HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jay-anderson

515 karma · joined August 17, 2013

submissionscomments
jay-anderson··on Microsoft Turned Consumers Against the Skype Brand
They're pushing skype for business in my workplace as well (larger corporation). We've been using zoom and the IT department keeps telling us to stop, but skype for business just doesn't work well: high memory usage (seen on multiple machines taking 20gb+ before having to be killed), lack of features (e.g. video conference recording), instability, general flakiness of software. It is truly bizarre all of the problems given how long the software has been around. The only thing I can believe is microsoft is not putting the resources needed into it. They will fail unless they change that quickly. Us engineers will pay for zoom out of our own pockets before using skype for business.
jay-anderson··on OLPC’s $100 laptop was going to change the world
I still have mine, but I haven't pulled it out in quite a while. It was quite slow, but I remember it using it fondly and really liked the sugar UI (https://sugarlabs.org/). My kids were very young and we had fun messing around with it (there was a nifty audio application that I remember). Another thing I remember about it was the security system, bitfrost, which seemed well thought out. It also had LEDs wired into the mic and camera so you knew when they were listening/watching. I'd really like to see that in other laptops.
jay-anderson··on Fuchsia is not Linux
Old software often had requirements or made design decisions based on assumptions that aren't true anymore. These can make it more difficult to deal with or extend. I agree that in general we should just use the old software that works. However big projects like fuscia can reap some long term benefits. In the end it's a cost/benefit analysis to decide.
jay-anderson··on Google Workers Urge C.E.O. To Pull Out of Pentagon A.I. Project
> several Google employees familiar with the letter would speak of it only on the condition of anonymity, saying they were concerned about retaliation

This is too bad that the fear of retaliation exists for a letter like this. Is this actually the case? Or did the author read into them wanting to remain anonymous incorrectly? Perhaps they didn't want to become a spokesman for this issue outside the company, but are fine making their opinion known to coworkers and managers.

jay-anderson··on You can't Rust that
> things don't move if you don't tell them to

This is something I've struggled a bit with when playing with Rust. I've had a hard time understanding whether I'm telling the compiler to move or copy. In other words I need to understand better what I'm telling it to do (I probably just need to buckle down and study the new book in this area better). It wasn't immediately obvious to me when I last played with it.

jay-anderson··on Million-dollar Strads fall to modern violins in blind ‘sound check’
Many of of the great composers of yore wrote for operas, ballets, theater, and such which is the equivalent to movies today so I think that's an apt comparison.

That said much of the experimentation in classical music has been worked on and refined and yielded music which worked well later. For instance Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring sounded weird to the audience of the time, but we've come to accept it and many of its devices have been used to good effect (for instance by John Williams). One reason I think is audience have grown to accept and understand these sounds. Another reason I believe is the context. I think often we hear these together with a movie and it fits emotionally, but when we hear the music in isolation in a concert hall it we don't get it.

So, I think classical (and jazz and music in general) has always been weird and people have tried to push the boundaries and generally it's brought good results over time even though we may find it difficult to appreciate it right away or without the right context.

jay-anderson··on B-Heap vs. Binary Heap (2010)
> This said, the article feels quite arrogant.

Agreed. Its tone is very off-putting. From the article:

> Not just wrong as in not perfect, but wrong as in wasting half, or more, of your performance.

I wish articles would move away from this use of 'wrong'. Neither of those definitions are what I understand when I read 'wrong'. If you mean sub-optimal than use that word instead. Feels like much of the rest of the article is built around this misused terminology.

jay-anderson··on Surprising Things About School
There are probably a couple ways to interpret the metaphor depending on your context. There's more competition, yes, but there are also more opportunities to grow.

A similar analogy is it's better to be the worst player in the best band than the best player in an awful band. You're going to learn less and learn it more slowly in the latter situation. I think this is more what the author was going for.

jay-anderson··on Talent vs. Luck: the role of randomness in success and failure
I'd rather put it as everybody has the opportunity to develop their talents and skills.
jay-anderson··on Three girls, a dead raccoon, and a crockpot
There's an owl living above an abandoned silo on a relative's property. It's always fun to see how interested kids are in looking through the bones at the bottom. Though in this case there are too may different types of bones to attempt to make a full skeleton.
jay-anderson··on Teacher in Ghana has no computers so he draws Microsoft Word on the blackboard
My first thought was that most of my computer science classes in college were in classrooms without computers. I think that was a very good thing. It's interesting that this is instead teaching an understand of basic UI concepts and specific applications.
jay-anderson··on Words for “yes” in Romance languages
Sardinian for yes is 'eja' which I've read is derived differently from the two methods suggested here though I haven't seen any suggestions on what that derivation might be.
jay-anderson··on Goodbye to Eclipse – the end of an era as an Eclipse plugin developer
We're a mostly java shop at work and I'm one of the last few hold outs still on eclipse. I'm used to it and it mostly does what I need. I use the excellent vrapper (http://vrapper.sourceforge.net/home/), but even that has ceased development it seems. Last I tried intellij the vi plugin was unusable for me. I periodically think it's time to give it a try again. It is too bad the eclipse seems to be falling behind and losing mindshare.
jay-anderson··on Picking Apart the Crashing iOS String
There was a similar bug about a year ago as well. I'm surprised more fuzzing, static analysis, and general testing hasn't gone into this area since there have been issues found there already. Maybe they have done this extra work and just didn't catch this one. It's hard to know. Still feels like the way it fails is unacceptable.
jay-anderson··on Let's Learn About Waveforms
I think it's okay in a text like this to say frequency = pitch. Frequency is the primary factor in how we perceive pitch.
jay-anderson··on The ReMarkable E Ink Tablet
This looks good and feels like the larger screen e ink devices are getting better. Unfortunately I haven't found one which ticks the boxes I want (mostly to use for sheet music):

