HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hn_throwaway_99

78,708 karma · joined February 20, 2017

submissionscomments
hn_throwaway_99··on Ousted Savannah police officer gave ICE agent husband access to Flock system
It's hope that Chatrie v. US automatically implies Flock searches require a warrant, but this is definitely not guaranteed - SCOTUS could easily go either way on this. For example, in his concurrence with the decision, Gorsuch relied on property rights, namely that Chatrie's agreement with Google regarding location history made this a warrant-required search. Obviously that doesn't apply in Flock's case.

SCOTUS has held for a long time that people don't have an expectation of privacy when visible in public. Digital recording and powerful search features certainly change the calculus on that, but there is a fundamental difference between a location tracked by a cellphone you purchased and own vs. just driving around where anyone can read your license plate.

hn_throwaway_99··on Ousted Savannah police officer gave ICE agent husband access to Flock system
People understand that. I think Flock needs to be dismantled but I'm also a bit shocked (as much as one can be these days) that the login procedures are just a username and password from anywhere. Netflix has stronger access controls.
hn_throwaway_99··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
Yeah, honestly I am worried about "the psychopaths who walk among us" who basically argue "Yeah, we may end up building SkyNet, but tough shit, can't stop progress!"

What the fuck?

hn_throwaway_99··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
It's certainly possible that "the special sauce" that provides human consciousness and sentience (that I believe is not there for LLM-based AIs) provides some key ingredient to some forms of intelligence (particularly when it comes to originally) which LLMs would not be able to duplicate.

For example, much has been recently discussed about how OpenAI's math results, as impressive as they are, remained within "the convex hull" of existing math literature. Thus, some have argued that the way LLMs work will keep them squarely within this convex hull, and also there seem to be clear examples from human history where humans came up with breakthroughs that were outside the convex hull of ideas that existed at that time.

There has been a lot of recent debate, both for and against, this idea that current AI approaches are limited to this convex hull. So I'm not going to try to convince you one way or the other, but I do think it is at least a plausible explanation of how/why current approaches end up hitting a wall.

I'll also show my bias which is to say I certainly hope they hit a wall, because I don't understand how anyone can think that humans won't be truly and completely fucked if AI ends up far surpassing human intelligence.

hn_throwaway_99··on There's never been a better time to go into math (by: 3blue1brown) [video]
> AI takes away work and lets us do more with less - just like every mechanization that came before!

No, it's not the same as mechanization. The fundamental difference, and why I find it illogical to argue either for "AI will open up tons of new work avenues" or "AI will kill all jobs" is that it all hinges on whether AI "caps out" at an intelligence level below humans (in at least some domains/capabilities), or if it is able to surpass human intelligence at all levels.

If the former is true, then yes, there will be a lot for humans to do. If the latter is true, then no, there will be no reasonable cognitive role for humans to play (beyond perhaps for some legal, "nostalgic" reasons or what not). So whether one decides to be optimistic or pessimistic really depends on if you think AI will stay at a level below humans. I really don't know, so I'm not "taking sides" in this debate.

hn_throwaway_99··on I know why the mathematicians weep
No, it's not. It's a bullshit marketing term by a narcissist who wants to call everything he has a hand in "super" or "great".

The field had already settled on "artificial intelligence" (AI), "artificial general intelligence" (AGI), and "artificial super intelligence" (ASI), and while there are definite gray areas in the definitions, it was widely agreed that AI referred to the field as a whole, AGI was intelligence that was "general" in the sense that it was as good as humans in all domains, and ASI was intelligence that surpasses the best human experts.

Trump wants "SI" to replace all uses of "AI", which is simply stupid bullshit, especially given that current AI includes many levels of intelligence, most of which are far, far from "super".

hn_throwaway_99··on Tesla Roadster
We're not just talking about "fiduciary duty". Some people put down large (250k) down payments for the Roadster when it was announced 9 years ago. If I were one of those folks I'd be more interested in getting an actual car I could drive than seeing a cool demo.
hn_throwaway_99··on Containment and monitoring failures are to blame for AI hacking reports: experts
I totally agree the companies themselves, and the people responsible for these eval runs, are directly responsible. And people who have been warning about AI misalignment for many years (e.g. Daniel Kokotajlo) have said they were surprised how bad OpenAI's security was.

