HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

isaachinman

92 karma · joined July 22, 2018

Me: https://isaachinman.com

Currently building: https://marcoapp.io

submissionscomments
isaachinman··on Offline-First Landscape – 2025
...Exactly?
isaachinman··on Offline-First Landscape – 2025
Replicache certainly fits the bill!
isaachinman··on Offline-First Landscape – 2025
Actually, the complete opposite. We're building this app because we need it ourselves.

Turns out a lot of other people do too.

isaachinman··on Offline-First Landscape – 2025
Our dbs range from hundreds of MB to gigabytes.

This is discussed in the blog post. A lot of offline-first tools fall apart at this scale.

isaachinman··on Offline-First Landscape – 2025
Yeah, I did fail to mention OPFS in the blog post. It does look very promising, but we're not in a position to build on emergent tech – we need a battle-tested stack. Boring over exciting.
isaachinman··on Offline-First Landscape – 2025
Yeah that makes sense for your use case. We're RN for web, mobile, and desktop, so it works smoothly for us.
isaachinman··on Offline-First Landscape – 2025
Yes, Replicache works beautifully on our mobile/native targets.

The constructor allows you to pass in any arbitrary KVStore provider, and we happen to use op-sqlite as its performance is exceptional.

There is no "different data layer" per se, just a different storage mechanism.

Replicache also holds a mem cache that is limited to ~50MB if I recall. Our use case is extremely data-heavy, so we might end up never migrating to Zero – who knows.

Perhaps I misunderstood your question, let me know if I can clarify further.

isaachinman··on Offline-First Landscape – 2025
Hah, funny to see this reposted – I'm the author.

We've had great success with Replicache+Orama since this was written. We're keen to give Zero a spin once it's a bit more stable.

Triplit has essentially folded as a "company" and become some sort of open-source initiative instead.

InstantDB has matured massively and is definitely worth a look for anyone starting a new project.

isaachinman··on Ask HN: Why is Gmail so incompetent at basic search?
As others have mentioned, the search and overall performance of "legacy" products like Gmail and Apple Mail are absolutely terrible, not because those companies lack the technical capacity to improve them, but because they have very little financial incentive to do so.

We’re building an IMAP-native email client:

https://marcoapp.io

All metadata is stored locally on the client, so full-text searches complete in single-digit milliseconds.

Most people have simply grown accustomed to the insanely slow search speeds of traditional IMAP clients and don’t realise how bad they are until they try something faster.

isaachinman··on Thunderbird 140 “Eclipse”
We're using Orama for client-side search, which is best in class as far as we can tell, after quite an extensive period of research.

It is able to use BM25, QPS, or PT15.

We're still playing around with various weights/settings, but have seen fantastic results so far.

What do you mean by "double quoted phrases"? Do you mean the ability to search for an _exact_ term?

isaachinman··on Thunderbird 140 “Eclipse”
Check out what we're building: https://marcoapp.io

Basically a cross-platform Thunderbird replacement whose sole goal is to "not suck". Full-text search is entirely client side (not via IMAP) and returns results in single-digit ms.

isaachinman··on Evolution Mail Users Easily Trackable
I believe DOMPurify is considered best in class.
isaachinman··on Grammarly acquires Superhuman
Yes, that's one of our core USPs. It's possible to view one email account at a time, all at once, or any user-generated combination you might desire.
isaachinman··on Grammarly acquires Superhuman
We're building what you want:

https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on Why email startups fail
> push notifications are literally part of IMAP

You are conflating things. IMAP supports IDLE, NOTIFY, and _sometimes_ P-IMAP, but IMAP is never going to trigger a push notification on your iPhone/Android.

isaachinman··on Why email startups fail
Superhuman, Shortwave, Missive, Spark, HEY, Canary, Zero.

Everyone has their own threshold/requirements for privacy.

I completely understand your viewpoint, to be clear.

isaachinman··on Why email startups fail
Forward Email is not a competitor of ours, they offer a completely different kind of product.

