HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

heymijo

2,927 karma · joined August 1, 2016

heymijo.hn at gmail
submissionscomments
heymijo··on A 2020 Vision of Linear Algebra
You're between a rock and a hard place.

The rock are the incentives, how your performance is measured, and the short duration you will have teaching these students.

The hard place is students who have likely spent 13 years in K-12 learning without understanding and are now being asked to do engage in practices they have little to no experience with.* They also have incentives to get good grades and a good GPA, which can be at odds with actual learning.

*To get more concrete, the practices have a name--Standards for Mathematical Practice (SMPs). The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics developed them and considers them the "heart and soul" of the Common Core Mathematics Standards. Not only are these practices absent from most classrooms, all too many teachers are not even aware of them! (see my Notch Generation reply to Sriram to understand why)

https://www.teacherstep.com/breaking-down-the-common-cores-8...

heymijo··on A 2020 Vision of Linear Algebra
Hi Sriram, a teaching system can incorporate both!

Apologies if my original reply made it seem like it can't.

Why don't teaching systems in America incorporate both the majority of the time?

Two major reasons:

1. Cultural inertia. Most teachers emulate the pedagogy that they experienced in their schooling. Some are aware that you can try to mix conceptual+procedural and try to. I call them the "notch generation"- trying to teach in a way that is different than they were taught. It's hard to do because...

2. The system is not designed to accommodate it. Incentives and higher order effects all conspire with cultural inertia to thwart it.

heymijo··on Waymo has raised $3B in the last two months
That all makes a lot of sense especially in light of the lack of urgency to bring things to market that has been reported about Google X throughout its history.
heymijo··on A 2020 Vision of Linear Algebra
Durable and flexible knowledge...

After reading your comment and ansible's reply [0] I wanted to pause and comment on this.

The United States Air Force Academy found that its cadets who took their first calculus class with a professor who focused on conceptual understanding helped those cadets create a durable and flexible understanding of the math [1].

The kicker is that the cadets got worse scores in Calculus I and gave professors who taught in this way worse ratings.

Ansible's anecdotal reply is what a lot of students experience. A feeling of initial success with the material, but they later find that their knowledge of it was fleeting and inflexible. What the Air Force Academy study found was that professors who taught in the manner ansible described, that resulted in fleeting and inflexible knowledge, were rated higher by their students. Those students got better initial scores in Calculus I, but went on to do worse in later calculus courses and related courses.

I encourage you to read the study. It is as good of a study design and execution you can get in the social sciences.

David Epstein also discusses the study in Chapter 4 of his book, Range [2].

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23154241 [1] http://faculty.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/scarrell/profqual2.p... [2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/41795733-range

heymijo··on Waymo has raised $3B in the last two months
Fossuser gave the best answer thus far to your question. [0]

A few confounders I haven't seen though:

1) Waymo is its own entity, but its brand is linked to Google/Alphabet. A reader of this article will be clear on that by the time they have gotten through the sub-headline.

Any success or catastrophic failure of Waymo/self-driving will have Google spoken of in the same breath as Waymo.

2) Capital Allocation & Diversification - Google had $119 Billion of cash on hand at the end of FY2019 earning no return. More than any other company.

- Alphabet is not Berkshire Hathaway waiting in the wings to deploy its capital in a downturn or buy up unrelated businesses.

- Diversification is a fine strategy, but when you have this much capital to allocate—and ostensibly Alphabet has this much because they don't know what to do with it—not fully funding Waymo itself doesn't make sense.

3) The Waymo blog post about this that Rutledge linked below gives a possible alternative [1]

> “Today, we're expanding that team, adding financial investors and important strategic partners who bring decades of experience investing in and supporting successful technology companies building transformative products. With this injection of capital and business acumen, alongside Alphabet, we’ll deepen our investment in our people, our technology, and our operations, all in support of the deployment of the Waymo Driver around the world.”

Building technology is hard, but building out a car company that can produce vehicles on any scale is also hard. Tesla and Elon now know this.

So maybe by opening up to outside investment they allow strategic partners to share in the risk and outsized reward of success.

Curiously though, only one of the six outside investors listed seem to be "strategic." That would be Magna International, "a leading global automotive supplier."

The other investors are:

- AutoNation: a used/new car buying/selling website

- Andreessen Horowitz: VC firm

- Canada Pension Plan Investment Board

- Silver Lake: private equity

- Mubadala Investment Company: United Arab Emirates sovereign wealth fund

From the outside looking in, I have further questions as to how those are "strategic" investments that could help develop and/or bring Waymo cars to market.

tl;dr Alphabet/Google has so much capital it needs to deploy not using it to fully fund Waymo is curious. Waymo is not a distinct brand from Google/Alphabet. It's not readily apparent how six of the seven outside investors chosen for the "strategic" investment add value beyond capital.

