HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jasonhong

1,257 karma · joined May 17, 2017

submissionscomments
jasonhong··on A quick look back at when Microsoft made an interactive Barney toy
Many years ago, some researchers at Xerox PARC hacked Barney to be an interactive interface, to the amusement of many.

Here is a longer writeup: https://dourish.com/barney/index.html

And an excerpt: Using the Barney Protocol Stack, we built a number of applications for Barney. Some were simply feedback applications, that would tell you the progess of activities such as printing your document. Some were monitoring applications that revealed the state of other systems, such as the current network status. Some were communicative applications, such as one which allowed two people to communicate through "Barney semaphore".

So far, getting Barney to say things he doesn't already know how to say still eludes us. We know he uses LPC encoding, but we don't know how the LPC information is striped across the transmitted packets. So for now, our Barney applications can only say things that Barney already knew how to say on one of his applications. The up-side of this is that Barney is always in character; he'll say "Super-dee-duper" rather than "print job accepted". The down-side of this is that it's very hard to find instances of Barney saying negative things; so he'll say "Please try again" (the most negative thing he has to say) instead of "your stupid printer messed up again".

You can read a paper about this work that will appear in the CHI'99 conference https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/302979.303021.

jasonhong··on A mental health crisis in science
I think it's referring to this case: https://huixiangvoice.medium.com/the-hidden-story-behind-the...

And for outcomes, the paper in question was retracted and the professor involved resigned. However, I haven't seen updates regarding the review ring (where a bunch of peer reviewers collude).

https://retractionwatch.com/2021/03/16/after-grad-student-su...

https://www.wuft.org/news/2021/04/23/university-of-florida-p...

jasonhong··on The future of programming: Research at CHI 2023
Or maybe their chasing it because it's a highly relevant topic that might impact lots of people around the world, you know, a kind of human-computer interaction.
jasonhong··on Palo Alto Research Center (PARC) to join SRI International
I don't know which specific oral history, but you're most likely referring to Adele Goldberg. She's mentioned several times that she protested showing Steve Jobs their work. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adele_Goldberg_(computer_scien...
jasonhong··on Loopholes in Google’s data safety labels
Somewhat related to the original post, our research team at Carnegie Mellon University has been investigating how well developers can fill out these kinds of privacy nutrition labels.

This paper looks at iOS developers. We found that there was a lot of misconceptions and misunderstandings that led to under-reporting as well as over-reporting of behaviors. For example, on iOS, "tracking" is defined only in the context of advertising. A lot of people also misunderstood what "Data Linked to Users" means https://dl.acm.org/doi/fullHtml/10.1145/3491102.3502012

Our research team has also been crawling these labels on both Apple App Store and Google Play to understand changes in labels over time. One early result is that these nutrition labels are not updated very often. https://dl.acm.org/doi/fullHtml/10.1145/3491101.3519739

Lastly, we've developed an IDE plugin for JetBrains to help developers fill out labels more accurately (and hopefully more easily too) for Google Play. The key idea is to have developers add privacy annotations (in the form of Java annotations) directly into their code. The plugin uses a bunch of heuristics to flag where you might need an annotation, and helps you fill out those annotations. These annotations are then used to generate a CSV file that can be uploaded to Google Play. https://matcha-ide.github.io/

I also have a talk called Helping Developers with Privacy. It summarizes the last decade of our team's research on this topic. (Note that Slideshare has become a bit spammy, inserting ads in between slides, sorry about that) https://www.slideshare.net/jas0nh0ng/helping-developers-with...

Stepping back, our team has been looking at two big ideas for privacy. One is these privacy annotations. I think annotations has the potential to be transformative for the privacy ecosystem. They can help developers, they can be assisted with IDE tools, they can be embedded into compiled code, they can be used to help auto-generate privacy user interfaces, and can also be used as a major hint to check the behavior of the apps (by app stores, by auditors, by journalists, and by researchers).

