HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jcnnghm

2,348 karma · joined December 23, 2009

submissionscomments
jcnnghm··on The myth of America's missing software engineers
Who can't negotiate? It's your fault if you can't/won't negotiate.

If there is a pool of labor willing to accept a free lunch and campus-like atmosphere, coupled with cheap imported labor, in lieu of perhaps $100,000 in pay, it depresses wages across the entire industry.

I'd posit that the reason finance pays more for engineers than STEM is because most of us think that the atmosphere at a finance company will suck and as a result they have a smaller labor pool (I've literally never responded to a single financial recruiting email).

And this is the funny part. Do you really believe working somewhere like EA is different than working somewhere like Goldman Sachs?

jcnnghm··on The myth of America's missing software engineers
That is an excellent question, and I wish I knew the answer. I have tried finding data on that before, but was unable to. My inclination is that GS has a much higher standard deviation than Google, with the data skewed right.
jcnnghm··on The myth of America's missing software engineers
I posted this in response to a comment the last time this came up. That article was killed, so I'm reposting:

Whereas the reason there are open positions for programmers at high tech companies is that these companies want star programmers

Maybe they should try paying like stars. What percentage of engineers that aren't founders or within the first five employees make over $300,000 a year? The money is in Silicon Valley, Google's 2011 net income was $299,874/employee [1], but the vast majority of engineers aren't going to be the ones to get it. How about paying a market wage, instead of offering a "free lunch" to people that cannot negotiate. I am not interested in playing video games at work, I have a house for that. Last I looked at it, the difference in pay between finance and stem jobs is enough to hire a personal chef to deliver lunch to you at work every day, and cook for you at home, and buy all the games you want, with a bunch of money left over. Apple and Google are both posting ~25% net profits because engineers are willing to work for peanuts, and a free lunch. On top of that, cost of living in the bay area is outrageous, we're talking $35,000/year for housing, unless you want to live like a college student.

An average (median) engineer should be making $200,000 a year, and the "rockstar" (>80th percentile) engineers that everybody is trying to hire for $85,000 and 0.5% of equity, should be making $350,000+. These are hard jobs that few people can do at all, and fewer can do well. Great engineers can create millions of dollars of value a year.

It seems that the industry has shifted focus, now that the collusion agreements have been squashed, toward importing cheap labor. This problem has been solved in other industries through partnerships and professional societies (e.g. in the legal industry, with large partnership firms and bar associations). In the interim, it seems like the best way to capture value is to build companies to flip in talent acquisitions, while planning to leave to do it again as soon as you're vested.

[1] Goldman Sachs 2011 net income was $162,913 per employee. Average pay was $367,057. It's harder to get data on Google, but it looks like the mid-career median salary is $141,000.

Google's Gross Profit (Total Revenue less Cost of Revenue) was $24.7B in 2011, and GS's was $24.5B. At the same time, Google had 32,467 employees to GS's 35,700. Yet, the Google net income was $9.7B compared to $4.4B on the GS side. The difference seems to be made up entirely by the difference in employee compensation.

jcnnghm··on Goldman Sachs sent a computer scientist to jail over 8MB of open source code
The article talks about the requirement to release source code to the public, if modifications are made. This is a common misconception, but generally not the case, depending on the license. Typically, source code release is required if the software is distributed. If you've modified open source software for internal, private use, you typically are not compelled to release the source code, because you are not distributing the software.
jcnnghm··on The perils of online college learning
I think the real failure here is the belief that the majority of people need to pass for something to be worthwhile. It doesn't seem likely that online learning will work better for everyone, but I strongly suspect that it will work better for some subset of people. In the long run, personalization will be extremely important in education.

Have you ever had a great teacher you really engaged with, but also heard from other people that they didn't really like the teacher? For myself, I'd say that I've found that only about 5% of teachers are actually engaging, with depressingly few of those before college. Imagine if you had a personal learning profile built up over your education, so that over time you were matched with the best possible (world-class) instructor for your learning style for every class. I'd bet most of the people here were near the top of their class; imagine never having to slow down for anyone, and automatically skipping reinforcement you don't need, so you can learn and advance as quickly as you are able. I think some people respond best to coursera style lectures, others respond better to Udacity-style continuous socratic method lessons, while others respond better to group work and discussion. Why bother trying one-size-fits-all solutions, when technology can allow for direct personalization. My Netflix experience isn't like anyone else's, why should my education.

I think there is actually a great opportunity to build a platform business in this space, where different instructors can design and build different types of courses. Imagine 20 different calculus courses, but the student only sees one. The best lessons are cherry-picked for them, and the curriculum and delivery is tailored to the rate that they are learning. I'd really like to build something like that, if anybody else wants to give it a shot, shoot me an email.

jcnnghm··on Facebook Is Currently Worth $24 Billion Less Than When It First Went Public
A slight miss or hit of earnings expectations in a quarter really can make a rational person change their valuation of a company by 20%.

