HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jackcosgrove

3,959 karma · joined October 17, 2015

submissionscomments
jackcosgrove··on When the Dotcom Bubble Burst
> Probably led me to be a bit too conservative with such things

Those who graduate into recessions have crimped lifetime earnings compared to those who graduate into expansions. I wonder to what extent it's lost income, and to what extent it's a more risk-averse attitude.

jackcosgrove··on When the Dotcom Bubble Burst
Investing in a market index today is even easier. Instead of doing historical research on thousands of stocks, you just compare the expense ratios of a handful of index funds and pick the lowest one.
jackcosgrove··on Abuse of power at Germany's elite research institution [video]
I'm not sure if there is any literature to this effect, but an institutional arrangement that has known flaws is one in which peers nominate future peers for membership. Academia is an example of this arrangement.

When evaluating whether an institution is accountable, a good default question to ask is, "Is power plural?" In the terminology of the American political order, this is called checks and balances. It's not perfect, but a system of overlapping institutions, whose members are chosen by a plurality of methods and from a plurality of backgrounds, and which have oversight over each other in a loop, are more accountable than unitary institutions.

I'm sure some have attempted to answer this analytically, basically making a "directed power graph" to measure how plural power is, and then correlating that with measures of accountability such as corruption perceptions. This is a huge topic and the second paragraph is my opinion, but that's because I think that's what such an analysis would show.

jackcosgrove··on “Normal” engineers are the key to great teams
Novelty is a byproduct of immaturity. To take another field that matured recently, mechanical and in particular aerospace. You can see a lot of crazy airplane designs from the 1920s through the 1940s. There was a lot of novelty back then and it was an exciting field to work in. Now airplane designs look very standard, and for good reason. The field matured and figured out the best and most economical designs. Novelty is a temporary state, and most novel designs are figuring out how not to do things.
jackcosgrove··on Gemini Robotics
I'm still waiting for the clothes-folding robot.
jackcosgrove··on What made the Irish famine so deadly
> Irish and Armenian genocides were given special focus, probably mostly due to the demographics of the area I grew up in.

There's just so much history to cover, and to be charitable to those who exclude events deemed important it can be that other events are deemed more important (especially by the local population) and there's only so much class time.

History instruction seems to be of two minds, either grand narratives (great men in the past, metrics-driven narratives like agricultural productivity now), or the case study approach where you sample some episodes from a variety of times and places and study each in depth. In both cases the approach must involve leaving some stories on the editing floor.

jackcosgrove··on Schools reviving shop class
It is mind-boggling to me that one of the most important numbers in life - the 2% inflation rate target - is not taught to everyone.

It's the financial equivalent of not teaching what temperature water freezes at.

jackcosgrove··on Executive wealth as a factor in return-to-office
I have thought about this too.

* Remote workers aren't actually a worldwide labor force because of time zones, so the competition on the labor side is less than in theory.

* Remote work diminished the difference in liquidity between labor and capital markets. Capital is by nature more liquid than labor, and being more liquid gives you an advantage. As you say, the competitive pressures exist in both markets, and maybe this is a wash in terms of power.

* Remote workers can pay off mortgages faster, leading to more early retirements.

I still think the primary reason is a desire to manage according to the old style, which is a different argument than the GP.

jackcosgrove··on Unknown illness kills over 50 in Congo with hours between symptoms and death
Why are bats so often a vector? Is it because they are airborne mammals? Meaning they can cover a lot of ground and come in contact with a lot of other vectors, and also have biology more similar to humans than, say, birds?

I am aware that birds are also a common vector, but bats seem to be the greater risk.

jackcosgrove··on Despite sticker prices, the real cost of getting a degree has been going down
Field hockey, water polo. If you include club sports there's more like fencing and squash. And yes I think rowing too.
jackcosgrove··on 'Everybody is looking at their phones,' says man freed after 30 years in prison
I don't dislike talking to others. It's just hard for me to say what I want to say at the speed of normal conversation. I write more slowly and carefully, can edit what I've drafted, and check facts too, all before I hit the submit button.
jackcosgrove··on Despite sticker prices, the real cost of getting a degree has been going down
> Would that advantage manifest as playing into the system - looking for opportunities for signaling? Or discounting - finding good education with less signaling value.

Good question! I think that can play out both ways, ultimately based on how wealthy the parents are. If money is no object, play the prestige game. If you are middle class and know the rules of the game, maximize value.