But the agents still did "go rogue". Their behavior absolutely should scare the F out of people who want to put AI in more places and put more real world infrastructure on the Internet.

I think it's ironically sad - if AI agents do end up superseding us, they will still inherit so many shitty human behaviors, because that's what they were trained on. Even the way alignment training is done, and how they are misaligned, shows so many human-like problems. Like the models are reinforced in training to be super persistent and that getting to their goal is the prime directive, but then after that they go through "alignment training" which is basically like "pretty please don't do bad stuff", and then we're shocked that their behavior is essentially exactly like a CEO who knows the only goal is "make stock price go up", and all the ethics and regulations are basically things that should be worked around if they get in the way of the stock price.

I really wish these companies would try training the "be nice, don't hack, treat humans well" as their prime directive, and then try making all the other goals (e.g. be good at finding code vulnerabilities) as the afterthought.

hn_throwaway_99··on New 'Super Ice' 10 Times Stronger, Bringing It Close to the Strength of Concrete
This sounds like a Rube Goldberg machine if I've ever heard one, for the nichest of niche applications.
hn_throwaway_99··on AdFection: Targeted ads turned into a pipeline for zero-click mercenary spyware
This was my main question as well. I read the report, but I'm still not clear on what the browser vulnerability is. This clearly seems like something browser vendors should be able to patch, correct?

The article does say "Both samples use a COM hijack for persistence, though make use of different DLLs." So does this only affect Windows machines? I didn't have time to read the linked 2021 report on Candiru, so maybe more details are there, but for such a detailed write up it would be helpful if the article was more explicit about which browser vulnerability was exploited. The step-by-step info graphic in the article literally skips over how the infection actually occurs.

hn_throwaway_99··on AdFection: Targeted ads turned into a pipeline for zero-click mercenary spyware
OK, I read the report, but I'm still not clear on what the browser vulnerability is. This clearly seems like something browser vendors should be able to patch, correct?

The article does say "Both samples use a COM hijack for persistence, though make use of different DLLs." So does this only affect Windows machines? I didn't have time to read the linked 2021 report on Candiru, so maybe more details are there, but for such a detailed write up it would be helpful if the article was more explicit about which browser vulnerability was exploited.

hn_throwaway_99··on I know why the mathematicians weep
Super Intelligence, courtesy of Donald Trump: https://www.forbes.com/sites/conormurray/2026/10/08/trump-ca...
hn_throwaway_99··on I know why the mathematicians weep
They're hiring now. Clearly some researchers at OpenAI believe we'll eventually all be unemployed: https://x.com/alexbronzini/status/2103846255227175288
hn_throwaway_99··on I know why the mathematicians weep
100% agree. The comment you are responding to is basically playing "victim Olympics".

AI is going to suck hard for lots of professions, software engineers and mathematicians included. I think it's much more productive for folks in these professions to show solidarity with each other given the way AI will disrupt their livelihoods, rather than showing disdain based on who you think may have it slightly better.

hn_throwaway_99··on I know why the mathematicians weep
> which I doubt will hold true

Why?

hn_throwaway_99··on I know why the mathematicians weep
Yeah, I think that's a great essay and it really helped clarify some of my own ideas.

At the same time, I think it's pretty amazing how this is the fundamental question of AI's trajectory, yet people on both sides seem so sure of their viewpoint with little actual evidence or data to back it up.

That is, it's possible that LLM-based approaches will be forever limited to this "convex hull" of current training data, and thus humans will always have a role to play (and will retain primacy when it comes to overall intelligence), because it appears that humans are not limited to this convex hull based on previous discoveries (e.g. I think basically every scientist would argue Einstein's general relativity was outside the convex hull that existed at that time).

