HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

j-g-faustus

923 karma · joined April 9, 2010

submissionscomments
j-g-faustus··on How we buy plane tickets and why it's ruining air travel
> I travel far FAR less often now than a few years ago.

So do I. I never found flying particularly pleasant, whether economy or business class, and after a decade of frequent business flying I pick other alternatives (including staying at home) whenever I can.

But the US travel statistics http://www.bts.gov/publications/national_transportation_stat... seems to say that "people" still fly more - 350 bill. passenger miles in 1990, 530 bill. in 2000, 583 in 2008. Although it's down a bit from the peak years 2006-2007.

j-g-faustus··on How we buy plane tickets and why it's ruining air travel
I'd add a fourth factor: The fact that we travel more frequently.

If you are flying something like once per decade flying might feel like an adventure in its own right and you may be willing to splurge a bit.

But the more often you need to fly between A and B, the more similar it becomes to taking the bus, subway or a taxi, all of which already are commodities.

I expect there is room for more "exclusive" experiences at a higher price, just like there is for groceries. Or as with limousine rental vs taxi.

But fundamentally it's just transport - I'm flying because I need to get somewhere else quickly. If I were traveling for the experience I would probably go by motorcycle, train or boat instead.

j-g-faustus··on Let me see your papers, let me see your source
It's been a few years since this was relevant for me, but my primary concern would be that in order to publish actual code I would either have to spend months cleaning it up, writing documentation etc., or spend the next year fielding support calls. Or both.

I agree with another poster here that having somebody else repeating the experiment with their own implementation is a better test for validity - if a second paper just copies the source code from the first and makes a few tweaks, mistakes could easily carry over.

But having the data available would be great.

j-g-faustus··on Clojure 1.2 quick reference/cheat sheet
It's mine, I had no idea it would make it to Google and HackerNews that quickly. Glad you like it :)

On bigger fonts, can't you just use the browser "increase font size", Command-+ on my system?

I prefer the smaller fonts to make room for more on one screen. But if people find it hard to read, I can increase it a bit.

j-g-faustus··on Running a start-up is great, growing a business is boring
True enough, I think.

Then the primary driver is not a vision of technology as such, it is political: If you aim to change (or rule) the world, bigger is always better (as bigger equals more power, people and money to change the world according to your vision) and you never run out of challenges.

I suppose a Leonardo da Vinci quote is appropriate:

    It had long since come to my attention that people of
    accomplishment rarely sat back and let things happen to
    them. They went out and happened to things.
Then I suppose it becomes mostly a matter of scaling the vision along with the size of the company. And the ability to keep the vision alive without drowning in administrative day-to-day tasks.
j-g-faustus··on Giant Plumes of Oil Forming Under the Gulf, decreasing oxygen levels by 30%
There is a shutoff valve at the bottom of the sea, another valve on the drilling rig at the sea surface, and a pipe connecting them.

The way you close off a well is by a) closing either of the valves or b) pumping a few tons of sand and cement down the pipe to block the drilling hole.

Here the top valve failed (with the first explosion) and the bottom valve doesn't work. The pipe broke when the platform sank, and without a connection to the drilling hole the well can't be blocked in the normal fashion. Plus it's too deep underwater for divers or normal submarines.

Without a connection to the well or a working valve, you're basically screwed.

The only certain way to stop the leak at this stage is to drill a new hole at an angle to the first one, a relief well, then you have a connection you can use to pump in the sand and cement to block the well beneath the sea bottom. They have started the process of doing that, the only problem is that it will take months.

Fixes that are known to work in shallower water, like the dome to contain the spill so it could be pumped up, didn't work here - it got clogged up by deep water crystals.

Drilling at these depths is still largely experimental, so there's not much prior experience to draw on.

Maybe they will find a solution at some point, but besides drilling the relief well no fix is know at this time - it's basically trial and error.

j-g-faustus··on _why: A Tale Of A Post-Modern Genius
The entire concept of art is relatively recent (from the Renaissance on), the ancient Greeks considered a sculptor to be a craftsman just like a smith or carpenter.

