HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

jgowdy

595 karma · joined January 12, 2017

submissionscomments
jgowdy··on My Samsung Galaxy Fold screen broke after just a day
There's no way I'd buy the first generation of this kind of tech. Of course the folding screens broke. Anyone could have guessed that would happen. Just like we can guess what the spin will look like etc.

That being said, I just bought a Samsung Galaxy S10+ and it's a beautiful device. I'll watch the folding glass demos on YouTube for the cool factor.

jgowdy··on Nearly every sport except long-distance running is fundamentally absurd
Humans aren't the best living creatures at something, so doing it competitively or watching others do so is absurd? I don't believe that follows.

Only the most anti-social people on Earth would recommend we not have Special Olympics for handicapped persons to compete, improve themselves, feel good about the effort they put in and the results, etc. They're obviously not the greatest athletes in the world, but that does not detract from their efforts at all. I admit this is top of mind because of recent federal funding controversies.

Men's divisions generally have better numbers than women's divisions to my limited knowledge (I assume there are exceptions) but that doesn't detract from our enjoyment of women's divisions in the Olympics, nor does it detract from the accomplishments of great female Olympians.

Carried to it's natural conclusion, why does anyone watch lesser league play, like the minor leagues? Maybe because sports is about something more than proving you're the greatest at performing that task among all life forms on Earth.

(I hope my use of these groups of athletes to make the point, isn't interpreted as detracting from any of them in any way.)

Basically, I'm going to assert that the implied claim (that I am reading into the article) that any sort of physical competition is absurd if there are other humans or other forms of life who do things better than you, is ridiculous on it's face. I will continue to watch Olympic swimming, without thinking to myself "ugh, a dolphin would tear these athletes up."

jgowdy··on Hacking Google ReCAPTCHA v3 Using Reinforcement Learning
I'm somewhat glad to hear I'm not the only one who has been subjected to extremely excessive recaptcha tests according to these comments. Especially when I'm filling these out just to login to websites of which I'm a customer. I get it for ordering, but if you put this on your customers logging in, it's like you're begging for cancelations. Google is the one determining your paying customer's user experience.

And if I pass your captcha, can you not cookie me with a signed token indicating that I already proved I was human for 30 days? It's like these lazy people can't handle bot login spam, so they just throw recaptcha on their login form and call it a day.

If your login form requires paying customers to fill in recaptcha each time, you're doing it wrong. Please stop. Or go out of business faster.

jgowdy··on California Restaurants Are Dying Due to High Labor Costs
For rough comparisons in these threads:

The tax rate for someone making $20 USD per hour in the United States is:

Gross pay: $41,600 Tax due: $6,157 Net pay: $35,083

The same wage through Denmark's tax rates:

Gross pay: $41,600 Tax due: $23,212 Net pay: $18,388

Now in the United States, add unreported tips to that already colossal difference in net pay. Add reported tips to the gross pay side of the equation.

That gives the American $20/hr wage earner an additional $16,695 plus tips to attempt to secure health care coverage compared to an equivalently paid Danish citizen.

Effectively $1,391 a month to pay for health care coverage.

You're also able to be on your parents health care plan until age 26.

jgowdy··on European Parliament approves copyright reform
What amazes me is with GDPR, so many people were cheerleaders of Europe being the regulator of the internet. Regardless of what you think of GDPR, once we get a political body comfortable with the idea of regulating the internet, this is what we get. The next wall they're working on knocking down is the national sovereignty boundaries of the reach of laws. It's already in progress and soon we will have European nations enforcing their perspectives including limits on free speech, worldwide. We have started sliding down the slippery slope my friends.
jgowdy··on California Restaurants Are Dying Due to High Labor Costs
If you're going to compare wage numbers between nations, why are we comparing gross pay? If you're taxed drastically more, the pay difference isn't very relevant. Obviously you get social benefits, which become much harder to compare. But comparing someone taxed at 39% to someone taxed far far less by comparing gross wages is nonsensical to me. When you look at the tax rate, the difference in pay is far less severe.
jgowdy··on Japan plans to lower age of adulthood to 18 (2018)
I would guess it's a simple cooling off period, which some states in the US have. It gives you 72 hours to recend the agreement. This allow you to escape the social pressures of the room where the contract is being signed. Allows you to escape the pressures of salesmanship and techniques. Allows you to consult with friends and family.