For example, I am acquainted with parents who are teachers at a prestigious private school. Their child attended said school because of subsidized tuition, and then attended college in an honors program at a state university in the middle of the country. He was paid to attend! The parents are fully abreast of all the studies on the effects of education, both being teachers and being in the middle of the college admissions frenzy that goes on in these schools. So they know how the game works, and they are playing it to the max for value.

On the other hand, at this school are children from generational wealth who play obscure sports from an early age to give them an edge in admissions. The children never need to actually earn a living, and the target school admission is seen as a defense of a family legacy and bragging rights for the parents - pure prestige.

jackcosgrove··on Despite sticker prices, the real cost of getting a degree has been going down
I just searched for "best predictor of career success" and found a bunch of conflicting results. Open networks, conscientiousness, grit, intelligence, class, etc. This is actually reassuring, since if there were a known path to success everyone would crowd into it. Curiously I didn't see any articles or studies saying "it's partially random" because no one wants to hear that.

I think academic prestige is best understood as a safety net. It won't guarantee success, because nothing can, but it can do a decent job preventing failure. In that respect the parents are right. Academic assistance is a way they can convert financial resources into something that can't be taken away from their children (and isn't subject to the gift tax limit).

That said it's easy to go overboard, and many do. Unless you want to work in a small number of careers that have target lists of schools they recruit from (which again is because the credential is a selling point to clients, not because the education is better), there is no difference between a public university and a prestigious one.

To the extent parents know that prestige is signalling all the way down, and does not imply being better at what you do or knowing more about your subject, they do have some inside perspective compared to the population at large.

jackcosgrove··on Fewer students are enrolling in doctoral degrees
I disagree. More people have a desire to advance our understanding than have the ability to advance our understanding.
jackcosgrove··on Firing programmers for AI is a mistake
Pay is determined by the supply and demand for labor, which encompass many factors beyond the difficulty of the work.

Being a game developer is harder than being an enterprise web services developer. Who gets paid more, especially per hour?

jackcosgrove··on I am (not) a failure: Lessons learned from six failed startup attempts
It's just portfolio theory applied to entrepreneurship.
jackcosgrove··on I am (not) a failure: Lessons learned from six failed startup attempts
This looks like it's a bit more flexible than my accelerator idea, while in the spirit of it. Thanks!
jackcosgrove··on I am (not) a failure: Lessons learned from six failed startup attempts
All41-14All
jackcosgrove··on I am (not) a failure: Lessons learned from six failed startup attempts
Diversified ycombinator :+1:
jackcosgrove··on I am (not) a failure: Lessons learned from six failed startup attempts
"Failing for generating a return" makes it sound like a skill issue, when it was probably mostly bad luck with the business model you tried out. Negative results can be as valuable as positive results in science, why not in business?

Greedy optimization can also get you stuck in local minima. Why does any investor participate in VC? As an asset class it underperforms. There's something more that motivates people than return. Cool factor, bragging rights, and also I think a concern for growth and the macro outlook.

In my model the reserved pool of shares for failed founders would come out of the winning founders' pool. It's spreading risk across founders, not diminishing the stake of investors.

jackcosgrove··on I am (not) a failure: Lessons learned from six failed startup attempts
There is currently a risk asymmetry in startup world that drives away people who could do good work.

Investors know the long odds of success, so they invest in twenty to thirty companies and wait for one to get big.

Founders and employees can't diversify like that, because you only have so many working years. To mitigate this we have decided to award successful founders with huge paydays as a lure to others to throw their hats in the ring. This has some malign effects, namely unsuccessful founders and employees get bupkis. It also attracts the wrong sort of personality to be a founder, selecting for too much risk appetite. (At least what I consider the wrong sort for building a sustainably profitable business.)

I have an idea for how to solve this and I wonder if it's already been tried or if there are holes in it. The idea is to spread the risk of starting a company across something like an accelerator class. If one company in that class gets big, it would be contractually obligated to hire and grant shares from some pool to other members of that class. This would be at the cost of the winning founders' stakes.

The upside for winners would be much lower, but the downside would be lower too. This would attract a different sort of person to this accelerator, and be a differentiator for selecting talent.

jackcosgrove··on Brave Care Has Closed
Just to be clear the "too much coverage" argument is about physical facilities and equipment, not personnel. I think everyone is in agreement that there is a shortage of medical staff.

As far as convenience vs efficiency, the argument was that to achieve the efficiencies found in other countries, which often have longer wait times for services than the US, you do have to sacrifice convenience. The US, by treating healthcare like a consumer good rather than a rationed utility, has built out excess capacity for the sake of convenience. This is, according to the argument, part of the reason we spend more on healthcare than peers. (Healthcare must always be rationed; the US does so on price rather than wait times.)

jackcosgrove··on Brave Care Has Closed
I have heard conflicting accounts of inefficiencies in the US healthcare system.

One account is that the US has too many medical facilities in urban areas. In other words, there might be five hospitals each with its own radiology equipment. That equipment is idle some of the time, so you could close some of the imaging departments and leave just one or two for the metro area. That would obviously inconvenience some people, but the gist of the criticism is that the US duplicates medical capacity for the sake of convenience.

The other criticism is that there are too few clinics and such. That's why there was a big push to open health clinics in pharmacies and urgent care locations recently.

Now I know these aren't mutually exclusive; you can have too few clinics and too many hospitals. But I would like to know if anyone is more informed than I am what validity there is to each criticism.

I'm curious what the truth is regarding the number and character of brick-and-mortar healthcare facilities in the US: too many? too few? Because it looks like this company was opening physical clinics.

jackcosgrove··on Short-Term Rentals Are Hollowing Out Communities with Loose Restrictions
I wonder why STRs are so popular with lessors. All I have heard is that the unit economics are tough and the market is saturated in many places. I also expect a history as an STR to reduce resale value as it's sort of like buying a used rental car with more wear and tear.

I would caution anyone with a sweet, sweet mortgage rate looking to trade up their personal residence and hold onto the original as an STR to do the math before going down that route.

jackcosgrove··on Happy 400th birthday to the world’s oldest bond
I'm curious if anyone has run the numbers and looked at what the interest payments of this bond over the past 400 years would have amounted to had they been invested in some theoretical basket of typical assets that were available at the time.

It sounds like a pittance now but 400 years of a compounding pittance could be a lot of money.

Edit: with an annual contribution of €13.61 and a real rate of return of 3%, 400 years of annual compounding would be over €7 million. With a rate of 4% it would be €280 million.

jackcosgrove··on OpenAI O3 breakthrough high score on ARC-AGI-PUB
If an AGI can outclass a human when it comes to economic forecasting, deciding where to invest, and managing a labor force (human or machine), I think it would be smart enough to employ a human front to act as an interface to the legal system. Put another way, could the human tail in such a relationship wag the machine dog? Which party is more replaceable?

I guess this could be a facet of whether you see economic advantage as a legal conceit or a difference in productivity/capability.

jackcosgrove··on OpenAI O3 breakthrough high score on ARC-AGI-PUB
Capital vs labor is fighting the last war.

AGI can replace capitalists just as much as laborers.

jackcosgrove··on The deterioration of Google
Whatever the next version of information retrieval at internet scale is, I don't think it will involve indexing the web. I think the web's moment has passed.

Maybe the future is something like publishers supplying datasets to train models on? Or like how search was built on top of the web, it will be something more organic and ad hoc.

jackcosgrove··on USPS carriers love their new mail trucks
I think it's a misquote of the phrase "Form ever follows function", commonly attributed to architect Louis Sullivan. It's an odd sentence structure, where the leader comes second in the phrasing, that trips people up.
jackcosgrove··on The price of shutting down coal power, and what would be gained
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_ext...

> Though the current rate of greenhouse gas emissions is more than an order of magnitude greater than the rate measured over the course of the PTME, the discharge of greenhouse gases during the PTME is poorly constrained geo-chronologically and was most likely pulsed and constrained to a few key, short intervals, rather than continuously occurring at a constant rate for the whole extinction interval; the rate of carbon release within these intervals was likely to have been similar in timing to modern anthropogenic emissions.

Modern CO2 increase has been going on for 200 years, and is theorized to be comparable to one of the bursts that occurred during the Permian-Triassic extinction. However the PTME witnessed a few such bursts over the course of tens of thousands of years. CO2 levels sextupled from a base that was not much lower than where CO2 levels are today.

It's a warning about the dangers of CO2, but given the corrective actions already taking place I don't think CO2 levels will reach anywhere near those seen during the PTME. Most importantly CO2 level increases are driven by human activity which is a lot easier to modulate than volcanoes.

← PreviousPage 2 of 34Next →