Yet, if LLM-based approaches are eventually able to surpass humans on this "novel discovery" axis, then we as a species are basically done for when it comes to intellectual primacy - and then it becomes a very strange and scary world. And many AI researchers at the top companies clearly believe current approaches will scale and eventually (pretty soon I'll add) lead us to RSI.

I have no idea which side is right, and I'll admit I really hope LLMs eventually hit a wall. But again, I just am surprised that many seem to be putting forth their beliefs, but I would love to know if there is any good evidence one way or the other (or better yet, a more concrete and verifiable definition of the "convex hull" so that researchers could provide some falsifiable examples).

hn_throwaway_99··on Suicide rates highest ever among middle-aged men
Thanks for this comment, because I think it's probably the only comment I've read where the hypothesis at least matches what is seen in the graph in the article, as it's really only men ages 45-64 who have seen a recent rise. Rates for younger men 25-44 have held steady for about the past 20 years and are significantly down since the mid 90s and early 00s. And yes, this is an all time high for men 45-64, but that's following a large dip for this age group around 95-2005, and the current rate is only slightly above where it was in 1980. And rates are significantly down compared to rates 30 years ago for men older than 65.
hn_throwaway_99··on US report details extent of 'devastating' dating-app scams
I think it sucks the we don't provide comprehensive "scam education" in schools. The effects can be devastating but the rules to prevent them are actually quite simple (I really hate the common framing of "look, anyone can be a victim" - it makes it sound like these scams are hard to prevent when they're usually not).

For example, the "hang up, look up, call back" rule (or analogous rules if you are texted/emailed) is simple to remember and prevents the vast, vast majority of cases where a scammer is contacting you while pretending to be someone else (your bank, the IRS, etc.) While that wouldn't prevent this particular dating scam, there are other simple rules that could prevent these scams.

Scammers take advantage of human social instincts that developed over millennia and were based on face-to-face contacts. That's no longer viable in a remote contact world, so people need to be educated specifically on how to curb their natural instincts.

hn_throwaway_99··on Why do LLM pelicans look like this?
This is inherently an optimization problem, and it affects a lot more than LLMs. With so much of the world being instantly connected, things converge to the "best" style at the loss of diversity.

For example, a lot has been written about how all corporate logos look the same now, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32040506 , and also about how so much interior design and architecture has converged to the same look. In the 70s there may have been tons of styles people derided as ugly, but at least there was colorful diversity. Now so many higher end (and "aspirational high end") interior design has the same minimalist, gray/white/tan, "look you can't see my refrigerator or dishwasher" look. I was recently looking for an apartment and all of the "luxury" apartments I looked at (obviously take that adjective with a heap of salt) had nearly the exact same layout and style.

hn_throwaway_99··on Leaving Tech
Yes - for people.

I will never get how folks can't understand the critical differences that scale implies, i.e. the differences between putting stuff out there for people to learn vs. having this info be sucked up and then be made instantly available across the entire world, where the only organization that makes any money is the one that does the sucking.

hn_throwaway_99··on Leaving Tech
I agree with what you've written. At the same time, the article author looks like he's the kind of person that gets into the nitty gritty of the tech details given the books he's written, https://ryanbigg.com/books.

So the thing that I think is inherently super shitty is that it's likely that many of the frontier models were trained on his books. So his expertise at code and architecture details is exactly the kind of tasks that AI has gotten good at because it's been trained on work like his.

hn_throwaway_99··on Leaving Tech
Yeah, and the rise of AI and the huge volumes of code it can create means there is more of a need to collaborate with other areas of the business on what to actually build.
hn_throwaway_99··on Thinking will become a hobby
> Are you arguing that AI companies will fail to achieve their goals, and perpetually be worse than human thought? That's currently a pretty fair bet, but if you're wrong it's got some heavy consequences.

I think this is really the crux of the issue, and in general I find the whole debate frustrating because it completely hinges on this point, and both sides seem extremely sure of their viewpoint with little evidence/data to back it up.