I understand arguments for and against these cooling off periods. However, I think for individual consumers they do more good than harm.

jgowdy··on Japan plans to lower age of adulthood to 18 (2018)
Why not avoid artificially grouping those age restrictions out of an artificial sense of "fairness"? I was one of the previously rabid "if you can be sent to war you should be able to have a drink" back in my teens. The two topics aren't related. I insisted that they were to the ends of the earth before, but they aren't. Alcohol is a dangerous trap. Having the age be 21, even with some sneaking it early, is smart. 18 year olds don't need to try to deal with alcohol when 50 year olds can have a hard time with it. Your time will come.

When I was in my teens and 20s, I felt like older people were just rigging the rules for their benefit. As I approach 40, let me tell you younger folks something (even if it's useless), we are all on the same team and we're trying to make things the best we can (for you too). And when you get to this age, you'll do the same and younger people will rail at you the same way.

jgowdy··on 737 MAX crashes “linked” by satellite track data, FAA says
I think it resonates with the HN crowd because many of us are on the 737-800 when we are on the nerd bird and many other Southwest flights.
jgowdy··on 2017 saw highest rate of death due to alcohol, drugs, suicide in US history [pdf]
No offense, but do you honestly believe most heroin users are going to buy a test kit to test their drugs and then if it tests positive not use them? The practical value of those test kits seems low to me, as I don't believe they would be heavily used and I don't believe that many herion users wouldn't continue in the fact of a positive test.
jgowdy··on NYC Open Letter to Jeff Bezos
Thanks for the No True Scotsman logical fallacy. Let me say in return that if you're this irrational, your adherence to the left (and your gatekeeping the left) is far more of a disservice to the left than a service.

I defend anyone's personal human rights from inappropriate threats, because I actually understand why we have those rights and why they're important. You are trying to dehumanize the billionaires so you can deny their fundamental rights and you're calling that "the left." I'm defending everyone's human rights, and I'm calling that "the left." I pray that I'm right and the left is more filled with thoughtful intellectuals who want to improve things rather than violently irrational people who want to seize other peoples' property and dehumanize their fellow citizens.

jgowdy··on NYC Open Letter to Jeff Bezos
> We should be able to do that. Exterminating the billionaire class (by taking their money) would be a great thing for society.

Historically, weak private property rights are used to hurt the poor, the vulnerable, the weak, the unpopular, the racial minorities, and the immigrants. My fellow members of the left make a grave mistake in assuming that private property rights are only important to the wealthy.

I will predict that assailing private property rights to accomplish societal goals will be seen as a major unforced error by this political movement because it will end up being used to harm non-billionaires FAR more than its used to rob the rich.

Not to mention that just like wiretapping and anything else, it's a lazy shortcut to just suspend rights to achieve your ends rather than doing the proper work within the system and without violating anyone's property rights. We need to put more thought into things than these kinds of facile solutions.

jgowdy··on NYC Open Letter to Jeff Bezos
It's sad that people sit here and beat their chest about how wrong Amazon is without looking at the other side. Amazon doesn't owe you jobs, tax revenue, or anything else. The discounts are reductions in the amount of money they would owe local and state governments IF they moved their location there.

Since they aren't obligated to move their business there, they don't owe you that money. That's not your tax discount money to spend on other things, it's their tax discount money that they no longer potentially owe you.

The underlying flaw of all of this is that Amazon should "be a good corporate citizen" (do what we want with their money), that tax credits are made of money otherwise spendable by governments (when in fact they're otherwise spendable by the corporation, because it's their money until they owe the tax debt), and that we should be able to beat and shame billionaires into giving us their money and providing these opportunities. Good luck with that strategy, but I think it's unwise.