The second is that every app should have a simple manifest that whitelists an app's privacy-related behaviors. The manifest describes what data will be used and a chain of transformations, similar to Unix pipes. In the context of smart homes, an example might be: get access to microphone -> transform to loudness -> send to sleep.com. While we don't know exactly what sleep.com will do with the data, we can have more assurance that it's not sending raw microphone data. Here's a paper at Oakland Security that describes our ideas. An interesting part of our initial analysis is that the vast majority of apps don't need raw data (raw microphone data, GPS data, logs, etc). Rather, they need a processed and more granular form of it (e.g. loudness, what city you are in, etc). http://haojianj.in/resource/pdf/peekaboo-preprint.pdf

Happy to chat more about these topics, we've been working on privacy for quite a while and have had some successes with industry and with the US Federal Trade Commission.

jasonhong··on Surely you're publishing, Mr. Feynman
While I love 2x2 matrices, there are two incredibly important things missing. The first is the career of the PhD students you (as the faculty) are mentoring and supervising. Sure, you might do fun things, but if it ends up not helping their career, then you as the faculty have really failed them.

This issue of students is something often missing in discussions of the modern research enterprise. Speaking as a computer science faculty, if a PhD student wants to compete for an academic job, they need about 1 publication per year. Sure, back in the 1970s and 1980s you could get a CS faculty job with just 1 good publication, but that's not the case anymore. Of course, everyone is doing this, which then leads to more publications overall.

The second is the overall funding of science. There's an unstated compact that the public is funding science to help solve important problems and lead to breakthroughs that can advance the economy. This is the framework that has been in place in the USA since WWII thanks to Vannevar Bush, and is why NSF, NIH, and other funding agencies exist. Sure, as researcher, I strongly agree that we should be doing things we view as fun. But those fun things should have some angle as to why others should care. Another way of framing this is Pasteur's Quadrant, which is good science and good applications.

The more general advice I give to all students (undergrad, MS, and PhD) when looking for jobs: do something that is (1) fun (because there are many job opportunities in our field and life is short), (2) something that will keep pushing your boundaries (because you're smart and will be bored otherwise), and (3) good for humanity.

jasonhong··on The Man Who Stole the Mona Lisa and Took It to Italy
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Matthew_effect

The Matthew effect of accumulated advantage, Matthew principle, or Matthew effect for short, is sometimes summarized by the adage "the rich get richer and the poor get poorer". The concept is applicable to matters of fame or status, but may also be applied literally to cumulative advantage of economic capital. In the beginning, Matthew effects were primarily focused on the inequality in the way scientists were recognized for their work. However, Norman W. Storer, of Columbia University, led a new wave of research. He believed he discovered that the inequality that existed in the social sciences also existed in other institutions.

jasonhong··on Separation Logic
Funny coincidence, our (Carnegie Mellon's) IT department recently re-encoded lectures by John Reynolds on Separation Logic, you can view the entire course here:

https://scs.hosted.panopto.com/Panopto/Pages/Sessions/List.a...

This special topics course was held shortly before John Reynolds passed away.

(If you're bored, you can also see other things we have hosted on the same platform, including Deep Reinforcement Learning, Intro to ML, and the Computer Science Department holiday party :)

jasonhong··on The importance of exponentially more computing power
Economist Robert Solow famously said in 1987 that the computer age was everywhere except for productivity statistics. Wikipedia has a pretty good article about this Productivity Paradox.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Productivity_paradox#End_of_th...

One hypothesis I've heard that isn't on the Wikipedia page is that productivity from IT also requires new kinds of organizational structures. If you had many layers of middle management, and replaced paper memos with email, it wouldn't necessarily improve productivity because that wouldn't harness the full potential of computing.

jasonhong··on Xerox PARC’s engineers on how they invented the future and Xerox lost it (1985)
I've studied HCI and Engelbart's work for quite a long time, and I'm not sure I would fully agree that things would have been better had Engelbart continued working on NLS, or if NLS had won out.

One simple example is with copy and paste. NLS had a highly complex and error prone copy-and-paste system. A lot of the commands in NLS were modal (vs modeless), and thus error prone. See this article for more info: http://worrydream.com/refs/Tesler%20-%20A%20Personal%20Histo...

Another issue was basic usability of NLS. Engelbart's vision was on continuous bootstrapping, continually aiming to create more powerful and expressive systems. This vision was pretty good for technical people, but also comes at the cost of basic ease of use and entry for newcomers. For instance, think about how many problems non-technical people still have with today's PCs and smartphones, many of which strive for "walk up and use" kind of usage.