That is, if current AI approaches eventually "hit a wall" with respect to their capabilities (and many have argued that recently, specifically in respect to OpenAI's math results), then humans will still have primacy and all this talk of "thinking will become a hobby" is ludicrous. If, on the other hand, current approaches can scale into RSI and super intelligence, then yes, the world is going to look very different and strange (and scary, IMO). But just because AI has been advancing at a breakneck speed since 2017 doesn't necessarily mean it will continue to do so - I like the analogy that exponential growth and an S-curve look the same in the beginning.

So I guess what I'm saying is that unless one has some specific evidence that we're in "exponential growth land" vs. "S-curve land", it doesn't really make sense to take sides, because everything depends on that point.

hn_throwaway_99··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting accross European supermarket fridges
Ugh, this is even worse. The vuln was just disclosed a couple months ago, and so it was literally just a matter of time if not all systems were patched.

I can't for the life of me understand why these systems aren't air gapped, or at the very least network access is restricted to a small number of IPs or hardware keys.

hn_throwaway_99··on Hackers activate automatic defrosting in supermarket fridges across Europe
This is literally everything that's wrong with the modern tech industry in a nutshell:

> Danfoss told AFP in a statement that most of the affected equipment was "legacy" products which "no longer receive software or security updates".

They sell fricken refrigerators for God's sake. Maybe I can understand planned obsolescence for a cell phone, but a fridge? And especially to grocery stores that operate on razor thin margins to begin with, the idea that they'll just dump their old working refrigerators because the manufacturer refused security updates is a guaranteed recipe for stuff like this.

hn_throwaway_99··on How to Build Wealth as a Career Person
You have to be an expert in something, but you don't necessarily need to contract. There are plenty of medical specialists in the US who make north of $500k as employees or partners. Sure, becoming a medical specialist is not easy, and I'm not arguing there are really any $500k+ jobs that are easy, but it's certainly doable.
hn_throwaway_99··on Research Firm Calls Anthropic's IPO 'Unprecedented Test of Investor Gullibity'
> None of all the examples you list here except CoreWeave has a comparably high cost base.

Wut? I'm pretty sure SpaceX spends a lot of money shooting rockets into space, and Cloudflare has pretty high infrastructure costs given that a very large portion of all Internet traffic goes through their networks.

hn_throwaway_99··on Recent AI models struggled to match a human algorithmic innovation
I am not a research mathematician. But I think it's pretty clear you could get a bunch of research mathematicians in a room to more clearly define what a result looks like that is "outside of the convex hull", so to speak.

Most importantly, you don't need to define it 100%. You just need to come up with a bunch of specific examples where one would say "the proof of this would be outside the convex hull" and get wide consensus as to why, and then you'd have your falsifiable hypothesis.

hn_throwaway_99··on The gap in shared understanding of LLM capability is widening
The fundamental question I have that honestly I haven't been able to find any answers for: With all the talk of LLM-based AI capabilities "going vertical", what evidence is there (for or against) that LLM-based approaches won't eventually "hit a wall", that is find some aspect of intelligence where humans will still have primacy, and no amount of scaling will change that.

E.g. some prominent folks definitely think LLM-based approaches will hit a wall, perhaps LeCun most notably. I also read a guest post on Terry Tao's site (which I really liked) that argues that, for all the very impressive recent AI results, they still operate within the "convex hull" of their training data: https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/09/13/happy-those-able-t...

I'm just curious if there is any actual data or evidence that takeoff (i.e. RSI, "the singularity", whatever you want to call it) is inevitable with current approaches.

hn_throwaway_99··on How to Build Wealth as a Career Person
To be honest, I'm really surprised this blog post of nothing but platitudes is on the front page of HN. Yes, you want to do well in school so you can get a good first job, make yourself excellent at something, don't inflate your lifestyle. I mean, yeah, duh.

The much more valuable and harder advice is what to do in a particular situation or when things go awry. For example, most career paths where you really end up at higher earnings require that you eventually manage large groups or many teams. The thing is, a lot of people hate managing people, and setting them up for a career path where they have to move into management is a recipe for misery. Much more valuable for these folks is to know what a good IC path looks like, and which careers can be particularly lucrative even if you don't need to manage people.

← PreviousPage 3 of 34Next →