HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

in_cahoots

1,730 karma · joined December 7, 2014

submissionscomments
in_cahoots··on What happens when even college students can't do math anymore?
Considering private schools cost tens of thousands of dollars and get to choose who they admit, as good (in reading) and worse (in math) than schools with similar demographics seems pretty damning, doesn't it?
in_cahoots··on What happens when even college students can't do math anymore?
Did you read the article? These kids can't even divide a fraction in half. It's basic numeracy and foundational skills that are missing.
in_cahoots··on Hemp ban hidden inside government shutdown bill
The fact that 8 individuals voted says nothing about how any of them actually felt. It's not a coincidence that none of them are up for reelection soon. This was all done with the blessing of leadership, they were just the sacrificial lambs.

In Nancy Pelosi's memoir there is a story about some red-state Democrat who came out publicly against Pelosi on some issue. Turns out the entire scheme was her idea- make the representative look good to his own state by throwing herself under the bus.

I'm not saying any of this is good or bad, but this is what politics actually is. A bunch of behind the scenes scheming to advance leadership's agenda. Not individual politicians voting for what they think is best.

in_cahoots··on Ticker: Don't die of heart disease
I don't know the exact details, but I thought the Framingham survey was just a cross-section of the population. So getting upset about a 50th percentile score makes no sense at a population level.

A quick Google says that the Mesa study was actually of people without cardiovascular disease at the beginning of the study. So again, these conclusions don't make any sense to me.

in_cahoots··on Ryanair flight landed at Manchester airport with six minutes of fuel left
As an aviation fan just reading this thread is quite eye-opening in terms of how much risk tolerance the average commenter has vs what is standard in the aviation community and on aviation forums. It's almost like peeking into two different worlds. I wonder if there would be any value in teaching an "engineering when lives are on the line" or "war stories from accident investigations" classes to new engineers. I feel like there's value in appreciating just how much more work goes into building a system where people's lives are at stake.
in_cahoots··on Bob Ross paintings to be auctioned to fund US public broadcasting
I don't watch the newer Star Treks so I can't connect with you there.

I should have been clearer in my post: PBS shows treat everything in a heavy handed way. Daniel Tiger will explain the main theme of the episode, have characters burst into song repeating that theme over and over again, and then repeat the theme again at the end. It's a long ways from Mr Roger, who seemed to treat kids like little adults. To be honest it's not my cup of tea. But I wouldn't call it the least bit political, just bad writing and/or best practices depending on who you talk to.

in_cahoots··on Bob Ross paintings to be auctioned to fund US public broadcasting
PBS kids shows teach (sometimes via a heavy hand, I'll admit) things like acceptance of people of different skin colors and ability levels. There's a show featuring Inuits called Molly of Denali, not McKinley. Some of the characters are even LGB (not trans as far as I've seen). Sadly in the current world these concepts are considered 'political'.
in_cahoots··on It's just a virus, the E.R. told him – days later, he was dead
I didn't say that technology won't fix anything, merely that it won't fix everything.
in_cahoots··on It's just a virus, the E.R. told him – days later, he was dead
No. I can transcribe every interaction with 100% accuracy, but if those notes aren't used in any way it's not data-driven. This article shows that the notes are inaccurate, suggestions using the notes are routinely ignored, and that doctors and legal review think this process is acceptable. There is no professional or legal liability if the records are wrong. And yet if you talk to a medical professional they'll explain that the records are to establish a legal paper trail if anything goes wrong.

Some executive(s) have been told that detailed medical records are the solution to so many problems in modern medicine. But they lack either the guts or the expertise to make sure that these systems are actually accomplishing what they set out to do.

in_cahoots··on It's just a virus, the E.R. told him – days later, he was dead
For your first example, wouldn't the friction be reduced just by telling patients the business hours of the pharmacies nearby? I hate how this question is always posed, as if I'm supposed to come up with a name and address out of a hat. If it's the middle of the night or Christmas Eve and I'm trying to get medicine for the baby, the provider probably has a better intuition than myself as to which pharmacy will actually serve me. If I ask explicitly, the provider is usually happy to suggest some options. Even a simple web interface listing hours of operation would be better than the current method, where the patient is expected to pick a pharmacy from memory before they even know what medicine they need or how long it will be before they are discharged.
in_cahoots··on It's just a virus, the E.R. told him – days later, he was dead
I think the real implications are much more chilling. As much as we like to believe otherwise, there is always a chance that a seemingly-healthy college kid will drop dead of something that even the best doctor wouldn't have anticipated.

And as much as we would like to believe otherwise, the modern healthcare system is riddled with problems that no technology or checklists will fix. It doesn't take someone's death to verify this- just go read your own charts and discharge papers. Even for something relatively routine there are bound to be inaccuracies. Doctors know this, which is why they spend so much time doing handoffs and interviewing patients.

We pretend that the medical 'record' is infallible, helping to reduce the mental load on doctors while protecting them from liability. But as this case shows, the 'record' is both inaccurate and not useful in showing fault. It's a paper tiger. I'm not saying we should scrap the whole system, but I do think it needs to be examined in a data-driven manner.

in_cahoots··on Autism should not be seen as single condition with one cause, say scientists
They see the same people but definitely don't get the same treatment. The insurance codes are different and the body of research is different. Putting $1 of research into genetic blindness does nothing for preventing astigmatism, even though patients may go to the same doctor.

