Home Depot-Grade Fake Wood
But that's not failing the test. The point is that you are supposed to see it as A or B, and that will give the test administrator insight into your viewpoint.
hcknwscommenter··on Release of methane gas from the seafloor in the Southern Hemisphere
Not the original commenter, but I think the point of the comment is different from your interpretation. Typically "ocean fertilization" refers to the concept of seeding the ocean with iron and other nutrients to encourage blooming of oxygen generating (CO2 consuming) photosynthetic microorganisms. The idea is not to literally consume the rising bubble as it boils off the ocean floor, but to slow down/reverse global warming in general by reducing atmospheric CO2.
hcknwscommenter··on Release of methane gas from the seafloor in the Southern Hemisphere
The biggest negative feedback loop I am aware of is clouds. Higher temp, more moisture in the air, more clouds, greater reflection of incoming light (and greater retention of heat, so not a clear negative loop in all scenarios). However, as far as I can tell, clouds are a lot easier to model than the positive feed back loops we know/suspect, albedo decrease, clathrate guns, peat breakdown, etc. Thus, we are in a situation, where negative feedback loops seem well accounted for and there are a few potentially catastrophic, but perfectly plausible, positive feedback loops that are too difficult to properly assess. It is scary.
hcknwscommenter··on The CDC has failed: Ex-health officials urge states to abandon agency
This is nonsense. You completely disregard that the entire world's medical community has become vastly better at treating infectious people. In the early days, when NE states, Spain, Italy, etc. were hit hard, people who had to go to the hospital died at alarming rates. Since then, we have learned that prone position, dexamethasone, supplemental (non-intubated) oxygen, convalescent plasma, etc. contribute to vastly lower death rates. Of course per capita death rates are high in the NE states. We had no effective treatments then.
hcknwscommenter··on I had Covid-19, and these are the things nobody tells you
I see it differently. Yes, young people are much less likely to have a serious illness from COVID. But, there are still young people who will die from COVID (the death rate is not zero for 0-18yrs old even without preexisting conditions). For those young people, it is death. To say, "you young person, you'll be fine". Is inaccurate. To say, you will most likely be fine. Yeah, sure that's accurate, but some of those people will actually die. Let's not candy coat that. Death is permanent and awful.
hcknwscommenter··on I had Covid-19, and these are the things nobody tells you
There is an animal coronavirus vaccine that works. Human coronaviruses, until now, either disappeared from the face of the earth (SARS) or are simply not very bad (cold), so there is literally no market for a human coronavirus vaccine, and therefore no reason to make one, until now. It costs at least a billion to make a human coronavirus vaccine, no company can just snap their fingers and spend a billion dollars for no reason. We now have a reason. It is not pollyanna to expect a coronavirus vaccine in the next 6-12 months.
← PreviousPage 9 of 26Next →