HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

itistoday2

628 karma · joined June 18, 2011

I upset the powers that be through my support of Bradley Manning, and now have this new account.

    Previous Karma  : 2231
    Previous Avg    : 7.47
    Previous account: http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=itistoday
I've got https://lobste.rs invites! (HN "like the good ol' days".) Happy to invite folks I feel will contribute positively to the community.

On Lobsters: moderation is public info, and so is who invited who. Downvotes require reasons, and they are undoable.

Send me an email (itistoday at gmail) with your HN profile and temporarily place your email info in your HN profile so that I can verify you.

submissionscomments
itistoday2··on Ross Ulbricht Sentenced to Life in Prison
> Are you implying drugs don't hurt anyone?

Drugs, like spoons, hurt people. Some other items that kill people include:

Cars. Motorcycles. Trees. Water. Too much air. Too little air. People. Dogs. Sticks. Bath tubs. Guns.

In the end, drugs are no more inherently harmful than any of the items listed above.

What usually kills people, however, is not drugs, but things associated with drugs that exist only because we have decided they should exist:

- Drug gangs and cartels and the violence associated with them are the product of US government policy, not drugs.

- Drug overdoses are the product of US government policy, not drugs (in most cases), because especially with illegal drugs people don't know what they're getting or how much of it or how to use it.

It is primarily we that kill people. Look around you. If you see a face that supports the drug war, that person is partially guilty in all drug related deaths.

The irony of this case is that Judge Katherine Forrest is now much more responsible for the drug-related deaths she is trying to prevent.

itistoday2··on Deep Learning – Review by LeCun, Bengio, and Hinton
Why do these articles on RNNs and "Deep Learning" never mention Hierarchical Temporal Memory?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hierarchical_temporal_memory#D...

itistoday2··on Using logs to build a solid data infrastructure
Could someone compare Apache Kafka to Eris Industry's centralized blockchain model?
itistoday2··on Speculation About The Eventual Death Of Bitcoin
> The whole article seems written around "Stellar good, Bitcoin bad" premise

Having read the paper and discussed with others, the claim also seems untrue.

Stellar's new protocol, Stellar Consensus Protocol (SCP), like Bitcoin, allows forks.

Unlike Bitcoin, however, it has no way of resolving them. Further, it seems easier for a fork to occur in SCP than it is in Bitcoin.

What this means is that in Bitcoin everyone agrees to what your balance is, but in SCP they will not once a fork occurs. There will, in effect, be multiple Stellars, with no limit to how many.

In attempting to make it easier for others to join the verification process, Stellar has actually made their entire protocol less secure than Ripple (which restricts membership and therefore can better prevent such forks).

See also Gregory Maxwell's criticisms: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9342348

itistoday2··on How a drug dealer’s IP was found out by package tracking
Can we not have wars on things?

Like, if someone or something else starts a war on us, we can self-defense them, but otherwise let's try to get this word out of our collective vocabulary by ceasing all the unnecessary and harmful wars we're fighting.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
> You consent to taxation by living here

Why this is wrong was addressed previously so not gonna repeat myself.

> And your parents consented for you when you were too young to do on your own.

Your parents cannot give this consent for you. Can they consent for you to be raped? Would their approval of you being raped suddenly make it not rape?

No. You're arguments are nonsensical. Go home. I'm done here.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
You're just repeating yourself now. You are not making logical arguments or responding to arguments made before.

> That you don't like the other countries out there (they aren't "fair alternatives") does not mean that, suddenly, taxation here is actually theft.

Yes, it does. The word for it is extortion.

1. No consent existed to begin with and money was taken forcibly. Theft. By definition. Go argue with a dictionary.

2. An alternative presents itself but the alternative is rape and so the choice is between theft or rape. This is called extortion. By definition. Go argue with a dictionary.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
> As an adult, you can revoke your consent and leave.

To revoke consent I would have had to have been of a mind to have given it in the first place.

My parents payed taxes when I was a child. I did not. I then grew into a situation where I had to make money to stay off the streets and was forced to pay this government.

Maybe this isn't so black and white. I would be willing to agree that your point of view carries more weight the longer I stay here in a capacity where I am capable of moving to another country.

However, it starts out as theft and remains so until I have no excuse remaining for not leaving, and then it's only if there is a fair alternative available.

If there's some country out there that doesn't have an income tax but rapes its citizens 12 hours out of the day, that can't be counted as a fair alternative. It would still be extortion then ("pay us or get raped!").

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
> Just like, when you sit down at a restaurant and order a meal, you're agreeing to pay for it without negotiation, without a specific contract outlining specifications for the food, etc.

There is a verbal agreement (contract) outlining the specifications of the food. It says "pancakes" in the menu, it shows me the price, and I choose to order the pancakes for that stated price.

