Without getting into the legal contours of each, I'd say the defamation claim is at the bottom of the list of Zenefit's legal concerns here.
[1] http://www.scribd.com/doc/268286803/ADP-v-Zenefits-Defamatio...
207 karma · joined February 18, 2015
Without getting into the legal contours of each, I'd say the defamation claim is at the bottom of the list of Zenefit's legal concerns here.
[1] http://www.scribd.com/doc/268286803/ADP-v-Zenefits-Defamatio...
See this study(1) showing that the best two cyclists out of 11 world class professionals tested had a VO2max that was closer to this amateur reporter (before doping) than to the elite cyclists with the highest VO2max. (1) https://d3epuodzu3wuis.cloudfront.net/R063.pdf
Of the 11 world class cyclists tested, the best two riders were in the bottom 4 (<70 ml/kg/min) in pure VO2max. Interestingly, that means those two riders were closer to the amateur reporter in this story, even before the doping, than they were to the pros with the highest VO2max.
________
RUNNING PREDICTS RUNNING BETTER THAN PHYSIOLOGY (a duh? moment here)
Noakes, T. D., Myburgh, K. H., & Schall, R. (1990). Peak treadmill running velocity during VO2max test predicts running performance. Journal of Sports Sciences, 8, 35-45.
The best laboratory predictors were: (a) peak treadmill running velocity (r = -.89 to -.94); (b) running velocity at lactate turnpoint (r = -.91 to -.93); and (c) fractional use of VO2max at 16 km/h (r = .86 to .90). The predictive value of the lactate turnpoint measure increased as the distance increased.
The poorest predictors were: VO2max (r = -.55 to -.81) and VO2 at 16 km/h (r = .40 to .45).
If you wanted to translate a $5MM cap, for example, into the equivalent price per share, you need to know how many shares are involved. The noteholders don't know what that number will be when they enter into the notes.
So this really has nothing to do with the notes and everything to do with the cash investor's failure to specify in the termsheet. Unless it's expressly pointed out that what ever pre-money valuation is being offered must include any note conversions, then it seems relatively straightforward that the pre-money would include fully-diluted shares (typically the founders' stock and any option grants). This has nothing to do with the terms of the note--it is simply a matter of what the investor is "valuing" when he gives a pre-money valuation. Don't blame the terms of the notes for a problem that is created by the cash investor's miscommunication.
I don't think that Facebook meant to break "things" like big time securities laws (without even consulting a lawyer or, presumably, even incorporating the business). Maybe no one has done it before because it's illegal--not because it's so innovative.
You are equating criminal incarceration (even unjust incarceration) with intentionally terrorizing innocent African villages, capturing their people and shipping them to another continent to live in chains.
It's a little like the tendency to call bad things, when they are bad enough, "genocide" or "holocaust" despite the very specific meanings of those words.
How could it possibly be true that in the 100 years between 1770 and 1870, the fastest milers lost a full 30 seconds (25% performance decrease)[1]? How could it be that men like Thomas Horspool[2] were widely recognized as champions and world record holders while running so much slower than amateurs from only half a century before?
Anyone who has trained seriously on the track would know the type of all-encompassing effort--nutrition, sleep, physical therapy, training--and modern science--VO2Max, heart rate, running economy [3]--that go into training for a four-minute mile. The idea that people were doing all of that in Britain in the 18th century is laughable.
[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/timeline/d3c109a21... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Horspool [3] http://sportsscientists.com/2007/12/running-economy-part-i/
Book bans (in general, with few exceptions) have been recognized as unconstitutional far, far longer than we've had mass adoption of the internet.[1]
Here's the Supreme Court in 1982: "Local school boards may not remove books from school library shelves simply because they dislike the ideas contained in those books …"
To be fair, however, yours is a mistake than many, many people have made -- including some very successful economists.
Coase said that in a world without transaction costs it doesn't matter who the liability falls upon. When you turn to the real world, the fact that it matters greatly who the liability falls on shows just how important transaction costs are.
Coase was trying to get economist to stop ignoring transaction costs and pretending that the type of bargaining in your comment will solve all our problems.
Here's Coase himself:
The world of zero transaction costs has often been
described as a Coasian world. Nothing could be further
from the truth. It is the world of modern economic
theory, one which I was hoping to persuade economists
to leave
Here, read this (pdf). It explains your misunderstanding (shared by many others) in great detail: http://www.deirdremccloskey.com/docs/pdf/Article_306.pdf