Having been in research for over two decades now, my position is that we researchers will often identify the right problem and get the right general direction, but not always the right form. For instance, in the late 90s at Berkeley, folks correctly identified cluster computing as the future, and that we should aim to create abstractions to host Internet services to make them more scalable and robust. The specifics went in a very different direction (e.g. cloud computing, Kubernetes, etc), but the general thrust was right. As another example, my colleagues and I correctly identified rapid prototyping and testing tools for user interfaces as a major need, and while we inspired a lot of ideas with our work (pen-based sketching), industry went in a very different direction (see Figma and Axure and InVision).

I think the same is true with Engelbart's work. He was definitely a pioneer and helped open up people's imaginations as to what was possible with computing, but was off on a lot of the details and specifics that really matter for adoption. And that's ok because to a large extent, that's one of the many reasons we as a community and society do research.

jasonhong··on I can't let go of “The Dunning-Kruger Effect is Autocorrelation”
Consider taking a more Bayesian view of the world, especially with scientific papers. I informally tell the students I work with to look for a constellation of papers that offer supporting evidence from multiple perspectives.
jasonhong··on Ask HN: I'd like to practice coding GUI from scratch. Any recommendations?
I'd recommend two things. The first is Brad Myers' Software Structures for User Interfaces course at Carnegie Mellon University, which focuses on the guts of how graphical user interfaces work.

https://www.cs.cmu.edu/~bam/uicourse/05631fall2021/

The second is Dan Olsen's book Developing User Interfaces, which has all of the details of how GUIs work, from graphics to interactor trees to events to dispatching. For some reason, it's absurdly expensive on Amazon right now.

Both Dan Olsen and Brad Myers were early pioneers in GUIs and GUI tools, so you'd be learning from the masters.

jasonhong··on How did Europe become the richest part of the world?
It seems that a lot of historians strongly disagree with Jared Diamond's methods and thesis in Guns, Germs, and Steel. See here for /r/AskHistorians FAQ about him:

https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/historians_views...

jasonhong··on Ask HN: What are some good tech magazines?
Seconding IEEE Spectrum, it covers a broad number of fun technical topics. Off the top of my head, some articles over the past year included supersonic transportation, satellite transmissions, crowdfunded space travel, COVID detection mechanisms, software failures, and data compression.

Communications of the ACM is also a good print magazine if you are interested in computer science. It has more of an academic bent, but is meant to be of general interest to computer scientists (disclosure: I'm on the Editorial Board of CACM). Again, off the top of my head, some recent articles include K-12 computer science education, a survey of word embedding techniques, software-defined cooking using a programmable microwave (I'm a co-author of this), differential privacy, a survey of AI bias issues, and Green AI.

jasonhong··on Notational Intelligence
Yes, Tufte's most popular book, The Display of Quantitative Information, is quite good, though he pushes minimalism far too much. Note that Tufte also makes a lot of assertions without evidence to back it up. His philosophy on design is that designers should think really, really hard and just get the design right, completely discounting the value of user testing.
jasonhong··on Notational Intelligence
Don Norman has a rather good example in his book The Design of Everyday Things. He presents a two player game. Each player alternately chooses a number from 1 to 9. Each number can only be chosen at most once. The first player to pick three numbers that add up to exactly 15 wins.

Even writing things down with paper and pencil, this game is hard. However, Don Norman shows how, if you put the numbers into a Tic Tac Toe grid, the game becomes trivial.

This person has a description of the same game plus the tic tac toe grid: http://www.andreweifler.com/which-game-are-you-playing-pick1...

Like the original article, I mention in my classes Roman numerals vs Arabic numerals as a good example of how notation can influence things.

The whole field of information visualization is also a great example of how to leverage the power of human vision to easily see patterns and understand data, which overlaps a lot with notation.

jasonhong··on Best Paper Awards in Computer Science over the past 25 years
Yes, CHI is quite broad as a field. It started out primarily as computer scientists and psychologists, grew to include design, and has since then expanded to include elements of anthropology, art, material sciences, ICT4D (tech for developing countries), and more.

