HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

itsprofitbaron

729 karma · joined February 1, 2012

https://www.profitbaron.com/

@profitbaron

submissionscomments
itsprofitbaron··on Ask HN: Why hasn't Rap Genius been shut down?
Undertexter was profiting from simply translating subtitles whereas, Rap Genius falls under fair use because, they're creating a new layer on top of the lyrics.
itsprofitbaron··on The Commoditization Of SaaS
What I mean by this is don't make your selling point about having more features (since a competitor can copy them) but rather create an additional value-add that meets your customers or potential customers needs.

SaaS currently tries to say "this is the solution" and as I was saying in the post it needs to be flipped to focus on actual customer pain points (since the current solution may not actually meet their needs) which you can the re-create a slightly new solution which becomes your unique selling point and defensible base (which is why it's important to go beyond competing on features). Essentially SaaS is becoming the method to provide the customer with the product rather than the actual business model and if your SaaS works with your customers & solves a key problem for them beyond "hey pay us X for these features" you will become a preferred partner who is solving a key problem which is critical to the success of your customers

itsprofitbaron··on The Commoditization Of SaaS
Your Salesforce example highlights a SaaS replacing Enterprise Software - Salesforce vs. Siebel. Regarding your point about software being sticky like some hardware offerings have been commoditized - software can also suffer this to some extent (especially in the SaaS space as noone is doing anything that revolutionary that a competitor or competitors cannot come along and literally clone them).

I do however agree with you about the switching costs, Salesforce actually use this as part of their lock-in & differentiator in that they have got their users to associate them with CRM - their stock ticker is it etc - this they become product evangelists for them. As a result, there is a network effect built around Salesforce which has helped them create a lock-in.

However, that sill does not mean users won't switch (look at the new http://www.moz.com it isn't a coincidence that the UI looks like Google Analytics - that is one such example of how to "break" the lock-in). Moreover if a customer is offered a Salesforce alternative for 20% of the cost & it does exactly what Salesforce can do (as well as having a similar UI) that becomes a serious incentive for a business to switch - after all most of the decisions are made by the CIO etc who doesn't necessarily use the product day-to-day.

Finally to address your point about there being no commodity version of MS Office the problem is, is that no alternative has actually managed to provide a product to a similar level - Excel is by far the most superior spreadsheet product on the marketplace.

itsprofitbaron··on The Commoditization Of SaaS
I wasn't arguing about adding more features (since a competitor can also do that) but rather create an additional value-add that meets your customers or potential customers needs.

Whereas SaaS currently tries to say "this is the solution" it needs to be flipped to focusing on actual customer pain points (since the current solution may not actually meet their needs) which you can the re-create a slightly new solution which becomes your unique selling point and defensible base (which is why it's important to go beyond competing on features). The reason I'm arguing this point is because, SaaS is becoming commodified in that they they winning SaaS in the SMB space start getting pulled upstream to the enterprise market where their margins become much greater and SaaS becomes their method to provide you with the product than their actual business model.

Your examples actually reaffirm my point - Walmart has added value by offering "everything under one roof" so instead of going to 10-20 store you just go to the 1. Their value is convenience alongside this they also compete on price to protect their market from disruption and ensure they're the dominant player (its a 3 pronged attack which Amazon is replicating on the web). On the other hand Tiffany's offers you a more personal experience than a Walmart does (in my opinion) which is their comparitve value-add alongside their actual products.

itsprofitbaron··on The Commoditization Of SaaS
I mentioned the uniqueness elements to highlight areas where SaaS services can evolve into from their "solution" service to a "problem" service.

I do however agree with you that, you should always try to offer something unique (as this is the USP and where you can make higher profit margins) and that it can sometimes take time to achieve this. However, SaaS is not revolutionary and it can be copied by anyone and some of them may have a nice user interface and/or great product functionality but it is not revolutionary aka a commodity - which as I mentioned in the post is a death spiral as it focuses on competing on price.

itsprofitbaron··on The Commoditization Of SaaS
In regards to the commoditization point & to you examples of Oil, Investment Funds and Pharmaceuticals there has been consolidation within these. For instance, OPEC has effectively brought all the oil-producing nations under one rule so to speak which has established uniform pricing throughout the world.