So while the college students can proudly stand there and talk about how they won with their ideals, the people who would actually benefit from it (families, struggling people who could use additional services paid for by additional tax revenue) are given not the benefits but the warm and fuzzy feeling that the collective nose has been cut off to spite the face.

jgowdy··on Moving our privacy advocacy forward to protect Australia and you
I don't get how this blog post helps anything. It seems like they're saying, we did what we can and we will keep trying but we're convinced most of you will just come to peace with it because there aren't a lot of better options (have you actually tried importing mailboxes of any size into ProtonMail?).

No thanks. Much respect to the FastMail crew, and as an American I understand what it's like to have your government passing these kinds of laws. But this is WAY beyond what we've done in the US, in that it requires employees to accept being subverted. That's a bridge too far my friends. US access to international email is offensive, but mandated subversion of employees is ridiculous.

I really hope for Australia to moderate their laws a bit, just like I hope the US will. But I don't think it makes sense to say "oh well" and keep using a provider in the law in question. Really sucks for the hard working people at FastMail, but I have to say no and recommend that others do the same.

Employees of FastMail, has the company considered more internal controls to try to pick up on employee subversion issues? Even if I was conceptually okay with government mandated employee introduced back doors, how do we know the extent of the exposure? What if someone else gets in the same way? It's just way too much to write off in my opinion.

jgowdy··on So Long, Macbook. Hello Again, Linux
I try to avoid me too posts, especially on HN, but I recently ditched my MBP for an XPS 13 running Mint. I'm very impressed with how much software is natively available now, Wine 4.0 staging is reaching amazing levels of support, and even Steam gaming with native titles and Windows games running under Proton. I'm very pleased with the transition and recommend that if you're on the fence, give it a shot and see if it works for you. Ignore how things were last time you tried.
jgowdy··on AWS gives open source the middle finger?
"When the terms you offer are accepted, hold to them. Else no one will trust you."

For someone to release a major software package under an open source license with particular terms, and then to get angry when other people enjoy that software under the terms that YOU specified, is just nonsense. You aren't happy with the way things played out, because you didn't really understand the types of activities that were possible or maybe just didn't think about it.

Look, it's their software and they can re-license it as they see fit. But to vilify AWS for using their open source software legitimately under the terms they licensed it under is offensive. That is giving the middle finger to open source.

How exactly the author of this article can write something that finds fault in the company using software legitimately under an open source license, and not with the company who is re-licensing their software to a non-OSI license? Who is truly giving the middle finger to open source?

jgowdy··on Chinese battery expert is charged with stealing trade secrets from US employer
As dguido posted below, the details are a bit different than the tiny pair of sentences you're basing your analysis on.

> On 12/12/2018 at approximately 10:30 a.m., Tan contacted his supervisor, advised he was resigning from Company A, and gave his two weeks' notice. Tan told his supervisor that he was returning to China to be with his family as he is the only child to aging parents. Tan told his supervisor that he did not currently have a job offer, but was negotiating with a few battery companies in China.

> Tan's resignation prompted Company A to revoke his access to company systems, and conduct a Systems Access review of Tan's computer activity.

> That review confirmed that Tan had accessed hundreds of files, including research reports. The reports included not only how to make Product A, which, according to Company A, is a complicated and technically difficult process, but also Company A's plans for marketing Product A in China and in cell phone and lithium-based battery systems. These files included information that Company A considers to be trade secrets and outside the scope of Tan's employment with Company A. The review revealed Tan downloaded restricted files to a personal thumb drive. In the course of his regular duties and responsibilities, Tan should have used his company issued laptop. Tan did not have authorization to use a thumb drive to download Company A files. Tan's supervisor confirmed that nothing in the downloaded files was within Tan's area of responsibility. Further Company A confirmed, through Tan's supervisor, Tan did not have a work related need to access or download the restricted files.

jgowdy··on Chinese battery expert is charged with stealing trade secrets from US employer
Yes, as long as every corporation continued to invest at the same rate despite the fact that their trade secrets would be worthless and they'd be undercut by cheaper competition.

This fantasy of "if only all commercially valued knowledge were free" ignores the realities of economics, which pays for the development of technology. Even open source software development exists largely on the corporate dollar with a few companies funding most development.