And the Renaissance artists had to make a living somehow, much of their art we know today was made to order for Church, State or rich merchants.

We may consider "pure art" to be "form without function" and "pure utility" to be "function without form". But fields like industrial design, architecture and engineering (ex. bridges) has room for both: Aesthetically pleasing form that merges well with their function.

If programming is art, it's the form+function sort of art. And just like with bridge building, the form part is optional - if the program works and the bridge does not collapse they are doing their job.

I don't consider the code for my day job to be art either. But I still think art can arise under such conditions, generally because someone with the power to do so goes beyond the call of duty and decides to make their bridge or code not only functional but beautiful as well.

There are plenty of constraints that can stop considerations of form dead in their tracks; like whether the client is willing to pay extra or wait longer for a more aesthetically pleasing result, or how much control you have over the final result - there are limits to how creative you can be if you are a subcontractor for a bridge pillar, or if you are designing an ad that needs to fit within the company's design guidelines and an existing ad series.

Still, I think art can arise in the most unexpected places, it's mostly a matter of spotting the opportunities and deciding that it is worth the bother.

j-g-faustus··on Scientists Explain Why Computers Crash But We Don't
Well, we can find or create equivalences.

Someone I knew did a master thesis on the male reproductive system, he told me that males have 10-15 largely independent biological pathways to produce sperm. From nature's perspective the point is presumably that if you can still breathe, you should be able to reproduce :)

If we were to put the same level of effort into a file reading module, we would have the files replicated over 10-15 different systems with file reading code written by a dozen different people in a dozen different languages, all using different heuristics to locate a similar file (or a backup) if the original wasn't found. Add some sort of selection mechanism to pick the best result from the 10-15 return values, and you would have a very resilient file reader :)

I can't imagine we will ever want to write code like that by hand - drawbacks include development cost and maintenance hassle, and the system becomes very hard to understand and debug.

But it's still an interesting approach. In computer systems I suppose we could bring it about by some variant of evolutionary programming. ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolutionary_programming )

j-g-faustus··on Great Marketing: Honest Tea Tests Wall Street's Honesty
Don't think so, it was clearly marked with price list and everything.

I imagine it's more along the lines of "I'll pay them all by the end of the week/month", and then they forgot about it. Or perhaps sales grabbed a bunch to hand out to potential customers, assuming that the company would reimburse any losses.

Either way I don't think the high-income earners were deliberately cheating more than average.

But I think it is a point that the price of a candy bar looks like smaller and smaller change the more you earn, perhaps to the point were it seems irrelevant.

j-g-faustus··on Great Marketing: Honest Tea Tests Wall Street's Honesty
A few years back a company in Scandinavia tried to sell candy bars at workplaces by leaving a tray of candy bars and a jar for the money.

They found that it worked well at low-income workplaces (90-95% honesty) but poorly at high-income workplaces (20-30% honesty).

It appears that at least by some metrics, honesty is inversely proportional to income.

j-g-faustus··on Clear animation on how the SVM "kernel trick" works
Classification. The goal is to find the simplest description that will separate two sets of data (here: the points inside the circle from the ones outside).

Linear classifiers - in 2D, a straight line that separates the two groups - are preferred when possible since linear is as simple as it gets. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linear_classifier

The video shows how a classification task that cannot be handled by a linear classifier in 2D can still be described by a linear equation (a flat plane) by transforming the data to 3D.

j-g-faustus··on On Geeks and Gays
I've always thought that [gay | labor | women's | black's | etc] rights all collapse to merely human rights, and find it curious that we see the need to carve it up in a whole bunch of special cases.
j-g-faustus··on Why Are Nerds Unpopular, An Alternative To PG's Essay
> So are you saying that that's not actually the case, that smart people aren't disproportionately unpopular?

I think they aren't. As an example, we could hypothesize that people have a few simple attributes - say IQ (math), physical skills (sports), looks (hot or not), empathy (good at getting along with others) and political skills (good at influencing others).

I imagine that looks and physical skills are the most important factors for popularity, with empathy and political skill next, while IQ is basically irrelevant - unlike good looks, high IQ in and of itself does not cause popularity.