- Hands free page turning (a bluetooth foot pedal would be idea) - Large size (at least as large as a4 paper). - Split screen page turn (That is do a page turn in two steps: (1) show the top of the next screen and the bottom of the current (2) show all of the next page) - Cross platform file transfer (I use linux and mac and would like to be able to transfer files from both) - No cloud services for document storage (I want to keep everything locally)

This device is a bit smaller than I want. The Sony dpt-rp1 is close, but it doesn't support bluetooth foot pedals or cross platform file transfer (I'm not sure why they're crippling their devices).

jay-anderson··on Extensions in Firefox 59
To get around this you can disable the inclusion of the referrer. In firefox set `Network.http.sendRefererHeader` to `0` in about:config. Of course this only lets you avoid it. But, yeah, I agree. That's pretty rotten behavior and worth avoiding linking there.
jay-anderson··on Why I left Google (HN search results)
> it would be interesting if engineers could earn medals (similar to the ones in the military) for each company they worked for

We get t-shirts instead. Can't wear multiple at the same time though.

jay-anderson··on How I review code
One thing we did to get past the most picky review comments was institute some static analysis with some agreed upon rules which are run automatically during build checks of pull requests (sonar and checkstyle). If someone brings up an issue along these lines that you believe is unrelated to the task at hand you can ask them to propose a change to the rules instead.

That said, in the end, correctness is important and justifying and communicating your change to others is the purpose of a change request. If you aren't following define standards and idioms then you should get on board. If they aren't defined then they should be defined and reviewed to get everyone on the same page. If everyone is using code reviews to grandstand or show off their knowledge that's a cultural problem that needs to be addressed.

jay-anderson··on Datomic Cloud
https://danluu.com/anon-benchmark/ - "That time Larry Ellison allegedly tried to have a professor fired for benchmarking Oracle" - Looks like other database vendors do the thing. That doesn't excuse the behavior though.
jay-anderson··on North Carolina Is Ordered to Redraw Its Congressional Map
Feels like we need to get away from geographic based representation at the state level. In a hypothetical state where voters of parties are evenly distributed geographically we would end up with the majority party always winning anyway no matter how the district lines are drawn. This feels like the end goal of gerrymandering -- it's just that since party voters aren't distributed evenly geographically they need to draw odd districts to get the desired distributions.

Switching to a system where as a state we pick based on party representation or as a whole pick N candidates (something like they do in parts of Europe I believe) seems preferable and renders gerrymandering ineffective because there are no districts to draw. Hopefully we'd get representation based on the voters being represented with this style of system.

jay-anderson··on Why It’s OK to Block Ads (2015)
Makes me think of the littering ads from the 70s (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keep_America_Beautiful). It focused on how littering was bad, but was led by many of the companies producing the stuff that was the litter. That is instead of them attempting to reduce the production of waste the ethical blame was moved people using their product.

It's not a perfect comparison because litter still is bad and I don't think ads always have to be. However it is similar in that we generally believe the production of ads is the default therefore blocking ads is unethical. As opposed to giving users alternate methods of funding your work. (Feels like these are popping up more so maybe ad blockers are making a small difference.)

jay-anderson··on Show HN: Prime numbers visualization
What does the vertical axis mean?
jay-anderson··on Bill Gates buys land in Arizona to build 'smart city'
https://www.phoenix.gov/waterservices/resourcesconservation/... - Phoenix has pretty good water management. That said more water conservation measures in general would be good for the southwest.
jay-anderson··on Freedom of Information Release on Nikola Tesla (2011)
While all of that may be absolutely true, the title of the group of that source doesn't instill confidence as unbiased historians. It makes me wonder if they're promoting team edison. Can anyone recommend a better source?
jay-anderson··on A History of Music Notation
This depends on the instrument. For many instruments reading ledger lines below the staff is more common. For instance french horn players are used to reading well below the treble clef staff and tuba players well below the bass clef staff. Standardizing on one clef isn't sufficient to fix the issues in my opinion.
jay-anderson··on A History of Music Notation
As others have said there are bigger issues than this. Becoming fluent in two clefs is unfortunate, but doesn't take too much time. Adding most lines I could see becoming more confusing and it takes up more vertical real estate. The overall score will expand vertically.

My biggest problem with music notation is it being centered around the key of c major. When ever critiques of current music notation come up I like to bring up the janko keyboard. It has an isometric layout which means that any interval will have the same shape no matter the starting pitch. With this layout if you learn a major scale in one key you've learned it for every key. Transposing from one key to another is just shift your hands. I haven't seen an alternative music notation system which has advantages like this while still being compact and readable.

See here for some experiments in attempts to improve the situation: http://musicnotation.org/

jay-anderson··on Napoleon’s Miniaturized Traveling Library
Does anyone know how small the books were? There's nothing in the picture to give a sense of scale.
jay-anderson··on Ask HN: What non-work task have you automated?
For classes that I needed/wanted to take which had prereqs I tried to show up on the first day of class and get an override signed by the teacher at the end of class. It usually worked. For example in a low-level music theory class I showed up and answered questions during the class (I think I correctly wrote out a d-flat major scale on the board). That was enough to prove to the teacher that I'd be okay in the class.
jay-anderson··on WaveNet launches in the Google Assistant
Hopefully there will be enough details on how they accomplish this when they release their paper.
← PreviousPage 3 of 6Next →