If more secrets were shared, stolen, distributed, whatever, that will change the equation for companies deciding to invest. You're better off optimizing for time to market and making a half ass product than trying to achieve technical differentiation/superiority only to have the results of your research and development stolen outright.

jgowdy··on Linux Kernel Developers Discuss Dropping x32 Support
> (worst case, if the cache line were stuffed end to end with pointers)

Worst case scenario is probably a GOT or vtable.

jgowdy··on Linux Kernel Developers Discuss Dropping x32 Support
It’s simple. Pointer sizes being twice as big consume twice as much cache, thus you’re effectively cutting your cache size in half (worst case, if the cache line were stuffed end to end with pointers). I imagine the idea that cutting the cache size by up to 50% causes a severe performance impact doesn’t require much explanation.
jgowdy··on Chrome 69: “www.” subdomain missing from URL
If only we had something other than the subdomain to indicate what protocol we want to use to access the host in question. Like maybe some kind of... port number and/or protocol prefix.

"www." is useless. Eliminating it wouldn't be a bad thing.

"m." for mobile sites is extremely archaic. Sites should work on mobile without special subdomains.

If you issue subdomains to strangers on your root domain, the URL bar showing the subdomain shouldn't be your "security model."

The root domain is the root authority behind the site in question. Chrome showing users that information in a clear and concise way isn't "subverting the domain name system".

Safari has been doing this for a long time, and Chrome/Chromium have settings/flags that allow you to turn this behavior off. The amount of crying over this change is ridiculous in my opinion. As long as they keep this configurable (in fact, they should add a UI config for it) I see no problem here.

jgowdy··on A Detailed Look at RFC 8446 (a.k.a. TLS 1.3)
TLS 1.3 doesn’t currently have encrypted SNI. It’s a work in progress.
jgowdy··on On Apple's Love Affair with Swift
Power efficiency, performance, concurrency, compile time error detection through strong typing, etc. You know, trivial things. :)
jgowdy··on Beijing struggles to defuse anger over China's P2P lending crisis
I agree with this being a valuable heuristic. Not for whether or not the food tastes delicious in terms of seasoning or flavor, but are they moving product. It’s easier to think of it in terms of a butcher shop. You don’t want to buy meat from a butcher shop that gets few customers (yes exceptions for boutique expensive butcher shops). You want the busiest butcher shop you can find that meets your other parameters. It’s only one factor, but I consider it a rather important one.

I’ve seen too many episodes of Kitchen Nightmares and similar shows to take a chance on a low volume restaurant that isn’t low volume due to an intentional design decision.

jgowdy··on Women Die More from Heart Attacks Than Men Unless ER Doc Is Female
Unfortunately, outside of more rational circles, I believe a significant number of people will in fact draw some kind of inaccurate and superficial conclusion from this data.
jgowdy··on STARTTLS Everywhere
I appreciate what they're trying to do, and it may improve the status quo, but we've learned that the push away from implicit SSL/TLS and towards STARTTLS was wrong. Using one insecure aspect (DNS) to note that you SHOULD be able to do TLS with my mail server isn't a great solution.

We need to revisit the STARTTLS vs implicit TLS debate in light of the obvious vulnerability and overhead of starting with plain TCP connections and then hopefully signalling towards security. HTTPS is obviously implicit TLS and it works great. We know STARTTLS has issues. Can we not keep going down the STARTTLS road for email, while going down the implicit TLS road for other things?

jgowdy··on Enforcing TLS protocol invariants by rolling versions every six weeks
Userland TCP/IP stacks are in fact a thing once again, for the sake of performance and scalability in high end systems. It's not common to most systems, but to say it isn't done anymore isn't true. As we move beyond 40Gbps and 100Gbps Ethernet it's only going to become more common.

https://datatracker.ietf.org/meeting/87/materials/slides-87-...

https://shader.kaist.edu/mtcp/

https://github.com/google/netstack

https://openfastpath.org/

https://github.com/libos-nuse/net-next-nuse

http://www.f-stack.org/

jgowdy··on What exactly are “preppers” prepping for?
Remember how government agencies and people would literally advise everyone to have an emergency plan, first aid kits, flashlights, and other preparedness? It was considered wise and rational to be prepared for disasters.

