HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

hymanroth

200 karma · joined October 26, 2008

David Semeria

Founder of lmframework.com

david at (domain as above)

submissionscomments
hymanroth··on The Anatomy Of The Twitter Attack
The million dollar question: would we have been so interested in how the attack was made if we hadn't had at least a glimpse of the compromised information? In other words, could TC argue that publishing the confidential information was a valid way of raising awareness of the security issue? I'm not convinced, but it's a tough one.
hymanroth··on Myths about Financing Start-ups that Hurt Entrepreneurs
He mentions debt but not security. Most banks won't finance a pre-revenue company without personal guarantees. And if you end-up borrowing against your own assets, you're basically financing yourself.
hymanroth··on If Execution Is What Matters, Where Does That Leave Ideas?
Well, that's a matter of opinion. From what I have read, their method was innovative, hence the patents. The problem with working this kind of stuff out is that history is always biased towards the winners (in the sense that nobody talks about the losers). With that it mind, you could quite possibly be right.
hymanroth··on If Execution Is What Matters, Where Does That Leave Ideas?
Twitter's key insight was to extend a blogging platform to mobile phones (hence the 140 limit). It was definitely innovative and smart, but not the kind of thing they give out Nobel prizes for. I think the Google boys' idea went much deeper, and their indexing methods were completely novel at the time, hence much more relevant results.
hymanroth··on If Execution Is What Matters, Where Does That Leave Ideas?
The whole idea/execution riff is reductionist. Some ideas are more or less obvious. Twitter is a great example: there was basically no idea, it was all execution and marketing. But other ideas are huge. Larry and Sergey's idea of how to index the web was genuinely novel. The best team in the world could have executed on pre-Google search tech and would have got nowhere.

It all depends on the idea: some are just so much better than others...

hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
+1 for humor
hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
I stand corrected then. Respect.
hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
Yes, if the documents only related to how twitter intends to treat UGC, then you would have a point.
hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
Sure, they did it to help the 'little guy'. Page views never entered the equation.
hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
The was a public interest element there. The public has a right to know about those situations.

We may may interested, but we have no underlying right to know everything about a private company's operations and strategy.

hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
When the storm fades away you will go back to the site. TC knows this.
hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
The documents are not so positive.

They diss a large number of celebs, call GOOG and MSFT 'distractions' and really go to town on Marissa Mayer.

hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
There's no doubt the content is fascinating - but they're private documents. TC had no right to publish them, and we should all feel a little guilty for in part legitimizing TC's decision to publish them.
hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
Agreed - it's a crap and immoral defence (sic).

It's unfortunate bloggers don't have their own Geneva Convention (and no, that's not a tech conference in Europe)

hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
Like the part where they call Google and Microsoft a 'distraction'

Or diss Marissa Mayer?

hymanroth··on Twitter’s Internal Strategy Laid Bare: To Be “The Pulse Of The Planet”
TechCrunch's Faustian dilemma: to sell or not to sell its moral soul (or what's left of it) for an astronomical number of page views?

Gee, that was hard - now where's the damn 'post' button?

hymanroth··on Chrome OS - When pull is better than push
But that was the whole point of the post! The OS is no longer the platform - the browser is. We both seem to agree on the need for an open interoperability layer - we just don't seem to agree on where it should go :-)
hymanroth··on Chrome OS - When pull is better than push
One of the key points of the post is that the browser is the platform, not the OS - so, regardless of the specific details of Chrome OS, it can't do much to improve the platform.
hymanroth··on Chrome OS - When pull is better than push
The semantic aspect was only a part of a wider notion of an interoperability layer which can be rolled-out whilst the 'web platform' is still in its formative phase.
hymanroth··on Chrome OS - When pull is better than push
That's a bit off base, and Google is not making a web OS.

What was wrong with the original summary: instead of pushing users into using web apps, big G should pull them in with better ones?

hymanroth··on Chrome OS - When pull is better than push
I was thinking more in terms of an open semantic dictionary containing the top-level concepts most often used by SN and business.