One thing I've never quite figured out, though, is that other fields in CS tend to splinter into new conferences when the main one gets too big (or perhaps its just systems conferences). In contrast, CHI seems to just get bigger and broader every year.

jasonhong··on Ask HN: How would a programming language look if designed by non-programmer
You will be very interested in my colleague Brad Myers' work on Natural Programming. http://www.cs.cmu.edu/~NatProg/

In particular, one of his PhD students John Pane did a number of studies looking at how people would naturally describe the behaviors in Pac Man. It was really nice work.

You should also take a look at Programming by Demonstration. One book, Watch What I Do, is published online in its entirety by the editor Allen Cypher, see here http://acypher.com/wwid/.

Another book in this space, Your Wish is My Command, is also published online https://web.media.mit.edu/~lieber/Your-Wish/

Both of these are collections of research papers showing how people can demonstrate what they want to a computer, and have the computer figure out what they want. There's a more recent book on programming by demonstration, but I don't recall the title.

But definitely check out the first link on Natural Programming, Brad Myers is one of the world experts on this topic.

jasonhong··on Biases in AI Systems
This is a really good question, one that we've discussed amongst at our university (a lot of researchers at Carnegie Mellon).

To be useful, ML systems have to have some kind of bias. However, the distinction here is that some of these biases are harmful biases. Kate Crawford talks about allocative harms (how resources are allocated) and representation harms (e.g. stereotypes).

Some of these harmful biases are really blatant. For example, labeling Blacks as "Gorillas" is offensive for many reasons.

Some of these biases "correct" but that's due to biases in the data set or society. The ProPublica investigation of recidivism prediction is a good example, where it was more likely to say that Blacks should not be released. However, police are also more likely to arrest Blacks, which naturally leads to this bias. Other examples here include Amazon's resume system that was biased against women (since they used Amazon's hiring practices as ground truth), and image search for "professional hairstyles" that showed White women but "unprofessional hairstyles" that showed Black women.

Other biases are also "correct" but greatly miss the underlying context. For example, a naive AI system might tell you don't go to a certain medical doctor that is a professor, since they have a higher rate of deaths. However, this doctor might also be a doctor of last resort, hence the high mortality rate.

What I'm trying to get to is that even the term "correct" has a lot of subtleties to it. In many cases, figuring out what is "correct" (or ground truth in ML terms) can be a clash of values and world view, and might have different results based on differences in race, gender, age, culture, context, and power.

jasonhong··on Building the First GUIs
> I wonder when we'll see the last GUIs, and everything will be speech-based

The answer is never. The reason is that different kinds of UIs are effective for different kinds of tasks.

I can't remember who I heard this from, but they asked the audience to imagine a speech-based steering wheel for cars. "Turn left... more... more... MORE!!! LESS! LESS!"

Speech also has problems with sensitive data in public places ("Please enter in your password" or "Your stock portfolio is now worth ..."), has problems with noise, and can also interfere with some parts of your cognitive processes. In addition, speech is serial, which means that you can pretty much only process one stream at a time. Contrast this with a web page that you can skim, or a visualization that can show a lot of data.

Different kinds of interactions have different tradeoffs. Speech is good for some tasks, and not very good for others.

jasonhong··on How Should We Critique Research?
> If a study doesn’t replicate then it’s almost certainly nonsense.

For some fields, especially natural sciences, this statement makes sense. However, for sciences of the artificial (to use Herb Simon's term) I would respectfully disagree.

For example, sometimes the underlying context has changed. I remember a luminary in my field (HCI) once argued that we should consider re-doing many studies every decade, because each cohort uses a different set of tools and has a different set of experiences, and because the underlying demographics of those cohorts change.

jasonhong··on The fight against fake-paper factories that churn out sham science
This leads to another problem that we (the science community) are already facing: how should we allocate funds between older and more established researchers vs new researchers? Or, who will be the next Einsteins?

If you only fund the more established researchers, then new researchers are starved out and more likely to leave the field. However, my belief is that new researchers are more likely to develop big new innovations than (say) the really old professors that are well past their prime.

You also have another related problem: given a large pool of new researchers, who are the ones that will be really good? Plus, there are other possible goals, like spreading the money around to broaden the base of researchers.

jasonhong··on Tensions in Google's ethical AI group increase as it sends demands to CEO
I find it interesting how, in the other current thread about an antitrust suit against Google (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25448718) that people there are criticizing Google's lack of ethics, and in this thread people are criticizing a team in Google whose goal is to try to get Google to act more ethically.
jasonhong··on Software Needs Philosophers (2006)
Helen Nissenbaum (now at Cornell Tech) wrote a famous paper framing privacy as Contextual Integrity, which has been highly influential for researchers on computer privacy as well as public policy makers.