[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23157082

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23156434

heymijo··on A struggling Rust Belt city pinned its revival on a self-chilling beverage can
> Now, Youngstown’s approach to economic development is coming under greater scrutiny as the city’s former finance director and a prominent developer prepare to face trial on public corruption charges. At the heart of the case are allegations that officials steered taxpayer funds to favored projects in exchange for bribes.

Corruption runs deep in Youngstown. Search for "Youngstown corruption" and you'll get a grab bag of "mob/mafia/politicians/FBI" from any decade post-WWII to present.

FTA: > Among the offenders are Enviva Materials, a tire recycling operation; Industrial Waste Control, a pressure-washing and waste handling business; and Domestic Linen Co., a uniform laundry and rental operation. All received 10-year tax abatements without creating a single new job or substantially missing their employment targets.

Some firms, like Allied Consolidated Industries Inc., a steel erecting and dismantling company, received back-to-back incentive packages, even after reneging on their initial agreement.

I think corruption is Occam's Razor here.

Source: grew up in Cleveland reading about Youngstown's corruption and watching clowns like former Congressman James Trafficant [0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Traficant#Trial_and_expu...

heymijo··on Complexity Has to Live Somewhere
Thank you, that's helpful.

Is a Mealy state machine implied in your description?

heymijo··on Complexity Has to Live Somewhere
> One change would cause another issue, or regress a bug.

> made a chart of every path and pattern of events

> It never had to be addressed again

Am I reading you correctly--every possible issue was knowable and preventable with enough prior thought?

heymijo··on Mark Zuckerberg Asserts Control of Facebook, Pushing Aside Dissenters
Board of directors are like courtiers of old in a monarch's court.

They are there for the proximity to power. They scheme, connive, and work to improve their own position.

In the court of Zuckerberg, the courtiers exist at his behest, and his only. The directors who forget this are banished.

In other courts, the courtiers have more power because they can remove the CEO.

But even in courts where all of the power isn't concentrated in the CEO, heads can roll, and sycophants can be installed. Steve Jobs' return to Apple comes to mind.

heymijo··on Teenagers are better behaved and less hedonistic (2018)
This is true!

However, it ignores a few things. There is always an advantage to being ahead, even at state schools.

Come in with more AP credits or college credit plus? - Get priority scheduling over your peers

Get priority scheduling - More likely to be able to graduate in 4 years

Come in with more credits, take less gen ed requirements and get into a major earlier - Build relationships with faculty in your major sooner, more opportunities come your way, internships, etc.

It's compounding, but instead of for interest in your bank account, it's your life.

heymijo··on Teenagers are better behaved and less hedonistic (2018)
> being young in 2020 in the hyper-competitive culture of major coastal metro areas of the US

I think you'd be surprised how many 8th graders across the country are already stressing about SAT/ACT scores in places like southeast Ohio or Branson, MO.

I just pulled Branson out of a hat and here's their recommendations for ACT/SAT testingv[0]. I've seen a lot of schools across the U.S. This schedule matches up with offical recs, but it's half the story.

Goodhart's Law is in effect here. Those who are ahead will try to cement their leads. So official recs are ACT/SAT round 1 junior year. Those at the head of the pack find ways to test as early as middle school. These students know the game and feel the pressure, even when their families aren't pushing that hard.

This culture is institutionalized in places well beyond the coasts and major metros.

[0] https://www.branson.k12.mo.us/Page/3011

heymijo··on How to Speak (2018) [video]
What do you think enabled the analogy to work for you even though you hadn't heard of Mary Lou Retton?
heymijo··on How to Speak (2018) [video]
That's a good point about "famous olympic gymnast." I wonder if being familiar with the olympics is enough?

Also, with Simone Biles in the popular zeitgeist I wonder if someone not familiar with Mary Lou Retton might picture Simone instead when hearing "famous olympic gymnast."

heymijo··on How to Speak (2018) [video]
Were you familiar with her prior to the lecture?

Did the point he was speaking about resonate with you?

heymijo··on How to Speak (2018) [video]
Agreed. He did explain, and still I'm trying to put myself in the shoes of someone unfamiliar with her. If I have never heard of her, how strongly does that anecdote land to convey the message about knowledge being a big K in the formula and far more important than talent?

Were you familiar with her prior to the lecture?

Did you know what the iconic hands in the air thing meant?

heymijo··on How to Speak (2018) [video]
Communication is perception. Whose perception? The recipient(s).

I'm 2 minutes in. Lecturer revealed a formula for quality speaking. Knowledge, he says, is the biggest of the three components.