The key point is that it should be open to all applications.

hymanroth··on Ask HN: Critique this idea
This proposal is not too dissimilar to the ideas behind P-BOS (http://lmframework.com/page.php?id=pbos)

P-BOS works best when the modules are small, and hence breaking down individual contributions within a given module does not get too messy.

As to the 'morality' of charging for FOSS, the issue can easily be sidestepped by giving developers complete control of the licensing and payment terms for their modules.

For example, a given module (component) could be free for everyone, or just non-commercial users. Developers should also be similarly free to route a certain percentage (0-100) to charity. The key point is to leave all the key decisions to individual developers.

If anybody wants to know more about P-BOS, feel free to drop me a line: david-lmframework-com

hymanroth··on Kamikaze Marketing (why usage billing kicks freemium's bottom)
How can a model that has never been tried be unpopular?
hymanroth··on Kamikaze Marketing (why usage billing kicks freemium's bottom)
There will always be explicit permission from the consumer.

But you're right about trust. For this reason we are not trying to roll this out ourselves.

hymanroth··on Kamikaze Marketing (why usage billing kicks freemium's bottom)
Thanks, will do
hymanroth··on Kamikaze Marketing (why usage billing kicks freemium's bottom)
The term 'Kamikaze' crops up frequently in the media out of its original context. For example, the UK chancellor used the same term to describe the bankers who created the housing bubble (http://bit.ly/Qdmlj) - so I don't see how it can be tasteless.

I'm sure if a company started giving away free cars in the hope of charging for premium petrol then they would probably attract similar (if not stronger) adjectives. And the workers in the plants making cars for money would certainly get caught in the shrapnel.

As for my blog being ugly - I couldn't agree more.

hymanroth··on Kamikaze Marketing (why usage billing kicks freemium's bottom)
David,

When I wrote the original article I was already aware of Shirky's views on micro payments, but it's true that the comments both here and on my blog made me understand that this issue was more important than I had previously thought - and so for that I am certainly grateful to you.

As to my use of a 'thought experiment' - well I've been doing them ever since I tried to get my head around relativity 20 years ago. I can't remember if Shirky uses a thought experiment in his original article, but even if he does, I don't see it as being particularly relevant.

As to you wanting to short our (yet inexistent stock) - well, I can see you're upset, but isn't that a bit harsh?

hymanroth··on Kamikaze Marketing (why usage billing kicks freemium's bottom)
I disagree. My interpretation of Shirky's thinking is that the dialog is the issue, rather than the payment size.

The key is to create an almost friction-free and fair method of payment. People are happy to pay a fair amount for content (cf. the piracy argument) as long as it's hassle free.

The usage component is essential so that people don't end up paying for services they don't use. If you stop using a service you stop paying for it. No lock-in.

D.

hymanroth··on Kamikaze Marketing (why usage billing kicks freemium's bottom)
Thanks for a great comment.

It's true that we are attempting to solve quite few problems in one go, but this just reflects the nature of the challenge - rather than any particular desire to blow ourselves up.

If you look at AWS, they spent $2 billion implementing their vision of cloud services. They understood that you can't just graft a business model onto existing technology, so they created a platform where the technology and revenue system go hand-in-hand.

We're trying to do something similar for the browser. We don't aim to own or dominate the platform. It will be very open, with space for any number of compatible billing systems.

D.

hymanroth··on Freemium - Shmeemium (or why micro-billing is better)
If you use a service without charge which entails a non-zero cost to produce and supply it, then I'm afraid somebody, somewhere is subsiding it. So that's my first abuse of language sorted.

As to the price of premium services being 'artificially high' - as I make clear in the post - this refers to paying for a benefit that is necessarily incremental (if it wasn't, nobody would use the free service). The price of that benefit is generally excessive when compared to what can be had for nothing.

You many not agree with those words, but I don't think they, too, represent an abuse of language.

← PreviousPage 2 of 3Next →