The Wikipedia entry on Contextual Integrity is pretty good: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contextual_Integrity

The basic idea is that rather than focusing on broad rules about privacy (like the Fair Information Practices, which underpins almost all privacy laws today), it's important to understand the norms around what is appropriate and inappropriate in specific contexts.

In my field of human-computer interaction, Paul Dourish is perhaps the best known researcher that straddles philosophy and software (though I'm sure philosophers would consider him more of a software person). He has several well-known papers, e.g. on "spaces vs places" for collaborative software (http://www.dourish.com/publications/1996/cscw96-place.pdf), on privacy as boundary negotiation, on why ethnographic research shouldn't have to discuss implications for design (http://onemvweb.com/sources/ethnography/implication_design.p...), and more.

jasonhong··on Randy Pausch Last Lecture: Achieving Your Childhood Dreams (2007) [video]
My current office at CMU is actually Randy's last office before he passed away. He was really fun in faculty meetings, everything you see in the video was exactly what he was like in real life.

When I was in grad school, I heard from some of his students how, every so often, he would get the itch to do some programming (I think this would have been Alice, their 3D virtual world). The students asked him to mark where he started and where he ended in the source code, so they could go fix things afterward, all in good humor.

Randy also claimed to be the person who started the trend in SIGGRAPH papers of including a giant splash image at the top of the first page, as part of his Aladdin paper. Here's a copy of the paper. http://ivizlab.sfu.ca/arya/Papers/ACM/SIGGRAPH-96/Storytelli...

He was also notorious for how he started the first day of class of Programming User Interfaces (a class for non-programmers about prototyping user interfaces). He would bring in a VCR and a sledgehammer. He would talk about how bad user interfaces would make people so angry, they would want to smash things. He would then proceed to smash the VCR into bits. I heard that some students would come to the first day just to see him do this. (I took over that course several years ago, and no, I definitely don't do that!)

Randy was a really great person, I still miss him.

jasonhong··on Ask HN: How are online communities established?
The book shows for me as $35 on Amazon (paperback) and $150 for hardback, so I'd suggest getting the Kindle or paperback version.

I've used parts of the book in a class I taught on the Social Web, and yes, I did find it really useful and I think the students did too. This book really is the best one out there summarizing a lot of the experimental scientific research by the research community.

It presents a series of Design Claims, and then backs up those claims by synthesizing the results of previous studies and analyses done by the research community. If you're less interested in the scientific literature, you can just read the Design Claims and still get a lot out of it.

Here is one example Design Claim from the book (you can see it on p29 in Amazon Look Inside feature): Compared to broadcasting requirements for contribution to all community members, asking specific people to make contributions increases the likelihood they will do so.

(Or to operationalize things more: if you want people to do something, don't send a mass email, send the request individually. I've personally found this to be a more effective way to get things done. Remember to only use this power for good, though.)

Also, let me clarify my conflict of interest: I'm a professor at Carnegie Mellon University in the same department as one of the authors (Kraut), who I'm pretty sure the vast majority of people doing scientific research on online communities would say is a clear leader in the field.

jasonhong··on Ask HN: How are online communities established?
Here is a very good book that summarizes a lot of the scientific research about creating and fostering online communities.

Building Successful Online Communities: Evidence-Based Social Design

Here are the chapters:

  * Encouraging Contribution to Online Communities
  * Encouraging Commitment to Online Communities
  * Regulating Behavior in Online Communities
  * The Challenges of Dealing with Newcomers
  * Starting New Online Communities
jasonhong··on Airbnb Has a Hidden-Camera Problem (2019)
My colleagues and I recently published a paper at CHI 2020 that was inspired in large part by this problem of hidden cameras in AirBnBs. Here is a link to ACM Digital Library (https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3313831.3376585) and a PDF copy of the paper on my Box account (https://cmu.box.com/s/89iugeaf3hcc51ir9f4akrp1a9b0mogd).