Moreover, commoditization doesn't happen immediately as there may be industries who disrupt existing solutions (as SaaS has done to Enterprise Software) but aren't yet fully established themselves (or in particular verticals of the new industry) and these can have time to evolve before commoditizing. Having said that, it's always better to commoditize yourself before customers (and potential customers) perceive you as a commodity. The reason for is that it becomes much harder to evolve into a preferred partner/problem service where you can make much higher profit margins during this stage as you are being compared on price & not your defensible value add.

itsprofitbaron··on Ask HN: What is better: artist.domain.com or domain.com/artist?
If you want to build strong domain authority and have the artist profiles take advantage of the positive metrics & ranking ability of the domain then use: domain.com/artist (the sub-domains do not always inherit all of the positive metrics and ranking ability of domain.com)
itsprofitbaron··on Goodbye SEOmoz. Hello Moz
I'm glad they've finally moved to Moz.com (I predicted they would do this when Rand started blogging on Moz.com) because apart from when it was an SEO blog, SEOMoz has never really been just about SEO - they're more of a marketing suite (and I'm assuming the new Moz.com is step 1 in becoming this)

The post itself mentions some of their services (and acquisitions such as FollowerWonk) which shows the company are not really just an SEO software company although, the bigger point around it goes back to them being beyond SEO as the content they have always focused on themselves alongside the tools they have provided were/are more than just your standard SEO tools.

Personally, I think it’s a smart move for them and the new branding allows them to tackle a much bigger market too!

itsprofitbaron··on The $6,600 Master's Degree.
I understand that EU-citizens get free Masters' education. This is somewhat a side-effect of the EU-wide Bologna process, which promoted everyone's Bachelors degree into a Masters by adding a year's worth more of education and introducing a credit-system.

This isn't true. I'm from England (hence EU Citizen) and Batchelors and Masters degrees are two different things.

I have had to pay for both my Batchelors and my Masters degree - having said that the government does offer a basic loan for Batchelors degrees BUT there isn't any funding for a Masters degree, you have to pay that yourself.

itsprofitbaron··on The Yahoo board has approved a deal to pay $1.1 billion in cash for Tumblr
Yahoo employees can't keep secrets and are always leaking things to AllThingsD (a sister company to WSJ).
itsprofitbaron··on Ask HN: What analytics do you use when Google Analytics reaches its limits?
They'll use the GA Enterprise version which serves up to 1 Billion "hits processed per month" its £90,000[1]/$150,000[2] as a flat fee per year.

[1] http://www.google.co.uk/intl/en_uk/analytics/premium/feature...

[2] http://www.google.co.uk/intl/en_us/analytics/premium/feature...

itsprofitbaron··on Mt. Gox Dwolla account frozen by DHS
For instance when two nations go to war it doesn't really matter who wins or loses because, they're both creating debt (the one who loses the war usually ends up with the most debt) in order to fund their conflicts.

Likewise, another example is a bookmaker - those who are in conflict are the punters who are betting on an outcome (one of them wins & one of them loses) - however, to the bookmaker it is trivial who wins or loses because they always make money on that outcome. It's the same with the banks etc.

itsprofitbaron··on Mt. Gox Dwolla account frozen by DHS
Regarding the last part In the US, when it comes to banking it's really not about logic but about power. which you wanted elaboration on, the OP is essentially referring to the fact that power is king (well one of the kings anyway) and in order to have power, one of the easiest ways to do it is through controlling the debt - after all if you can control the debt you can control everything - this is highlighted perfectly when there is any form of conflict between nations as, the true value from conflicts isn't who wins or loses but rather the debt it creates.
itsprofitbaron··on The Scientific 7-Minute Workout
You are allowed to downvote once you get a certain amount of karma.
itsprofitbaron··on Ask HN: "advisor" or "adviser"
I always go with advisor over adviser because, I believe that advisor looks "right" as you look at it whereas, adviser looks strange.

The statistics back this up as well specifically, the exact global searches in Google which are as follows:

Advisor - 74,000

Adviser - 33,100

itsprofitbaron··on Challenge to PG/YC
To address your comment, I respectfully disagree with the majority of it. Especially "attacking you personally" I didn't do that as highlighted by the fact that I clearly stated "this may come across as harsh but, it's useful feedback"

Moreover, your comment came across (alongside this response) that Google "stole" your idea after you reached out to Google Ventures. The idea has been around for a while for instance, Virtual Video Map launched in 2006 (their domain is a parked page) which used Google Maps + YouTube - http://googlesystem.blogspot.co.uk/2006/06/google-maps-youtu... - and that is something you should probably look at using their maps product instead of Google Earth would remove user friction considerably.

Similarly, the idea of a mole does ruin YC's credibility and it does not benefit YC - they are producing 2 Demo Day's per year who they have told the press and other investors that this batch of founders are ones who they believed are the most resourceful with potentially great ideas. Having a mole company goes against that ideology because, YC does not believe that this "mole" company is what they are saying but more importantly, YC are a company and they don't owe anyone anything trying to prove a point which is true.

Founders do have more power today - the cost of starting up a company has fallen drastically and more investors have realised that whilst they can provide help/ideas they have also realised/accepted that a founder may have more domain knowledge into the company then they do which is why, they let them run with their ideas. A classic example of this is with Fred Wilson / Tumblr - Fred wanted comments on Tumblr although David (Tumblrs founder) didn't and pushed back on the idea of not having comments on there - Fred agrees and covers it here: http://www.avc.com/a_vc/2013/05/great-entrepreneurs-will-lis...