Stock prices are generally considered to be the present value of all future cash flows. In other words, growth prospects are priced in. Because of this, missed earnings can seriously effect value because they can dramatically change market beliefs about probable future cash flows and growth potential. Smaller stocks and high P/E ratio stocks (broadly, growth companies) are particularly vulnerable because the present value of future growth is a higher part of the total value.

Edit: Forgot to mention, empirical data typically suggests that markets initially under-react to earnings surprises.

jcnnghm··on Facebook Is Currently Worth $24 Billion Less Than When It First Went Public
Actually, the premium is usually a multiple of the present value added by the combination of the two companies. Imagine two airlines with many different routes, but a bit of overlap. If they merged, some of those redundant routes could be eliminated, which would reduce the costs and probably increase utilization on the remaining routes, they may also be able to sell the redundant planes and terminal slots. This could potentially represent billions of dollars of value above the sum of the values of the two companies separately.

Think about how you would divide this premium between the target and the acquirer. It's actually pretty simple, imagine the next best possibility for the target. If there are many acquirers, the target should appropriate most of that value, hence, a high premium. If the next best alternative isn't as good, the acquirer should capture value. It follows logically that the optimal rational bid for a company is slightly more than the value added in their second best alternative (as an aside, this is really close to how IPO pricing works). Companies aren't necessarily rational though, so in competitive acquisitions companies frequently pay more than the actual value added. Empirically, acquirers in single-bidder acquisitions typically see price-appreciation of about 2% in event studies, whereas acquirers in multi-bidder acquisitions typically see price drops of about 1.33% in event studies. This indicates that acquirers in single-bidder acquisitions typically appropriate some of the added value, whereas in multi-bidder acquisitions, the target company captures all of the value added (plus some) by the acquisition.

A really interesting example of this was RJR Nabisco in the 80s. The idea was to separate RJ Reynolds, the tobacco company, and Nabisco, the food company. RJR was a cash machine, but they had a huge uncertain liability from tobacco lawsuits that was depressing the value of the entire company; the separated company was worth a lot more than the company was together. It was trading for about $55/share, then KKR structured a LBO to buy it and break it up, and paid $109/share (management initially bid $75/share for a takeover). In that case, there were many bidders, so the vast majority of the value was appropriated by the shareholders (in fact, KKR didn't generate a good return). [1]

In general, the market cap is the best indicator of the true value of a company in it's current configuration. That does not mean there is not some other configuration or combination where the company could be worth a lot more. It's worth mentioning that whenever the market price is incorrect, there is an arbitrage opportunity available to move the price to its true value. HFT is basically designed to capture these opportunities almost instantly, which is exactly what you would expect if markets are efficient.

1: I highly recommend the 1993 HBO movie Barbarians at the Gate, about this LBO.

jcnnghm··on Amash’s Amendment To Defund NSA Program Fails 205-217
What "popular vote" are you talking about. It's meaningless in this context given every congressional district is a separate race.
jcnnghm··on The Bogus High-Tech Worker Shortage
The finance industry majorly stepped up stock grants after the financial crisis to decrease moral hazard. How often do you hear about SV engineers getting million dollar spot bonuses? Tech bonuses are peanuts compared to finance bonuses. And cash is king, you're already overexposed to your employers stock because you rely on them for income, you are better off with a pile of cash.
jcnnghm··on The Bogus High-Tech Worker Shortage
Whereas the reason there are open positions for programmers at high tech companies is that these companies want star programmers

Maybe they should try paying like stars. What percentage of engineers that aren't founders or within the first five employees make over $300,000 a year? The money is in Silicon Valley, Google's 2011 net income was $299,874/employee [1], but the vast majority of engineers aren't going to be the ones to get it.

How about paying a market wage, instead of offering a "free lunch" to people that cannot negotiate. I am not interested in playing video games at work, I have a house for that. Last I looked at it, the difference in pay between finance and stem jobs is enough to hire a personal chef to deliver lunch to you at work every day, and cook for you at home, and buy all the games you want, with a bunch of money left over. Apple and Google are both posting ~25% net profits because engineers are willing to work for peanuts, and a free lunch. On top of that, cost of living in the bay area is outrageous, we're talking $35,000/year for housing, unless you want to live like a college student.

An average (median) engineer should be making $200,000 a year, and the "rockstar" (>80th percentile) engineers that everybody is trying to hire for $85,000 and 0.5% of equity, should be making $350,000+. These are hard jobs that few people can do at all, and fewer can do well. Great engineers can create millions of dollars of value a year.