That is completely different from how taxes work in the United States. An appropriate analogy would be being born in a restaurant and being forced to pay money for what you have no idea and no say in. There is no menu. What's given to you is chosen by people you don't know and who you've never had a single conversation with. And btw, you can't just "get up and leave" the restaurant either.

When the analogy is this incompatible, you can compare anything to anything else and declare that bananas are just like soap.

If you can't see the difference, you are deluding yourself.

itistoday2··on Servo: Embeddable Browser Engine
Different post. agumonkey posted the right one.
itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
http://nomadcapitalist.com/2013/11/24/top-5-livable-countrie...

Of the most "livable" countries:

- United Arab Emirates: don't want to live in the middle east, no thanks. I disagree with many of the laws there and have no close family or friends anywhere nearby.

- Bahamas: gotta buy land there or pay an annual fee. This is probably the most reasonable of all options, but my work precludes me from living there.

- Bermuda: One of the world's most expensive places to live. Possible if I could afford it (can't at the moment).

- Andorra: would be awesome. Not sure what the situation is with living there as a non-citizen (it takes 20 years to become one). Since one has to be a citizen of some country one wouldn't be able to renounce their US citizenship for 20 years (at least) and therefore would still have to pay income taxes to the United States.

- Monaco: "Getting a residence permit practically requires millionaire status."

I think ebrenes framed the situation well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9540888

Copied here:

~~~~

While you can theoretically leave the U.S. whenever you want, you cannot stop paying taxes whenever you want.

You have to renounce citizenship, pay a fine for renouncing said citizenship to avoid paying taxes and possibly be audited. And you might argue that's fine, because they should be able to collect back taxes but you'll generally have to pay taxes for the next 10 years.

~~~~

10 years, 20 years, whatever.

None of this changes the fact that what is being done in the United States is theft, plain and simple. The government never came to me and asked if I agreed to any of these income taxes, they just say pay up or we'll ruin your life. No negotiation, no agreed upon exchange for goods or services, just extortion.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
This is not at all the same situation.

The relationship governments have with their citizens is unique.

It goes like this: give us a chunk of your entire income forever or else we'll throw you in prison. Don't like it? Say good-bye to all your friends and family and enjoy surviving in a country where you don't understand anything anyone is saying, which will probably just give you the same ultimatum.

That's simply mafia-style protection-money robbery.

There is another option: voluntary association and voluntary taxation. This is just one possible form it can take: http://groupcurrency.org

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
One involves non-coercive mutual consent (a signed agreement), the other doesn't.
itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
It doesn't help if all other countries both severely restrict entry and/or force a tax upon you. I'd just end up in the same exact situation.

> And the "threat of prison" is some of the dumbest hyperbole...

It's not hyperbole. If you willfully fail to file that's grounds for imprisonment:

http://www.businessinsider.com/terrible-things-that-could-ha...

You're probably thinking of cases when people "forget" or make "mistakes" in their filing.

> ...out of the antitax crowd

I mentioned this already, I am not anti-tax. Please cut it with the labeling. It's late. We're going in circles. Have a good night, I won't be replying to whatever you post next.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
> You are free to move to another country.

Please explain how I can do that. I would actually like to move to Switzerland, could you explain how I can freely do that as everything I've researched indicates it's neither free nor possible in any reasonable amount of time. If not Switzerland I'll settle for some other country where I can live freely and be safe from coercion.

> If no automobile maker will sell you the exact car you want...

Nobody is forcing me to buy the car with the threat of prison if I don't, and I do not need a car to survive. I do need to live someplace however.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
> You agree to pay taxes by continuing to live here.

If we were free to move to a country where we agreed with the laws you might be right. That's not reality though.

We are not (currently) free to choose how we pay taxes in any country and our freedom to move from one country to another is restricted.

So, sorry, I never agreed to pay these taxes, I have little say in how they're used, and I have no alternatives except to go to prison. That's not freedom. That's simply coercion and theft.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
Stereotypes and ad hominem don't help the conversation.

I am not "anti-tax". I think taxation is a good idea as it helps a community re-invest in itself. I am anti-theft.

Saying today's taxation is not theft won't change the reality that it is. Nor will downvoting this post change that reality. In fact, barring a change in the definition of the word, there is not a single action in this universe that can change the reality that taking something that belongs to someone else without their permission is theft.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
I've lived long enough to be called "right wing" for the first time in my life... that is a first (I think).

As far as Proudhon (first time hearing this), it seems he was referring to land only, and that "property did not extend to exclusive possession of labor-made wealth."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Property_is_theft!

It's unclear to me how someone can "own" a piece of land which they did not create but stumbled upon. To me it just seems like a situation where the person with the biggest gun wins, and has nothing to do with "property". So in that sense, perhaps, yes, claiming ownership over something you did not create (Earth) might very well be interpreted as theft.