Finally, regarding "YC guarantees you funding" they invest $11k + $3000 per founder (as well as YC VC) but after that, you are on your own - being in YC attracts some investor interest but it does not guarantee they will hand you a check.

itsprofitbaron··on Challenge to PG/YC
In other news, rejected YC applicant[1] calls out PG asking to be a "mole" company[2] which could ruin YC's credibility in the long term with investors and doesn't even make sense - for a startup the OP admits they have been told no one wants and then goes onto try and call out Google Ventures because, YouTube launched a version of it[3] - a completely different version which is better executed as highlighted by the fact that it doesn't require any form of plugin etc (this may come across as harsh but, it's useful feedback - you have added user friction and you should remove as much of it as possible)

If you want to launch a product and succeed, YC doesn't guarantee you success nor does being rejected mean that you are a failure. YC have invested in numerous startups which have failed as well has having some great successes (Heroku, Dropbox, AirBnB, Stripe, OMGPop etc) but they've also missed out on some startups too:

- SendGrid - http://www.sendgrid.com/ (went through TechStars and have raised a series B)

- CouchOne - http://www.couchbase.com/

- AfterTheDeadline - Acquired By Automattic

- Light Sail Energy - http://www.lightsailenergy.com/ - Raised money from Khosla Ventures

- SignPost - https://www.signpost.com/ - Raised $1M off Google Ventures

- MyFit - http://www.myfit.com/ - Raised $1M

- Storenvy - http://www.storenvy.com - although they were kicked out of YC[4] but have recently raised $5M[5]

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5420541

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5671751

[3] http://www.youtube.com/trendsmap

[4] http://joncrawford.com/post/20378314843/how-i-got-kicked-out...

[5] http://techcrunch.com/2013/02/12/storenvy-goes-from-getting-...

itsprofitbaron··on Coinbase grew 15x in the past 3 months
Friendster was the extreme case because, of the poor management behind the company. For instance, they went through 4 CEO's over a short period of time and they chose to do a full rewrite from Java to PHP instead of trying to scale the service and because, the rewrite wasn't implemented properly it had to be rewrote again a couple of years later. Moreover instead of sharding/portioning, Friendster chose to scale their service by purchasing an SAN and using daisy-chained MySQL which resulted in considerable slave lag. For comparison, Facebook on the other hand used colleges to "portion" their database in the early stages of the company.

Instead of doing the rewrite, Friendster should have focused on trying to scale the service like Twitter did by bringing in PivotalLabs - if Friendster sharded their database for instance it would have helped them immensely and may have resulted in a different outcome for the company.

itsprofitbaron··on Should I Just Buy This Domain?
Without knowing what the domain is, I can't comment on its actual worth but considering everything that you have said you should buy it.

The reasons are because:

- You're already committed to the name - you have a trademark and you say the name is a great fit for your startup

- You are already willing to pay $1000 for it ($500 more isn't that much in real terms especially, if you think you can at least recover $1500 for the domain if the startup fails)

- If your startup becomes successful, you are going to want to acquire that domain name (and once you're successful the owner will want a more substantial price)

itsprofitbaron··on Ask HN: What would you consider to be the roles/duties of a CTO?
Here's how I see it:

Chief Technical Officer = Someone who looks at the market, trends, how their competition or potential competition are evolving their product(s) & trys to anticipate users demand within ~5 years. In other words a CTO is someone who uses their knowledge of tech to make money but they don't think about the exact details; they hire people to do that.

However, in order to help the CTO companies usually have a CIO (although that role is considered to be diminishing):

Chief Information Officer = Understands tech & uses it to reduce expenses & contain cost of growth

itsprofitbaron··on Facebook Tells Parse Developers “No Plans To Change How App Data Is Used”
Nothing has really changed with Instagram since Facebook acquired it, there was the TOS debate but that was overblown. Instagram’s core operation is around being able to quickly take and share photos & adding filters etc and that hasn’t really changed.

The only thing they really have done, is launched on the web (they just launched on Android a few days before the acquisition) and scaled up the Instagram team. Likewise, they also enlarged photos on Facebook itself (although that was for everyone not just Instagram) - the fact that they haven’t even given them a tab in their app shows how autonomously Facebook have let Instagram run since acquiring it etc.

Having said that, Instagram now has to play by Facebook’s rules and I expect that we’re more likely to see further integration between the two going forward this year such as advertising etc.

itsprofitbaron··on Facebook Tells Parse Developers “No Plans To Change How App Data Is Used”
"why do developers feel more comfortable now that Facebook owns the product/company?"