It seems that the industry has shifted focus, now that the collusion agreements have been squashed, toward importing cheap labor. This problem has been solved in other industries through partnerships and professional societies (e.g. in the legal industry, with large partnership firms and bar associations). In the interim, it seems like the best way to capture value is to build companies to flip in talent acquisitions, while planning to leave to do it again as soon as you're vested.

[1] Goldman Sachs 2011 net income was $162,913 per employee. Average pay was $367,057. It's harder to get data on Google, but it looks like the mid-career median salary is $141,000.

Google's Gross Profit (Total Revenue less Cost of Revenue) was $24.7B in 2011, and GS's was $24.5B. At the same time, Google had 32,467 employees to GS's 35,700. Yet, the Google net income was $9.7B compared to $4.4B on the GS side. The difference seems to be made up entirely by the difference in employee compensation.

jcnnghm··on Embrace the desire to make money
So, anyone with less than 15-20 million in the bank is financially insecure.

Depending on your age, yes. If you are old enough you can draw down your savings, though that's a tricky game because if you live too long you run out of money. If you can't stop working and maintain a comfortable standard of living for the rest of your life, you are financially insecure.

Is it just me or is there a serious lack of perspective going on here?

There is, you should really try to figure out what you would actually need to live the rest of your life comfortably if you were unable to work. Maybe you want to live like a college student forever, in which case, you would probably need less than $10 million, but if you don't, taking 70% of your salary as an assumption, then multiplying that by 100 wouldn't be a terrible estimate.

jcnnghm··on Embrace the desire to make money
Yeah, but the reason its the hedonic treadmill is because when you ask people of any income bracket if they have enough money, they almost all say that they need 15-20% more.

High income doesn't always imply high net worth. In 2011, fewer than 1.1% of households had over $5 million in assets. Given that at least 98.9% of households don't actually have enough money to provide moderately high current income indefinitely, everyone thinking they need 15-20% more is more of an indication of a failure in planning and basic financial literacy, not an indicator that they don't actually need more money. I think I need $10-20 million, indexed in real terms, assuming I don't step up my quality of life expectations, which is more than 20% beyond what I have today.

Think of it this way, you're walking down the street in San Francisco, and you get attacked by a hobo (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/11/naked-subway-man-vi...), which causes brain damage, leaving you unable to work in your current profession. How many years until you have to make a serious quality of life reduction?

The whole hedonic treadmill is kind of like saying that even the people with the most food today, think they will likely need more food in the future, which isn't really shocking.

jcnnghm··on Embrace the desire to make money
I recall a recent study asking millionaires if they had enough money, and most of them said something like "no, I won't feel secure until I have 10-20 mil."

That's a rational response, given that's about the minimum necessary to provide high current income ($100-200k/year), securely growing with inflation, without touching the principal. That's basically the definition of financial security. The study indicates that empirically, rich people tend to make sound financial decision, which isn't shocking.

jcnnghm··on Will students fork over $60K for an online master’s degree in data science?
If the risk and time-adjusted reward is greater than $60,000, probably.

But in the long term, the cost structure of online courses is radically different than in-person. I would expect institutions that don't adopt to fail in the long term, as new providers with the lower cost structure enter and dominate; classic disruption. Their strategy right now would have been like if Apple released the iPad for $1,599 instead of $499 out of fear of cannibalization of their laptop market. If there is a way of offering a substitute at radically lower cost, somebody is going to cannibalize, it's just a question of who. If Universities don't do it to themselves, they should expect a slow and steady decline.

jcnnghm··on The Forbidden Island
Of course, many other countries cook the infant mortality books be not reporting premature babies that die shortly after birth or are "hopeless" because they don't have the medical tech that the US does. Consequently, that skews US life expectancy down.
jcnnghm··on The SEC Just Voted To Lift The Ban On General Solicitation
Take a step back and look at the secondary market offerings like Twitter.

A company with a speculative run-up and no business model is very high risk. Also, the limiting reagent in secondary market trading is investor count. At 500, the company has to go public, so many companies contractually limit secondary sales to avoid the additional reporting requirements.

jcnnghm··on The SEC Just Voted To Lift The Ban On General Solicitation
I'm just waiting for this to blow up like it did right before all these rules were added (i.e. the great depression). Startup investments are hugely speculative, the vast majority turn a lot of cash into nothing. The public is risk adverse; look at the last financial downturn, there is still a subset of people pushing legislated guaranteed stock market returns because they don't understand the risk/return relationship. As soon as a few people lose all their money, this whole scheme is going to violently implode.