However, the notion of "land property" is a potentially convoluted rabbit hole that is very different from a straightforward discussion about taking money people earned with their own labor under the threat of force.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
> It's more like someone stealing $200

Sounds like we're in agreement then. :)

> and giving you a bicycle you didn't ask for

s/bicycle/war. No worries, I make that typo all the time. ;)

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
> Guess who defines who the rightful owner of property is? Government.

A compelling argument. In that case this appears to be a non-story, and I'm not sure what the fuss is about.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
In common usage, theft is the taking of another person's property without that person's permission or consent with the intent to deprive the rightful owner of it.

We are unable to give consent (consent implies choice), so it is theft through coercion (prison).

See "group fund" for a voluntary form of taxation: http://groupcurrency.org

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
> Civil forfeiture isn't "soft language", it's a precise legal term.

It is both.

> calling it theft is no different from a libertarian doing the same with taxation.

Taxation today is theft.

itistoday2··on How the DEA took a young man’s life savings without charging him with a crime
I am concerned that by calling it "civil forfeiture" this article is using language to mask a very basic crime.

What was described in this article is called stealing or theft. To call it anything else is to mask and downplay what was done to this man. It is to enable the very act that was committed.

George Carlin observed this as a dangerous trend in our language: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vuEQixrBKCc

Call it "civil forfeiture" once if you have to (perhaps as a footnote). But to repeatedly use such "soft language" is to delay an end to such injustice.

itistoday2··on Inspiration vs. Imitation
It's the one that looks like Cushion. ;)

If the story's true the best retribution would be to not give the competitor any visits.

itistoday2··on Warrantless airport seizure of laptop “cannot be justified,” judge rules
> I also find it funny that this sort of illegal government activity actually caught someone selling weapon parts

All it said was that he was selling accelerometers, which could be used in a variety of things (i.e. autonomous vehicles, commercial aircraft, etc.):

The defendant was accused of unlawfully selling Q-Flex Accelerometers—models QA-2000-10, QA-2000-20, and QA-3000

There was no statement of intent (in the article at least), so saying these were to be used for weapons seems a bit premature.

itistoday2··on Passcard
For those curious, there's also BlockchainID (something I've worked on):

https://github.com/okTurtles/blockchainid

And BitAuth:

https://github.com/bitpay/bitauth

itistoday2··on Passcard
Passcard is a decentralized, blockchain-based identity system.

The idea is to give you back control of your online identity, which you currently do not own (you either rent or borrow it from companies like Facebook and Twitter). With the blockchain, you can actually own your digital identity.

Onename will (hopefully), remain a "default" but not essential intermediary.

Passcard will hopefully replace login systems like Facebook Login, Twitter Login, etc.

Info: I do not work for Onename, I am not paid by them, but I collaborate with them because I believe in the importance of decentralization and they are helping with that.

itistoday2··on Group Currency
> The key question is how do you stop non group members joining your group?

This is up to the group to decide. To join a group the group must approve you to join.

The more groups there are, the more choice people have. It's healthy competition as per usual free market capitalism, but with some decency and wisdom thrown in.

In other words, everyone ends up better off. Standard of living improves for everyone involved because workers have more freedom to work on complex tasks since their brains are not per-occupied by the mundane and they are happy.

itistoday2··on Group Currency
> However, a group of nail salon manicurists cannot.

So, this is true today, but I think it's missing the bigger picture of a world where UBI actually exists.

Basic Income leads to Universal Basic Income (UBI).

One of the reasons why there are so many nail salon manicurists today is because we have made higher education very expensive, among other reasons.

Do you really think most of the people working as manicurists today would be doing that if they didn't have to in order to pay the bills and higher education were free (or very cheap)?

No. They would not. That's not to say there's anything wrong with being a manicurist. Indeed some may do it because that's what they want to do. But I do know that most people, including most software developers, wouldn't be doing what they are doing right now if the basics were guaranteed for them.

The future is a world where most of today's jobs are automated away. It's very different from the one we live in right now, so it makes little sense to think only in terms of today's world when talking about BI / UBI.

This is necessary preparation for the future. You've got "Star Trek" on one side [1][2], and "Dawn of the Dead" on the other. You're going to have to choose somewhere along that spectrum.

[1] http://lemire.me/blog/archives/2013/10/17/toward-star-trek-e...

[2] https://medium.com/@RickWebb/the-economics-of-star-trek-29ba...

itistoday2··on Group Currency
I'm not sure it's that simple. Think of it in terms of shares in a company. When Apple does well does any executive sell their shares? Maybe, maybe not.

Nothing is preventing this musician from selling their MusicianCoins. If there are enough coins and enough musicians it won't do much to the price if the market knows how to value the coin properly. The musician might simply end up losing out on a profit by this action. Depending on the situation, maybe they might end up annoying the group and getting kicked out, who knows. It shouldn't be an issue though, just as it's not an issue with company shares.

← PreviousPage 5 of 14Next →