So let's say that popularity is a function of a weighted average score of looks, physical skills, empathy and political skills.

When we say that someone is "popular" or "smart", we don't mean "average" but more something like "top 10%".

Obviously 10% of the population will be among the 10% most popular, and 10% among the 10% smartest. But if popularity and IQ is statistically independent, only 1% will be among the top 10% in both.

So people that are both smart and popular can indeed be rare even when IQ and popularity are independent, we don't need more than a random distribution to explain that.

If we add the fact that people tend to focus on (and thereby improving) things they are good at and ignore (and thereby fall behind in) areas where they suck, it will only strengthen the trend.

I think nerds and jocks both follow the path of least resistance by putting most of their efforts into areas where they have a natural advantage. But doing so is rational behavior, it's hard to argue against it.

j-g-faustus··on Living With a Computer (1982)
"When I sit down to write a letter or start the first draft of an article, I simply type on the keyboard and the words appear on the screen."

I suppose any sufficiently advanced technology actually is indistinguishable from magic.

j-g-faustus··on Ask HN: Where the hell is all this recent hate on Gen Y'ers coming from?
Doubtful. Here's Hesiod around 800 BC:

"I see no hope for the future of our people if they are dependent on frivolous youth of today, for certainly all youth are reckless beyond words... When I was young, we were taught to be discreet and respectful of elders, but the present youth are exceedingly disrespectful and impatient of restraint"

Between the two hypotheses a) "society has been declining for thousands of years" and b) "older people tend towards grumpiness" I know which one sounds more likely :)

Although Hesiod's "I see no hope for the future of our people" may be vindicated by the fact that his culture no longer exists.

Perhaps cultures stagnate and corrupt over time, and complaints about youth is a symptom rather than a cause? Perhaps the collapse of a civilization every now and then is one of the mechanisms that keep human societies sustainable in the long run?

There are interesting questions here, but I don't think the older generation complaining about the younger generation is one of them. Not in and of itself, at least.

j-g-faustus··on Ask HN: Who is already sick of all of these "Like" buttons plastered everywhere?
http://techcrunch.com/

Every story has a Like, a Buzz and a Retweet button.

j-g-faustus··on Ask HN: Why is HTML so complicated?
HTML is not complicated at all, that's why it became a success - pretty much anyone could learn to write a basic web page in a few weeks.

Web pages became complex over the years as people wanted do things that HTML was never meant to do. Like page layouts: Early on, people would use invisible images for spacing, humongous nested tables to "hack" a page layout in a language that didn't support page layouts, and pictures of text rather than actual text for example for non-standard fonts or text shadows.

The primary problem is that HTML was never designed for the kinds of things we use the web for today. See the Crockford Javascript presentation for a history of HTML and Javascript, I recommend Episode IV: http://yuiblog.com/crockford/

Designing an "HTML killer" is no simple task, all attempts so far have failed - from Java applets to XML.

But even today you can use applets or Flash to embed more complicated programs. The web protocols turned out to be eminently hackable, and with server-side page generation, forms, CSS, Javascript and now canvas it is "good enough" for more and more tasks, so I expect it is safe to say that HTML will be with us for quite a while longer.

j-g-faustus··on How To Design Like Apple
Along the same lines, Donald Norman (usability guru, started the usability field almost single-handedly with the book "The Design of Everyday Things") recently said:

"I've come to a disconcerting conclusion: design research is great when it comes to improving existing product categories but essentially useless when it comes to new, innovative breakthroughs." http://jnd.org/dn.mss/technology_first_needs_last.html

You can't ignore customers completely. Apple discovered this with the Lisa computer in the 1980s, which apparently was amazing for its time, but at $10,000 found no market. Perhaps Lisa was the computer Jobs wanted for himself, but it turned out that few others were willing to shell out that kind of money.

On the other hand, it is clearly pointless to ask consumers how to design attractive or revolutionary hardware or software - you're the expert, you figure it out.