Yet today some people (seemingly largely on the left, although I'm on the left and I don't share this) seem to take pride in their reliance on society to continue to function no matter what happens. They look at those who have different opinions as to the level of preparedness one should have, and what types of situations one should prepare for, with contempt.

Does that really make sense? The future is uncertain. Many people on the left believe in climate change. We talk about how climate change is a serious and potentially existential threat. It could lead to unexpected disastrous storms like Katrina. In theory someone who practices the most "crazy" form of prepping could have been better prepared for that situation than someone who simply relied on "society" which definitely let everyone down in Katrina and cost many people their lives.

Are there people who overdo prepping? In my personal opinion, yes. But they don't need my approval, and I'm not taking responsibility for their safety and security if something horrible happens. What right do I or anyone else have to tell them they're doing something wrong by being what I consider over-prepared? How can we be of the perspective of live and let live for so many lifestyles and activities, but then act like these people are contemptible fools for having different opinions about likelihoods of disasters?

jgowdy··on Facebook and Google hit with $8.8B in lawsuits on day one of GDPR
I think perhaps I didn't explain my perspective very well. I'm not saying I don't think you should have to pay for products, just that when it comes to the idea that every party to a contract should receive "consideration" (that everyone gets something from the deal) I don't think the "right" to pay someone to use their service should be considered consideration. I may be completely off base on my opinion on that, but to me it feels like this isn't a contract because one party is dictating terms to another party and the only consideration the one party is being given is the "right" to purchase a service.

The fact that no one is stopping you from hiring a lawyer to explain the T&C doesn't somehow help the inferred assertion that we should consider this a valid and enforceable contract. Personal responsibility is valid and important, but I would assert that government recognition and enforcement of contracts is in fact a threat of violence in the indirect governmental sense. If I don't honor the contract you can secure a judgement against me in civil court and if I don't pay the judgement you can have the county sheriff come seize my property on your behalf. If I tried to stop the county sheriff from seizing my property, I would be on the losing end of violence.

Signing up for something doesn't imply that you understand what you're agreeing to. Contract law has historically idealized that all parties are of sound mind, that they are capable of understanding or receive the necessary help to reach that understanding, that they can read the language the contract is written in, or have a translation that's factually accurate, etc.

This isn't about competition or the free market, and fighting for libertarian principles. This is about business owners using the same governmental threat of violence that they reject with regards to regulations, to enforce one sided terms of a "contract" without any sort of meeting of the minds, consideration, or other traditional factors that go into agreements that governments are willing to enforce.

We seem to have a sliding standard of different types of contracts that have different requirements in order to be enforceable. A prenuptial agreement in many places requires that both sides have an attorney representing them, or that they at least have equal representation and equal footing. If I made a prenup in the form of a 100 page document that had no consideration for my fiancé, and had her sign it by clicking on "I agree" on a website she visited, that would be thrown out in seconds in a divorce proceeding and standard community property laws would apply.

If having a meeting of the minds, consideration for all parties, and understanding of the terms are important concepts for some kinds of contract law, why do we let business make up "business models" where they dictate all the terms, they claim you "signed" a contract through implicit actions like entering the premises or clicking "I agree", and where businesses can unilaterally update those terms at will with nothing more than notification of the other party. I mean there's really not even an effort to pretend there's an equitable relationship between the two parties of the contract.

jgowdy··on Facebook and Google hit with $8.8B in lawsuits on day one of GDPR
There are a lot of considerations around making sure that all parties have adequate representation and they're able to read the terms of the agreement or have it explained in their native language. So yes, I think all binding legal contracts should require either common person accessible language or require access to counsel to advise the person on what they're agreeing to. This would motivate companies to make terms that not only protect them but are also reasonably accessible to the people signing them. Right now they're only optimizing for their own protection.
← PreviousPage 4 of 7Next →