He then takes about a minute using an anecdote about Mary Lou Retton to demonstrate why knowledge is so important.

And yet, I'm wondering, how many people in his audience know enough about who she is to understand what he seems to want to say is an important point?

If they don't, then I think he just lost a bunch of them in the first two minutes.

Communication is perception and if his audience can't perceive his analogy, he hasn't communicated.

heymijo··on Systems that defy detailed understanding
This lines up with a principle from the Toyota Production System (TPS) in manufacturing--reduce complexity.

In TPS, they found that a focus on reducing complexity leads to improvements in the metrics you'd want to measure: better quality, reduced costs, and customer satisfaction.

heymijo··on Airbnb Paying More Than 10% Interest on $1B Financing Announced Monday
What of the employees?

Five days ago the Financial Times reported on Airbnb lowering its internal valuation from $31 billion to $26 billion.

They also mentioned the delay of any IPO and said this:

>The push to go public was motivated, in part, by expiring stock options held by staff.

What happens to the employees in this situation?

heymijo··on Show HN: Play poker with friends. No cards or chips needed
Serendipity. I was just looking for something like this.

Looked in to blockchain.poker and PPPoker, but all I really wanted was a way to re-create an in-person poker game with friends. I look forward to trying this out.

Thanks for sharing it.

heymijo··on How many jobs can be done at home? [pdf]
> 2) do companies want to pay you as much if you work from home?

Is there anyone out there with a good argument for why remote workers should be paid less?

Especially interested in hearing from anyone not incentivized by this practice (eg not the CEO or Chief People Officer of an org that practices this)

> will people abuse the system such that it ruins it for everybody else

An inevitable question and likely consequence.

A counter question: are the myriad ways in-office employees game/abuse the system working materially worse than how remote workers might?

heymijo··on Industry spent millions selling recycling, to sell more plastic
I think this is an excellent comment when taken by itself.

As a defensive human however, I think it assumes something about my original comment that is not there.

heymijo··on Honda bucks industry trend by removing touchscreen controls
You are correct.

> The US Navy is replacing touch screen controls on destroyers, after the displays were implicated in collisions.

Unfamiliarity with the touch screens contributed to two accidents that caused the deaths of 17 sailors, said incident reports.

Poor training meant sailors did not know how to use the complex systems in emergencies, they said.

Sailors "overwhelmingly" preferred to control ships with wheels and throttles, surveys of crew found.

https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-49319450

heymijo··on Industry spent millions selling recycling, to sell more plastic
I see plastics as our generations asbestos.

Analogy isn't perfect, but it's a material we saw as benign that could end up having untold impact on our bodies.

heymijo··on Ask HN: How to self study management, especially supply chain management?
> (like "The Goal"...These last two books are classics dealing with physical production.

The Phoenix Project is a 2013 IT/DevOps version of The Goal [0]. It's an easy read that would be a complementary follow up to The Goal. It would help in understanding principles from The Goal outside of physical production.

[0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/17255186-the-phoenix-pro...

heymijo··on Macy’s to Furlough 100k Employees
> At least they can stay on their health insurance.

FTA: At least through May

heymijo··on New Grad vs. Senior Dev
I think this seems like a good critique, but as you noticed this is a nascent concept for me. As I learn more, I'll have this critique in mind.
heymijo··on The internet should be a public utility
1) Ownership

Nationalized companies are owned by the state. AT&T had/has private shareholders.

2) Control

With ownership comes control. The U.S. government granted AT&T a conditional monopoly. In the early 20th century it was in exchange for extending service across the nation. Mid-20th century for defense work.

Aside from these conditions the U.S. government did not exert control on AT&T's operations.

heymijo··on New Grad vs. Senior Dev
This sounds like the phenomenon dubbed Chesterton's Fence [0].

A core component of making great decisions is understanding the rationale behind previous decisions. If we don’t understand how we got “here,” we run the risk of making things much worse.

So you helped the new dev understand the current lay of the land. They listened, then suggested an improvement based on their new understanding. You agreed and together improved the code.

[0] https://fs.blog/2020/03/chestertons-fence/

heymijo··on The internet should be a public utility
You seem to have interpreted this as monopoly prices were less than today's prices.

My read of the parent comment is that monopoly era phone service from AT&T was cheaper when compared to phone service in other parts of the world during that era.

I can't speak to the veracity of this claim.

heymijo··on The internet should be a public utility
> We had nationalized telecommunications for over 70 years

No.

Until 1982 AT&T in the United States was a legal monopoly, not a nationalized telecom.

The book, The Idea Factory about Bell Labs has most of the history including why the the defense work Bell Labs did during WWII and beyond helped them justify a nationwide monopoly on telecom.

← PreviousPage 7 of 18Next →