But this doesn't necessarily mean that you ignore target markets altogether - the iPad is innovative, but still clearly focused on a particular set of use cases with a price to make it competitive with netbooks.

j-g-faustus··on Ask HN: What is your productivity setup?
This is what I am using for a one-person home office:

1. Gmail for everything, two accounts (private and work). I found Outlook folders more convenient than Gmail tags, but Gmail is great at being accessible from everywhere and works well enough that setting up my own Outlook server seems a waste of time and money. I have no other archive than Gmail, but if something is especially important (like an order or contract) I save it to the hard drive as well.

2. That's a kludge, I haven't really found a good general solution. I have a standard directory structure for projects, and use a central Mercurial versioning system to share code between computers. I use 3-4 editors/IDEs, generally based on which editor has best support for that particular language. At the moment I use NetBeans for JavaScript and Ruby, Xcode for Go and Objective-C, TextWrangler for configuration, scripts etc. and Emacs when on Linux. Builds are generally shell or Ruby scripts.

3. Manually. IM is generally turned off, I enable it only for specific conversations by appointment. Leaving it on constantly gives too many interruptions to get anything done.

4. I have a Mac mini hooked up to the TV and hi-fi to handle all media. A Linux server provides a few TB media storage. (But this is entertainment, I don't use media for anything related to productivity.)

5. All locally. I use a software called CrashPlan which autobackups my two Apple laptops to a central Linux server. On the server rsnapshot runs as a cron job for daily/weekly/monthly backups to an external disk. I would like an offsite or web snapshot as well - I might consider something like Mozy.com for a small subset of the most important data.

6. In general: Whatever is simplest and cheapest. For mail and calendar, that's cloud based (Gmail and Google calendar), which also takes care of reconciling. For code, documents and accounting, it's local. Code is shared through Mercurial, documents through a shared folder on the local network. Backups are local mostly due to cost.

j-g-faustus··on The Original Techcrunch 40: Where are they now?
> It shows how fundamentally difficult it is to make credible business forecasts in technology.

Becoming a major success is fundamentally hard and predicting the future is fundamentally hard, so it shouldn't be much of a surprise.

You can see the effect in major established companies as well: Microsoft has two very successful products (Windows OS and Office), Google has one (search/AdWords). In both cases the core products are pretty much the entire profit for these companies. This is hardly for lack of trying, they have both launched dozens to hundreds of other products (and have tons of money to back them up), but have so far been unable to replicate the success.

It's not just technology either: Peter Lynch (a successful fund manager) coined the term "ten bagger" for a stock investment that increases tenfold in value. According to Lynch, ten baggers were incredibly satisfying and incredibly hard to find. (As I recall it from his book, the fund invested in hundreds of companies each year and there was still years between each ten bagger. In that perspective, one major success out of 40 seems pretty good.)

I guess it mostly goes to show that mountains of money tend not to lie around for the taking :)

j-g-faustus··on KLM pushes to resume passenger flights after tests
And Europe has 22,000 daily flights normally, 17,000 of them were cancelled Saturday. 17k flights times average number of passengers (100?) times average ticket cost ($100?) - it adds up to a lot of lost income. And as mentioned, the airlines were barely profitable as it were, and most of their costs are the same whether they are flying or not.

Analysts are saying that many/most of the airlines in Europe will be bankrupt in a couple of weeks if nothing changes, some think we will be seeing the first bankruptcies within a few days.

j-g-faustus··on Moral judgments can be altered ... by magnets
Sounds like you are assuming that "moral" is an exact concept. Practically speaking, there seems to be lots of cases where opinions on what is moral differ: Abortion, porn, finance...

What would worry me with a machine that could tweak everyone to the same 'standard' moral is who gets to decide what that standard is: Having my moral controlled by the porn industry, Goldman Sachs or the religious right all seems equally bad.

I like my moral just the way it is, thank you :)

j-g-faustus··on What Programming Langauge Are You Learning?
>One thing I have learned is that there is nothing that you can do in one language that you can't do in another

While this is true, I have also learned that there are significant differences in convenience and ease of development, that libraries matter a lot for actual applications (as opposed to experimenting to get the 'feel' for a language), and that the new concepts and coding-and-code-structuring conventions I learn along with a new language may be as important as the language itself.