Consider this, the 10-year early stage VC performance was 3.9% [1], with late stage and expansion focused funds at 9.3%. Average VC returns were 6.1%. By comparison, the DJIA returned 8.6%, the NASDAQ returned 10.3%, and the S&P 500 returned 8%. Private, non-qualified investors are going to get slaughtered. VCs are professional investors and their overall industry returns are awful. In addition, private investors have no connections. Those returns include VC's that now routinely liquidate failing companies to other portfolio companies and their LP's as "talent acquisitions", where they recover their investment through their liquidation preference; Joe six-pack won't be able to do that, he will just lose all his money.

The average mutual fund generates below market returns in the long run. If the average fund manager, a professional that spends 100% of their time trying to find strong opportunities for investment can't consistently generate excess returns, does anybody actually believe that the public will be able to? This is only compounded by the extreme risk and volatility of startup investing. Maybe you hand-wave this off, and say the average fund manager is stupid, and maybe they are, but I'd bet they are nowhere near as stupid as the average member of the general public, just go read some YouTube comments.

My bet is that late-stage and expansion deals still go to the VC crowd because they can bring mountains of cash, fast, with connections. The early-stage funding, with the 3.9% long-term returns will go to the public, with even lower than historic returns. As soon as the public figures out that they are hundreds of times more likely to get wiped out than become billionaires, this whole mess will get legislated away again.

[1]: http://www.avc.com/a_vc/2013/02/venture-capital-returns.html

jcnnghm··on Video shows plane's moment of impact at SFO
informed the audience earlier in the news cycle and led to less speculation

Interesting. Does reducing audience (public) speculation actually matter? What if the person that captured the video immediately sent it to the NTSB and FAA so as not to impede the investigation, but sold it to the media?

CNN had the video endlessly looping for hours today, so my assumption would be it has serious economic value.

jcnnghm··on Video shows plane's moment of impact at SFO
The entire transaction strikes me as a bit tasteless

I agree, but it does cause me to pause to consider the entire news business. CNN would pay for a video like this because they'll generate substantial revenue from it. If it were posted on Youtube, Google would generate substantial revenue from it. So I guess the question is, where is the line. Is for-profit news ethical? I definitely get immediately turned off when I see people profiting from stuff like this, but doesn't the media do exactly the same thing, just at scale?

jcnnghm··on How much do BART Employees make?
Google it, stop being lazy. You're welcome to do your own research and refute something.
jcnnghm··on How much do BART Employees make?
Not that hard to google it yourself: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/24/bart-strike_n_34931.... Simple interest isn't additive, that should be the first clue.
jcnnghm··on How much do BART Employees make?
Plus 2% cost of living each year. That's actually 22.5% over 3 years.
jcnnghm··on How much do BART Employees make?
BART jobs are quite supply constrained

That's because they pay way too much. If they paid commensurate to required skill level, demand would drop because the true equilibrium price is much lower.

jcnnghm··on How much do BART Employees make?
$71,000, which is high, but not astronomical

They also, on average, get a $50,000/year benefits package, including a fixed-benefit pension. Plus paid overtime. That's not high, or astronomical, it's absolutely outrageous.

jcnnghm··on How much do BART Employees make?
You can make as much doing menial work for BART as you can in engineering. Except that you don't actually have to do anything difficult when you work for BART, it's almost impossible to lose your job, there is no unpaid overtime, and you get more vacation.

The economics of bay-area engineering are broken. Consider this, how many engineers making comparable salary could take over these jobs with minimal training? What about vice-versa?

jcnnghm··on The Bomb Didn't Beat Japan
Estimated casualties were thought to be up to a million people. The US ordered 500,000 Purple Hearts in anticipation of that, so many that those ones are still being given out today.
jcnnghm··on 'Brave' creator blasts Disney for 'blatant sexism' in princess makeover
Disney's agenda is to make money.
jcnnghm··on 'Brave' creator blasts Disney for 'blatant sexism' in princess makeover
Where did I say there's a hidden agenda? It's not hidden, it's front and center.

subconsciously, they are soaking in the sexy 'come hither' look and the skinny aspect of the new version. It's horrible! Merida was created to break that mold — to give young girls a better, stronger role model, a more attainable role model, something of substance, not just a pretty face that waits around for romance."

jcnnghm··on 'Brave' creator blasts Disney for 'blatant sexism' in princess makeover
Chapman fumed. "When little girls say they like it because it's more sparkly, that's all fine and good but, subconsciously, they are soaking in the sexy 'come hither' look and the skinny aspect of the new version. It's horrible! Merida was created to break that mold — to give young girls a better, stronger role model, a more attainable role model, something of substance, not just a pretty face that waits around for romance."

That seems to indicate they tested it, and it performs better. The pushback seems to be from people whose agendas aren't being served.

jcnnghm··on 'Brave' creator blasts Disney for 'blatant sexism' in princess makeover
It's unethical to give people what they say they want?
← PreviousPage 2 of 14Next →