This happens with the majority of acquisitions that, as soon as they are acquired they see an uptick in signups. The uptick would be more interesting if they announced it in a month’s time or in an even longer period of time. There are several reasons for this including, the perception of “X has acquired them and they’re a massive company which means that the service will be around for a while” (which is not necessarily true) and the fact that, the acquired company gets a lot of press from areas they may previously not have done so they get new users either as customers or simply joining to ‘look’ at the service – although they may not become actual valuable users – by those I mean ‘look’ at the service, I’m talking about other employees of the acquiring company, shareholders of the acquiring company etc.

itsprofitbaron··on What's a "medium.com" and why is it all over HN?
Biz Stone is a founder of Twitter, Obvious and now Jelly. I don't consider Biz Stone to be a founder of Medium as it operates independently of Obvious.

Obvious have invested/incubated Medium, Branch, Jelly, Lift, Beyond Meat, Good Fit and Neighborland. (There may be more but I'm pretty sure that's all of them)

Medium, Branch and Jelly are what the Obvious founders are now focusing on (although they sit on some of those other startups boards):

Ev - Medium, Branch - Jason and Jelly - Biz

itsprofitbaron··on What's a "medium.com" and why is it all over HN?
Medium.com is a publishing platform for the sharing of ideas and experiences.

It's founded by Evan Williams[1] of Blogger, Twitter etc.

[1] https://twitter.com/ev

itsprofitbaron··on Ask HN: Suggestions for spacewalk procedure writing?
Reading your requirements specifically in relation to the procedures using “2 astronauts working outside the space station (called EV1 and EV2), plus a robotics operator inside, and other actions taken by mission control on the ground. All of this is happening in parallel. Sometimes EV1 may be working on a task where all the steps can be done independent of what EV2 is doing, while other times their steps are heavily intertwined. The same goes for robotic and mission control steps” it seems like you need a project management tool.

Whilst you’re currently using Microsoft Word for this, it would actually be much easier to do this using Excel (and create a Gantt Chart) OR you could use something like Asta Power Project[1] which is used in the Construction Industry as well as with Technology Organisations, Engineering, Manufacturing, Oil & Gas and Financial Services etc which rely on projects running in parallel.

The reason I recommended the Asta Power Project tool is because you can:

- Create accurate schedules easily using a drag/drop feature

- Have complete visibility over multiple projects in real-time

- Optimise your project resources

- Access powerful reporting tools

- ETC

I've actually used the Asta Power Project Software myself; it's pretty powerful and feature rich.

[1] http://www.astadev.com/products/asta-powerproject/

itsprofitbaron··on I skateboarded 85km from Sydney to Wollongong. It took me 12 hours
The most skateboarding I've ever done is playing Tony Hawk but this was a really interesting read!

Congratulations on finishing and for an awesome achievement - you've confirmed to yourself you can do anything you want when you put your mind to it and you did something what a lot of people don’t do (apart from skateboarding the from Sydney to Wollongong) in that despite, previously giving up for various reasons you still achieved your goal. Congratulations once again!

itsprofitbaron··on The Quickest Wins in SEO
Not as much since the algorithm has evolved. Personally, I'm more interested in a site's Domain Authority[1] (anything over 30 is good)

[1] http://www.seomoz.org/learn-seo/domain-authority

itsprofitbaron··on The Quickest Wins in SEO
Actually your examples: mywhateverblog.com/red-widgets-in-texas/ and mywhateverblog.com/?p=545 isn't comparing keywords in URLs but Static vs. Dynamic URLS - and static URLs e.g. /red-widgets-in-texas/ is NOT better than /?p=545 - This is something that Google have even said so themselves[1]

[1] http://googlewebmastercentral.blogspot.co.uk/2008/09/dynamic...

itsprofitbaron··on The Quickest Wins in SEO
bear in mind that Google has acknowledged that keywords in URLs "help a little"

Actually, Google released an EMD update[1] in order to fix that issue.

[1] https://twitter.com/mattcutts/status/251784203597910016

itsprofitbaron··on Bitcoin Is Fundamentally Flawed
So by the "economy" think of Bitcoin like they are a country (a really small one) and that’s the only currency for them and in some cases deflation can be beneficial to some people in an economy. For instance as I was saying in the previous comment it's beneficial for those with the cash and income streams as they become more valuable as time goes on and its good for the debtor.

However, you are correct in that there is always going to be a semi-stable price (or a price floor) when the money supply starts to help create inflation and grow the economy again. In terms of how it’s bad for Bitcoin building on the previous comment, let’s pretend that people have bought coins at $200 and deflation kicks which means that, people either hoard it (to try and get something cheaper tomorrow) OR once it hits a certain level everyone tries to recover their losses and starts selling the coins which causes an economic crash to a highly volatile market (a $500k trade can usually cause a lot of issues) and the market will not level out until, there are enough buyers interested to buy back into Bitcoin.

← PreviousPage 2 of 9Next →