One of the things we did was a survey of N=226 AirBnB users. 86 people said that they manually searched for devices in AirBnBs, and 8 actually found undisclosed devices. As you might imagine, manually searching is hard because devices are small, but also because you don't always know if you've found everything, and because it looks socially awkward too.

People also reported on how they looked for devices, ranging from manual search (most common) to using WiFi / Bluetooth scanning tools. Here is an excerpt from our paper as to what people said they did.

11 (13%) tech-savvy participants used special tools to help search, such as using a phone camera or flashlight, scanning Bluetooth and the Wi-Fi network, and using an infrared scanner. For example, participants reported that they turned off all the lights and used their smartphone flashlight to shine around the area and look for reflections that might indicate a camera lens. Some participants reported that their smartphone cameras did not have an infrared filter, and so they could detect invisible infrared light emitted by cameras. Other participants reported using smartphone apps, such as Fing and iNet, to detect suspicious devices connecting to the network. Two participants brought RF signal detectors to scan the room for the source of RF signals (cameras). However, these methods require a strong technical background, and the devices might not be cheap (e.g., over $100 USD on Amazon for a popular RF signal detector).

The main point of the paper, though, is to look at ways for IoT device manufacturers to help physically locate devices. We called these IoT Locators. An example might be to have devices blink or beep. It's trying to address the physical layer of privacy, to help people have more awareness of what's nearby and where these devices are. The logical layer might tell you that there's a camera nearby, but we also wanted to help people find those devices and see (for example) where those cameras might be pointed. There's a big difference between a camera in an AirBnb that is pointed toward the living room versus pointed out the window, something that isn't captured just by knowing that a camera is nearby.

There's lots of limitations, for example needing lots of standards among device manufacturers and how to incentivize them to install things like these in devices. I would say the main idea, though, is that we need to really think more about the physical dimensions of privacy (which has been underlooked in research and industry), and that we need to think more about how to help hotels, AirBnBs, and device manufacturers that do want to do better on privacy w.r.t devices, but don't know what to do.

jasonhong··on Patrick Collison's Questions
I don't have full answers for all of your questions, but my colleagues doing Learning Science often mention this two-sigma improvement, and are working on computer-based cognitive tutors that can adapt and model what a student is learning. I vaguely recall that these cognitive tutors are at the 1-sigma level for certain subjects (primarily STEM subjects), but that was many years ago and I'm not sure of the details.

Here is one example abstract from one of my colleagues (sorry I don't have the full paper): https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/3-540-44566-8_14

Cognitive Computer Tutors: Solving the Two-Sigma Problem

Individual human tutoring is the most effective and most expensive form of instruction. Students working with individual human tutors reach achievement levels as much as two standard deviations higher than students in conventional instruction (that is, 50% of tutored students score higher than 98% of the comparison group). Two early 20th-century innovations attempted to offer benefits of individualized instruction on a broader basis: (1) mechanized individualized feedback (via teaching machines and computers) and (2) mastery learning (individualized pacing of instruction). On average each of these innovations yields about a half standard deviation achievement effect. More recently, cognitive computer tutors have implemented these innovations in the context of a cognitive model of problem solving. This paper examines the achievement effect size of these two types of student-adapted instruction in a cognitive programming tutor. Results suggest that cognitive tutors have closed the gap with and arguably surpass human tutors.

jasonhong··on Computer Search Settles 90-Year-Old Math Problem
Famed mathematician William Thurston has a good response here (from On Proof and Progress in Mathematics https://arxiv.org/pdf/math/9404236.pdf):

"The rapid advance of computers has helped dramatize this point, because computers and people are very different. For instance, when Appel and Haken completed a proof of the 4-color map theorem using a massive automatic computation, it evoked much controversy. I interpret the controversy as having little to do with doubt people had as to the veracity of the theorem or the correctness of the proof.

Rather, it reflected a continuing desire for human understanding of a proof, in addition to knowledge that the theorem is true. On a more everyday level, it is common for people first starting to grapple with computers to make large-scale computations of things they might have done on a smaller scale by hand. They might print out a table of the first 10,000 primes, only to find that their printout isn’t something they really wanted after all. They discover by this kind of experience that what they really want is usually not some collection of “answers”—what they want is understanding."

← PreviousPage 3 of 5Next →