Saying that everyone who goes to a therapist, or an oncologist gets the same treatment and therefore should be lumped together is absurd. Most other specialties are moving toward taxonomic differentiation, not away from it.

in_cahoots··on Autism should not be seen as single condition with one cause, say scientists
Do blind people and nearsighted people have the same treatment? Saying people with profound autism need the same treatment as people with autism commenting on Hacker News is patently absurd. Go ahead and try offering therapy and workplace accommodations to nonverbal people living in a residential home. You're proving my point for me, we've lost sight of these people.

Even with cancer- the diagnosis and treatment vary tremendously depending on what type of cancer you have, how far along it is, and more recently how your particular genome responds to that version of cancer and each version of treatment. We don't just say, "whoops you have cancer" and start chemotherapy on the targeted area. Your argument doesn't make any sense.

in_cahoots··on Autism should not be seen as single condition with one cause, say scientists
I am way way out of my wheelhouse here. But you asked, so I'll share my experience and opinion in a roundabout way.

When I was a kid, my parents' nicknames for me were Spock and Ms. Literal. I was gifted, at the top of my class, and my parents advocated for me every single year so that I received a high-quality education. The school was receptive, and I thrived academically. I struggled socially, but being a girl it demonstrated in a lack of friends rather than behavioral disruption. So in every way I was the ideal student. Today I would easily be diagnosed as autistic, but in the 90s that wasn't in the conversation. Especially given our experience with my cousin. I don't think of myself as autistic, I'm just a person with strengths and weaknesses.

Today for better or worse we live in a society that thrives on labels and categorization. Your kid gets a label and all of a sudden the school is able to give him an IEP and the support he deserves and should have been getting all along. In the cynical perspective, your kid gets a label and that affects the way he sees himself and relates to the world. The label becomes a justification instead of just a descriptor.

From the educational perspective, I want the school to do everything possible to help my child succeed. If that means jumping through hoops to get him support then so be it. But from the identity perspective I want my kid to be unburdened. To learn from the world around him without getting pigeonholed. And if a diagnosis was going to lead down this path I would be very intentional about when and to whom I disclosed this information.

This isn't getting into the world of false positives. In my experience (2 boys similar in age to your own) teachers tend to be good referrers just because of the volume of kids they deal with. So if your teacher recommends this there's a good chance they will fall under some diagnostic criteria at some testing facility. The question is what to do with the information.

in_cahoots··on Autism should not be seen as single condition with one cause, say scientists
I'm not well-versed in the Asperger's debacle so I didn't feel like it was my place to speak up here. Thanks for adding your perspective.
in_cahoots··on Autism should not be seen as single condition with one cause, say scientists
Social media is not disconnected from society as a whole. Influencers are called that because they have actual influence. You only need to look at and truly understand the MAHA movement to know this. It's not a movement by RFK; it's a movement of people (often moms) who are dissatisfied with their current situation and trying to do something to change it. They may be flat out wrong, but they have influence nonetheless.

Did the diagnostic criteria in DSM 5 change as a result of social media, was it the other way around, or was it hidden variables affecting both? Regardless, the money and attention tend to follow what the common people are saying. See: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

in_cahoots··on Autism should not be seen as single condition with one cause, say scientists
The overloading of the term autism has had a real damaging effect on some people. My cousin is profoundly autistic: he's nonverbal, and will never live independently. In the 90s most autism research was focused on helping people like him. He was involved in some pioneering studies at John's Hopkins University.

Today most of the money and advocacy is for high-performing or moderately-performing people with autism. Not just in relative terms, the amount of funding for people like my cousin has gone down. It makes sense; they are the larger group by volume and are able to advocate better than people like my cousin.

I wish it weren't a zero-sum game, and we recognized that autism is just a word for a broad series of conditions. It would be like if we called everyone with poor eyesight 'blind': yes, your vision is impaired. But the solutions you need are very different than the solutions Stevie Wonder needs.

See also: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/10/01/health/autism-spectrum-ne...

in_cahoots··on Do YC after you graduate: Early decision for students
This is the part I think young people don't understand. My husband and I worked around 16 years combined in tech. We started pretty late, since we both have PhDs, and we're not engineers so we aren't making top of the market. We still had enough money after that time to buy a house, have 2 kids and go on a multi-year sabbatical. And most of this working period was not at FAANGs.

If you're young, talented, single and bringing home $200k a year including RSUs, you are on track to basically do whatever you want in a decade. Make it to senior manager / Staff level and you should be clearing $400k a year at least. And if you do it smartly you're working 9-5, not some 996 bullshit. That's a ridiculous amount of money.