Among my formative experiences, I'd list C, Lisp, Java (namespaces and Javadoc), Javascript and Erlang - they take quite different approaches to computing.

j-g-faustus··on What Programming Langauge Are You Learning?
Google's Go (www.golang.org)

I'm also considering the "seven languages in seven weeks" book (http://www.pragprog.com/titles/btlang/seven-languages-in-sev... ). I know some of those languages already, but I think it's worthwhile to spend a few weeks getting an overview of what else is out there.

j-g-faustus··on App Store Bans Pulitzer-Winning Satirist. For Satire
I was thinking more of the (relatively few) cases where someone ends up on the Patrician's bad side:

"The Patrician could not tolerate mime artists. It was a strange aversion, but there you are. Anyone in baggy trousers and a white face who tried to ply their art anywhere within Ankh's crumbling walls would very quickly find themselves in a scorpion pit, one wall of which was painted the advice: Learn The Words."

For the Patrician it was mimes, for Jobs presumably Flash, bikinis and now also satire ;-)

j-g-faustus··on App Store Bans Pulitzer-Winning Satirist. For Satire
I imagine Steve Jobs as The Patrician in Terry Pratchett's Discworld series:

"Ankh-Morpork had dallied with many forms of government and had ended up with that form of democracy known as One Man, One Vote. The Patrician was the Man; he had the Vote."

I suppose Steve doesn't like satire...

j-g-faustus··on EFF: The Entertainment Industry's Dystopia of the Future
"The planned release of a blockbuster motion picture should be acknowledged as an event that attracts the focused efforts of copyright thieves... Enforcement agencies (notably within DOJ and DHS) should plan a similarly focused preventive and responsive strategy. An interagency task force should work with industry to ... react swiftly with enforcement actions where necessary."

Looks like the movie and music industry thinks that file sharing is a threat to society along the lines of terrorism.

j-g-faustus··on Programming languages, operating systems, despair and anger
Sure. But the gist of the rant is that he keeps doing the same repetitive, mundane tasks over and over again, merely to shuffle data from one part of the system to another and convert between representations on the way.

Like when you have a database, a server application and an AJAX web page, you may have four to five different representations of the same data (DB table, server language object, JSON, Javascript object and finally HTML) and need a whole bunch of code just to move data from A to B and convert between representations.

It's not just a language problem. It's just as much a problem of impedance mismatch between different systems, protocols and data formats. Various frameworks attempt to reduce the tediousness, but tend to come with issues of their own.

PG has something on this too:

"Of course the ultimate in brevity is to have the program already written for you, and merely to call it. And this brings us to what I think will be an increasingly important feature of programming languages: library functions."

"I think a lot of the advances that happen in programming languages in the next fifty years will have to do with library functions. I think future programming languages will have libraries that are as carefully designed as the core language."

http://www.paulgraham.com/popular.html

Whether the common case is made simple by the language, libraries, frameworks or standardization (we may need all of them) ultimately does not matter much to the developer, only that you can handle conceptually trivial everyday tasks with the minimum of fuss.

We have a long way to go before this becomes a reality.

j-g-faustus··on Ask HN: Less features with new releases. Have you done it?
A company I worked for tried to remove a feature:

One release added a "tagging" feature (similar to Gmail tags) while the next release had a "hierarchical folders" feature (similar to Outlook folders).

The thinking was that tags and folders did pretty much the same thing, and folders were clearly superior since they were hierarchical. So we stripped the tagging and shipped with just the folder feature.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, there turned out to be customers that had built a whole lot of import/export/processing infrastructure around the tags, and were less than happy about having to reimplement it all using folders. Plus they had a ton of tagged data and we hadn't included a tool to convert the old format to the new one. (Because we thought noone were using the tagging feature, it had only been in the product for a single release.)

The lesson learned is that released features are similar to published APIs: If you remove or change them you will inevitably break something for someone.

j-g-faustus··on Ask HN: Any good books on graphing/charting/visualization?
Agreed. I was assuming that you have read your Tufte :) and can tell informative visuals from those that are primarily pretty or entertaining.
← PreviousPage 4 of 5Next →