HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

heyitsguay

1,081 karma · joined January 5, 2017

submissionscomments
heyitsguay··on Choose-Your-Own-Adventure AI Dungeon Games
I think people are in agreement with this conceptually, and the challenge is figuring out how to effectively implement it. I'd certainly love to see a hybrid like this with a coherent world model, but for example, how do you avoid the existing challenges with procedural worlds where you're basically limited to combinatorial combinations of a small number of primitive features? If the free-form text can't affect more than toggling of predetermined procedural state combinations, it's basically just an interface to a traditional world sim with more window dressing.
heyitsguay··on I spent 300$ on an NFT and I regret it
> There can't be that much criminal money out there.

There can be and there is, especially in cryptocurrency. The only economic use for Bitcoin back in its early days was in black market transactions. The holders of early extremely large positions in crypto are techie early adopters who liked messing around with the technology (significant, but only gets you so far), and criminal groups. The former are probably more interested in the crypto ecosystem, the latter are highly motivated to find ways to turn their massive positions into cash.

That isn't to say that every high-priced or weird NFT purchase/crypto transaction/whatever is part of a nefarious money laundering scheme, just that if there are spaces that make money laundering easier, you can bet that people with money to launder are trying to take advantage of them in general.

heyitsguay··on Fiatjaf/nostr – a censorship-resistant alternative to Twitter
> Traditionally nobody was censored in the town square.

This isn't true, it's just that the spatial constraints IRL mean there's never been a need to scale moderation of town squares beyond intuitive methods. Go to your physical town square and start screaming slurs and threats of violence at passers-by, and see how long it takes before the community "censors" you.

heyitsguay··on Fiatjaf/nostr – a censorship-resistant alternative to Twitter
It absolutely is an option! There are open source social media projects out there that you can fork and start hosting today, if you want. Or you can use one of the existing alternatives. It's just that not many people use them right now, because Big Tech "censorship" has done a pretty good (definitely not perfect) job of just targeting bad actors. If a large non-toxic chunk of the population starts getting banned, non-toxic alternative platforms will become viable for the network effects that power social media centralization. Until then, the alternatives will look like Voat and Gab, and it seems like the online public doesn't love platforms that are dominated by the toxic castoffs from more mainstream platforms.
heyitsguay··on Fiatjaf/nostr – a censorship-resistant alternative to Twitter
In particular, it used to be called "forum moderation" until that was deliberately conflated with censorship by far-right groups, angry at their loss of audience, starting I guess somewhere around 2010.
heyitsguay··on Pixor: Real-Time 3D Object Detection from Point Clouds
It looks like this is 3 years old and based on a really old version of PyTorch - did something happen to bump its popularity recently? Is this still SOTA? (I would assume not given how fast the field moves)
heyitsguay··on Non-Fungible Olive Gardens
Great idea. I just registered your house on my favorite blockchain. You can leave any furniture you don't want on your way out. If you feel this is an error, please don't resort to any centralized statist mechanisms to resolve this dispute.

The issue isn't a lack of imagination on the part of skeptics who actually understand the underlying technical mechanisms behind blockchains. It's a lack of understanding by proponents about how the physical world works and how it can and can't be made to relate to digital comstructs.

heyitsguay··on Non-Fungible Olive Gardens
There are two sleights of hand here that make this analogy sound reasonable when it actually isn't.

(1) "Buying" a Rolex (or knockoff) vs NFTs - buying a physical (or digital) good gives you privileged access to it. The same is not true of an NFT, which just adds your name next to a pointer in a (decentralized) database. Nothing changes in regard to access to the underlying good unless people decide to build mechanisms on top of the chosen blockchain to artificially enforce access privileges, but you don't need a blockchain for that (cf. skins in CS-GO or stock images one pays for to purchase and download).

(2) "Indistinguishable" - with physical goods, that's a perceptual property and when you're talking about knockoffs of luxury goods, it really just means "hard to tell the difference (unless you examine it closely)". With digital media, the way it's been set up with NFTs, indistinguishable means completely identical. There are ways to actually sell protected digital media - e.g. you show a low-res version on a website and only send a full-res version once a purchase is made. But that's also been happening since the internet became a thing and doesn't need blockchains or NFTs either.

heyitsguay··on Non-Fungible Olive Gardens
Ah but not to worry, give the project enough money and they will definitely, totally give the NFT owners the assets that get purchased!
heyitsguay··on S.Africa says vaccines, prior infection help mildness of Covid cases
Basically agreed, but to me whether "new infections" matters or not hinges on the long-term effects of these different variants in vaccinated people. What's the prevalence of "long COVID" if you're vaccinated? If you're vaccinated and boosted? Is there evidence of any more or less lasting lung damage in chest X-rays than in unvaccinated people?