It's not as sexy as building a startup. But at least for me the ROI has been incredible. And I'm not super smart- my whole college career I looked down at people who spent their lives in front of a computer. I completely missed the trend of tech and Silicon Valley, and I definitely don't work any harder than the next guy. But if you do good work I've found that it tends to pay off.

in_cahoots··on Apple Photos app corrupts images
Yeah, after you've had this problem once it seems you'd uncheck delete after import before buying a literally entirely new photography system.
in_cahoots··on Children and young people's reading in 2025
I was alive at that time and I loved the Redwall books, Enders Game, LOTR before the movies, and some Heinlein. Never read Harry Potter, which came out when I was in middle school. And I was a girl.

Characterizing girls as only liking Harry Potter and Orlando Bloom is like saying boys only liked WWF and Jackass. It's a mindless stereotype.

in_cahoots··on The sisters “paradox” – counter-intuitive probability
The other part doesn't change anything at all. Here you go:

Q1: I looked at only one of a pair of two randomly selected children and it was a girl. What is the probability there are two girls?

Q2: I looked at both of two randomly selected children and at least one of the pair of children is a girl. What is the probability there are two girls?

in_cahoots··on The sisters “paradox” – counter-intuitive probability
How did you determine at least one is a girl? Presumably you looked in some way. But did you look at one child or both? That's the crux of the ambiguity.
in_cahoots··on The sisters “paradox” – counter-intuitive probability
But it's a valid point, the question is not well-posed. If you said, "I looked at both children and saw that at least one was a girl" more people would get the right answer. Many people will assume that the author looked at only one child, not both. And there's nothing in the wording to indicate either way.

As others are pointing out, this is just the Monty Hall problem. But the way the question is posed there is much clearer.

in_cahoots··on A Ritzy L.A. Enclave Learned a Bitter Lesson About the Limits of Its Wealth
I think point #4 is a little off. Rich people think they have more power than poor people, but at least in this case they lacked the motivation to actually try to change things.

Look at the facts. The article throws out a bunch of famous names, and shows the Kardashians protesting. And yet the protest seemed to last only a few days before one person was arrested and the rest lost interest. A city of millionaires only raised $76k in a GoFundMe.

This doesn't paint a picture of powerful people being thwarted. It's a bunch of unserious people writing letters for a few weeks and then losing interest when things don't immediately go their way.

in_cahoots··on Jim Lovell, Apollo 13 commander, has died
They were also the only Apollo crew not to have a divorce amongst them. It's an interesting contrast to the happy, proud, and thrilled 'All-American' stereotype they and their wives were presented as.
in_cahoots··on We may not like what we become if A.I. solves loneliness
I was going to disagree with you as that hasn't been my experience, but I think you're actually on to something. The younger generation doesn't drink as much as they used to. I'm sure I would have thought twice about some of the things I did in college if every person present had the potential to film me and post it on the internet, ending my career before it even started. It's better prevention than DARE or prohibition could ever be- the risk of having one single mistake recorded and available for everyone to see for the rest of your life.
in_cahoots··on Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of biofuels
I assumed something similar. But the author presents this as some sort of trump card, as if the agriculture industry was suggesting farmers grow corn for ethanol instead of for food. And then the researcher lost interest before he could be proven right. Maybe he actually was right, but there's no evidence here.
in_cahoots··on Big agriculture mislead the public about the benefits of biofuels
I read the whole article and I still don't see how Big Ag misled anyone. I may be misunderstanding, but it seems that the author is trying to differentiate between growing corn for food vs growing the same corn for ethanol. I assume the entire reason the lobby exists is that farmers want to grow corn for food and ethanol. But the researcher lost interest before proving anything around there. Maybe ethanol is actually worse, but I didn't see any evidence in this article.

Instead, this article is a master class in the red herring fallacy. Every person on the 'wrong' side of the issue has their sordid past and connections exposed, whether it's their association with Wall Street or the fact that they're a sex offender. Nevermind the science, the author just assumes that because the reader (presumably) has a certain political persuasion denigrating the other side will serve as a convincing argument.

in_cahoots··on Lead pigment in turmeric is the culprit in a global poisoning mystery (2024)
Cognitive dissonance is a thing, yes. Would you also be surprised to know that some Americans smoke and don't use seatbelts?

Not every immigrant is a twenty something working on a Masters degree or working in the tech industry. Most of the Bengalis I know, especially in the NYC area, are here by sheer luck and determination moreso than formal education. The older ones have survived famine, cyclones, and literal genocide. At that point, trying to convince someone that their favorite spices or sweets that they grew up with for 40+ years may be harmful is pretty difficult.

If anything, getting to know the immigrant community has been enlightening in pointing out my own biases. It's easy to point the finger at someone else because they're a fish out of water. But put me in a different culture (or really just let time pass with the attendant changes in culture and technology) and the same thing would be true for me.

in_cahoots··on Lead pigment in turmeric is the culprit in a global poisoning mystery (2024)
But for anyone who knows the Bangladeshi community this isn't a surprise at all. Neither the source nor the way it wakes its way into immigrants diets. Every time my Bengali friends visit Bangladesh they take an empty suitcase to fill with spices, sweets, and the like. The adulteration has been going on for decades.

I feel like the article should have been written from that perspective- an outsider discovering how a different community operates and polices itself- instead of from the perspective of some Western saviors uncovering a new problem.

← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →