HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jakubp

803 karma · joined September 25, 2011

submissionscomments
jakubp··on Request for Education Startups
"You learn a lot about interacting with others, getting a social life, developing relationships with different people, discovering more about yourself and the list goes on."

This. Very important, and this process is made much more effective if parents or teachers or other adults are with the young on that journey to coach them. Not easy to do online as you need to see the young people in their everyday interactions.

"But the Internet will never replace teachers."

I'm not sure. The point isn't to replace teachers, is it? You can get to great teachers, mentors and peers through other means, schools aren't the only source of teachers for the young.

You can follow thinkers, business people etc. online, and reach out to them or their communities, and that effectively can act as a teacher.

You can actually meat with people who become your teachers/mentors because you engaged in online activities.

None of these require an institution, and specifically, poorly run schools will actually promote groupthink and monoculture. It's good balance to get some experience and 'education' outside the regular system for diversity.

jakubp··on YC’s Essential Startup Advice
When we give advice that's too vague to be actionable, we aren't helping
jakubp··on A Coloring Book about Group Theory
Also coloring doesn't work, and uBlock Origin kills the app.
jakubp··on EU lost up to €5.4B in tax revenues from Google, Facebook: report
I don't understand the issue with VPN. The idea would be to tax the profit of an ad company based on the country of origin of the institution buying the service from them (not country of origin of the seller, which seems to easy to game). VPN can shadow users' location, but not corporate location of tens of millions of companies, at least that's my intuition.

I don't know anything about policy in general, but I'd rather reconsider existing taxes and their mechanisms before introducing even more taxes. Still, I'm guessing just shifting the taxation based on buyer's location would be groundbreaking, possibly not functional for many companies, and introduce a lot of extra work just to get some money from multinationals....

Yearly national tax probably reflects the instinct many people have, that other companies within these markets are taxed for similar activity, but multinationals aren't, and maybe they are getting too good a deal.

There is something similar going on in Poland and I'm guessing many other developing countries: foreign corporations open their shared services centers, recruit really well educated people but get significant tax benefits on this. Also supermarket chains are somehow exempt from some taxation. Supposedly this is to promote jobs locally, but in reality it seems more like a brutal scam: you get great, cheap workforce and do not have to pay as much for access to it in taxes.

Multinationals selling globally, but paying taxes where they like is similar. The sentiment among my friends is that the local corporations sucking in workforce, pulling it away from building our own products and services with international potential, AND getting tax deals is quite bad in the long term.

jakubp··on EU lost up to €5.4B in tax revenues from Google, Facebook: report
Majority of revenue is coming from ads.

If Google were taxed for each ad income based on the country of where the ad buyer is located, they couldn't manipulate it as easily. Also clients wouldn't be inclined to set up shop in tax havens, because why would they? It's not their problem.

I'm not sure this is a good solution, it might also be possible to game it, but at least that would make sense from the perspective of assigning benefit to a territory: if a myriad small businesses in, say, France, need Google ads, why not tax Google in France for that amount? It is in a sense Google's access to French market that we are taxing.

Could that work?

jakubp··on General and Surprising
Can you give examples of such things that probably don't work, but you can't say it if you don't want to be ostracized?
jakubp··on Delete Facebook Account
That would make sense if we only had a few friends. If you have a few hundred, you only see a small percentage of what they posted, regardless of your actions. Now I understand that my actions impact what I see, but I'm pretty sure it's way more nuanced than what you describe: what does it mean "like that"? I may like or read two posts and discussions about food, and Facebook infers it's about food, but I actually just liked the pictures of broccoli and don't want more food articles. I didn't curate anything, i just wanted to see the damn broccoli.

It's not "me" who decides what I see. I may just want the damn broccoli, but it may take a year or two before Facebook's AI figures that out. And I sure as hell will never figure out what THEY inferred about my preferences, because there isn't any "here's what _you_ decided to see" list that summarizes my inoccuous choices...

How many signals go to the feed? How many of these are my conscious choice? And I am what you could call an expert computer user who actually worked for one of those big tech companies so I can at least imagine some of that complexity and reason about it...

jakubp··on Delete Facebook Account
I was with you until the last sentence. A feed we curate ourselves? Really? I never got to see most of what my friends posted over the years, so I can hardly be curating any of it, can I? :)
jakubp··on It’s Okay to “Forget” What You Read
I also noticed this with books. My impression is that the same book can be called "great" by one person and "boring" or "uninteresting" by another, and it says really more about those people in relation to the book at that point in their lives, than about the book itself. It can show you what developmental stage these people are in.

For some, reading a simple book on emotions will be a game changer, while for others it will be stating the obvious and they won't even read more than a chapter or two, deciding that the book was too basic or even "bad".

I've developed a habit of buying and beginning a lot of books, but many I discard or set aside for the future. Few books seem "too basic" for me, with many I sense that their time is yet to come, or their utility at this point in my life is unclear.

BTW I have the same experience with movies; some of them have a great number of really interesting detail that I often miss the first time around.

jakubp··on Taking meldonium for performance enhancement
Yes, I agree that how strong a deterrent is is not necessarily the best way to decide how to punish. But again, I can't claim it _would_ work, I'm just saying that there are other reasons to punish people who willingly violate basic rules they agreed to previously. If there were no consequences to those violations (like there often aren't any if you violate some less important road traffic rules) I'd say "screw the rules", but if someone is winning millions, fame, respect etc. at the expense of his fair competitors, I'd say "bye bye" as soon as I could.

Such moral violation is for me first sign that counterparty is dangerous to the well being of others. Why not exclude such counterparties from the game altogether? I don't care as much if it will deter the future ones, I just want the ones already caught to be out of the game!

jakubp··on Taking meldonium for performance enhancement
This doesn't seem an adequate analogy to banning someone from sports: if a burglar was sentenced to death we would be taking all he has and also permanently punishing his loved ones. By banning a sportsman we take away his career, but he is free to pursue anything else and continue life in his community, contributing to it. We may consider taking back some of the winnings as punishment. Removing someone from a circle of trusted athletes is not really a punishment -- it's a punishment for that community to endure such misconduct.
jakubp··on Taking meldonium for performance enhancement
As a sports outsider I see the problem with doping to be moral and societal.

Moral: we agree on some rules, compete, and the guy who won may have broken a trivial rule to get an advantage. How is this acceptable?

Societal: I'm not a fan of spectator sports in general, but... when people become rich and famous and powerful by cheating, that probably strenghtens the view in many people that winning at the expense of others and ignoring our own earlier declarations is more important than cooperation, fair conduct, honesty etc. Not a world I would like to live in.

jakubp··on Taking meldonium for performance enhancement
Athletes in many high paying and highly respected disciplines were caught on short and long term use of forbidden drugs. This includes top names e.g. in tennis and cycling. These sportsmen dont seem to care about safety too much. They just probably want to win.

If professional orgs would ban athletes for life, there would be little doping, but somehow nobody does that. Why? Perhaps money from sponsors is much more important than safety and fairness?

jakubp··on Indictment of Marcus Hutchins aka "Malwaretech"
Going by your logic, US could proactively import a computer that is a victim of a crime from somewhere in the world onto US territory, and arrest the person responsible.
jakubp··on Research does not say that people produce more when working 40 hours per week
A fellow student of mine did a study back in 2005 about this. He found that the worst time to fix a bug was Friday afternoon, as it introduces the most (new) bugs into the code.

I see similarities to another area where I have more experience: business meetings. I believe that most people are terrible at meetings held in the afternoon, either due to heavy lunch, or just because it's after 3pm and they are simply tired. A single meeting like this can cause great damage to the individuals and whole teams, measured in intangibles such as motivation, trust, momentum.

jakubp··on Research does not say that people produce more when working 40 hours per week
The point your predecessor was making was that if you make bad design decisions or create bugs, your output isn't growing.
jakubp··on Dropbox Is Getting Ready for IPO
So this is interesting. You may feel closer to people you haven't seen for a while when they are always "with" you on Snapchat -- I have certainly experienced that with people I don't talk to often or people who live on another continent.

But then again, I can't shake the feeling that this is more about fun than really being close. I remember having close friends in high school and at the university. We spent many hours a day together for several years. Can't fake that, and I doubt anything like that will be born through Snapchat or similar tools.

You sound quite certain that it has value. However, some claim that "communication" through technology can also alienate people. Some say it's a bit more shallow, that it doesn't have the same feel as actually talking to someone or even touching them for a second or two (really important for bonding).

Value is not always clear. Forgive me a drastic comparison, but factory farming strikes me as similar: it brought cheap, tasty meat to a great number of people, but the jury is still out on whether it's good.

jakubp··on Starting and self-funding a software business in Eastern Europe at the age of 23
If they are local, they may not want to go abroad. The mindset here is that you begin to accumulate large amount of cash savings early in life (20s-30s), which is a huge boon. This gives you a number of benefits compared to your peers in less hot industries: you can buy an apartment and save on rent long term; you can start your own business; you sleep better not worrying about the future; you can negotiate better work conditions because you are not afraid you'll lose a job.

The fact that you would not have the same position abroad (i.e. your cash savings are large locally but small if you lived in a rich country) is not a loss of any kind, it's just a fact that has no bearing on daily life.

jakubp··on European Commission fines Google €2.42B for abusing dominance
"While it made me angry when Google put their results above ours, I never questioned that they had a right to do that. It is their website."

The website is theirs, but the content they scan through and link to is not theirs. Google Search is of incredible value (to us in form of service _and_ to Google in form of an asset), but it's been built on top other people's content. They took that content for free. Perhaps it gives those "others" some rights in deciding what kinds of things can be done with such a service. It could be done through law, conversation, or applying a fine when a large enough group of representatives of a large market decide that maybe they do something a bit off.

jakubp··on How to become better at software estimations
Or perhaps it's simply an empirical measure of the typical ratio of known to unknown in software engineering: 1:2. It can be used as a heuristic to accommodate for the fact that we have biases and can't predict everything, but the industry as a whole has found a way around that.
jakubp··on How to become better at software estimations
This. It strikes me as odd these days when managers and engineers assume symmetrical distribution of time required to complete tasks. This is not only relevant in software development: in my experience, the larger the organisation or set of people/departments involved in any kind of work, the heavier the time distribution is on the "late" side.
jakubp··on Oculus founder Palmer Luckey is developing border surveillance technology
Changing work can be costly, risky, difficult and just plain annoying. It may have negative consequences for the family and for your CV (imagine leaving your job soon after you realize what you _really_ are working on... and then again... and then being asked in an interview about that). These are all reasons enough to stop some people from simply changing a job once they realize it's not what they want to work on. Because oftentimes you don't know how you respond to something until you're in it.
jakubp··on Lyft and Waymo Reach Deal to Collaborate on Self-Driving Cars
If I enter a market, then the market penalizes me for breaching its rules, and I pull out, I am not calling it "voluntary".
jakubp··on Are we underestimating the vulnerability of bridges?
They may take some of the decisions, but that doesn't make them knowledgeable or financially invested. How would a politician make money from a construction project? The company that engineered it does, sure, but the guy who commissioned it? He benefits from being in office.
jakubp··on Stop the Daily Standup Meeting
A thousand man-years of effort? Sounds like a very large project.

Just for contrast: I've been working for a medium size software house for the past 4 years. Typical project size is somewhere around 500 to 1000 man days. On that scale, individual days matter.

Still, I also have the impression that they matter because Clients demand certainty and precision in reporting rather than focusing on actual value delivered, but the management doesn't always see it that way.

jakubp··on Stop the Daily Standup Meeting
The latter statement undermines your position in the group. Not a smart thing to say long-term.
jakubp··on Stop the Daily Standup Meeting
If you're in a situation where you have to 'hide' the work you have been doing, then your team atmosphere is poisonous and avoiding stand-ups is not going to fix that.

Unfortunate office reality is that it's sometimes beneficial to withdraw by "hiding" your work or by not contributing openly to a discussion. The benefit is in avoiding (negative) spotlight, avoiding additional work or pressure, or similar consequences. This can happen even in an otherwise happy and supportive environment. If you're not pushed too hard by anyone, you can become complacent and settle on doing less. You can argue this is poisonous, but I'm not sure many people would call those "low ambition" or "low stress" or "hands off management" environments poisonous.

jakubp··on Stop the Daily Standup Meeting
"This task needs to be broken up into manageable pieces badly."

This seems to be a sentiment I see a lot, but I don't think it applies equally to all people.

Maybe it depends whether the person doing the task is a mature worker (in the sense of doing independent work).

When you break things down, you make it easier for less experienced workers to complete work. It helps the managers with tracking progress.

However, increased breakdown is very costly on many levels. You need extra time to break things down (senior dev), extra effort to track it in project management tools, extra time to deal with it all every day. It's costly.

Moreover, dividing work that way is harder and less efficient for more experienced workers. They often dislike being micromanaged and probed multiple times a week (or day) about their progress. Give them space and they excel, but ask them to explain what they do, what's next, how much time is left, etc. and they get annoyed.

Mature workers generally know who needs to be informed of issues, recognize them early on, and proactively resolve those. "Process" is what you typically need when you don't have many mature workers. It's fine, but perhaps it's best to be careful who we apply it to.

jakubp··on Stop the Daily Standup Meeting
[edit] Reporting on a high level ("yesterday - analytics, today - analytics") is fine only up to a point. This statement only works when team members are 1) mature (to admit problems) and 2) very self-aware (to accurately assess if they are making progress).

Unfortunately, huge percentage of people in software houses I've seen are young and therefore both immature and not very self-aware. They have a hard time recognizing the upcoming issues, and will not admit they made a mistake or are unsure if they can succeed on time.

The results? People claim they are on track, then they fail, goals aren't achieved. This happens over and over.

Eventually Project Manager or senior developers start probing more and more, dividing the work more, creating smaller (shorter) tasks to cater for less independent employees, adding short iterations, daily checkups and ...

Wait, we created "agile". Haven't we?

Overreport and micromanage to deal with issues.

jakubp··on Are we underestimating the vulnerability of bridges?
So you're saying it's unreasonable to expect maintenance continuity over multiple decades from a private company and its employees, but it is resonable to expect the very same thing from a party that's less knowledgeable and less financially invested in the project?

To me that feels lacking, unless the government bodies responsible for infrastructure maintenance get proper resources and time and expertise to do this on a large scale. Can people today really expect to understand how things were built a 100 years ago? (honest question, imagine the same for IT)

← PreviousPage 5 of 7Next →