Hospitalization matters for short-term policy, but long-term damage could end up affecting long-term healthcare policy even more in the coming decades

heyitsguay··on Pfizer’s Covid-19 Pill is 89% Effective in Phase 2/3 Study
Yeah that's a big omission that i don't see addressed in the article. In particular given the development timeline, does it have the same efficacy for the omicron variant? I doubt the trials being reported here tested it.
heyitsguay··on Pfizer’s Covid-19 Pill is 89% Effective in Phase 2/3 Study
For the variants at the time. The spread of the delta and omicron variants was tracked so closely and garnered so much attention in large part due to their abilities to at least partially evade vaccine-induced immunity, but this was always a known risk. The larger the infected population, the more chances for such an event to occur, hence the importance of measures like vaccinations, social distancing, and lockdowns to curb the spread.
heyitsguay··on Kolmogorov Complicity and the Parable of Lightning (2017)
I think you can draw parallels between that trajectory and the dynamics of "censorship" (moderation) on big social media platforms.

You compare Twitter vs. Gab or Reddit vs. Voat, and these free speech alternatives get stuck in that alt-right filter bubble precisely because social media moderation has been largely (certainly not entirely) effective at targeting hatred and toxicity. When you only ban a bunch of hateful toxic people from your platform, any competing platform for the banned will be dominated by hateful toxic people, and nobody wants to be a part of that. If Reddit bans cat pictures tomorrow, suddenly there is a huge opportunity open for a competing platform that can appeal to wide mainstream audiences. This dynamic helps keep social media moderation in check.

Similarly, if there had been hard, actionable truth at the core of Damore's claims, there would have been a huge opportunity to gather evidence and observe effects and come up with an organizational system that better reflected the reality of human social relationships. If that wasn't the case, then all he would be left with is the path he seems to have taken - align with a camp in the culture wars and seek exposure through identity-based media.

heyitsguay··on U.N. talks adjourn without deal to regulate 'killer robots'
Yeah I've been kinda wondering about what the deal is there - given the slow public build-up of forces it seems hard to imagine Russia going forward with an old-school invasion when all those troops will just be drone fodder. Is it for internal propaganda? A way to gather intelligence on Ukraine's defensive responses? I'm sure it's hard to tell from the outside.
heyitsguay··on U.N. talks adjourn without deal to regulate 'killer robots'
Chemical weapons were banned because they weren't very effective on the battlefield and generated horrible PR for all involved, so it was an easy win for everyone to ban them.

The problem with autonomous weapon platforms (probably swarms) is that it looks like they're very powerful weapons that give their users advantages over existing capabilities. Enforcing a ban on them will be like enforcing a ban on gunpowder with swords and castles.

heyitsguay··on Housing is both a human right and a profitable asset, and that’s the problem
You're right, it's the negative vs positive rights thing. So there for sure is a difference, and the stance that the government's purpose is to protect the rights of the empowered and to hell with anything that helps anyone else is a consistent viewpoint that I just strongly disagree with.
heyitsguay··on Housing is both a human right and a profitable asset, and that’s the problem
There is no possible delineation. Anything you can't be deprived of is a thing that others are forced to provide you under state compulsion. What falls under that category is up to social consensus, and is subject to change and debate, as we're seeing with housing now in response to skyrocketing prices and the perverse incentives of the prominence of a house as a reliable investment vehicle.
heyitsguay··on We invited an AI to debate its own ethics in the Oxford Union
Gosh, how embarrassing. Did any of you all ever see those pictures of the baby monkeys given a rough stuffed blob to act as a mother figure, which the babies then clung to? It made me feel a certain hard-to-describe mixture of pain and pity, for this creature that was investing so much meaning into what anyone could see was a very crude simulacrum. Reading this article gave me a bit of a flashback to that feeling, albeit tinged with more of a mean smirk at these foolish humans who really ought to know better. Of course when you prompt a text generator with "AI will never be ethical", it'll give you a paragraph on the subject! And of course when you prompt it with "AI can be ethical", it'll generate follow-up to that too. There may one day be an interesting debate to be had between humans and an AI with some sort of persistent internal world model, but this is more like a bunch of serious humans huddling around a Markov text generator*, waiting on every word with baited breath. Funny, and sad.

* Of course GPT-3 and kin are much more sophisticated than a Markov bot, and i really appreciate the amazing technical achievements that OpenAI has accomplished with models like this. But for people with a firm understanding of the methods being used in these and older text generators, these reactions are quite absurd - the technical accomplishment is that now we can efficiently make use of much longer word histories than simple probabilities based on the previous 1 or 2 words like Markov bots used to do, but these models "know" no more about the world or the words they're producing than the Markov bots.

heyitsguay··on How Coinbase Thinks about the Metaverse
I think most digital services with longevity have endured because they make it easier for humans to achieve their existing wants and needs. Communicating via email is a lot faster than mailed letters - faster, cheaper, and saves you a trip to the post office. For all the shit social media has caused, it caught on because people want to talk to each other. Facebook became publicly available my senior year of high school - I'm in one of the first cohorts that didn't have to just drift apart from everyone I knew when I left my little hometown.

What are the things that VR makes easier? There are some exciting possibilities for games (I love playing around with Unity in VR!), but using a headset is more effort than a mouse and keyboard and monitor, and taking yourself completely out of your surroundings is an added level of separation. Qualitatively, it doesn't seem like the marginal benefits over games and social spaces on screens outweigh the costs for lots of users. Maybe further hardware and ergonomic improvements will tip that balance the other way though.

More egregious lately, in my mind, is how the conversation seems to have shifted to "the" metaverse, rather than "a" metaverse or metaverses. Having a single bounded spatial entity jibes with our intuitions drawn from the physical world and has made for some exciting settings in novels, but it's at odds with decades of precedent building virtual worlds for traditional computers. Metaverses should be like webpages - some small, some big, some simple, some elaborate, with no barriers to travel between them, built off a backbone of open protocols. An alternative of megacorp-curated experiences and artificially-imposed scarcity for the sake for making money seems far more bleak, I don't think it's a place where i could find fun or lasting value.

heyitsguay··on Power imbalances and sex
I'm saying that if you're trying to understand dynamics of power and sex and your conclusion is that the big issues are men are traumatized because nobody liked them as teens and older women ask for too much, you're so far off the mark from the real world that there's no point in trying to explain the disconnect. My comment wasn't to educate anyone, just a beacon for anyone else who is disheartened by the collective psyche of the folks who post about women on HN.

None of this is disputing the broad gendered trends in "sexual value" (ew) by the way - aging is social hell for women as far as I can tell.

heyitsguay··on The future of artificial intelligence is self-organizing and self-assembling
Not as much as you'd think. The original paper sets up its models so that Swin-T ~ ResNet-50 and Swin-S ~ ResNet-101 in compute and memory usage. They're still a bit higher in my experience, but i can also do drop-in replacements for ResNets and get better results on the same tasks and datasets, even when the datasets aren't huge.
heyitsguay··on The future of artificial intelligence is self-organizing and self-assembling
This take is both overly cynical and downplays the contributions people like Lecun and Bengio have made to the field of machine learning, both through their own work and their academic progeny. I see you work broadly in the area, but I doubt your research touches on anything they've affected (that you know of) if you earnestly feel that way.

This article's focus doesn't strike me as especially aligned with current problems in applied AI (how will self-organizing systems relate to prediction problems in NLP, tabular data, or computer vision?) but the connections to robotics are plausible, and in any case the tone doesn't come off as a wannabe thought leader trying to stake a claim, more like an excited learner who is really interested in some new ideas in a niche that may end up being narrower than they currently hope. I won't be assembling object detectors this way any time soon, but it was still a really pleasant read.

heyitsguay··on The future of artificial intelligence is self-organizing and self-assembling
That's how i felt at first, but getting deeper into the Swin transformer paper it actually makes a fair bit of sense - convolutions can be likened to self-attention ops that can only attend to local neighborhoods around pixels. That's a fairly sensible assumption for image data, but it also makes sense that more general attention would better capture complex spatial relationships if you can find a way to make it computationally feasible. Swin transformers certainly go through some contortions to get there, and I bet we'll see cleaner hierarchical architectures in the future, but the results speak for themselves.
heyitsguay··on Web3 is going just great
It's not bullshit but it's also not very useful compared to existing alternatives (compare latency, availability, and reliability), and it requires juuust enough technical knowledge to understand why that you can still build a convincing narrative about it for laypeople. Which you are incentivized to do when their buy-in makes you money.
heyitsguay··on Kryptology: Coinbase’s Open Source Cryptography Library
Clearly, we must augment these computational systems with a social mechanism by which experts on system rules can interpret their intent and make judgements when things go awry. To make it fair when there's a problem, we could even let each party have their own rule experts make their cases before an impartial third party rule expert!
heyitsguay··on Weird: Generative Art in Common Lisp
That's really beautiful, awesome work and explanation of how it was done!
heyitsguay··on Buy Nothing groups offer an antidote to waste and isolation
For local activities tied to IRL interactions, a key benefit of FB groups is the lack of anonymity - easier to block people and alert the group to scams or other malicious activity. It's not perfect and there are still ways to subvert policies, but it seems to work in practice. I wish there were other popular options for explicitly-not-anonymous social media, perhaps we'll see some eventually.
heyitsguay··on Miramax Sues Quentin Tarantino over Planned ‘Pulp Fiction’ NFTs
Lolol yup, now you understand NFTs :)
heyitsguay··on Miramax Sues Quentin Tarantino over Planned ‘Pulp Fiction’ NFTs
The owner would have their name in a distributed ledger next to a hash of some representation of the associated content. Their legal rights to the content itself would be unaffected by the process and would instead be determined by the traditional legal contracts surrounding the ownership of the property. Which, as the article indicates, Miramax is keen to assert.

Tarantino could sell as many NFTs of the underlying asset as he chooses, since they have no relationship to it.

heyitsguay··on AWS down again?
Can't speak to their particular config, but at least LivePatch for Ubuntu can apply most updates without the need to restart.
← PreviousPage 8 of 15Next →