I am not putting words in anyone's mouth. Direct quotes from the article:

> The companies that actually succeed in email don't try to reinvent the wheel

> Adding "AI" doesn't solve email's fundamental non-problems

Also, the article itself details the "Electron Performance Crisis".

Draw your own conclusions – this is a discussion. We're discussing.

isaachinman··on Why email startups fail
When you're a team of two, writing in one language is a practical choice, not a philosophical one.

If we had a team of ten, we'd certainly be writing fully-native apps.

Linear, Slack, Discord. The discussion goes on ad nauseam. This thread is about email, not electron.

isaachinman··on Why email startups fail
Yes, there is a massive difference in runtime RAM usage.

> Sorry, but I just want to read my damn email

The good news is that there are literally dozens of email client options. If cross-platform sync and push notifications don't matter to you, Apple Mail and Thunderbird are good options.

Talanoa indeed operates via Google and Microsoft APIs, not IMAP/SMTP.

isaachinman··on Why email startups fail
I think you're conflating Electron apps with hybrid apps. Electron literally bundles Chrome and NodeJs, resulting in apps that are 300mb+. The Marco macOS app is 3mb.

Yes, we have a server runtime between the client app and the upstream IMAP provider. As does Superhuman, Missive, and any other product that actually provides push notifications. For users that see this as a non-starter, we enthusiastically recommend local-only clients – Thunderbird, Talanoa, etc.

The waitlist is not marketing. We are in alpha right now and are genuinely not ready for GA. As soon as we are, the waitlist will disappear.

No, I do not live in the bay area, or even the US.

You may consider toning down the negativity in the future.

isaachinman··on Why email startups fail
It seems Forward Email has come to the exact same conclusion I did in a blog post awhile back: https://marcoapp.io/blog/marco-an-introduction

I agree that "reinventing" email, or building a business based on "AI features" are both terrible ideas.

We began building Marco not to do either of these things, but simply because _there wasn't_ any actual cross-platform IMAP client.

Apple Mail exists (but is terrible) if you only have Apple devices. Lots of other options like Superhuman and Shortwave exist, but only support Gmail+Outlook.

All we're doing is building the app that should have existed 10 years ago: a cross-platform, offline-first "Thunderbird". Except far more lightweight and modern. And yes, we've built it from the ground up. And no, it's not Electron.

https://marcoapp.io

isaachinman··on SaaS is just vendor lock-in with better branding
This is the way to go. Also has the added security bonus of keeping all your services in a private network, as opposed to exposing everything to the internet.
isaachinman··on Reverse engineering of Linear's sync engine
You could achieve something almost identical with Replicache + (Mobx or Orama). Only mentioning Mobx because it's what Linear uses. That level of the implementation is interchangeable.
isaachinman··on Show HN: Tesseral – Open-Source Auth
Have a look at Authkit.
isaachinman··on You're a little company, now act like one
What services do you offer, exactly?
isaachinman··on Proton threatens to quit Switzerland over new surveillance law
Have you seen this thing?

https://github.com/ProtonMail/proton-bridge

I'm not too familiar with it, but we're building Marco (https://marcoapp.io) and a customer just showed it to me recently.

isaachinman··on Ask HN: Email Provider for Main Account?
Personally, I use iCloud+ for custom domain hosting. I migrated from Gmail about a year ago. Yes, it's a walled garden, but a lesser of two evils for sure.

And if you have email accounts spread across multiple providers, check out the email client I am currently building:

https://marcoapp.io

Supports anything that supports IMAP/SMTP, but crucially is cross-platform (desktop + mobile apps).

isaachinman··on Gmail to SQLite
We're using app passwords for Marco (https://marcoapp.io), until we get through the unnecessarily-rigorous process of gaining privileged OAuth access for email scopes.

Here's the support article we link our users to:

https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/185833

Workspace is a bit different, however. You need an admin to enable app passwords.

isaachinman··on Gmail to SQLite
That is 100% untrue. I've built functionality on app passwords and use them on a daily basis.
isaachinman··on Gmail to SQLite
Indeed. Quite a hassle to enable now. Multiple requirements including 2FA.
← PreviousPage 4 of 6Next →